Column: President Trump's dramatic ‘Iron Dome' proposal has long history
President Donald Trump's dramatic surprise announcement giving priority to an advanced missile defense to protect the United States continues to generate debate. 'Iron Dome' is the name of the effective anti-missile defenses protecting Israel.
Actually, missile defense is a well-established United States policy. North Korea threats led the Barack Obama administration to deploy Lockheed Martin's THAAD (Terminal High Altitude Air Defense) anti-missile system in South Korea, Hawaii and the island of Guam.
The George W. Bush administration announced the deployment of ballistic missile defenses in Poland and the Czech Republic. Initially, the Obama administration planned to limit such weapons to sea-based forces, but Russia's 2014 annexation of Crimea and Ukraine invasion led to land-based deployment. Thereafter, a NATO summit meeting emphasized missile defense and new troop deployments in Europe.
Debate over the best balance of defensive and offensive military capabilities is as old as warfare. Technology complicates, but does not abolish, this dual challenge.
'Hitting a bullet with a bullet' is the way even proponents of anti-missile systems describe the extraordinary technical challenge. Nonetheless, there has been sustained pressure within the U.S. government for many years to build such weapons.
There also has been a remarkable success in the development of these complex weapon systems.
During the Dwight Eisenhower administration, defense spending absorbed more than half the entire federal budget, and a much larger percentage of gross domestic product than today. Eisenhower maintained control over the military primarily, though not exclusively, by putting an overall ceiling on the Pentagon budget, effectively setting the Air Force, Army and Navy against one another for available resources.
One byproduct was considerable duplication of effort. For example, each service developed a separate strategic missile program, jealously guarding research and development information from the others.
In the successor John F. Kennedy administration, Defense Secretary Robert McNamara was immediately offended by the lack of formal logic in this approach, and decisively imposed organization-chart order. The Air Force was given land-based strategic missiles, the Navy sea-based submarine systems and the Army was removed from any program.
Additionally, McNamara and his civilian analysts rejected arguments for anti-ballistic missiles because any conceivable defensive systems could be overwhelmed at a relatively low cost by simply increasing the number of attack vehicles. Using strategic concepts of that time, which McNamara's team embraced, leaving populations vulnerable was considered stabilizing, and termed 'Mutual Assured Destruction.' Defending missile sites was acceptable, since that move signaled we were not planning to attack the Soviets first.
McNamara's domineering style quickly unified the services against him. The Army eventually achieved an anti-ballistic missile (ABM) role. President Lyndon Johnson, in desperate political trouble over the Vietnam War, forced McNamara to resign. Johnson generously named him president of the World Bank, but also forced him publicly to endorse the ABM.
In the 1980s, President Ronald Reagan promoted space-based missile interceptors, termed the Strategic Defense Initiative. The Air Force became the lead service but the entire Joint Chiefs of Staff endorsed the effort. President Donald Trump during his first term created a new military 'Space Force.'
An erratic, irrational nuclear-armed government or group, actual or potential, argues for developing our defenses. Influential if eccentric nuclear war strategist Herman Kahn used exactly this argument in print to help the humiliated McNamara when the earlier ABM system was announced.
The radical rogue totalitarian regime of North Korea is precisely the sort of threat far-sighted Kahn had in mind.
The startling manner of the White House announcement distracts from this long history.
Arthur I. Cyr is the author of 'After the Cold War' (NYU Press and Macmillan/Palgrave).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Senate Republicans try to get Trump's tax cuts over the line, setting aside cost concerns
By Richard Cowan and Bo Erickson WASHINGTON (Reuters) -U.S. Senate Republicans on Monday will try to pass President Donald Trump's sweeping tax-cut and spending bill, despite divisions within the party about its expected $3.3 trillion hit to the nation's debt pile. They were set for a marathon session in which the minority Democrats are allowed to offer an unlimited number of votes, part of the arcane process Republicans are using to bypass Senate rules that normally require 60 of the chamber's 100 members to agree on legislation. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office released its assessment on Sunday of the bill's hit to the $36.2 trillion debt, figuring that it would add about $800 billion more than the version passed last month in the House of Representatives. Many Republicans dispute that claim, contending that extending existing policy will not add to the debt. Nonetheless, international bond investors see incentives to diversify out of the U.S. Treasury market. Democrats, meanwhile, hope the latest, eye-widening figure could stoke enough anxiety among fiscally minded conservatives to get them to buck their party, which controls both chambers of Congress. 'Republicans are doing something the Senate has never, never done before, deploying fake math and accounting gimmicks to hide the true cost of the bill," Democratic Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said on Sunday. "Republicans are about to pass the single most expensive bill in U.S. history to give tax breaks to billionaires while taking away Medicaid, SNAP benefits and good-paying jobs for millions of people." The Senate narrowly advanced the tax-cut, immigration, border and military spending bill in a procedural vote late on Saturday, voting 51-49 to open debate on the 940-page megabill. One powerful illustration of the Republican divide came on Sunday when Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina said he would not seek re-election, after Trump threatened to back a challenger to him in next year's midterm elections over his vote against the bill. Trump on social media has hailed the progress as a "great victory" for his "great, big, beautiful bill." In a separate post on Sunday, he said: "We will make it all up, times 10, with GROWTH, more than ever before." Trump wants the bill passed before the July 4 Independence Day holiday. While that deadline is one of choice, lawmakers will face a far more serious deadline later this summer when they must raise the nation's self-imposed debt ceiling or risk a devastating default. If the Senate succeeds in passing the bill, it will then go to the House, where members are also divided, with some angry about its cost and others worried about cuts to the Medicaid program. Republicans can afford to lose no more than three votes in either chamber to pass a bill the Democrats are united in opposition to. HITS TO BENEFITS The legislation was the sole focus of a marathon weekend congressional session marked by political drama, division and lengthy delays as Democrats seek to slow the legislation's path to passage. Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky, the other Republican "no" vote, opposed the legislation because it would raise the federal borrowing limit by an additional $5 trillion. The megabill would extend the 2017 tax cuts that were Trump's main legislative achievement during his first term as president, cut other taxes and boost spending on the military and border security. Senate Republicans, who reject the CBO's estimates on the cost of the legislation, are set on using an alternative calculation method that does not factor in costs from extending the 2017 tax cuts. Outside tax experts, like Andrew Lautz from the nonpartisan think tank Bipartisan Policy Center, call it a "magic trick." Using this calculation method, the Senate Republicans' budget bill appears to cost substantially less and seems to save $500 billion, according to the BPC analysis. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
CNN
28 minutes ago
- CNN
5 things to know for June 30: Idaho shooting, Trump bill, US-Canada, Iran, escaped inmates
The Justice Department has reportedly fired at least three prosecutors involved in criminal cases tied to the 2021 US Capitol riot. In recent months, the DOJ has also terminated employees who worked on prosecutions against President Donald Trump and demoted many career supervisors who were seen as insufficiently loyal to the president. Here's what else you need to know to Get Up to Speed and On with Your Day. Two firefighters were killed and a third was injured on Sunday when they came under attack while responding to a brush fire in Coeur d'Alene, Idaho. 'It's clear to me that this fire was set intentionally to draw us in,' one firefighter said while calling for help. Residents were asked to shelter in place as hundreds of local, state and federal law enforcement converged on the area to look for the gunman. Then on Sunday night, a deceased man was found on Canfield Mountain with a firearm nearby, and the shelter in place order was lifted. The man is believed to have started the fire before shooting at the responding firefighters, the Kootenai County sheriff said. The Senate's marathon voting session on President Trump's sweeping agenda bill is expected to begin at 9 a.m. today. During the session, known as a vote-a-rama, lawmakers may offer as many amendments to the bill as they want to vote on. Only after that's finished can a final vote on the bill be held. Over the weekend, North Carolina Sen. Thom Tillis announced that he would not be seeking reelection next year. Tillis is one of only two Republicans who voted against advancing the tax and spending cuts package, citing concerns about the impact that cuts to Medicaid would have on his constituents. On his social media site, Trump called Tillis' decision 'Great News!' In a bid to restart trade negotiations with the Trump administration, Canada announced on Sunday that it will rescind its digital services tax. Set to take effect today, it would have taxed online services from large tech companies, such as Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta and Microsoft — retroactive to 2022. On Friday, President Trump canceled trade talks between the two nations and blamed the tax, saying it was 'a direct and blatant attack' on the US. Following its latest tax decision, the Canadian government said Prime Minister Mark Carney and Trump had decided to resume trade talks 'with a view towards agreeing on a deal by July 21, 2025.' US strikes on Iran last week fell short of causing total damage to its nuclear program, and the Islamic Republic could start enriching uranium 'in a matter of months,' according to the head of the UN's nuclear watchdog. Rafael Grossi's comments on CBS Sunday appear to support an early assessment from the Pentagon's Defense Intelligence Agency, first reported by CNN, which suggested the US strikes did not destroy the core components of Iran's nuclear program and likely only set it back by months. President Trump decried the CNN story and has claimed the US attack set Tehran's ambitions back by decades. Authorities have captured another inmate who escaped from a New Orleans jail on May 16. Antoine Massey, 33, a serial escapee who was most recently charged with vehicle theft and domestic abuse involving strangulation, was arrested Friday in a rental property just miles from the Orleans Justice Center where he and nine other inmates made their brazen getaway. In the weeks since they fled, the police have arrested nine of the fugitives. Derrick Groves, the last remaining escapee, is still on the run. Groves was convicted of killing two people in 2018 and later pleaded guilty to battery of a corrections officer. There is a $50,000 reward for information leading to his capture. Fox News suedThe $787 million lawsuit stems from a dispute between California Gov. Gavin Newsom and President Trump over the timing of a phone call during LA's recent immigration protests. Bey is safe!Singer Beyoncé had to briefly stop the show in Houston after her 'flying' car prop experienced a mishap in midair. No biting, sirActress Alicia Hannah-Kim called the police to a fan convention in Washington and accused one of her 'Cobra Kai' co-stars of assaulting her. A forest returnsUnderwater forests of crayweed are slowly being restored off Australia's southeastern coast after disappearing in the 1980s, likely due to dumped sewage. Blue screen goes bye byeMicrosoft's infamous 'blue screen of death,' which would appear on computer monitors whenever Windows users experienced 'unexpected restarts,' will soon be retired. 110,000That's how many Russian troops have amassed near the eastern Ukrainian city of Pokrovsk. Russian forces have been trying to capture the area for almost a year. 'You can put any lipstick you want on this pig, but it's still a pig.'— Virginia Democratic Sen. Mark Warner, on President Trump's massive policy bill. Check your local forecast here>>> Despite a heat wave, massive crowds protested the Hungarian government's anti-LGBTQ legislation during Budapest Pride over the weekend.
