The Lens: Taiwan's death penalty and its clash between human rights and local feelings
Last week's response
Chan Bo-wen, 16, HKCCCU Logos Academy
Chan Bo-wen attends HKCCCU Logos Academy. Photo: Handout
Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is the state-sanctioned execution of an individual for committing a specific crime. Since 1976, more than 85 nations have abolished the death penalty, with human rights organisation Amnesty International stating that it breaches human rights laws.
In January, Taiwan carried out its first use of capital punishment in five years, executing rapist and murderer Huang Lin-kai.
Despite its reputation as Asia's most liberal democracy, capital punishment remains broadly popular in Taiwan, according to opinion polls.
The execution led to strong pushback from the European Union and human rights groups, with the EU's diplomatic service calling for Taiwan to abolish the death penalty.
The EU is a leading donor of global humanitarian aid, providing millions of people worldwide with need-based assistance.
With all its constituent countries having abolished the death penalty, the EU should have a right to give opinions on the legality and ethics of the death penalty globally.
The EU is actively developing its foreign policies, which are influenced by humanitarian and geostrategic concerns; hence, it should also be free to get involved in this particular discussion.
The vast majority of Taiwanese citizens support the death penalty as a way to prevent serious crimes. This could be due to the attitude of Taiwan's largest opposition party, the Kuomintang, which strongly supports capital punishment.
Being the largest single party in the legislature, its position on the criminal justice system strongly affects public sentiment.
Furthermore, Taiwan is a collectivistic society that heavily emphasises group harmony. Individuals who disrupt the collective welfare are viewed as deserving of harsh punishment, backed by the need for retribution.
Read up on the issue in last week's The Lens
Read and observe
Greenland residents overwhelmingly reject US annexation, according to a new poll. Photo: Xinhua
According to a recent poll, the vast majority of Greenland residents do not want their island to become part of the United States, as envisioned by US President Donald Trump. Trump has signalled that he wants the Arctic island – which is believed to hold large untapped mineral and oil reserves – to become part of the US.
He has suggested the possibility of using force or tariffs to annex the territory.
When asked if they wanted to become part of the United States, 85 per cent of Greenlanders said no, according to the poll published in the Danish Berlingske and Greenland's Sermitsiaq dailies.
Six per cent of those polled said they were in favour, and nine per cent were undecided, according to the poll by the Verian agency.
'It's the first poll that asked a representative section of Greenland's population, and I think this is very important,' Kasper Moller Hansen, a political-science professor at the University of Copenhagen, said. 'I think this poll shows very clearly that they do not want to be American,' he added.
Around 45 per cent of Greenlanders view Trump's interest in their island as a 'threat', while 43 per cent view it as an 'opportunity'. Another 13 per cent are still undecided, according to the poll.
The poll questioned 497 respondents aged 18 and older between January 22 and 26, with a margin of error of 1.9 to 4.4 percentage points.
Greenland has 57,000 residents.
Officials in Greenland, which depends heavily on Denmark for subsidies, have long been pushing for independence but have said they are open to doing business with the United States.
A day after Trump was sworn in as president, Greenland's Prime Minister Mute Egede insisted that Greenlanders 'don't want to be American'.
Staff writers and Agence France-Presse
Research and respond
Why do you think US President Trump is interested in annexing Greenland? Do you think the US has a right to fight for this land?
What does the poll signify about Greenlanders' attitudes towards this dispute?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTHK
4 hours ago
- RTHK
Govt condemns EU remarks over NSL arrest warrants
Govt condemns EU remarks over NSL arrest warrants A government spokesman has called on the European Union to stop interfering in Hong Kong matters. File photo: RTHK The government on Friday said it strongly disapproves remarks by the European Union about Hong Kong's lawful act to pursue people wanted for alleged national security offences. Police last week issued arrest warrants for 19 people accused of violating the Hong Kong National Security Law by forming or joining an organisation called the "Hong Kong Parliament". A government spokesman said in a statement that the "Hong Kong Parliament" is an organisation that aims to subvert state power and that 'any suggestion that certain individuals or organisations should be immune from legal consequences for their illegal acts... is no different from advocating a special privilege to break the law.' 'The HKSAR Government strongly demands that the EU immediately stop acting against international law and basic norms of international relations and interfering in Hong Kong matters, which are purely China's internal affairs,' the spokesman said. He added that people should not think they can evade criminal liability by fleeing overseas. 'Ultimately, they will be held liable for their acts constituting serious offences endangering national security and be punished by the law. No country or organisation should harbour criminals nor try to exonerate these people with different excuses," he said. The government also reaffirmed its commitment to safeguarding national security in the SAR, while protecting the rights and freedoms of Hong Kong residents according to the law.
