We must count the real costs of nuclear power
The first is that the world needs more energy. Poor countries certainly do. But the clean-energy transition involves shifting to much more efficient technologies, such as electric vehicles and heat pumps. Many studies, including by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, show that these can enable rich countries to halve their energy use while improving living standards. The whole world could have western European lifestyles and still use less energy.
The second error is to argue that wind and solar energy cannot power a reliable electricity grid. A major study by the Royal Society showed that a system based on these resources with some long-duration storage is not only feasible, but will be cheaper than a system with any level of nuclear power. Nuclear power is a costly distraction from building an efficient and renewable system.Nick EyreEmeritus professor of energy and climate policy, University of Oxford
Your author, in his enthusiasm to highlight the cheaper costs to build new nuclear plants, failed to include the ever-increasing costs of decommissioning nuclear plants at the end of their working life. This must be included in any comparison of costs.
He also failed to mention the problems of vast amounts of highly dangerous radioactive nuclear waste and accidents, freak weather – such as the tsunamis causing radioactive leaks in Japan – and potential terrorist attacks.
Nuclear may not cause atmospheric carbon waste but it does create hugely toxic radioactive waste that remains dangerous for hundreds of thousands of years. A problem that threatens the health of all life.
He mentions that Finland has made a deep burial site for nuclear waste, and the probability of geological activity and disturbance has obviously been factored in. However this does not mean it is guaranteed to stand the tests of time – and stable rock formations found at the site in Finland may not be so readily found elsewhere.Kathleen AskewHayling Island, Hampshire
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
12 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Police arrest dozens of protesters for supporting banned Palestine Action including vicar after activists' vows to go 'floppy' - a week after priest, 83, was among 29 seized
Police have today arrested more than 70 protesters for supporting newly banned terrorist organisation Palestine Action. A vicar was among at least 42 people detained by Scotland Yard officers as activists gathered for a second week in a row beside a statue of Gandhi in London 's Parliament Square, holding placards reading: 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action.' Another 16 arrests were made in Manchester and 13 people were also held in Cardiff at other related demonstrations on Saturday. A briefing document circulated to activists ahead of the action told protesters to 'go floppy' when they are arrested as it 'adds to the visual drama', reported The Telegraph. Five officers were today seen carrying one tattooed protester by her arms and legs, with one supporting her head. Some demonstrators could be seen lying on top of each other on the floor as police searched their bags and took their ID cards and handmade signs. Officers could then be seen carrying away a number of protesters who were lying down, lifting them off the ground and into waiting police vans parked around the square. Other standing protesters were also led away from the statues and placed into the vans. The last of the protesters was lifted from the Nelson Mandela statue shortly after 2.30pm. Those held were of mixed ages, from their 20s to 70s and many said they had jobs and had been arrested before. Officers could then be seen carrying away a number of protesters who were lying down, lifting them off the ground and into waiting police vans parked around the square. Other standing protesters were also led away from the statues and placed into the vans. The offences mainly related to Section 13 of the Terrorism Act 2000, an officer said. One protester, an architect called Steve, 59, said: 'I'm terrified. But some things in this world are bigger than fear of arrest. I will do whatever it takes to highlight this problem. 'They (the police) can do whatever they want. I don't care.' This Saturday is the second weekend Palestine Action supporters have protested and been arrested. A small group of protesters sat at the steps of the Mahatma Gandhi statue in Parliament Square for the demonstration, organised by campaign group Defend Our Juries, shortly after 1pm and received a brief applause. The individuals then wrote the message 'I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action' with black markers on pieces of cardboard and silently held the signs aloft, surrounded by Metropolitan Police officers, who formed a cordon, and members of the media. A number of demonstrators were carried away by police by their legs and arms after refusing to walk. A social care worker, who gave her name as Kate, 42, was taken away by police as demonstrators shouted 'free free Palestine around her'. Several people were arrested at Parliament Square in London for supporting newly banned terrorist organisation Palestine Action Around ten people in Parliament Square were held by a group of Met Officers next to a statue of Gandhi after they held placards which said: 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action' Officers could be seen carrying away a number of protesters who were lying down, lifting them off the ground and into waiting police vans parked around the square Others yelled 'from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free' - a controversial chant which some say is a call for Israel not to exist. Kate was holding a sign which said: 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action.' She said: 'It's shocking. I'm terrified. But the greater risk is genocide. That's more important. I don't have a phone. I've never been arrested before. 'I can't work because I've been trouble before connected to these activities. 