Lam sisters called family for help amid alleged abuse before killing their mother, court hears
Article content
On the day of Kieu Lam's death, her son received a call from his sisters asking for help after days of escalating abuse, only for their mother to take the daughter's phone away, a jury heard Friday.
The brothers are expected to testify next week when the defence begins its case.
Article content
Sisters Chau Kanh Lam and Hue Ai Lam are facing first-degree murder charges in the death of their mother, Kieu Lam, on Oct. 31, 2022.
Article content
Article content
Article content
Defence lawyer Ewan Lyttle, who is representing Chau, gave his opening statements to the jury Friday morning after the Crown closed its case against the Lam sisters.
Article content
Article content
The jury heard how Kieu gave her daughters a life devoid of love, compassion and protection. Instead, Chau and Hue's life was filled with 'control, violence and cruelty,' Lyttle said.
Article content
'Kieu Lam gave life to her daughters but Kieu Lam did not give her daughters a life.'
Article content
On Monday, the defence will begin presenting evidence and calling up witnesses, where Chau and Hue are expected to testify through a Vietnamese interpreter. Their older brothers are also expected to testify to their mother's alleged abusive nature throughout their lives.
Article content
The jury heard how the brothers witnessed the alleged abuse starting in the Lam sisters' early life in Vietnam, when they were beaten with straps, and continued at their home on Bowmount Street.
Article content
Article content
One of the brothers will say that Kieu was ashamed of her daughters for not getting married and not being able to work at times, Lyttle said. When Hue developed Parkinson's disease and was unable to work, Kieu's abuse allegedly escalated further, as Hue was the family's main source of income.
Article content
Article content
'They feared for their safety and had to kill their mother to end a decades-long mental and physical campaign of violence,' Lyttle said.
Article content
The jury heard that Kieu made the 'whole family suffer' and one of the brothers had to physically prevent their mother from attacking his sisters, Chau and Hue.
Article content
'Both brothers will tell you that their mother adhered to strict old-fashioned Vietnamese rules,' Lyttle said. In the culture they were raised in, he says no child would 'ever dare fight back.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Calgary Herald
10 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Jury begins deliberations in case of Calgary man accused of torturing and killing multiple rabbits
The fate of suspected Calgary serial rabbit killer Nicholas Weseen is now in the hands of jurors — at least for now. Article content The 12-member Calgary Court of King's Bench jury began their deliberations Friday afternoon after hearing final legal instructions from Justice Michel Bourque. Article content Article content But if they find Weseen guilty on any of the 13 animal abuse charges Crown prosecutor Rose Greenwood is seeking convictions on, his lawyer will likely ask for an assessment of his client. Article content Article content Defence counsel Eric Nelson-Addy told Bourque earlier this week he will seek psychiatric testing on his client to determine if he qualifies for a defence of not criminally responsible by reason of a mental disorder. Article content Article content 'There are reasonable grounds for such an assessment,' Nelson-Addy told the judge during proceedings in the absence of the jury. Article content Under the Criminal Code, portions of a court proceeding conducted in the absence of jurors are subject to a publication ban until they retire to deliberate the case. Article content Nelson-Addy said both his client's interview with Calgary police Det. Mark Weir and evidence from Weseen's former girlfriend Amy Miko, raised concerns about his client's mental health. Article content During his Jan. 22, 2023, police interview Weseen told Weir that when the rabbits were being harmed and killed it felt like someone else took over his body. Article content Article content 'It literally feels like there's a second person in control,' the city man said. Article content But in her closing arguments to jurors on Thursday, Greenwood asked jurors to ignore what she referred to as a 'charade' by Weseen to justify his unlawful behaviour by blaming the abuse on his alter ego. Article content Nelson-Addy had argued for an outright acquittal saying the Crown had failed to prove its case against Weseen beyond a reasonable doubt. Article content The assessment, if ordered by Bourque, would look into whether Weseen was suffering a mental disorder at the time which rendered him incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of his actions and that what he was doing was wrong. Article content
Calgary Herald
11 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Kidnappers flew from Vancouver to Calgary to abduct city teen for ransom, court told
