Looking back: Grading the Bucs 2021 NFL Draft class years later
Coming off their Super Bowl LV win, the Buccaneers' entered the 2021 NFL Draft with few immediate needs, but also few resources as last pick in almost every round. General manager Jason Licht and the Bucs front office opted to augment the roster with their championship roster and make risky bets at positions of need.
After four years, only one player from the 2021 class remains on Tampa Bay's roster. The Bucs derived little value from the premium picks and only got temporary contributions from the players who did see the field. Suffice it to say, the Bucs' 2021 draft class is not likely to be remembered fondly.
Here are the final grades from the Bucs' 2021 draft:
Joe Tryon-Shoyinka
The Bucs went for high upside at a position of need with their first pick, but outside linebacker Joe Tryon-Shoyinka simply did not work out. In four seasons with Tampa Bay, he never developed into much of a pass rusher, recording just 15 total sacks, 21 tackles for a loss and two forced fumbles. The best thing Tryon-Shoyinka had going for him was his durability, missing just two games since entering the NFL. While there were not any better options at the position, this was an instance of the Bucs reaching for a need in a weak class at edge rusher and paying the price.
Grade: C-
Kyle Trask
Taking swings on quarterbacks can be an underappreciated undertaking in the draft, but the Bucs appear to have swung too early on the wrong quarterback. Sure, Kyle Trask is the first quarterback the Bucs have ever drafted to receive a second contract, but he also could not beat out Baker Mayfield for the starting job in 2023 and has just 11 NFL dropbacks on his resume after four seasons. At a point when the Bucs could have bolstered their defensive line with the likes of Alim McNeil, Milton Williams or Osa Odighizuwa, they instead used their second-round pick on a career backup quarterback.
Grade: D+
Robert Hainsey
The Bucs' third-round pick was arguably the best of the class. After Ryan Jensen suffered an ultimately career-ending knee injury during training camp in 2022, Hainsey stepped in and started at center in every regular season game through the 2023 season. While the Bucs eventually upgraded the position in 2024 by drafting Graham Barton, Hainsey proved to be a valuable player likely to have a long NFL career.
Grade: B-
Jaelon Darden
In the fourth round, Tampa Bay took a chance drafting undersized North Texas WR Jaelon Darden. Darden has yet to emerge as a receiver in the NFL, but he has shown value as a returner, taking 50 punts for a 9.4-yard average in two seasons with Tampa Bay. However, the Bucs cut Darden in December 2022, and he has been a returner for Cleveland and Seattle since.
Grade: C-
K.J. Britt
When the Bucs took Auburn's K.J. Britt in the fifth round, they figured they were drafting a special teamer and linebacker depth. Devin White's regression over the next three years culminated in Britt filling in for White down the stretch in 2023 and entering 2024 as the presumed starter next to Lavonte David. However, Britt could not overcome his lack of athleticism and proved that he is best utilized in a reserve role.
Grade: C+
Chris Wilcox
The Bucs drafted cornerback Chris Wilcox with their first seventh-round pick. He was waived after the preseason and has bounced around practice squads across the NFL. Wilcox has yet to play a snap in a regular-season game and was out of the NFL in 2024.
Grade: D+
Grant Stuard
With their second seventh-round pick, the Bucs took 2021's Mr. Irrelevant, Houston LB Grant Stuard. While he only lasted one year with Tampa Bay, mostly playing special teams, Stuard is making a career out of his special-teams ability. He led the Indianapolis Colts in special teams snaps since the Bucs traded him for a 2023 sixth-round pick. The return value for the trade alone made Stuard one of the Bucs' better picks in 2021.
Grade: B
Overall
As the reigning Super Bowl XL champions, the Bucs had fewer resources than most teams in the 2021 draft and failed to capitalize on what little value they had. Taking the swing on Joe Tryon-Shoyinka was understandable, but the Trask pick in the second round remains a major blemish. Targeting special teams contributors over more conventional depth proved to be a wasted opportunity to carry the roster past the Tom Brady era. The 2021 class will be remembered as one of Jason Licht's worst as Bucs general manager, second only to the disastrous 2016 draft class.