'I was in social care. I had a good job. Nobody will employ me now. They'll think I'm a terrorist after this as well.' An elderly man - believed to be in his 70s - looked visibly unwell as he was taken into the back of a police van. A woman in her 40s was also taken away. Scotland Yard said its stance remains that officers will act where criminal offences, including support of proscribed groups or organisations, are committed. A spokesperson for the Met police said: 'We are responding to a protest in support of Palestine Action. Officers are in the process of making arrests.' This is the second round of protests in London in support of Palestinian Action and the group have said they will continue to take to Parliament Square every week. Last Saturday police arrested almost 30 people on suspicion of terrorism offences after protesters gathered in Parliament Square also holding signs supporting Palestine Action, just hours after a ban on the came into effect. One of those arrested was an 83-year-old priest and the Met said: 'The law doesn't have an age limit'. Around two dozen people, including a priest, professor and an emergency care worker who is just back from Gaza, sat in front of the Gandhi statue in Parliament Square on Saturday expressing support for the group, which is now a proscribed terrorist organisation. They held signs saying: 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action.' Shortly after their arrival, police officers could be seen engaging with the protesters and the Met said it had began making arrests. Several people were seen being carried away by officers. A spokesperson for the force said: 'Officers are responding to a protest in support of Palestine Action in Parliament Square. 'The group is now proscribed and expressing support for them is a criminal offence. Arrests are being made.' They later added: 'A total of 29 arrests were made during this afternoon's protest in support of Palestine Action in Parliament Square. They remain in custody.' It comes after the Home Office today last week the ban on Palestine Action, with the group failing to block its proscription as a terrorist organisation in a late-night legal bid. Lawyers representing co-founder Huda Ammori, whose father is Palestinian, asked for the decision to be delayed at least until July 21. The designation as a terror group means that membership of or support for Palestine Action is a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison. This includes chanting, wearing clothing or displaying articles such as flags, signs or logos. Palestine Action argues it is a protest group that has never incited or encouraged violence, but does support civil disobedience. Activists protest against the continuing war in Gaza, which has killed more than 57,000 Palestinians since October 7 - when 1,200 Israelis were killed by a Hamas incursion into the country. One of those protesting last week is former government lawyer Tim Crosland. He said: 'There are already 18 Palestine Actionists held in UK prisons without a trial, following lobbying by the Israeli government and Elbit Systems, the leading supplier of the machinery of genocide. 'If we cannot speak freely about the genocide of Palestinians, if we cannot condemn those who enable it and praise those who resist it, then the right to freedom of expression has no meaning, and democracy in this country is dead.' In a post shared on X, Defend Our Juries said the protesters had been arrested 'for holding cardboard signs' and that further arrests had been made at the Manchester demonstration. Scotland Yard said its stance remains that officers will act where criminal offences, including support of proscribed groups or organisations, are committed. The force added that this includes 'chanting, wearing clothing or displaying articles such as flags, signs or logos'. The terror group designation means that membership of, or support for, Palestine Action is a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison. The move to ban the organisation came after two Voyager aircraft were damaged at RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire on June 20, an incident claimed by Palestine Action, which police said caused about £7 million worth of damage. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper announced plans to proscribe Palestine Action, saying that the vandalism of the planes was 'disgraceful' and the group had a 'long history of unacceptable criminal damage'.
Daily Mail
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Common breast cancer treatment could reduce risk of developing Alzheimer's, research suggests
Women who undergo a common breast cancer treatment may have a lower risk of developing Alzheimer's disease, research suggests. The neurodegenerative disorder – which affects memory, thinking and behaviour – impacts more than 900,000 people in the UK. There is currently no cure and most cases of the condition are not linked to genetics. But scientists in South Korea have found that breast cancer patients treated with radiotherapy were significantly less likely to go on to develop Alzheimer's than women who hadn't received the treatment. Around one in seven women in the UK will be diagnosed with breast cancer during their lifetime. More than 70 per cent will be treated with radiotherapy, which uses high-energy radiation to kill cancer cells and shrink tumours. To investigate whether cancer treatment affects Alzheimer's risk, researchers at Samsung University analysed health records of more than 250,000 women. Around 70,000 were breast cancer survivors who had undergone surgery and treatment between 2010 and 2016. They found those who received radiotherapy were 8 per cent less likely to develop Alzheimer's than women who either hadn't had the treatment or had never had breast cancer. 'Based on these findings, we hypothesise that the risk of Alzheimer's dementia could be lowered shortly after cancer treatment,' said lead author Dr Su-Min Jeong. However, he added that this apparent protective effect faded with time. 'It may equalise as the survival period increases,' he said. Researchers believe radiotherapy may have anti-inflammatory or neuroprotective effects. It's also been shown to reduce levels of two types of brain cells linked to inflammation in Alzheimer's. Other theories suggest radiation may interfere with the formation of amyloid plaques – abnormal protein clumps found in the brains of Alzheimer's patients – or influence the immune system.
