Irishman jailed for 15 years for murdering girlfriend Kirsty Ward while on holiday in Spain
The two years Keith Byrne (34) has already spent in prison on remand will qualify as time served for the murder of the Dublin mother-of-one (36).
Byrne was also handed a restraining order preventing him contacting Kirsty's teenage son, mum or siblings, or going within 1,000 metres of them for 25 years.
He was ordered to pay her son €150,000 in compensation, her mum €80,000 and each of her siblings €20,000.
Public prosecutors demanded a 20-year jail sentence after a Jury convicted Byrne of strangling Kirsty to death at a hotel in Salou on July 2, 2023, after she told him she was leaving him.
The sentencing decision was revealed overnight in a 121-page written ruling by the judge who presided over Byrne's trial at a court in the east coast Spanish city of Tarragona.
The sentencing ruling can be appealed. It is not yet clear whether Kirsty's family have already lodged an appeal or intend doing so.
A private prosecutor for Kirsty's family said after the guilty verdict she was still seeking the 30-year sentence for Byrnes she argued for before and during the trial.
Sentencing judge Susana Calvo Gonzalez ruled the fact Byrne and his partner had been in a stable eight-month relationship made the crime more serious.
She said Byrne's consumption of alcohol and drugs before the murder diminished his cognitive faculties and was a prevailing mitigating factor.
The judge rejected arguments private prosecutor Estela Cortes put forward to justify a 30-year prison term: 'I understand that there is a prevailing basis for imposing the lower penalty and, therefore, imposing a sentence of between seven years and six months and 15 years.
'Within that range, the recognition of the aggravating circumstance and the motivation for the act…lead to the imposition of the maximum penalty, which is 15 years in prison,' she said.
In May, jurors found Keith Byrne guilty after three days of deliberations of strangling Kirsty Ward to death after she told him she was leaving him.
Byrne claimed during his trial Kirsty took her own life at their four-star Magnolia Hotel in the popular Costa Daurada resort of Salou.
He described himself as a 'respectful and intelligent' father-of-three who would never commit an act of domestic violence – and demonised Kirsty as someone who could be 'four people in one day' and who he claimed made their romance 'toxic'.
A private prosecutor acting for Kirsty's family sought a 30-year sentence for Byrnes, while public prosecutor Javier Goimil urged the judge to jail him for 20 years.
Advertisement
Goimil, a domestic violence specialist, rubbished Byrne's court claim that Kirsty took her own life during his closing speech to the jury last Wednesday on the final day of the murder trial.
He claimed the former soldier, who had been living in Duleek, Co Meath, decided: 'You're mine or you're nobody's' and strangled his girlfriend to death because she wanted to leave him.
He said the forensic evidence pointed to Kirsty had been strangled from behind between 8pm and 10pm on 2 July, 2023.
He told the court: 'Byrne has adapted his version of events of what happened in that timeframe nearly two years on in accordance with the evidence he's learnt there is against him.'
He added: 'What's occurred here is a violent and painful death, a strangulation from behind where someone is pulling from the front to the back. This was not a suicide.'
He also said: 'She didn't leave a note for her son or her siblings or her mum and what's more she had bought a plane ticket back to Dublin for 4 July.
'Kirsty's relationship with Byrne was very toxic, very intense and very emotional. She decided to end it during the week they stayed at the hotel in Salou and her partner couldn't accept that decision,' he said.
'His mindset at that moment was: 'Or you're mine or you're nobody's. You, woman, are no-one to say you're going to detach yourself from me the man and have your own independent life,' he added.
He said: 'That was why he killed her the way he did.'
He also said the amount of alcohol Kirsty had consumed before being killed would have impacted significantly on her ability to defend herself.
Kirsty's mum Jackie Ward described Byrne as someone she 'didn't like' and 'didn't trust' on day one of the trial on 23 April and said she had found out after her daughter's death she had planned to leave him during their 'make or break' holiday.
She was asked as she gave evidence whether she thought her daughter, whose son Evan was 14 when she died, could have taken her own life but replied angrily: 'She did everything for her son. She would never ever leave him. She would never do that to him.'
Following the jury verdict, Kirsty Ward's family said in a statement: 'Our family wish to thank our private prosecutor Estela Cortes and her team for guiding, supporting and representing Kirsty, her son and our family at this very difficult and painful time.'
They also thanked 'Javier Goimil the public prosecutor for his commitment and passion; the Spanish investigation teams and police for their expertise, empathy and understanding; and the jury for seeing and believing in what was the truth about our beautiful Kirsty.'
'Our family now request our privacy to be respected, while we grieve and come to terms with all that has happened during the past two years.'
Jackie Ward described her daughter after her death as a 'fantastic friend' to her parents and 'an absolutely adored daughter.'
It emerged following Byrne's Spanish arrest that he was wanted in England by Royal Military Police for going AWOL after he left for Ireland in 2017.
