Minnesota woman who traded places with twin following fatal Amish buggy crash pleads guilty to some charges
There were four children in the buggy at the time of the crash that occurred shortly before 8:30 a.m. on Sept. 25, 2023. Two children, a 7- and 11-year-old, were killed. A 9- and 13-year-old were taken to St. Mary's Hospital with serious injuries.
Sarah Peterson was charged with 16 felonies, including criminal vehicular homicide, criminal vehicular operation and aiding an offender, according to court documents. All 16 charges indicated that Sarah Peterson tried to conceal or take responsibility for her identical twin sister's criminal acts.
Court documents show Sarah Peterson pleaded guilty to two counts of aiding and abetting criminal vehicular operation. If a judge accepts the plea deal, she will be put on probation for four years and the prosecution will not argue for more than six months in jail.
Sarah Peterson's sister, Samantha Peterson, is facing 17 felonies, including criminal vehicular homicide, criminal vehicular operation, driving under the influence, failure to provide proof of insurance, careless driving and speeding. Four other felony counts were dropped in December due to lack of probable cause.
Samantha Peterson was allegedly high on meth when she crashed into an Amish buggy on County Road 1 south of the intersection with County Road 102 near Sumner Center.
Fillmore County Sheriff John DeGeorge DeGeorge said the fact the sisters are identical twins "added a lot of complexity" to the lengthy investigation.
DeGeorge says the inconsistencies included a review of an interview recording, which uncovered a conversation between the two sisters that indicated that "something might be up." He said another big piece of the investigation was being able to get a search warrant for the sisters' phones.
A search of Samantha Peterson's cellphone revealed a text she sent on the day of the crash, writing, in part, "I hit that Amish buggy and killed two ppl [sic]." She continued, "Made Sarah come there and take the fall for it so I wouldn't go to prison."
Sarah Peterson's sentencing hearing is scheduled for March 31.
Samantha Peterson's next court hearing is scheduled for June 10.
Note: The video above originally aired on Feb. 8, 2024.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
5 days ago
- New York Post
NY cops on hunt for stolen horse as they worry it might break its diet — with deadly consequences
There's a horse thief on the loose. New York State police launched a search for a horse named Koda that was stolen from an upstate farm last week — and has 'special dietary restrictions' that could spell his demise if he's not found soon. ''Koda' is a neutered male, called a gelding,' troopers said in a press release Wednesday. 'He is a flea-bitten grey color, which means he is grey with flecks of red and has a darker muzzle. 3 State police said Koda the horse was stolen from a farm in the upstate town of Union on July 24 or 25. New York State Police 'Koda's owners are also concerned about him because he has special dietary restrictions.' The horse was plucked from an enclosure in the farm in the Endicott and Union area, police said. Koda has two brands that could help identify him — a Roman letter L that resembles an upside Y on the front left shoulder, and an arrow pointing upward with a line underneath on the rear left flank. Troopers believe the horse was stolen on July 23 or 24 from the fenced-in property on Struble Road in the town of Union. 3 Koda has two brands, including this one on the left rear flank, according to police. 3 Koda, a horse stolen from an upstate farm last week, has a second brand in the right front shoulder. Anyone with information should call police at 607-561-7400, and cite case NY2500671337. Although it sounds like the Wild West, horse thieves still make off with four-legged booty now and again — including an Amish horse and buggy snatched from a Michigan Walmart last year. In 2023, a trio of teens riding stolen horses rode into a tragic traffic mishap that left one boy and two of the horses dead near a Dallas, Texas freeway. And in 2025 in St. Petersburg, Florida, a stolen championship horse was not only stolen, but later butchered before the owners could track down the gelding.