South China Morning Post
20 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Taiwan's William Lai vows to bargain with US as 20% tariff rate draws flak
Taiwanese leader William Lai Ching-te has vowed to push for a lower US tariff rate as criticism mounts over his administration's failure to secure a more favourable deal. Lai's pledge on Friday came after President Donald Trump imposed what Taipei described as a 'temporary' 20 per cent levy on Taiwanese exports to the United States. 'The 20 per cent tariff rate was never Taiwan's target to begin with. We hope in follow-up talks we are able to strive for a rate that's more favourable and reasonable for Taiwan,' Lai said at a press conference in Taipei. Trump imposed tariffs ranging from 10 to 41 per cent on imports from dozens of US trading partners in an executive order issued on Thursday. 01:15 Canada, Brazil hardest hit as Trump unleashes new global tariff blitz Canada, Brazil hardest hit as Trump unleashes new global tariff blitz While Taiwan's 20 per cent rate is lower than the 32 per cent he announced in April, it exceeds the 15 per cent rates fellow Asian economies Japan and South Korea ultimately secured – and falls short of earlier expectations from the Lai administration. Lai framed the rate as a 'phased outcome' of ongoing negotiations,saying: 'The US government has also expressed its willingness to proceed with further talks with Taiwan.'
HKFP
a day ago
- HKFP
Taiwan vows to seek lower tariff after Trump's ‘temporary' 20% levy
Taiwan vowed on Friday to seek a lower tariff after Donald Trump imposed a 'temporary' 20 percent levy on its shipments to the United States as part of his trade war. The US president's announcement was part of a sweep of measures — reaching 41 percent — against dozens of global partners as they scrambled for deals with Washington to avert the painful tolls. The figure is down from the 32 percent toll imposed in his April 2 'Liberation Day', since when Taipei and Washington have held four rounds of face-to-face talks and multiple video conferences to resolve the issue. On Friday Taiwan President Lai Ching-te said on Facebook they were still working to strike an agreement 'The US has announced a temporary 20 percent tariff for Taiwan, with the possibility of further reductions should an agreement be reached,' he wrote. 'The government will continue to strive for a reasonable tariff rate and complete the final stages of the tariff negotiations.' While Trump had set Friday as the deadline for agreements to be made, he delayed it until the end of next week. No timeline was given for Taiwan, which could mean the island was caught in the middle of US-China trade negotiations, said Alicia Garcia-Herrero, chief economist for Asia Pacific at Natixis. Washington and Beijing held two days of talks this week aimed at reaching a deal to extend a truce in their trade war and prevent the reimposition of sky-high tariffs on August 12. 'The conditions on Taiwan might be relevant for China, imagine export controls,' Garcia-Herrero told AFP. After US tech giant Nvidia announced it will resume sales of its H20 AI chips to China, Garcia-Herrero said 'there could be other stuff that China needs from Taiwan that the US can offer'. 'This is the ceiling' Taiwan is a global powerhouse in chip manufacturing, with more than half the world's semiconductors and nearly all of the high-end ones made there. The owner of a Taiwanese machinery exporter to the United States said he was worried that lower tariff rates on Japan and South Korea — 15 percent — would advantage his competitors there. He told AFP the recent appreciation in the Taiwan dollar against the greenback had also 'put a lot of pressure on us, creating a double whammy'. The uncertainty over tariffs was hurting US sales, said textile producer Eddie Wang, with clients 'feeling overwhelmed' and reluctant to place orders. Soaring demand for AI-related technology has fuelled Taiwan's trade surplus with the United States — and put it in Trump's crosshairs. Around 60 percent of Taiwan's exports to the United States are information and communications technology, which includes chips. In a bid to avoid the tariffs, Taipei has pledged to increase investment in the United States, buy more of its energy and increase its own defence spending. Economist Sun Ming-te said the 20 percent levy was 'probably the best outcome Taiwan can achieve with the US under the current conditions.' 'This is the ceiling, and it can go lower in the future,' Sun, from the Taiwan Institute of Economic Research, told AFP.
