
Pune court rejects plea to compel Rahul Gandhi to submit book in Savarkar defamation case
'No person accused of any offence shall be compelled to be a witness against himself. The burden of proof lies entirely on the complainant. Hence, the application filed by the complainant is liable to be rejected and is accordingly rejected,' judicial magistrate Amol Shinde said in the order pronounced in open court on July 3.
Advocate Sangram Kolhatkar, appearing for Satyaki Savarkar – Veer Savarkar's grand-nephew who filed the defamation complaint under section 500 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) last year – had argued that Gandhi's lawyer was deliberately delaying proceedings which are currently at the stage of recording the plea. Advocate Kolhatkar maintained that the book in question is essential to ensuring a fair trial.
In response, Gandhi's lawyer, advocate Milind Pawar, strongly opposed the plea, stating that the trial had not yet commenced and therefore Gandhi could not be compelled to disclose any part of his defence or supporting documents. Advocate Pawar argued that the burden of proof lies solely on the complainant and compelling the accused to produce material at this stage would violate the accused's constitutional protection under Article 20(3) which safeguards against self-incrimination.
Advocate Pawar submitted, 'The complainant is required to prove his case beyond reasonable doubt. The accused is presumed innocent until proven guilty. Forcing the defence to prematurely disclose material is not permitted under criminal law and violates constitutional guarantees.'
Advocate Pawar further argued, 'There is no legal obligation on the defence to provide any document or material to the complainant. Such a direction would seriously prejudice the accused's right to a fair trial and his ability to defend himself effectively.'
After hearing the arguments from both sides, the court noted that the case is still at the stage of recording the accused's plea, and that it arises from a private complaint. The court held that the burden of proving the allegations lies entirely on the complainant.
The court observed: 'Gandhi cannot be compelled to disclose or submit any part of his defence before the trial formally begins. He is entitled to present relevant documents at the defence stage as per the law. Forcing the accused to produce material at this preliminary stage would infringe upon his constitutional protection under Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India, which protects against compelled self-incrimination.'
The complaint alleged that Rahul Gandhi had made false and defamatory statements during his 2023 London speech, including a claim that Savarkar had written about enjoying assaulting a Muslim man in his book. Gandhi had earlier been exempted from appearing before the MP-MLA court presided over by magistrate Shinde and was granted bail on a bond of ₹25,000. He was also granted permanent exemption from personal court appearances, citing his public responsibilities and security considerations

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Hans India
14 minutes ago
- Hans India
60 women to get party ticket in next Assembly polls: Revanth
Hyderabad: The Congress party will lead by example, while earmarking around 60 tickets to women in the next Assembly elections. This categorical assurance came from Chief Minister A Revanth Reddy after launching 'Vana Mahotsavam'2025 at the PJT Agriculture University here on Monday. He would personally take up this responsibility and ensure that the allotment goes beyond the quota for women. The Chief Minister indicated that approximately 50 seats would be reserved for women after delimitation of Assembly seats and passage of the women's reservation Bill. In addition, the party would pick women nominees in at least 10 more seats to ensure a larger women representation in the state Assembly. Reiterating that the government has set a target of making one crore woman millionaires, Revanth Reddy maintained that women SHGs would also be formed in urban areas in their bid to empower women across fields. Revanth Reddy listed out the women empowerment schemes formulated by his government, including the responsibility of setting up solar plants, focussing on government schools for girls and encouraging women to rent out around 1,000 buses to TGSRTC. Women's groups are now able to market their products in Hitec City, where some of the biggest MNCs and corporate houses are located. Meanwhile, urging people to join "Vana Mahotsavam" by planting at least two saplings in their homes, he called upon mothers to take the responsibility of planting saplings in the name of their children. The popular saying propounded by the older generations "the forest ecosystem and our living are integral" is eternally relevant, he pointed out. The Chief Minister said that Telangana will be transformed into a complete 'green' zone if everyone cultivates and nurtures trees like children.


Hans India
27 minutes ago
- Hans India
Truckers halt delivery under Anna Bhagya Scheme
Bengaluru: Karnataka truck owners have halted the transportation of rice provided for free distribution under the Anna Bhagya scheme by the Siddaramaiah government. Retail Transport Contractors' Association President Shanmugappa issued a statement on Monday, announcing that trucks stopped transporting rice from midnight on Sunday. 'Chief Minister Siddaramaiah and Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar have failed to fulfil their promise of clearing transportation dues for trucks that carried rice across the state from February to June. The pending amount is Rs 250 crore,' he stated. 'Truck drivers and owners are going through a difficult phase. They are taking loans and facing the threat of losing their livelihood. Many are managing to continue operations by pledging their jewellery to purchase diesel and cover transport expenses,' Shanmugappa added. He further stated that finance companies which provided vehicle loans are now repossessing trucks, as the owners are unable to pay the EMIs. He slammed the government, stating that the Secretary of the Food Department had promised that payments would be made by June 19, but nothing has been done so far. The trucks have transported 25 lakh tonnes of rice to district and taluk centres across the state. Due to the state government's negligence, about 3,500 to 4,000 truck drivers are now in crisis, he said. As a result of this development, there will be delays in the distribution of free rice to beneficiaries. This situation is also expected to reignite debates over the Congress-led government's alleged struggle to generate sufficient funds. Under the Anna Bhagya scheme -- one of the Congress government's major guarantee schemes -- the state provides 10 kilograms of free rice per person for families falling under the Below Poverty Line (BPL) category. The state government claims it is distributing free rice to 4.42 crore individual beneficiaries from 1.19 crore BPL and Antyodaya card-holding families across Karnataka. Meanwhile, Karnataka BJP President and MLA B.Y. Vijayendra stated on Monday that the Congress-led government in the state is attempting to gradually halt the free rice scheme. 'They had promised to provide 10 kilograms of free rice, including the 5 kilograms supplied by the Centre. Now, they are preparing to distribute Indira Kits instead of free rice. The objective is to save Rs 700 to Rs 800 crore. They are using the excuse that beneficiaries are reselling the free rice,' he alleged.


Hans India
28 minutes ago
- Hans India
Oppn calls for 'Bihar bandh' tomorrow
Patna: Opposition INDIA bloc has called for 'Bihar bandh' on Wednesday to protest the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in the State. Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha and Congress leader Rahul Gandhi will also participate in the bandh. RJD leader Tejashwi Prasad Yadav said the Opposition has given a call for 'Bihar bandh' to vent their ire against the ongoing SIR of voters' list.