
Australia has no duty to protect Indigenous group from climate change, court finds
Justice Michael Wigney stated that decisions on carbon emissions and climate protection fall within government policy, not judicial oversight, despite accepting scientific evidence of "devastating" impacts.
The case was brought by two Torres Strait Islander elders, Paul Kabai and Pabai Pabai, who argued the government was negligent in failing to safeguard their ancestral lands from rising sea levels and other climate harms.
Experts said the ruling exposed critical gaps in Australia's laws, with the judge noting current law provides no effective avenue for individuals to claim relief for climate inaction.
The claimants expressed profound disappointment but are considering an appeal, while legal experts emphasised the need for Australian law to adapt to the realities of climate change.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Morning Mail: Trump lashes Maga ‘weaklings' over Epstein case, Australia's birthrate falls, and a Hiroshima love story
Morning everyone. He was meant to be the man to defeat the 'deep state' – but Donald Trump has found himself defending the transparency of his handling of the Jeffrey Epstein case, calling his Maga supporters 'weaklings' for not accepting the administration's line. At home, the birth rate is slumping in cities amid the cost-of-living crisis, Aldi is taking on Coles and Woolworths with home deliveries, and an Australian love story born out of the ashes of Hiroshima. Price challenge | As Aldi announces a trial of grocery delivery, our consumer affairs reporter Catie McLeod has put it to the test, pricing a basket of goods from the discount supermarket against the same products from Coles and Woolworths. Birth-rate blues | Low birthrates in Australia's biggest cities deepened last year amid sustained cost-of-living pressures, dragging the national figure to a near-record low. Outer-suburban and regional residents are increasingly likely to have higher numbers of children per person than inner-city dwellers. Strait talking | After Torres Strait Islanders lost their legal case about climate change, experts and advocates say it's time for the law to change. Race warning | Australia's race discrimination commissioner has warned there is limited detail in how Jillian Segal's plan to combat antisemitism would be implemented, and said he would work with her to ensure it does not restrict fundamental rights and freedoms. Albanese in tune | Anthony Albanese will return home from China after hitting the right notes on his diplomatic mission but it could become harder for the two countries to stay in tune, writes our chief political correspondent Tom McIlroy. Iceland eruption | A volcano on Reykjanes peninsula in Iceland has erupted for ninth time since 2023 and residents have been told to stay indoors because of high levels of toxic gas from the 2.4km fissure. Maga uproar | Donald Trump has called his own supporters gullible 'weaklings' for questioning the transparency of a secretive government inquiry into the late high-profile socialite and sex offender Jeffrey Epstein as he spent another day trying to stamp out a conspiracy-fuelled uproar among his Maga base. We have a timeline of the Epstein story and you can follow developments in Washington live at our blog. Elsewhere in Trumpland, the president has privately indicated he is on the verge of firing the Federal Reserve chair, Jerome Powell, rattling Wall Street and renewing questions over the US central bank's independence. Gaza crush | At least 20 Palestinians have been killed in a crush at a food distribution site in southern Gaza after guards used teargas or pepper spray on hungry crowds arriving at the centre. Mega Meta | Mark Zuckerberg says Meta will spend hundreds of billions of dollars on developing AI products and will build a data centre the size of Manhattan to drive the plan. We're not going on a bear hunt | The hunt for a brown bear that bit a man on the elbow in Norway has been put on hold after officials shot the wrong bear. Will this weekend's election end the political chaos in Tasmania? Guardian Australia's Adam Morton speaks to Reged Ahmad about the issues at stake in this weekend's state election and whether the winner will be able to work across the aisle to get things done. Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ It is nearly 80 years since the dropping of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima, and today we have the remarkable love story of a 16-year-old Japanese survivor who met and fell in love with an Australian serviceman. The couple settled in Melbourne in defiance of the White Australia policy, and their children tell Stephanie Convery why they are heading to Japan for the anniversary to honour their 96-year-old mother. When Australia's over-80s basketball team (the Boomer Boomers, we might call them) went to the world championships, Kieran Pender went along to hear inspirational stories of keeping active and never losing the dream of representing your country. There are also wonderful photographs by Marco Serventi. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Cycling | There was chaos on stage 11 of the Tour de France in Toulouse as the defending champion, Tadej Pogacar, crashed and an anti-Israel protester ran on to the final straight. Norway's Jonas Abrahamsen claimed the stage win. Golf | The R&A says it has held a 'really good discussion' with Donald Trump's family over the thorny issue of when their Turnberry course might stage the Open again. Rugby union | Wallabies coach Geoff Parling knows all about the pressures of a Lions tour because he was once a tourist himself back in his England playing days, writes Robert Kitson. Football | Italy are in a women's major tournament semi-final for the first time since 1997 after a stunning 2-1 victory over Norway in the dying minutes of the first Women's Euros quarter-final. Follow all the reaction on our live blog. The family of outback murderer Bradley Murdoch tell the NT News that he was a 'devoted' family man and would be missed. Many people in the Liberal party are 'pissed off' about the plan to challenge the Bradfield election result in the courts, the Daily Telegraph claims. The Geelong Advertiser reports that dozens of people have been arrested and weapons seized in police raids across the city. Rugby Australia has defended the cost of tickets to see the Lions test, as the Sydney Morning Herald points out that a seat in the nosebleeds is going for $379. Sydney | Public hearing of the NSW inquiry into the impact of renewable energy zones on rural and regional communities and industries. Canberra | Anne Hollands and Grace Tame speak at a roundtable at 9.30am on the rise in AI child sexual exploitation. Economy | The latest employment data is released by the ABS at 11.30am. If you would like to receive this Morning Mail update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or finish your day with our Afternoon Update newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. And finally, here are the Guardian's crosswords to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword


