Author to sue Kangana's firm over ‘Emergency' adaptation
Kapoor, whose 2015 book chronicles the 1975–77 Emergency era, alleged the film contains 'glaring historical inaccuracies' that contradict her work, mislead viewers and damage her credibility as a scholar and writer. HT reached out to Netflix and Manikarnika Films but the two had not responded till the time of going to press.
Kapoor said in 2021, Ranaut's brother, Aksht Ranaut of Manikarnika Films, approached her for the rights to adapt a single chapter from her book focused on Indira Gandhi. A tripartite agreement was signed between Kapoor, Penguin (the publisher), and the production house, with Kapoor's lawyers inserting clauses to protect her work, the writer said. The contract mandated that the film's content align with 'historical facts in the public domain' and barred the use of Kapoor's name or book title for promotion without her written consent. Despite this, Kapoor said, she was never consulted on the script and discovered only after the film's Netflix release on March 17 that it prominently credited her book as its basis.
The movie's disclaimer on Netflix said, 'The film is inspired by the book 'The Emergency' by Coomi Kapoor and 'Priyadarshani' by Jaiyanth Vasant Shinde.' The disclaimer then towards the end says, 'The film 'Emergency' is based on the books 'The Emergency' by Coomi Kapoor and 'Priyadarshani' by Jaiyanth Vasant Shinde.'
Kapoor said she messaged Ranaut on WhatsApp in 2023 to insist the term 'based on' not be used. Ranaut assured compliance but never shared the script or responded to follow-ups, the writer said. When the film was initially released in theatres in January 17, Kapoor said, she was travelling and relied on reviews that noted a disclaimer about being 'inspired by' her book. Later, when she watched the Netflix version, Kapoor said, she discovered the claim of it being 'based on' her work. 'They ignored everything I wrote and presented rubbish,' Kapoor said.
Among the inaccuracies she highlighted is the film's portrayal of Akbar Ahmed, a friend of Sanjay Gandhi, as being blamed for banning Kishore Kumar's songs on All India Radio. Kapoor's book explicitly identified then information and broadcasting minister VC Shukla as responsible, a detail Ahmed confronted her about after watching the film, the writer said. 'I had to explain my book never made those claims,' she said. Other errors include falsely depicting journalist Nikhil Chakravarty — who was never jailed during the Emergency — as being imprisoned, and conflating timelines around the Emergency's revocation and 1977 elections, according to Kapoor.
Legal notices sent to Netflix and Manikarnika earlier this month demanding the removal of the 'based on' credit went unheeded, prompting the lawsuit, Kapoor said, adding that the film's errors are not merely artistic licence but a breach of trust
The lawsuit will seek damages and the removal of all references to her book from the film's promotional material. 'This isn't just about legalities,' she said. 'It's about preserving historical truth and the integrity of my life's work.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
44 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Detective Ujjwalan' OTT release: Dhyan Sreenivasan starrer to stream on THIS platform
(Picture Courtesy: Facebook) After a decent theatrical run since its release on May 23, 2025, 'Detective Ujjwalan', starring Dhyan Sreenivasan , has kept fans guessing about its digital debut. Now, reports suggest that the wait might be over soon. The film is reportedly heading to Netflix for its OTT release — though no official date has been confirmed yet. According to film industry buzz, including a social media post by AB George, Netflix is believed to have picked up the digital rights. This move comes as a surprise to many, as the streaming giant hasn't often backed Malayalam films in recent months. So why Detective Ujjwalan? The 'Minnal Murali' connection Industry insiders speculate that the decision is largely due to the film's ties with Minnal Murali, the Tovino Thomas superhero hit. Detective Ujjwalan is set in the same cinematic universe — known as the Weekend Cinematic Universe — and takes place in the neighboring village of Plaachikkaavu. That shared universe connection may have been key in attracting Netflix's interest. On the TV front, there's also chatter that ZEE Network has acquired the satellite rights. What the film Is about and ETimes verdict Directed by Indraneel Gopeekrishnan and Rahul G, Detective Ujjwalan follows a quirky local detective navigating through minor village crimes — until a chilling series of murders shakes up his sleepy hometown. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Is your tinnitus getting worse? Do this immediately (Watch) Hearing Magazine Undo ETimes gave the Dhyan Sreenivasan starrer a rating of 2.5 stars out of 5 and our official review reads, "There are some rules that a detective story needs to make it work and for the effect to stay with us. Some red herrings that will confuse the audience so that we are emotionally and intellectually caught up in the story, a detective who uses logic that will baffle us with its brilliance and a final revelation of the culprit that will shock us. Detective Ujjwalan does not use any of these devices in a forceful enough manner. The period settings are interesting and the village characters are loveable enough, though some of the superb comic talents from social media, Ameen, Nihal Nizam, Nibraz and Shahubas, are barely utilised. The film seems to go in the direction of most Dhyan films; a bit of an anti-climax."