Grade: D
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
27 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Fantasy Football: 3 rookies (and one veteran) headline breakout candidates at the RB position for 2025
With the NFL season approaching and fantasy football drafts in full swing, there's never been a better time to determine which players could be this year's breakout stars. It seems easy in hindsight, but identifying young talent on the verge of making a major leap is often what propels fantasy managers to championships. Over the next week, I'll highlight my favorite breakout candidates at every key fantasy position. Today, we're taking a look at running Hampton, Chargers 2025 Fantasy Projection Carries Rushing Yards Rushing TDs Receptions Receiving Yards Receiving TDs Omarion Hampton 242 1,087 9 35 276 2 In the past, I tried to avoid highlighting rookies as breakout candidates because they're in a category of their own after we spend all offseason discussing them. However, in recent years it's become almost impossible to speak about breakout running backs without mentioning a couple rookies, especially when you have a class this strong. While Ashton Jeanty stole most of the headlines and eventually went sixth overall to the Raiders (more on him later), Hampton also earned that rare first-round RB draft capital — going off the board 22nd to the Chargers. While some people will debate whether it's smart to invest that high of a pick on a ball carrier, it was well deserved for both players. In addition to a 6-foot, 221-pound frame, Hampton posted an impressive athletic profile, including a 94th percentile speed score and a 91st percentile burst score. The 22-year-old is also coming off back-to-back seasons with over 1,500 scrimmage yards and over 15 touchdowns at North Carolina. Jeanty's presence in this class might have been the only thing keeping the Hampton hype train in check. Now, fantasy managers can let themselves be inspired by Hampton's potential in a Greg Roman scheme, where he can star as a north-south runner and a true three-down difference-maker. Jim Harbaugh even referred to him as a four-down back at one point this offseason. It was evident that Harbaugh wanted to build a strong run game a year ago, but the inconsistent health of J.K. Dobbins and Gus Edwards made that task harder than it should have been. Still, that duo accounted for eight top-15 weekly fantasy performances and Dobbins was the RB14 in fantasy points per game before injuries derailed his season. Hampton will presumably be running behind a better offensive line, as well. The Chargers added guard Mekhi Becton to a group that already featured three first-round picks and one of the best tackle tandems in the league. Maybe you're worried about Najee Harris turning this into a committee? Don't be. Hampton is unlikely to be a workhorse during his first season, but the good news is that he doesn't need to be in order to have meaningful fantasy results. Think about Jahmyr Gibbs, another first-round runner who was overshadowed by a superstar in his class (Bijan Robinson). In that debut campaign in 2023, Gibbs shared his backfield and only played 56% of the Lions' snaps, yet finished as the RB11 (fppg). [Join or create a Yahoo Fantasy Football league for the 2025 NFL season] Hampton is far more dynamic than Harris and will have a head start on the veteran, who's expected to miss some time at the beginning of training camp following an eye injury he suffered during a recent fireworks mishap. This all boils down to Hampton being positioned for a significant role in an ascending offense that wants to feature their backs. It's hard to believe a first-round runner could be under-appreciated by the fantasy community, but I'd argue that's where we're at with Hampton being drafted as the RB21 at the Round 4-5 turn. I'll have him on the majority of my redraft rosters if that continues. : RB17 (Strong RB2 with potential to push his way into the low-end RB1 range) Ashton Jeanty, Raiders 2025 Fantasy Projection Carries Rushing Yards Rushing TDs Receptions Receiving Yards Receiving TDs Ashton Jeanty 289 1,270 9 51 416 2 It seems silly to devote much space in this article to Jeanty, who is one of the more obvious rookie breakout candidates in recent years. On top of an elite prospect profile and the aforementioned top-six draft capital, he joins an offense ready to make him the engine of their attack. Chip Kelly has given us plenty of high-end fantasy starters over the years and he'll bring an uptempo approach to the Raiders, while giving Jeanty as many touches as he can handle. There's also minimal competition in the backfield, unless you're concerned about a 33-year-old Raheem Mostert. It might feel dangerous using your first-round fantasy pick on a rookie, but Jeanty is worthy and has an excellent shot to be a top-five RB in Year 1. : RB5 (Immediate bell-cow RB1 with an elite fantasy ceiling) TreVeyon Henderson, Patriots 2025 Fantasy Projection Carries Rushing Yards Rushing TDs Receptions Receiving Yards Receiving TDs TreVeyon Henderson 187 764 5 52 411 2 Henderson is the third and final rookie I'll mention on this list, though Kaleb Johnson should get an honorable mention for almost making the cut. Henderson gets the edge over him thanks to higher draft capital, a more explosive profile, top-notch pass-catching ability and his pass-protection skills. This should help win over a new coaching staff who would love nothing more than to keep Drake Maye's jersey clean. So, why does his ADP have him down at RB28 in the seventh round? Fantasy drafters who are scared off by the committees OC Josh McDaniels deployed in his previous seasons with New England should remember Rhamondre Stevenson has found himself in the doghouse with prior regimes due to fumbling issues and an overall lack of big-play ability. It shouldn't take long for Henderson to establish himself as the best option and a safety net for Maye. The Patriots also have the eighth-easiest RB slate in my Fantasy Strength of Schedule Matrix, so get ready for Henderson to significantly outproduce where he's going in current drafts. : RB20 (Low-end RB2 with a high floor thanks to receiving stats) Jordan Mason, Vikings 2025 Fantasy Projection Carries Rushing Yards Rushing TDs Receptions Receiving Yards Receiving TDs Jordan Mason 173 746 5 19 138 1 Mason is one of the few non-rookie backs who meet the criteria of a breakout candidate this year and in the interest of not making this an All-Rookie Team, I'm awarding him the last spot. If you read my article on players set to excel with new teams, you already know why I'm in on Mason this year. If you didn't, let's recap. The Vikings traded for Mason after he shone as an injury-replacement starter for the 49ers last season. Since then, Minnesota's coaches have spoken about their backfield as a two-man band with Mason serving as a power complement to veteran Aaron Jones, who turns 31 in December. That's a role that should make Mason a weekly flex option with the potential for much more if Jones starts to break down given his age and injury history. If Jones were to miss time, Mason would enter the fantasy RB1 conversation. : RB31 (Consistent flex option with league-winning injury-replacement upside) Stay tuned for the rest of Justin Boone's breakout series
USA Today
28 minutes ago
- USA Today
Puka Nacua cracks PFF's top 50 players list: How high did the Rams WR rank?
