Book review- A new era for State-Owned Enterprises: Dr Nimrod Mbele's blueprint for change
Image: supplied
In a landscape riddled with governance failures, Reimagined SOEs in Africa and Beyond emerges not from frustration, but from a profound sense of hope.
Author Dr Nimrod Mbele, whose journey from the township of Thokoza profoundly shapes his perspective, presents a powerful diagnostic and blueprint for transforming State Owned Enterprises (SOEs) across Africa.
His inspiration is deeply rooted in a decade of firsthand observation—engaging with boardrooms, public institutions, and media, all while witnessing the persistent governance failures plaguing SOEs.
Yet, this experience didn't lead to despair. Instead, it ignited a conviction that reform is possible if governance is reframed "not as compliance, but as a leadership system rooted in public value."
'South Africa must shift from leader-centric to leadership-centric systems - where performance is not dependent on individual personalities but institutionalised within strong, accountable structures.
'This requires reinforcing board independence, implementing merit-based appointments, instituting clear performance compacts, and establishing a capable and credible State Holding Company to ensure strategic coherence and protect SOEs from political interference,' Mbele said.
This central message, to "go beyond governance" toward institutional integrity, developmental purpose, and democratic accountability, is the driving force behind the book.
'Moreover, strategic SOEs like Eskom, SAA, and Transnet should operate on a commercial basis, with clearly defined mandates.
'Their profits should be reinvested into the national fiscus to support essential social objectives such as education, healthcare and social security.
'Persisting with outdated ideological approaches only entrenches inefficiency and deepens the financial reliance of SOEs on the fiscus, an unsustainable model, especially in a context where the economy has grown at less than 2% over the past decade. Reimagining SOEs is, therefore, not only about governance reform but also about restoring both public trust and institutional capability,' Mbele said.
His Thokoza upbringing, marked by systemic challenges like under-resourced schools and weak service delivery, provides a critical lens.
Mbele witnessed how dysfunctional institutions deepen inequality and erode hope, fueling his belief that reform transcends mere policy or structure.
'My journey from Thokoza, a township shaped by struggle and resilience, to becoming a thought leader in governance profoundly informs my perspective on institutional reform. Growing up amidst systemic challenges - under-resourced schools, weak service delivery, and socio-economic hardships.
'I witnessed firsthand how dysfunctional institutions deepen inequality and erode hope. This lived experience fuels my conviction that reform is not just about policy or structure, but about restoring trust, dignity, and accountability in public institutions. Institutional reform must be people-centered, prioritising transparency, ethical leadership and inclusive participation to break cycles of exclusion,' he said.
For him, it's about "restoring trust, dignity, and accountability in public institutions."
This lived experience, coupled with insights from consulting, academia, and broadcasting, culminates in a strategic agenda for renewal that bridges personal narrative, rigorous research, and public dialogue.
Mbele's advocacy for "governance that is accessible and responsive" underscores his commitment to ensuring institutions serve all citizens, especially those from historically marginalised communities.
This empathetic approach, combined with a demand for technical excellence, forms the bedrock of his vision for sustainable SOE reform.
The book is, at its core, a testament to the author's unwavering conviction that African SOEs can and must be instruments of transformation, not political patronage.