CBS News
29-07-2025
- CBS News
Pennsylvania man receives life in prison for murdering pregnant Amish woman
A man found guilty of murdering a pregnant Amish woman inside her Pennsylvania home last year received two life sentences on Monday, authorities said. Shawn Cranston will spend the rest of his life in prison after a Crawford County judge sentenced him for the killing of 23-year-old Rebekah Byler, the Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General said in a news release on Monday. In June, the 53-year-old Cranston, a truck driver who lived about 8 miles from Byler's home, was convicted of first-degree murder, second-degree murder of an unborn child, and related charges. On Monday, the judge sentenced the man to the mandatory life-without-parole sentence for the first-degree murder conviction, plus an additional sentence of life in prison. Authorities said Cranston shot and stabbed Byler to death after encountering her during a robbery of her home on Fish Flats Road in Sparta Township on Feb. 26, 2024. An autopsy previously showed the 23-year-old victim died of sharp force injuries and a gunshot wound to the head. "This defendant committed a truly evil act, and is now held fully accountable as he will spend the rest of his life behind bars without an opportunity to ever again harm another person in free society," Sunday said in Monday's news release. Byler's two young children were home when she was killed. They were not physically harmed, law enforcement said during the investigation. A Crawford County jury found Cranston guilty after four days of testimony in June. Officials said Byler "lived for her children and had a passion for cleaning." Her family members attended Monday's sentencing but did not speak, the news release said. "My thoughts are with the victim's family, whose quiet strength throughout the process has been inspiring," Sunday said.
Yahoo
13-06-2025
- Yahoo
He Walked Into an Amish Home and Killed a Pregnant Woman with Her Children Feet Away — But What Brought Him There?
Shawn Christopher Cranston, 52, was convicted of first-degree murder for killing 23-year-old pregnant Amish woman Rebekah Byler and second-degree murder for killing her unborn child Investigators linked Cranston to the crime through a shoe print and his belongings found at the scene, including Nike sneakers and guns Cranston, who had previously provided rides for a nearby family, had allegedly exhibited strange behavior, including wandering the property in black clothing with a pistolA truck driver was convicted of shooting a pregnant Amish woman to death inside of her rural northwestern Pennsylvania home while her kids were in the next room over. Shawn Christopher Cranston, 52, was convicted of first-degree murder for killing Rebekah Byler, 23, and second-degree murder for killing her unborn child, the AP reported. 'It is hard to fathom conduct more heinous than brutally killing a young expectant mother and her unborn child in her home,' Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday said to the outlet. 'Our homes are supposed to be our safe haven — this defendant violated the sanctity of home to commit these truly evil acts.' On the morning of Feb. 26, 2024, Rebekah was at her home while her husband was being driven to work, the AP reported, citing authorities. When her husband, Andy Byler, returned home from work, he found her dead. 'I didn't really believe it,' Andy said at a preliminary hearing for Cranston, the outlet reported. 'I walked in and saw her cap laying inside the door.' Rebekah and Andy's two other children, a 2-year-old girl and a 3-year-old boy, were at home when she was killed but the children were left unharmed, PennLive reported, citing court records. The boy later reportedly told police that a man in a green truck entered their home with sneakers and killed his mom. Investigators later found a shoe print inside their home resembling a Nike Air Force One sneaker and later found the shoes in the family's home, the outlet reported, citing police. Police also found some of Cranston's clothing, five bank bags, a box of gloves and seven guns with was a driver for an Amish man who lived a mile away from Rebekah's home, PennLive reported, citing court documents. Court records said the family had 'very odd experiences' with Cranston, saying that after he provided the first ride, he would randomly show up at the family's home. Amish people rely on drivers outside of the community since they do not drive vehicles. They also do not traditionally wear sneakers, according to their community rules. In one instance, Cranston allegedly drove a Jeep to the Byler's home, parked it in their driveway and wandered around the property wearing black clothing head to toe, PennLive reported. He allegedly had a black pistol in a holster on his belt and walked aimlessly, not making any sense when he interacted with neighbors. Neighbors have told police that he is a member of the War Dogs motorcycle club, where he serves as sergeant at arms, the outlet reported. Police are still not entirely sure what Cranston's motive was for killing Rebekah, local outlets reported. They're continuing to analyze his Jeep for evidence. Cranston is scheduled to be sentenced in July. Read the original article on People