Puka Nacua's production speaks for itself: 184 catches, 2,476 yards and nine touchdowns in his first 28 games as a pro. That's an average of 6.6 receptions and 88.4 yards per game, which both rank among the best in the NFL in the last two years. Not only is he one of the top receivers in football – despite what NFL coaches and executives think – but he's one of the best overall players in the league. Pro Football Focus ranked the top 50 players for 2025 and like Jared Verse, Nacua made the cut. Nacua came in at No. 32, ahead of fellow receivers such as CeeDee Lamb (36), Nico Collins (37), Tyreek Hill (39) and Mike Evans (48). All of those players were ranked higher in ESPN's poll of coaches and executives, where Nacua was 12th as an 'honorable mention.' Nacua played only 11 games in 2024 due to injury but still finished with the NFL's highest receiving grade at 93.0. He's also coming off a 1,486-yard rookie season in 2022. Over the past two years, he ranks seventh among receivers in PFF WAR (1.01). The scary part? Nacua is still getting better, building on an already elite level of production and efficiency. It's hard to know exactly how Davante Adams' arrival will impact Nacua, but it's not as if Puka hasn't played alongside an elite receiver before; he was Cooper Kupp's teammate for the last two seasons. He should still see a healthy number of targets and typically when the ball is thrown his way, he's producing a ton of yards. Only entering his third year as a pro, Nacua should continue to get better. He may have had more receptions and yards as a rookie but in fewer games last season, he was even more efficient and reliable. That's the exciting part.
USA Today
28 minutes ago
- USA Today
What is the Buccaneers biggest hope going into the 2025 season?
There are not many instances in the NFL where a team returns most of it's pieces after an early playoff exit, but that is what the Bucs did in 2025. Jason Licht and his staff looked at their roster and decided that there weren't any glaring holes, but rather some depth issues that needed to be addressed. Of course, they also had to bring back key pieces like Lavonte David and Chris Godwin Jr. in free agency, but after doing that there wasn't much else to manage in terms of contracts. Bleacher Report's Kristopher Knox wrote up each NFL team's reason for hope in 2025, and for the Bucs, it is the continuity within the roster that is giving him reasons to be optimistic. The team may have exited the playoffs early, but they had a roster that was ready for something special and Jason Licht knows that. Knox writes, "While the Falcons and even Panthers may be ready to challenge within the division—expectations should be lower in New Orleans—the Buccaneers should be considered the favorites entering camp. Why? Because general manager Jason Licht once again made it an offseason priority to keep top players in the fold. Mayfield, Mike Evans, Tristan Wirfs and 2024 breakout back Bucky Irving were always going to be back for the coming season. However, Tampa also re-signed standouts like Chris Godwin and linebacker Lavonte David while adding new contributors like Haason Reddick and rookie wideout Emeka Egbuka. . .While there's no guarantee that Tampa will be better in 2025, it's highly unlikely to be worse. That's reason enough to believe the Bucs could be sleeper Super Bowl contenders." The offense returns every starter for the 2025 season that it had in 2024, with a new coordinator of course. As for the defense, they add Haason Reddick, but otherwise it also remains untouched. It truly is unheard of for a non-Super Bowl team to run things back like this, but who are we to question Jason Licht and his Super Bowl ring at this point?
