India vs England: Can Bazball outplay India's new era? Key battles and what to expect

Time of India

19-06-2025

Director of cricket Rob Key, selector Luke Wright, captain Ben Stokes and coach Brendon McCullum speak during a nets session at Headingley. (Getty Images)
NEW DELHI: England under
Ben Stokes
and
Brendon McCullum
has been a team reborn: fearless, unapologetic, and often breathtaking.
Since their bold reinvention in 2022, the Three Lions have gone from tactical conservatism to swashbuckling spectacle.
The world calls it "Bazball"; England, somewhat sheepishly, calls it just "how we play.
"
Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel.
SUBSCRIBE NOW!
'It's a phrase created by the media,' Stokes said earlier last year. 'Baz hates it.'
McCullum went further, insisting that 'Bazball' wasn't about chaos but 'thoughtful, calculated pressure.'
Poll
Which aspect of England's team is the most concerning heading into the India series?
Overdependence on Joe Root
Inexperience among new players
Lack of a proven spin bowler
Absence of Anderson and Broad
Regardless of semantics, the method has yielded results: 15 wins in 20 Tests, a strike rate of nearly 74 for their top seven batters, and a renewed swagger in whites.
But now comes the real exam: a five-Test showdown against India at home, a side led by Shubman Gill's calm demeanour, Jasprit Bumrah's unrelenting pace, Rishabh Pant's fearless flair, and an increasingly deep spin arsenal.
For all the "Bazball" hype, cracks remain in the English setup; and India will be itching to probe them.
'Ginormous talent pool': Ben Stokes warns against underestimating India in post-Kohli-Rohit era
1. Bazball's high-risk nature: All-in or all out?
England's aggressive template works brilliantly -- until it doesn't. The ultra-positive batting style offers no room for conservatism or survival.
On seaming pitches under English skies or against disciplined bowling units like India's, all-out aggression can quickly spiral into all-out collapse.
The absence of an effective Plan B has been England's Achilles' heel as they swing hard, and sometimes miss harder.
2. An ageing dependency: Joe Root as the pillar
In a team full of strokemakers, Joe Root remains the anchor.
Since Bazball's inception, his 3,000+ runs at an average north of 57 are the glue that holds the side together.
But that's precisely the problem. The team depends on him disproportionately. If Root fails, the England middle-order often crumbles.
Against India's high-skill attack, even a player of Root's calibre may find the burden too heavy.
IND vs ENG: Ben Stokes, Brendon McCullum engage in intense discussion between Headingley Test
3. Life without Anderson and Broad
This summer marks a turning point: no James Anderson, no Stuart Broad, a sentence that would have sounded unimaginable for over a decade.
The new crop, Sam Cook, Josh Tongue, Brydon Carse, is promising, but raw.
Without the calming presence of two generational greats, England's attack lacks the kind of psychological edge that Broad and Anderson brought, especially in crunch sessions.
4. The Spin Equation: Still not solved
England's long-standing spin conundrum remains unresolved. Shoaib Bashir, the teenage off-spinner, is talented but untested.
In a long series against players like Pant, Jaiswal and Gill, who feast on spin, he may find himself targeted early and often.
The lack of a seasoned spinner in home conditions is a tactical vulnerability India is almost certain to exploit.
Nick Knight EXCLUSIVE: On Shubman Gill and absence of Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma in England
5. Middle-order uncertainty
Ollie Pope, Harry Brook, and Zak Crawley have all enjoyed purple patches.
But when the ball moves or when scoreboard pressure mounts, their flamboyance often becomes fragility.
Crawley averages under 40, and the same goes for Brook in the home conditions, and Pope, though improved, still lacks that air of inevitability.
6. Inexperience in the ranks
England's squad is dotted with talent but short on scars. Names like Jamie Smith, Jacob Bethell, and Shoaib Bashir suggest a team looking to the future.
But in a long, gruelling Test series, that lack of big-match experience could hurt. India's seasoned core, from Pant and Jadeja to Shubman and Bumrah, offers a battle-hardened edge.
"Bazball" has redefined England's identity, but this India series could be its most rigorous stress test.
There is confidence, there is firepower but also overdependence, inexperience, and tactical gaps. If India expose them early, "Bazball" could unravel quickly.
The question isn't whether England can win; it's whether they can adapt when their philosophy is cornered.
Game On Season 1 kicks off with Sakshi Malik's inspiring story. Watch Episode 1 here