Clean Air In Schools Needs Government Action
'Tamariki at our ECEs and schools should be playing and learning, not bringing home disease and spreading it to their families and across the wider community,' says ACA spokesperson Tara Forde.
'Too many educators and children are getting sick and there are no benefits from repeatedly getting Covid.
'We know preventative actions like increasing ventilation are proven to reduce transmission of respiratory viruses like COVID, reduce sick days and increase productivity.
'I'm a working parent, and I am dreading the coming winter. It can't just be on each family to hope for the best.
'If this Government is serious about increasing school attendance, they need to do more to protect the health of students and educators," says Forde.
Aotearoa Covid Action is calling for:
Ensuring each school and ECE can monitor air quality
Supplying technology to clean the air and reduce viral load
Granting access to all New Zealanders 6 months and older, to up-to-date vaccines, regular boosters and antivirals
Reintroducing free Rapid Antigen Tests
Providing extra sick leave for teachers; school support staff, including teacher aides; and caregivers
Recognising Long Covid as an occupational hazard for teachers
Recognising and better supporting children, teachers, and school support staff, including teacher aides, with Long Covid, through more research into its effects, diagnosis, and treatment.
Organisations in support include: NZEI, PPTA, Disability Person's Assembly, Long Covid Kids, Long Covid Support Aotearoa, ANZMES, Complex Chronic Illness Support, ActionStation, 350 Aotearoa, and the Air Quality Collective. Medical professionals in support include: Dr Amanda Kvalsvig, Dr Michael Baker, Dr Gary Payinda, Dr John D Potter, Dr Siouxsie Wiles, Dr Ed Hyde, Dr David Galler, Dr Matire Harwood, and Dr Stuart Ekdahl.
The open letter can now be signed by all individuals at ActionStation Clean Air in Schools petition: https://our.actionstation.org.nz/petitions/clean-air-in-schools
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
12 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Childhood illnesses surge: Rebuilding trust key to tackling vaccine hesitancy
Schools, kindies, daycare centres and even workplaces are Petri dishes of diseases, forcing families to take time off work and school. The knock-on effects are many. There are also many nasty illnesses such as whooping cough and measles that are preventable – but we are seeing rises in cases, sparking concern with public health officials. A national whooping cough, or pertussis, epidemic was declared in November and more than 250 cases have been recorded across the Bay of Plenty and Lakes health districts. Babies under 12 months old, whose mothers aren't immunised, are particularly at risk of infection because some are too young to have the vaccination themselves and will have a 50% chance of being hospitalised if infected. So far this year in Bay of Plenty, 146 cases of whooping cough have been reported. According to PHF Science, between October 19 last year and June 27 this year, 2635 probable, confirmed and suspected cases of whooping cough were notified nationally. Whooping cough, which is highly infectious, is also under-reported as people often don't realise they have it or don't go to the doctor. Symptoms often start with a cough and a runny nose – similar to a cold. Meanwhile, a measles outbreak in Wairarapa and Manawatū this month has shown just how nasty that disease also is, according to a paediatrician specialising in infectious diseases. Dr Emma Best from the Immunisation Advisory Centre said measles 'seeks out' people and young children who were not immunised. According to the US National Foundation for Infectious Diseases, measles is 'the most contagious virus known to humans'. It can result in seizures, deafness, blindness, permanent lung damage and immune amnesia (wiping out of prior immune protection). Nationally, 77% of New Zealand children had received their childhood vaccinations by the age of 24 months in the three-month period ending December 31, 2024. Vaccine scepticism, once a fringe distrust, has become more mainstream, especially under the shadow of Covid-19, when mandates and lockdowns damaged people's perceptions of the public health system – and indeed, science. Hesitancy comes from fear, confusion or being overwhelmed – not malice. Nobody wants to see their children suffer. However, shaming people is not the answer – rebuilding trust in public health is. Empathy and transparency are needed to help people understand what's at stake. Parents unsure about vaccines should be encouraged to speak to their trusted healthcare providers. GPs, schools and iwi also need to be part of the conversation. Consistent messaging is also important, but we should recognise the burnout from the information bombardment during Covid's dark times. We all have the same goals here, to keep our children and our families safe and healthy – so vital vaccine messaging needs to be inclusive, gentle and transparent. Sign up to the Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Scoop
a day ago
- Scoop
Political cosyism behind 3rd medical school decision-making