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Metro In Dino OTT release: When and where to stream Aditya Roy Kapur, Sara Ali Khan's film
Anurag Basu's much-awaited romantic drama Metro… In Dino finally hit theatres on July 4, nearly 18 years after his acclaimed 2007 film Life in a… Metro. Touted as a spiritual sequel, the film explores the highs and lows of modern-day relationships in a fast-paced urban setting, a theme that resonated deeply with audiences in the original. Featuring an ensemble cast including Aditya Roy Kapur, Sara Ali Khan, Neena Gupta, Anupam Kher, Konkona Sen Sharma, Pankaj Tripathi, Fatima Sana Shaikh, and Ali Fazal, the film has opened to a positive response for its poignant storytelling, soulful music, and nuanced performances. Interestingly, Konkona Sen Sharma is the only actor returning from the original film. While Metro… In Dino continues its theatrical run, it has also locked its OTT partner — Netflix. Though an official streaming date hasn't been announced yet, films typically arrive online 45 to 60 days after their theatrical release, which means the film could drop on the platform by late August or early September. In a recent interview, Konkona Sen Sharma recalled her experience filming Life in a… Metro, especially working with the late Irrfan Khan and Anurag Basu. 'Irrfan had such a relaxed energy, and so does Anurag. They never made the work feel too serious or heavy — the atmosphere on set was always light and creative,' she shared. First announced in 2022, Metro… In Dino brings back Basu's signature storytelling style, weaving multiple narratives with emotional depth. Whether you catch it in cinemas or wait for the Netflix premiere, this one's definitely worth adding to your watchlist. Meanwhile, on Day 2 of its release, the movie collected ₹ 3.39 crore on Saturday (Day 2), bringing its total domestic earnings to ₹ 6.89 crore. According to industry estimates, 'Metro In Dino' recorded an average theatre occupancy of: This reflects an upward trend from its first day, with afternoon viewership significantly improving across urban centres. The film performed best in southern cities, with Chennai reporting the highest occupancy rate at 69%. Bengaluru followed with 46.5%, and Hyderabad posted 34.5%.
New Indian Express
2 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Outsider by choice
The exercise, he says, was one of unlearning. 'To pretend to not know acting—when it's what I've done my entire life—is to go against my own instincts. And to do that without looking fake, to make the audience believe I was someone unequipped with technique, required a very different approach. I had to believe it myself first.' For Siddiqui, belief is the cornerstone of craft. 'You have to believe that this world you're in is real. In this case, I had to believe I was someone who had never acted before. That belief had to come before anything else.' Despite his success, Siddiqui remains deeply connected to the uncertainties that marked his early years. An alumnus of the National School of Drama, he began with minor, often overlooked roles in films like Sarfarosh and Munna Bhai MBBS. Recognition came gradually—first through Anurag Kashyap's Black Friday and then more substantially with Peepli Live and Gangs of Wasseypur, the latter making him a definitive voice in the new wave of Hindi cinema. Over the past decade, he has earned both acclaim and audience admiration for roles in Manto, Photograph, and the acclaimed Netflix series Sacred Games. Yet, for all his achievements, Siddiqui does not romanticise the industry. If anything, he is one of its most vocal critics. He speaks of a troubling creative stagnation, calling it a kind of 'creatocracy', a system where commerce replaces originality and comfort overrides experimentation. His concerns are not unfounded. 'We've normalised lifting—from songs to scripts, from international cinema to the Southern film industries. Even some so-called cult films are nothing more than polished remakes. Where is the originality in that?' He also points to the increasing reliance on marketing gimmicks and manipulated success metrics. 'You can inflate numbers, buy good reviews, and even book your own shows to make a film seem like a hit. But you can't sustain it. The audience is too intelligent now. They know the difference between what's being sold and what's being felt,' he adds.
