France Proposes Law to Accelerate Return of Colonial-Era Looted Artefacts to Africa

Daily News Egypt

a day ago

In a significant step toward addressing the legacy of colonial-era injustice, the French government has unveiled a new draft law that would dramatically accelerate the return of cultural artefacts looted from former colonies, especially in Africa. The bill—presented by the Ministry of Culture—aims to simplify the restitution process by removing existing bureaucratic hurdles and creating a clearer legal framework that allows for faster, more transparent repatriation of looted objects.
The proposed law marks a pivotal shift in France's policy toward its colonial-era collections, many of which were amassed through acts of violence, coercion, or unequal power dynamics during periods of imperial rule. If passed, the legislation would end the requirement that each restitution be approved through separate parliamentary legislation—a time-consuming process that has slowed down the return of many contested pieces.
Instead, decisions would be made via executive decree issued by the Council of State, France's highest administrative court, following a recommendation from a newly established scientific commission. This independent commission will include historians, curators, and legal experts from both France and the country making the restitution claim. The commission will be responsible for investigating the provenance of contested items and determining whether their acquisition violated ethical or legal norms, such as being taken under duress or through theft.
Importantly, the draft law introduces a limited exception to France's longstanding principle of inaliénabilité (inalienability), which holds that objects in the national collections cannot be removed or sold. The law would allow such objects to be restituted if it is determined that they were acquired through illegal or unethical means between the years 1815 and 1972.
These dates are not arbitrary. The year 1815 marks the beginning of early European discussions on the return of artworks looted during the Napoleonic wars, while 1972 is the year when UNESCO's Convention on the Protection of Cultural Property came into force, providing a formal international framework against the illicit trade in cultural goods.
The law comes in response to increasing international pressure and growing calls for European countries to return artefacts taken during colonial rule. France in particular has faced mounting criticism, with many African governments, academics, and civil society groups urging Paris to fulfill long-standing promises of restitution.
President Emmanuel Macron first signaled a new direction in French policy during a landmark speech in Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso, in 2017, where he declared that 'African heritage cannot be the prisoner of European museums.' In the years since, France has returned 26 artefacts to Benin and handed over items to Senegal, marking a symbolic yet limited start to broader restitution efforts.
If enacted, the new legislation could open the door to the return of thousands of artefacts currently held in French institutions, including the Quai Branly Museum in Paris, which houses one of the largest collections of African art in Europe.
Beyond the legal mechanisms, the proposed bill also reflects a deeper acknowledgment of the need to rebuild trust and cultural partnership between France and its former colonies. It signals a readiness to confront uncomfortable aspects of colonial history and to promote a more equitable framework for cultural exchange and heritage preservation.
As debates over cultural restitution gain momentum across Europe, France's draft law could set a precedent for other countries grappling with the legacy of empire. Observers say that if implemented effectively and transparently, the legislation could become a model for responsible restitution in the 21st century.