Kidnappers flew from Vancouver to Calgary to abduct a city teen who was bound with duct tape and held for ransom, court heard Friday. Article content Reading in a statement of agreed facts, Crown prosecutor Katherine Love told Justice Margaret Keelaghan of the female victim's harrowing experience. Article content Article content She said Raejean Hudson, 25, and Enyi-Egbe Idedevbo, 29, along with an unidentified third man, staked out the 19-year-old victim on April 29, 2023, before returning to her place of work three days later. Article content Article content When the girl, identified by the initials L.E., finished her shift on May 2, 2023, she wen out to the parking lot to her car, Love said. Article content Article content 'Upon reaching the driver's door of her vehicle, L.E. was grabbed by one of the males while the other two remained in the front seat of (their) vehicle. That male forced her to the floor of the back seat of the Santa Fe,' Love said. Article content 'She was forced into a position where she could not see where the vehicle was being driving.' Article content The trio took the victim to an Airbnb by the people that had been arranged by the people who hired them, Love said. Article content Victim had no idea why she was being kidnapped Article content 'There L.E. was taken to a room in the basement. She could see that there was something like black plastic covering the walls and floor. L.E.'s wrists, ankles and eyes were then bound with duct tape. One of the males recorded L.E. like this while another held an unlit butane torch in front of her face.' Article content Article content Less than a half hour after the abduction the victim's brother, who was overseas received the video from an unknown individual on a social media platform. Article content A still photo showing the teen bound by duct tape around her wrists, ankles and face, sitting on black plastic with a hand holding a butane tank was included in the agreed facts. Article content 'It shows the butane torch, Ms. L.E., and the black covering in the room,' Love said. Article content 'At the time she was kidnapped, she was unaware that she was related to anyone who was. She had no idea why she was being abducted,' the prosecutor said.
CBC
14 hours ago
- CBC
Prosecutors press Chau Lam on her mother's killing
Crown prosecutors spent the better part of two days this week pressing Chau Lam about the 2022 killing of her 88-year-old mother. Chau Lam, 59, and her sister Hue Lam, 62, each pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder in the October 2022 death of their mother, Kieu Lam. The jury trial began earlier this month in the Superior Court of Justice in Ottawa. Testifying in Vietnamese through a translator, Chau Lam began her testimony earlier this week by telling the court she loved her mother — and that she killed her. "I was scared my mother would hit my sister to death, she would hit me to death," she said. "Sometimes she just used a stick to hit us in the head. We had to protect ourselves." Since their arrest, the sisters have said they endured years of physical and emotional abuse at the hands of their mother. During Chau Lam's testimony, the court heard about her mother's history of medical issues, including a fractured hip and shoulder, and repeated visits to doctors and hospitals in the years leading up to her death. Chau Lam told the jury her mother never directly threatened to kill them, but said the violence had been escalating before the killing. Under cross-examination, Chau Lam could not point to any specific serious assaults or injuries inflicted by her mother. She also agreed there were no defensive wounds on her body when she was arrested. Prosecutors challenged the defence's argument the sisters were under their mother's control, noting that one held a job, they attended temple and both had taken English classes. The Crown has argued Kieu Lam gave life to her daughters, only to have hers taken. Prosecutors previously told the jury the woman was "sleeping defenceless" in bed when the sisters smashed her head with a hammer and strangled her. Chau Lam acknowledged that she was "angry" at the time of the killing — as she told police following her arrest. Difficult testimony The court recessed several times Thursday and Friday as Chau Lam became emotional under questioning. At one point, she broke down while describing how the abuse worsened after her sister was diagnosed with Parkinson's disease. "I'm a human being. I know what is right and what is wrong," she said. "It's not that my mom just scolded us a few times and then we would get upset and kill our mom," she added, saying if her mom had given them "a little bit of love" they would be content. As testimony continued, Chau at one point Thursday said she could no longer go on. "No matter how many times, you will not understand," she told the court. "I will now stop talking. The more I talk, the more it looks like I tried to blame my mom, so I [will] stop talking." Court was adjourned for the day. It resumed Friday with further cross-examination focused on the condition of the victim, who was 88 years old and used a walker. After 16 minutes of questioning, Chau again became emotional and another break was required. She told the jury: "The more people talk, people say that I try to blame my mom. My mom's already dead. If my mom was still alive, then I am not sitting here."