Reports in Ireland last March said Spanish prosecutors intended to interview at least two of his former partners about assisting the case by giving background information about him.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
28 minutes ago
- Sunday World
Boarding school educated woman spared jail for smuggling person into Ireland
Nko Mpase (62) pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court Nko Mpase (62) of Golden Ridge Close, Rush, Co Dublin, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to facilitating the entry into the state of another person at Dublin Airport on May 16, 2020. Ms Justice Patricia Ryan had adjourned sentencing after hearing evidence on a previous date to allow a probation report and documentation in relation to Mpase's previous educational and work history be provided to the court. Ms Justice Ryan noted the allegations were very serious and took into account factors including her early guilty plea and that she was not financially gaining from the offending. The judge also noted her work ethic and lack of previous convictions. She set a headline sentence of five years and, taking into account the mitigating factors, imposed a three-year sentence, which she suspended in full on strict conditions. At an earlier sentence hearing, Garda Sean McGlynn of the National Immigration Bureau told the court that Mpase and another woman arrived at Terminal One on a Ryanair flight from Paris Beauvais Airport. Both went to the same immigration booth, and Mpase's travelling companion produced a genuine travel document; however, on inspection, she did not look like the woman in the picture on it. The woman said she was a Congolese national and had travelled with Mpase from Beauvais Airport. When their phones were looked at, gardai saw communication between the two women on WhatsApp. Gardai found a picture of a ticket on the phone that Mpase had bought for the woman. Mpase accepted that she had travelled with the woman from Paris but did not make any further admissions. Mpase, as an Irish national, then left the airport. The court heard the two women were shown on CCTV as having been in each other's company and sat together on the plane. Data from Ryanair showed the booking was made on the same date. The first transaction did not go through as there was a suspicion of fraud, and then a different card was used to make the booking. Mpase pleaded on her arraignment date. She has two previous convictions for minor traffic offences and one for threatening behaviour. Under cross-examination, the garda agreed they did not find any evidence of financial gain, and Mpase has never done anything of this nature before. He also agreed Mpase was in Paris to visit family for five days. He further agreed that Mpase's husband died unexpectedly from complications of Covid-19 in 2021. The court heard an old friend from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) made contact with her, and that although no admissions had been made, 'the community is tight'. Patrick McCullough BL, prosecuting, told the court the maximum sentence is 10 years' imprisonment. Fergal McMorrow BL, defending, told the court his client came from DRC and 'appears to have a very good upbringing'. Counsel said she attended boarding school in Switzerland and trained as a paediatric nurse in Belgium. She fled the war and has been in Ireland since 2001. She first lived in Drogheda and then in Rush, where she worked as a carer and later in a Montessori setting. She suffered two heart attacks and changed her career. Her husband worked in laundromats for over 20 years and died of complications of Covid-19 in 2021. Counsel said his client 'contributed to this country in a very meaningful way'. He said 'she was not in it for profit' but 'shouldn't have done it'. She was anxious about going into custody.
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Revenue have seized hundreds of fake League of Ireland jerseys, 'retro' kits and designer shoes
ALMOST €150,000 WORTH of fake Irish, League of Ireland and GAA jerseys and sportswear was seized by Revenue over the last week. A total of 428 counterfeit items, including popular 'retro' football jerseys and dozens of pairs of fake designer shoes and handbags, were confiscated by customers officers. Revenue, which controls the entry of products into the country, confirmed with the products of the real sports tops and flashy kicks that the products had breached their intellectual property rights. It was among a number of seizures made last week, including up to €2 million in cannabis. Advertisement Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Extra.ie
4 hours ago
- Extra.ie
'Incredible' Indian support offered to woman who helped victim of brutal Tallaght attack
The Indian community in Ireland offered 'incredible' support to Jennifer Murray for helping their countryman in the aftermath of the brutal Tallaght attack last weekend. Gardaí confirmed to this week they are investigating the attack as a racially motivated hate crime. Ms Murray told she got bunches of flowers from local Indian community groups, received a call from a consultant oncologist in Beaumont Hospital who thanked her on behalf of the Indian medical community, and has had her whole family invited for dinner in the Indian restaurant in The Square, Tallaght. Jennifer Murray. Pic: Seán Dwyer The mum of six who is a carer for her mother-in-law, has also been interviewed on Indian TV this week when she said what happened is not representative of Ireland. 'I'm trying to get awareness out there,' she told 'I think negative people are just louder now, so positive people need to be braver and louder… the real Irish need to stand up and say 'they don't represent me.' Gardaí confirmed they are investigating the attack as a racially motivated hate crime. Pic: Artur Widak/NurPhoto via Getty Images 'I do not know anything about [politics], it is not a world I am a part of. But I do know if you shout something loud enough you will always find people to listen.' Ms Murray said the gang attacking were shouting that he was a paedophile. But the moment she met him, she knew this was not true. Jennifer Murray. Pic: Seán Dwyer 'The second I met this man, looked at this man, there was no question of this. I knew instinctively – then through logical, individual thinking – I could assess the situation very quickly.' A video of the man beaten and bleeding on the road was posted to a well-known Facebook account. Under the post were hundreds of hate-filled comments, coming mostly from Irish men. 'I made the video [about how she found the victim, and how he was innocent of the allegations], posted it and went to bed. 'I didn't even say it to my partner. I have not watched the video back, but I know what I said is true and it's how I felt. 'What happened to that man was wrong and incomprehensible to me.'
