Hong Kong court backs transgender person's right to use toilets that match chosen gender identity, China News
Judge Russell Coleman struck down the two provisions that made it criminal to do so but suspended the ruling for 12 months to let the government "consider whether it wishes to implement a way to deal with the contravention".
The Hong Kong government did not immediately respond.
"This is a matter of the line-drawing, which seems to me to be a question for the government or legislature to address," Coleman wrote in his judgment.
He also said the question of where to draw the line between a "female person" and a "male person" is "an answer not appropriately given by the courts, and is more appropriately a matter for legislation".
The legal challenge was launched by a transgender man, who identifies as K, born as a female and identifies as a man, and who sought to amend the Public Conveniences (Conduct and Behaviour) Regulations to allow individuals undergoing Real Life Experience (RLE) treatment under medical supervision to use public toilets that align with their gender identity.
This is the latest ruling from the city's judiciary in recent years that recognises the rights of transgender people.
The city's Court of Final Appeal in February 2023 unanimously sided with appeals launched by transgender activists that barred transgender people from changing their gender on their mandatory ID cards unless they undergo full sex reassignment surgery, saying it violated their rights.
The Hong Kong government last April revised the policy and allowed transgender people who have not completed full sex reassignment surgery to change gender on their ID cards.
[[nid:719678]]
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
4 days ago
- CNA
Hong Kong trans man wins challenge against public toilet law
HONG KONG: A Hong Kong court on Wednesday (Jul 23) ruled to strike down parts of the city's law criminalising people going into public toilets designated for the opposite sex. The case was brought by a transgender man, known as "K", who was encouraged by doctors to use men's public bathrooms as part of his gender dysphoria treatment. K's Hong Kong ID card still identified him as female, which meant he could be fined up to HK$2,000 ($255) under existing rules. He argued that this breached his rights to equality, privacy, and to be free from discrimination. High Court judge Russell Coleman agreed and struck down two provisions in the city's regulations, giving the government a year to make the change. Transgender activists in the financial hub have notched several wins over the past decade in Hong Kong courts, which are separate from those in mainland China. The city's top court decided in 2023 that it was unconstitutional for the government to require a person to complete full gender-affirming surgery before the "sex entry" on their ID card could be changed. This decision meant the government had largely conceded its case in the public toilets legal battle, Coleman wrote on Wednesday. K did not challenge the constitutionality of sex-segregated public toilets. He was undergoing hormone treatment pending surgery when he launched the legal challenge. His treatment required that he undergo "real life experience" including using public toilets that match his identified gender, according to the ruling. "Many trans people choose not to use public conveniences at all, due to fear, the threat of harassment, and to avoid having their gender identity invalidated or undermined," Coleman wrote.
AsiaOne
4 days ago
- AsiaOne
Hong Kong court backs transgender person's right to use toilets that match chosen gender identity, China News
HONG KONG — A Hong Kong court ruled on Wednesday (July 23) in favour of a transgender person who challenged laws that criminalise them for going into public toilets that align with their chosen gender identity. Judge Russell Coleman struck down the two provisions that made it criminal to do so but suspended the ruling for 12 months to let the government "consider whether it wishes to implement a way to deal with the contravention". The Hong Kong government did not immediately respond. "This is a matter of the line-drawing, which seems to me to be a question for the government or legislature to address," Coleman wrote in his judgment. He also said the question of where to draw the line between a "female person" and a "male person" is "an answer not appropriately given by the courts, and is more appropriately a matter for legislation". The legal challenge was launched by a transgender man, who identifies as K, born as a female and identifies as a man, and who sought to amend the Public Conveniences (Conduct and Behaviour) Regulations to allow individuals undergoing Real Life Experience (RLE) treatment under medical supervision to use public toilets that align with their gender identity. This is the latest ruling from the city's judiciary in recent years that recognises the rights of transgender people. The city's Court of Final Appeal in February 2023 unanimously sided with appeals launched by transgender activists that barred transgender people from changing their gender on their mandatory ID cards unless they undergo full sex reassignment surgery, saying it violated their rights. The Hong Kong government last April revised the policy and allowed transgender people who have not completed full sex reassignment surgery to change gender on their ID cards. [[nid:719678]]
Straits Times
5 days ago
- Straits Times
Hong Kong court backs transgender person's right to use toilets that match chosen gender identity
Find out what's new on ST website and app. People take part in the annual LGBT pride parade in Hong Kong. HONG KONG - A Hong Kong court ruled on July 23 in favour of a transgender person who challenged laws that criminalise them for going into public toilets that align with their chosen gender identity. Judge Russell Coleman struck down the two provisions that made it criminal to do so but suspended the ruling for 12 months to let the government 'consider whether it wishes to implement a way to deal with the contravention'. The Hong Kong government did not immediately respond. 'This is a matter of the line-drawing, which seems to me to be a question for the government or legislature to address,' Mr Coleman wrote in his judgment. He also said the question of where to draw the line between a 'female person' and a 'male person' is 'an answer not appropriately given by the courts, and is more appropriately a matter for legislation'. The legal challenge was launched by a transgender man, who identifies as K, born as a female and identifies as a man, and who sought to amend the Public Conveniences (Conduct and Behaviour) Regulations to allow individuals undergoing Real Life Experience treatment under medical supervision to use public toilets that align with their gender identity. This is the latest ruling from the city's judiciary in recent years that recognises the rights of transgender people. The city's Court of Final Appeal in February 2023 unanimously sided with appeals launched by transgender activists that barred transgender people from changing their gender on their mandatory ID cards unless they undergo full sex reassignment surgery, saying it violated their rights. The Hong Kong government in April 2024 revised the policy and allowed transgender people who have not completed full sex reassignment surgery to change gender on their ID cards. REUTERS
