Michael Flatley being portrayed as a villain rather than a victim, court told
Michael Flatley
is being portrayed in proceedings before the
Commercial Court
as 'a villain' rather than 'a victim of circumstances', his counsel has told a judge.
It was the second day of two applications before the court where a building contractor and insurance companies involved in carrying out works at Flatley's Castlehyde mansion in Co Cork are seeking to have the star
put up €2.8 million security for costs
before his action against them begins.
Mr Flatley's counsel Ronnie Hudson BL, instructed by Maxwell Mooney solicitor, on Wednesday referred to what he called the characterisation of the entertainer by the other side in court.
'He is being portrayed as a villain rather than a victim, a victim of circumstances,' Mr Hudson said.
READ MORE
The statement was made as the Flatley side sought to introduce a chartered accountant's valuation of the Flatley whiskey business which the court had previously heard was worth in the region of €10 million.
Andrew Fitzpatrick SC for the underwriting and insurance defendants objected to the new information being put before the court and he said it was 'a naked attempt to upend this application'.
And he said there was no evidence why the valuation was not available when documents were being exchanged in advance of the security for costs hearing.
Counsel for building contractor Austin Newport, Stephen Dowling SC, said allowing the new document in at this stage could open up a collateral hearing on the basis of the €10 million valuation.
Ms Justice Eileen Roberts said it was not obvious to her why the information was not put before the court when there were ongoing directions in place in relation to the exchange of documents.
[
Michael Flatley says request to put up €2.8m as security for costs is an attempt to embarrass him
Opens in new window
]
The judge said she did not want to completely derail the security for costs hearing and she refused to admit the document.
Mr Hudson told the court that in the security for costs application, Michael Flatley was being faced with a bill for almost €3 million 'for defending himself'.
He said Mr Flatley has never defaulted and is a 'man of means and a man of his word'. He said Mr Flatley 'in theory can return' to Castlehyde but he 'can't in practice because of the condition of the property'.
'Michael Flatley is a man of his word and has a considerable reputation in Ireland and the US,' Mr Hudson said.
In an affidavit opened to the court at the start of the hearing on Tuesday, Mr Flatley said the Lord of the Dance show is continuing to sell out venues worldwide and has sold more than €1 billion-worth of tickets.
Lord of the Dance, which he said had received 'a lifetime of standing ovations', has been valued 'at a conservative minimum of €200 million'.
[
Michael Flatley: The deal that let the dancer keep his Castlehyde mansion
Opens in new window
]
Mr Flatley said his Statement of Affairs – which valued Lord of the Dance at €200 million, his whiskey business at €10 million and his Castlehyde mansion at €20 million – is accurate. He said he owns all of the rights and intellectual property for Lord of the Dance and that the true valuation could be double the €200 million figure.
He said his liability is a €7.9 million mortgage on Castlehyde which will be repaid from his business activities over the next two years.
In the affidavit which was sworn last month, Mr Flatley also said he 'intends to return to live in Ireland permanently as soon as possible'.
In the main proceedings, the Riverdance performer claims he and his family had to vacate the Castlehyde period property in October 2023 after alleged toxic chemical residue was detected during routine maintenance.
Mr Flatley is suing Austin Newport Group Ltd, the main contractor and insurance underwriters – MS Amlin Underwriting Ltd, AXA XL Underwriting Agencies LTD and Hamilton Managing Agency Limited along with Lloyds Insurance Company.
All of the allegations are denied.