On 21 May I was introduced to two new words (always a moment of light excitement for me) by Dr Bryce Edwards, Director of the newly established Integrity Institute which publishes regular Integrity Briefings. On this occasion the new word was 'chumocracy' and 'cosyism': Chumocracy and cosyism. He was referring to the work of Auckland University Professor of Economics Robert MacCulloch who was calling out 'soft corruption' by political and business elites in Aotearoa New Zealand. His focus included government, banks, big business and the rightwing 'thinktank' New Zealand Initiative. Such was the strength and persistence of the hostile response from these elites that he felt sufficiently pressured to close his website. The core of MacCulloch's argument is that New Zealand is run by a 'chumocracy' of elites who are connected by what he calls 'cosyism'. Third medical school announcement These were the words that I began to think about after absorbing the announcement by Health Minister Simeon Brown and Universities Minister Shane Reti early in the afternoon of 21 July that it was proceeding with the proposed third medical school at Waikato University: Official announcement. Later that the same day I was interviewed about the decision on Radio New Zealand's The Panel where my main focus was on the poor process which was likely to lead to an eventual poor outcome: Medical school decision based on poor process. Nearly two years earlier I had outlined my concerns about the Waikato University proposal in an article published by BusinessDesk (26 August 2023): Third medical school caution. What is the third medical school The new medical school is to provide a four-year medical degree for students who already are graduates with a non-medical degree to work as general practitioners (or as other rural doctors) in regional and rural areas. The medical degree at the existing two medical schools, Auckland and Otago, is five years. The advocated expectation is that the proposed Waikato Medical School will be graduating 120 doctors a year once it is up and running. With its opening scheduled for 2028 the first graduates should start working as general practitioners or other rural doctors at the earliest in 2037. This gap comprises both the time at the medical school and the time as resident (junior) doctors in training. Last year the Ministry of Health commissioned a report which advised that that Waikato's teaching model would be similar to the model in Wollongong University, south of Sydney. Reportedly 45% of the latter's graduates become GPs of which around 30% proceeded to work in rural areas. In 2017 the Auckland and Otago medical schools had proposed that they be allowed to jointly establish a new joint 'school of rural medicine'. However, while the previous Labour-led government and Ministry of Health was favourably disposed to this initiative, progress was understandably impeded by the Covid-19 pandemic. In a memo to then Health Minister Shane Reti in September last year, Treasury recommended that Auckland and Otago Medical Schools be asked to present a counter-factual argument to the Waikato proposal. However, it appears that no such invitation was made. Analysis by the Integrity Institute The best commentary I have seen on this decision has come from Bryce Edwards in another Integrity Briefing published the same day as the Government's announcement and after my The Panel interview (21 July): Costly case study in policy capture. Edwards also drew upon the excellent investigative work of Radio New Zealand's Guyan Espinar. Consistent with his above-mentioned piece on 'chumocracy' and 'cosyism' he describes the decision as: … not, at its core, a decision about health policy. It is a decision about political power, influence, and the erosion of good process. This project serves as a textbook case study of policy capture, where the interests of a well-connected institution, amplified by high-powered lobbyists, have overridden expert advice, fiscal prudence, and superior alternatives. Later in his piece he adds: This lack of transparency and due process is antithetical to good governance. The entire Waikato med school saga has unfolded via secret contracts, private lobbying meetings, and politically wired relationships – all largely hidden from the public until journalists and watchdogs pried it into the light. Backing this up Edwards draws upon many questionable process features including: Waikato Vice-Chancellor Professor Neil Quigley working 'hand-in-glove' in 'partisan coordination' with Shane Reti before the last election and promising the proposed school would be 'a 'present' to a future National government'. Waikato University helping pay for the National party's campaign announcement of the medical school plan (about $5,000). Government officials seeing 'red flags' in the proposal including alarm bells ringing from Treasury, the Tertiary Education Commission and the Ministry of Education warning of bloated costs, duplication risks and logistical hurdles. The use of two of the most well-connected lobbyists: initially former Labour senior adviser Neale Jones and more substantially former National cabinet minister Steven Joyce. Joyce's firm was paid about $1 million over three years by Waikato for 'consultancy' (le, leveraging his political influence). Questionable procurement in the way Waikato University hired Joyce leading to a public 'scolding' by the Auditor-General John Ryan. Ignoring the arguably better alternative of expanding the existing Auckland and Otago medical schools which were already running rural immersion schemes and satellite programs geared toward rural health. Edwards does not hold back: At its core, the Waikato medical school saga is an illustration of how not to make public policy. The process has failed every basic test of transparency, public accountability, and evidence-based decision-making. A public university and eager politicians cooked up a major spending initiative as a political favour, greased by lobbyists and implemented via dubious means. The normal checks and balances – open procurement, independent policy analysis, genuine stakeholder consultation – were subverted or ignored. It's the kind of deal that breeds public cynicism in politics, the sense that big decisions are made on behalf of the powerful or the connected, not the public. Further: By greenlighting this project in July 2025, ministers have signalled that political paybacks matter more than prudent spending. They have effectively rewarded a campaign of lobbying and pressure that sidestepped the usual contest of ideas. That sets a horrible precedent. It tells every other