The Albanese government wants the Gaza war to end now. So do most Israelis
Australia and 27 other countries this week signed a joint statement arguing that 'the war in Gaza must end now' and condemning the Netanyahu government's aid delivery model. Israel's foreign ministry and ambassador to Australia criticised the statement, as did the Coalition and local pro-Israel groups.
'All statements and all claims should be directed at the only party responsible for the lack of a deal for the release of hostages and a ceasefire: Hamas, which started this war and is prolonging it,' the Israeli foreign ministry said.
In Israel itself, however, the idea that the war has gone on for far too long is utterly mainstream. As is the idea that the Netanyahu government bears at least partial responsibility for the failure to bring it to an end.
A poll last week released this month by Israel's highest-rating television network, Channel 12, found that three quarters of Israelis want the war to end in exchange for a deal that would release all the remaining hostages at once. This included 60 per cent of people who voted for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's conservative coalition. A majority of Israeli voters said that Netanyahu's handling of the war has been bad, and 49 per cent believe he is resisting a comprehensive ceasefire and hostage release deal for political reasons.
These findings reflect repeated polls over many months showing most Israelis are fed up with the war in Gaza. Similarly, during a reporting trip to Israel last month, photographer Kate Geraghty and I found a pervasive fatigue with the war and an overwhelming desire to secure a hostage release deal. 'Finish it, it's enough,' car salesman and passionate Netanyahu supporter Ronen Sha'a Shua told us, reflecting a common sentiment. 'We can't move on until our hostages come back.'
Loading
Asked about the joint statement signed by Australia, Opposition Leader Sussan Ley said the 'most important' thing was rescuing the 50 hostages that remain in Gaza, of whom around 20 are believed to be alive.
Most Israelis agree. Crucially, though, they believe that the war is hindering rather than helping secure the release of the hostages. The most passionate Israeli advocates for ending the war are the family members of the remaining hostages in Gaza. Many of these relatives are also fierce critics of Netanyahu, whom they believe has made the release of their loved ones a low priority and has continued the war to placate the far-right members of his governing coalition. Convinced that lobbying the Netanyahu government is an almost futile effort, many have turned to pleading with US President Donald Trump to secure the release of the hostages.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
21 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Labor dumps tradition to knock Coalition MPs from key parliamentary posts
Coalition MPs face being dumped from the top spots of key parliamentary committees that scrutinise legislation after Labor broke from tradition and ended a bipartisan practice guaranteeing balanced leadership. The move opens the deputy chair position on three key committees – climate change, the environment and energy; healthcare, aged care and disability; and economics – to crossbench MPs, reflecting the Coalition's diminished numbers in parliament after the May election. But manager for opposition business Alex Hawke accused the government of introducing the change without notice and using it to avoid scrutiny. 'The Albanese Labor government has the worst track record for blocking freedom of information requests and orders for the production of documents,' Hawke said. 'Now, the prime minister has barred Coalition MPs from being deputy chairs on three important committees. Labor's plan to stop Coalition MPs from being deputy chairs was kept secret and sprung on the opposition at the moment.' Traditionally, the government of the day picks who chairs lower house committees and the deputy chair positions are automatically designated to the opposition, which decides internally who gets the roles. However, the government used its numbers in parliament to change the rules last week, meaning a committee vote will decide who gets to be deputy chair. Loading Former deputy chair of the standing committee on economics, Liberal MP Garth Hamilton, said he would be unlikely to get the role again because he will not have as many backers as some independents. 'The clear alignment of voting behaviour between the teals and Labor will render these committees mere echo chambers under these changes,' he said.
The Age
21 minutes ago
- The Age
Labor dumps tradition to knock Coalition MPs from key parliamentary posts
Coalition MPs face being dumped from the top spots of key parliamentary committees that scrutinise legislation after Labor broke from tradition and ended a bipartisan practice guaranteeing balanced leadership. The move opens the deputy chair position on three key committees – climate change, the environment and energy; healthcare, aged care and disability; and economics – to crossbench MPs, reflecting the Coalition's diminished numbers in parliament after the May election. But manager for opposition business Alex Hawke accused the government of introducing the change without notice and using it to avoid scrutiny. 'The Albanese Labor government has the worst track record for blocking freedom of information requests and orders for the production of documents,' Hawke said. 'Now, the prime minister has barred Coalition MPs from being deputy chairs on three important committees. Labor's plan to stop Coalition MPs from being deputy chairs was kept secret and sprung on the opposition at the moment.' Traditionally, the government of the day picks who chairs lower house committees and the deputy chair positions are automatically designated to the opposition, which decides internally who gets the roles. However, the government used its numbers in parliament to change the rules last week, meaning a committee vote will decide who gets to be deputy chair. Loading Former deputy chair of the standing committee on economics, Liberal MP Garth Hamilton, said he would be unlikely to get the role again because he will not have as many backers as some independents. 'The clear alignment of voting behaviour between the teals and Labor will render these committees mere echo chambers under these changes,' he said.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Critics wary of Israel's pause in fighting to allow food into Gaza
Israel has announced a daily pause in the fighting in three areas of Gaza to allow more food to get into the strip. The move has been welcomed by aid groups and Palestinians. Israel is also allowing limited airdrops in Gaza. But critics ask if it will make any real difference to the more than 2 million people suffering from severe shortages of food.