Ms Justice Eileen Roberts will give her decision on security for costs at a later date.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Doctor who had opioid addiction is spared jail for stealing and forging prescriptions
A doctor who told a court that work stress caused his chronic opioid addiction and led him to steal and forge prescriptions is to be spared jail and a criminal record. Daniel Nevin (39) pleaded guilty at Mullingar Circuit Criminal Court to the theft of prescription pads from two hospitals, 46 counts of forgery and using false instruments between 2021 and last year. His fiancee Rebecca Moylan (35), a qualified nurse, admitted stealing prescriptions and unlawfully using them in pharmacies. Judge Keenan Johnson said these offences undermined the integrity of the medical prescription system and said Nevin was in the throes of an addiction but had never put a patient at risk. READ MORE He said the couple whose careers have been ruined and reputations tarnished had only damaged themselves, saying, 'The main victims of this are the two accused.' Nevin achieved a PhD from Trinity College Dublin, specialising in pharmacology, and had worked in medical research in Australia before returning to Ireland to continue his studies. He qualified as a medical doctor in 2018. When the addiction started in 2019 he tried to tackle the problem, but relapsed around the period of offending. Judge Johnson said Nevin was a 'high achiever', but had removed himself from working onwards as a clinician and moved into a tutoring role at Midlands Regional General Hospital. The judge was also mindful of the pressures placed on medical professionals working 24-hour shifts in busy environments. He said the couple did not reach the threshold for a custodial sentence and said they had paid a huge price. Judge Johnson said they could be spared convictions and would receive the benefit of the Probation of Offenders Act if Nevin and his fiancee donated €15,000 and €5,000 respectively to the Merchant Quay drug treatment project as a form of restorative justice. Among Nevin's charges were thefts of prescriptions from University Hospital Galway between July 2021 and July 2023 and from the Midlands Regional General Hospital in Mullingar from July 10th, 2023, until February 18th last year. The remaining charges he admitted included three counts of using false prescriptions in pharmacies in Kells, Co Meath, at Kilbeggan, Co Westmeath, and in Tullamore, Co Offaly. Moylan admitted theft of prescription pads from St James's Hospital in Dublin from September 1st, 2023, until November that year and using prescriptions forged by her partner in several pharmacies. The couple, of Greenpark Meadows, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath, used a fictitious patient's name on most of the prescriptions to get OxyContin, a highly addictive opioid-based medicine. Their offending was exposed when a pharmacist in Mullingar became suspicious in May last year, the court heard. He contacted University Hospital Galway and discovered they had no record of the prescription or the named patient. In court, Nevin agreed with his barrister, Colm Smyth SC, that the 'stress and strain of the job precipitated and aggravated' Nevin's addiction. The doctor initially managed to buy opioids online before he sought help to tackle the problem. He said after a substantial period of sobriety, he had a relapse, resulting in a prolonged absence from work and 'I took myself out of the clinician domain'. He said he switched to a teaching role in the hospital, saying he was passionate about education. Nevin said the consequences had been devastating. He expressed remorse and said he was attending addiction counselling. The court heard how Moylan, while studying to be a nurse, had cared for her terminally ill mother. Dara Foynes SC, defending, said Moylan acted out of the highest level of compassion and concern for her partner and was trying to manage a situation that was out of control, resulting in self-inflicted harm and a fall from grace. The court heard Moylan has resigned from her job, agreed not to work as a nurse again, while Nevin awaited a decision on the future of his medical career. Their court case was adjourned until Friday.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
George Gibney consents to extradition to Ireland to face sex crime charges
George Gibney , the former Irish Olympic swimming team coach, has formally consented to being extradited from the US to Ireland to face 79 sex crime charges. He has also withdrawn a request to fight his continued detention, which was due to be heard in court on Friday. Mr Gibney remains in custody in the US on foot of a request to the authorities in Florida, where he has been living, to arrest him for the purposes of extradition. The 77-year-old is accused of 78 charges of indecent assault and one of attempted rape. The alleged victims were aged between eight and 14 or 15 years when they say they were abused by Mr Gibney, who was their swimming coach in South Dublin at different times between 1971 and 1981. READ MORE In the latest court filings related to his case, Mr Gibney's lawyer Alec Fitzgerald Hall sets out how he