vested interest: hire the right insiders, make the right donations or deals, and you too can get the government to write a big cheque, officials' advice be damned. And: The Waikato medical school greenlight might be a political win for a few, but it's a loss for New Zealand's standards of governance. It undermines confidence that our health investments are made wisely and fairly. And it should prompt some soul-searching in Wellington: if this is how we make big decisions now, what does that say about who really runs the country? Unconvincing contrary views There have been contrary analyses supporting the Government's decision which I find unconvincing. Luke Malpass, Stuff Political, Business & Economics Editor and formerly holding a leadership role in the New Zealand Initiative expressed a negative view of current medical schools describing them emotively, but without substantiation, as a 'duopoly'. Writing in The Post (22 July; paywalled) in a flaky critique he dismisses those critical of the process, presumably including Bryce Edwards, as 'weird': Flaky rather than investigative. Two days later Waikato University ethics professor and philosopher Nick Algar wrote a paywalled opinion piece in The Post abstractly arguing that those critical of the Government's were guilty of 'sloppy thinking'. This reminded me of the expression 'pot calling the kettle black': Sloppy thinking in the debate over Waikato medical school | The Post Sloppy analysis of 'sloppy thinking'. He also reminded me of Oscar Wilde on philosophy although without the latter's famous and infamous wit: 'My philosophy? I'm always right and you are wrong.' The last word Let's leave the last word to the action of the Government in releasing its redacted 'cabinet business case' material at 6.45pm last Friday as reported by the Otago Daily Times the following day: Politically expedient timing of third medical school case. This timing has been a common practice of successive governments recognising that this is the most difficult time for media scrutiny before it is taken over by other news. If the difficult to substantiate claim of $50 million savings per year stood up to rigorous scrutiny it would have been released at a time convenient for media scrutiny. But 'chumocracy' and 'cosyism' necessitated otherwise. Ian Powell Otaihanga Second Opinion is a regular health systems blog in New Zealand. Ian Powell is the editor of the health systems blog 'Otaihanga Second Opinion.' He is also a columnist for New Zealand Doctor, occasional columnist for the Sunday Star Times, and contributor to the Victoria University hosted Democracy Project. For over 30 years , until December 2019, he was the Executive Director of Association of Salaried Medical Specialists, the union representing senior doctors and dentists in New Zealand.
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
Dengue fever outbreak: Samoa shuts down schools as cases surge, second child dies
Despite staunch efforts by his family to get him medical help, including being medically evacuated to New Zealand, he died in his parents' arms at Auckland's Starship children's hospital on April 13. More than 1700 confirmed cases Dengue fever, also known as break-bone fever, is a viral infection that spreads from mosquitoes to people and causes symptoms including sudden high fever, intensely sore joints and muscles, pain behind the eyes and a rash. Misiafa Nathaniel Lene, 12, died at Auckland's Starship Children's Hospital shortly after being medically evacuated from Samoa, after contracting dengue fever. Samoa declared a major dengue fever outbreak the week after Misiafa's death. Cases have continued to surge, however, with 1756 confirmed cases recorded between January to July 20 and an average of 100 new cases each week. 'Children and young people remain the most affected, with severe illness predominantly observed in those under the age of 15,' Ponifasio said. 'Hospitals - especially paediatric units - are under considerable strain; prompting the establishment of additional beds and temporary wards to manage the increased number of admissions.' Samoa's youngest Covid patient, a 1-year-old girl, is in a critical condition at the Tupua Tamasese Meaole Hospital in Apia. Photo / Dean Purcell The Samoa Observer newspaper described the paediatric unit at Moto'otua Hospital as 'packed' with children and worried families. Some of the more serious cases are being isolated, the publication reported. As part of the Ministry of Health's fumigation programmes in schools, government buildings and the National University of Samoa are also being sprayed as part of its preventative measures. Other parts of the Pacific have also declared dengue fever outbreaks over the last few months, including in the Cook Islands and Tonga. Tonga has reported three deaths and its most affected group are youngsters aged between 10 and 19. Influx of visitors ahead of national elections Church communities and villages in Samoa are being encouraged to hold clean-up efforts in a bid to keep mosquitoes away. The outbreak comes as the island nation is gearing up for national elections next month. As a result, an influx of Samoans from overseas - particularly from New Zealand and Australia - are expected to head back to the motherland to vote. No official new travel advisory has been released by New Zealand's Ministry of Foreign Affairs for Samoa. However, travellers are advised via the SafeTravel website that there are occasional outbreaks of dengue fever, zika, chikungunya and typhoid. 'Dengue cases have been reported in Samoa in the past,' the website reads. 'Before you travel, read our mosquito-borne illness information.' Vaimoana Mase is the Pasifika editor for the Herald's Talanoa section, sharing stories from the Pacific community. She won junior reporter of the year at the then Qantas Media Awards in 2010 and won the best opinion writing award at the 2023 Voyager Media Awards.