Times
16 minutes ago
- Times
UN expert demands Scottish government uphold sex-based rights
The United Nations expert on the rights of women and girls has told SNP ministers to immediately implement the Supreme Court ruling on the definition of 'sex' in law. Reem Alsalem, newly re-appointed as the UN special rapporteur on violence against women and girls, said there should be no 'pause' in action to ensure the sex-based rights of women were upheld and the Scottish government should 'actually get on with it and do it' 'I do not think we should pause or put on hold any action awaiting this guidance, and I don't think the Supreme Court said that either,' she said. Scottish ministers said they were waiting for guidance from the Equalities and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) before implementing the court ruling, which has significant implications for single-sex spaces such as changing rooms, refuges and lavatories as well as in sports, healthcare and public appointments. An EHRC consultation on the guidance closed on July 1. Alsalem said: 'While it is good you will have guidance, I do agree with those who say that there is a lot that can and should be implemented. It is not that there is ambiguity about all aspects of what the Supreme Court says.' The Supreme Court ruled this year against Scottish ministers in favour of the campaign group For Women Scotland, finding that 'sex' in equality law referred to biological sex and not gender identity. In an interview with The Sunday Times, Alsalem also said that organisations had 'punished' those who stood up for their sex-based rights. Referring specifically to Sandie Peggie, the nurse at the centre of an employment tribunal against NHS Fife, Alsalem said that public bodies that failed to support a woman's right to single-sex spaces were going 'against what is now the law of the land'. 'Particularly since the Supreme Court ruling, punishing women because they indicate their support for their sex-based right at work seems to me to be very problematic and goes against what is now the law of the land,' Alsalem said of the Peggie case. Peggie, a nurse at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, was suspended by NHS Fife last year after she complained about having to share changing facilities with Dr Beth Upton, who is male but identifies as a woman. • Sandie Peggie tribunal: NHS Fife in major 'blunder' as trans discrimination case resumes Alsalem was a vocal critic of the Scottish government's reforms to gender recognition legislation, warning in 2022 that proposals for self-identification could 'open the door for violent males who identify as men to abuse the process of acquiring a gender certificate and the rights that are associated with it'. Ministers pushed back on this suggestion and Shona Robison, then the social justice secretary, said there was no body of evidence pointing to 'bad-faith actors' trying to use statutory processes to abuse women and girls. In calling for the Scottish government to act, Alsalem added: 'If businesses and state-affiliated institutions and government entities recognise that this is the right thing to do, and now this has also been said clearly by the Supreme Court, they actually get on with it and do it.' Last month she presented a report to the UN human rights council in which she assessed gender-based violence in the UK. She wrote in the report: 'Women and girls, as well as their male allies, who wish to reassert their needs and rights based on their sex and have asserted the immutable nature of sex have been ostracised, attacked and punished by state and non-state actors, including political parties, universities, private employers and the media, for their beliefs and opinions.' Her findings said that the UK and Scottish governments must ensure the Supreme Court ruling was upheld by employers and healthcare providers and that it was incumbent on ministers to provide guidance on how to ensure the protection of single-sex spaces. A spokesman for the Scottish government said it had made it 'clear' that it accepted the Supreme Court's findings and that 'detailed work' was 'ongoing' to draft guidance. Alsalem also said it was of importance that Police Scotland clarified its approach to data collection and ended its practice of conflating biological sex with gender identity. 'The conflation of sex and gender data, in particular prioritising self-identified gender, erases biological sex records, distorting the male-driven nature of violence against women and girls and hindering root-cause analysis,' she said. 'This approach undermines crime statistics and policy effectiveness in relation to violence against women and girls.' The government spokesman added: 'We have already updated our guidance for the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018 and are amending the recruitment process for appointments to regulated public bodies. In addition, Police Scotland has published interim guidance on searching of transgender people.' Alsalem also backed proposed legislation to criminalise buying sex and said that Scotland should outlaw child marriage. She expressed support for the Nordic model — a system that criminalises men for buying sex and decriminalises women doing sex work. Her report recommends the Nordic model is introduced across the UK and Alsalem said she supports a new bill proposed by Ash Regan, the Alba MSP. 'The data emanating from countries that apply the Nordic model shows very clearly that it works,' she said. 'And data that comes from countries that legalise all aspects of prostitution — I don't use the term sex work, because you are not doing work and you are not selling sex. It is exploitation and abuse and it's not a regular job.' However, she said, the bill before the Scottish parliament did not go far enough and should be extended, as in Sweden, to cover websites such as Only Fans. The Scottish government has confirmed that it will consult on the issue of child marriage in Scotland, looking at raising the age of consent to be married to 18. Alsalem gave her support to the proposal, saying child marriage was a crime and that the minimum age for legal marriage should be raised to be 18, in line with elsewhere in the UK.