29 minutes ago
Asian shares are mixed after US stocks hit an all-time high
BANGKOK -- Asian shares started the week with gains after U.S. stocks closed at an all-time high following their recovery from the shocks of the Trump administration's trade policies. Canada's decision to cancel a plan to tax U.S. technology firms that had led President Donald Trump to halt trade talks helped to steady the markets. U.S. stock futures advanced after Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said the talks had resumed. In Tokyo, the Nikkei 225 climbed 0.8% to 40,487.39. Hong Kong's Hang Seng lost 0.3% to 24,084.20, while the Shanghai Composite index advanced 0.6% to 3,444.43. China reported that its factory activity improved slightly in June after Beijing and Washington agreed in May to postpone imposing higher tariffs on each others' exports, though manufacturing remained in contraction. In South Korea, the Kospi gained 0.5% to 3,071.70. Australia's S&P/ASX 200 rose 0.3% to 8,542.30. Taiwan's Taiex lost 1.4% and the Sensex in India was down 0.6%. In Bangkok, the SET gained 0.4%. On Friday, the S&P 500 rose 0.5% to 6,173.07, above its previous record set in February. The key measure of Wall Street's health fell nearly 20% from Feb. 19 through April 8. The Nasdaq composite gained 0.5% to 20,273.46, its own all-time high. The Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 1% to 43,819.27. The gains on Friday were broad, with nearly every sector within the S&P 500 rising. Nike soared 15.2% for the biggest gain in the market, despite warning of a steep hit from tariffs. An update on inflation Friday showed prices ticked higher in May, though the rate mostly matched economists' projections. Inflation remains a big concern. Trump's on-again-off-again tariff policy has made it difficult for companies to make financial forecasts and strained household budgets. A long list of businesses from carmakers to retailers have warned that higher import taxes will likely hurt their revenues and profits. The U.S. has 10% baseline tariffs on all imported goods, along with higher rates for Chinese goods and other import taxes on steel and autos and the threat of more severe tariffs continues to hang over the economy. The current pause on a round of retaliatory tariffs against a long list of nations is set to expire on July 9. Failure to negotiate deals or further postpone the tariffs could once again rattle investors and consumers. In an interview with Fox News Channel's 'Sunday Morning Futures,' Trump said his administration will notify countries that the trade penalties will take effect unless there are deals with the United States. Letters will start going out 'pretty soon' before the approaching deadline, he said. The Federal Reserve is monitoring the tariff situation with a big focus on inflation. The rate of inflation has been stubbornly sitting just above the central bank's target of 2%. In a report Friday, its preferred gauge, the personal consumption expenditures index, rose to 2.3% in May. That's up from 2.2% the previous month. The Fed cut interest rates three times in late 2024 following a historic series of rate hikes to cool inflation. The PCE was as high as 7.2% in 2022 while the more commonly used consumer price index hit 9.1%. The Fed hasn't cut rates so far in 2025 over worries that tariffs could reignite inflation and hamper the economy. Economists still expect at least two rate cuts before the end of the year. Bond yields held relatively steady. The yield on the 10-year Treasury fell to 4.25% from 4.27% late Friday. The two-year Treasury yield, which more closely tracks expectations for what the Federal Reserve will do, stood at 3.73%. In other dealings early Monday, U.S. benchmark crude oil lost 31 cents to $65.21 per barrel. Brent crude, the international standard, gave up 20 cents to $66.60 per barrel. The U.S. dollar fell to 144.06 Japanese yen from 144.46 yen. The euro fell $1.1722 from $1.1725.