consulted with his client on Tuesday and fully advised him of his rights in the extradition process. This included his rights to a detention hearing and an extradition hearing. Arising from that meeting, he said Mr Gibney has 'decided to withdraw his request to a detention hearing and stipulate to detention'. He has also stated he wants to 'waive his extradition hearing and be extradited to Ireland'. Mr Fitzgerald Hall added that an 'affidavit of waiver of extradition hearing' would be filed 'as soon as possible'. Mr Gibney's extradition to the Republic will now proceed and he is likely to appear before a Dublin court in the near future. He had requested a detention hearing in the US, but the US attorney for the Middle District of Florida, Gregory W Kehoe, last week urged the district court in Orlando to deny any application for bail for Mr Gibney pending his extradition. The court was told that as Mr Gibney was facing such serious criminal charges in Ireland, and the prospect of spending the rest of his life in jail, he had an incentive to flee if granted bail. In 1993, Mr Gibney appeared before the courts in Dublin charged with 27 sexual crimes. However, he took a High Court challenge to his prosecution and was successful. The court effectively ruled in 1994 that the allegations were too old, and many details were too vague, to warrant a prosecution. However, legal norms and legislation have since changed in Ireland, meaning the prosecution of historical sexual crimes now regularly occurs. Suspects in historical cases no longer have the grounds they once did to avoid prosecution. Mr Gibney left Ireland in the 1990s, settling in the US, and remained there for the past 30 years, residing in Florida in recent years. However, between 2020 and 2022 the BBC-Second Captains podcast, entitled Where is George Gibney?, prompted the four women now accusing him to give statements to the Garda. A fresh criminal investigation began, with the Director of Public Prosecutions directing in May 2023 that he should face 79 charges, with arrest warrants issued by the courts in Dublin. Last October, the Irish embassy in Washington formally made a request to the US authorities to arrest Mr Gibney for the purpose of extraditing to the Republic to stand trial. He was detained by US marshals in Florida on July 1st and remains in custody there.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Price of grocery staples running well ahead of general inflation
Irish consumers are paying €1.10 more for a pound of butter than this time last year, according to the Central Statistics Office (CSO) . The figure comes as the annual rate of inflation overall edged up to 1.8 per cent in June, from 1.7 per cent the previous month, the lowest reading this year. Excluding energy and unprocessed food, prices in general were 2 per cent higher than at this time last year. On a monthly basis, prices were 0.5 per cent higher compared to May, driven in large part by higher cost of package holidays which jumped 22.1 per cent. That saw the recreation and culture sector report inflation of 3.6 per cent for the month. The most significant increases on an annual basis were seen in the food and non-alcoholic beverages sector where prices in general were 4.6 per cent higher. But prices for some grocery staples jumped considerably more than that. READ MORE Anthony Dawson, a statistician in the agency's prices division, said butter, which now retails at around €3.99 a pound for own store brands and €5.49 for Kerrygold, was €1.10 more expensive than 12 months ago. Other dairy basics have also recorded substantial increases with Mr Dawson saying that shoppers were paying, on average, 95 cent a kilo more for cheddar cheese and 27 cent more for a litre of milk. The biggest increase over the past 12 months is in the price of beef and veal, which is now almost 22 per cent more expensive than in June 2024, according to the CSO. Those with a sweet tooth are paying 17.5 per cent more for chocolate. Bread prices have risen much more modestly, up between five and six cent for a standard sliced pan while pasta prices are unchanged. And a 2.5 kilo bag of potatoes was actually 29 cent cheaper in June than at the same time last year, the CSO found. Some sectors, including clothing and footwear, reported lower prices, down 2.3 per cent on the year. Transport costs are also 1.2 per cent lower than this time last year, although they did jump 1.2 per cent between May and June. Alcohol prices are down 1.1 per cent overall on an annual basis though the price of beer did rise over that time. As the Government continues to try to come to grips with the housing crisis, the CSO figures show that rents are 4.8 per cent higher than in June last year even as mortgage costs for homeowners dipped by 0.5 per cent. Home maintenance costs are also running ahead of the general rate of inflation at 3.5 per cent on an annualised basis. On energy, despite the easing of the energy crisis, consumers are still paying 1.3 per cent more for electricity than at the same time in 2024, and a more modest 0.5 per cent more for gas. However, motor fuels prices are lower, down 4.4 per cent on average compared with 12 months ago.