The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Indigenous Wampis are ambushed in Peru after government backs out of anti-mining joint patrol
An attack by armed assailants on a patrol of a mission by the Indigenous Wampis guards last week in the Peruvian Amazon has again brought into focus the issue of illegal gold mining in the ancestral territory. The 60-member mission was ambushed and shot at as they were patrolling near the Wampis community of Fortaleza on Saturday, just days after the Peruvian government's sudden withdrawal from a planned joint enforcement operation to confront the illegal mining. No one was hurt in the attack. For two years, the Wampis Nation has pressed state agencies and the public prosecutor's office in Peru to work together to monitor for and remove illegal mining operations from the Santiago River basin. Days before a scheduled joint operation, government agencies pulled out without explanation, according to Amazon Watch, a U.S.-based environmental and Indigenous rights nonprofit. In response, the Wampis launched their own mission and its first patrol was attacked on Saturday. Indigenous leaders say the incident highlights the growing risks faced by land defenders and the government's failure to uphold its promises. A Wampis official described the attack to The Associated Press. The around 60 Indigenous leaders, community guards and technicians were tasked with monitoring the environmental impacts of illegal gold mining in the Bajo Rio Santiago region. ' People started throwing explosives — I don't even know what kind they were — and then came the gunfire,' said Evaristo Pujupat Shirap, 45, communications officer for the Autonomous Territorial Government of the Wampis Nation. 'Bullets hit the vehicle and even pierced a teacher's jacket at chest level,' Shirap added. The Peruvian government did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Members on the Wampis mission were armed with hunting rifles, but according to Shirap, leaders had instructed the group not to fire under any circumstances. While they did fire a few warning shots into the air, no direct confrontation took place, Shirap added. 'We will not stand by while our rivers are poisoned and our forests destroyed,' said Galois Yampis, vice president of the Wampis government. Peru's "government failed to honor its commitments, so we are acting to defend our territory and the future of our people,' he added. The Indigenous Wampis territorial guards are community-led environmental defenders trained and organized by the autonomous territorial government of the Wampis Nation. Their aim is to protect Wampis ancestral lands from illegal activities such as mining, logging, and drug trafficking, while upholding their cultural values and vision of Tarimat Pujut — a life in harmony with nature. Raphael Hoetmer, Amazon program director at Amazon Watch, a longtime ally of the Wampis, said they only confront violent criminals — "yet are left to face danger without state protection.' The Wampis Nation has long been urging Peru and gold-importing nations to strengthen enforcement against illegal gold trade and invest in Indigenous-led territorial monitoring and sustainable development. ___ The Associated Press' climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at


Reuters
3 hours ago
- Reuters
EU lawmakers reject attempt to curb far right's sway on climate talks
BRUSSELS, July 9 (Reuters) - The European Parliament on Wednesday rejected a proposal to fast-track talks on the EU's new climate target, scuttling a move by liberal, socialist and green lawmakers to try to limit the influence of climate sceptic lawmakers on the goal. The far-right Patriots of Europe group, which rejects EU policies to curb climate change, on Tuesday took on the role of lead negotiators for the 2040 climate target, seeking to steer talks on the goal, which the group said it firmly opposed. Lawmakers rebuffed a proposal on Wednesday to fast-track the negotiations, which would have skipped stages where the Patriots could exert most influence, and limited their ability to set the timings for negotiations. A total of 379 lawmakers rejected the plan to accelerate the talks, versus 300 in favour and eight abstentions. The vote puts the Patriots firmly in the lead for the parliament as it negotiates the final 2040 climate target with EU member countries. The Patriots will now draft an initial negotiating proposal for the parliament. A Patriots spokesperson said the group would not prioritise trying to meet a September deadline for countries to submit new climate targets to the United Nations. "What truly matters is achieving a deal that delivers real benefits for our citizens. Patriots have never negotiated under pressure like traders in a marketplace," the spokesperson said. The Patriots are the third-biggest lawmaker group in the EU Parliament and the group includes the political parties of France's far-right leader Marine Le Pen and Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban. The Patriots secured the lead negotiating role in a closed-door meeting on Tuesday by outbidding the parliament's biggest group, the centre-right European People's Party, EU officials told Reuters. Green lawmakers said they feared the target would now be watered down or face long delays. "There is an acute danger that the European Union's climate target will be buried," said German EU lawmaker Michael Bloss. The attempt to fast-track the talks failed because it was not supported by the EPP - the party of European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. Dutch EPP EU lawmaker Jeroen Lenaers said the group did not deem the fast-track procedure necessary, and wanted to "improve" the Commission's proposed target to cut emissions 90% by 2040, without specifying further. Some EPP lawmakers have said a 90% target is too ambitious. Governments from Italy to Poland have pushed back this year on ambitious emissions-cutting goals, citing concerns over the costs for industries.