[email protected]
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
19 hours ago
- IOL News
Book review- A new era for State-Owned Enterprises: Dr Nimrod Mbele's blueprint for change
Dr Nimrod Mbele agues that affirmative action take South Africa back in his new book Reimagining State-Owned Enterprises For Africa and Beyond Image: supplied In a landscape riddled with governance failures, Reimagined SOEs in Africa and Beyond emerges not from frustration, but from a profound sense of hope. Author Dr Nimrod Mbele, whose journey from the township of Thokoza profoundly shapes his perspective, presents a powerful diagnostic and blueprint for transforming State Owned Enterprises (SOEs) across Africa. His inspiration is deeply rooted in a decade of firsthand observation—engaging with boardrooms, public institutions, and media, all while witnessing the persistent governance failures plaguing SOEs. Yet, this experience didn't lead to despair. Instead, it ignited a conviction that reform is possible if governance is reframed "not as compliance, but as a leadership system rooted in public value." 'South Africa must shift from leader-centric to leadership-centric systems - where performance is not dependent on individual personalities but institutionalised within strong, accountable structures. 'This requires reinforcing board independence, implementing merit-based appointments, instituting clear performance compacts, and establishing a capable and credible State Holding Company to ensure strategic coherence and protect SOEs from political interference,' Mbele said. This central message, to "go beyond governance" toward institutional integrity, developmental purpose, and democratic accountability, is the driving force behind the book. 'Moreover, strategic SOEs like Eskom, SAA, and Transnet should operate on a commercial basis, with clearly defined mandates. 'Their profits should be reinvested into the national fiscus to support essential social objectives such as education, healthcare and social security. 'Persisting with outdated ideological approaches only entrenches inefficiency and deepens the financial reliance of SOEs on the fiscus, an unsustainable model, especially in a context where the economy has grown at less than 2% over the past decade. Reimagining SOEs is, therefore, not only about governance reform but also about restoring both public trust and institutional capability,' Mbele said. His Thokoza upbringing, marked by systemic challenges like under-resourced schools and weak service delivery, provides a critical lens. Mbele witnessed how dysfunctional institutions deepen inequality and erode hope, fueling his belief that reform transcends mere policy or structure. 'My journey from Thokoza, a township shaped by struggle and resilience, to becoming a thought leader in governance profoundly informs my perspective on institutional reform. Growing up amidst systemic challenges - under-resourced schools, weak service delivery, and socio-economic hardships. 'I witnessed firsthand how dysfunctional institutions deepen inequality and erode hope. This lived experience fuels my conviction that reform is not just about policy or structure, but about restoring trust, dignity, and accountability in public institutions. Institutional reform must be people-centered, prioritising transparency, ethical leadership and inclusive participation to break cycles of exclusion,' he said. For him, it's about "restoring trust, dignity, and accountability in public institutions." This lived experience, coupled with insights from consulting, academia, and broadcasting, culminates in a strategic agenda for renewal that bridges personal narrative, rigorous research, and public dialogue. Mbele's advocacy for "governance that is accessible and responsive" underscores his commitment to ensuring institutions serve all citizens, especially those from historically marginalised communities. This empathetic approach, combined with a demand for technical excellence, forms the bedrock of his vision for sustainable SOE reform. The book is, at its core, a testament to the author's unwavering conviction that African SOEs can and must be instruments of transformation, not political patronage. [email protected]
The Citizen
19 hours ago
- The Citizen
Returning MG means business with ‘simplified' range-topping HS
Chinese-owned British brand's top-spec SUV doesn't overcomplicate, but will have a tough battle against legacy brand offerings, as well as those from its fellow countrymen. The return of MG to South Africa last year came with a degree of surprise after its less-than-stellar previous market entry under the auspices of Combined Motor Holdings (CMH). From down to the very top Bought, along with Rover, from the defunct Phoenix Consortium in 2005 by Nanjing Automobile, which then became part of Shanghai Automotive Industry Corporation (SAIC Motor) two years later, the line-up of the 3 hatch and 6 sedan failed to attract the same attention as the ZR and the terminally aged TF did under MG Rover South Africa. Reinvented by SAIC since then to become a top 10 selling brand in the United Kingdom and Australia, Morris Garages' third entry into the local market tapered off significantly until the Simola Hillclimb in April. NOW READ: MG HS declares war on fellow Chinese brands Chery and Haval Aside from the dramatic all-electric Cyberster that harks the closest back to its sports car roots, the brand also teased the new generation 3 in hybrid form ahead of its imminent arrival. For the time being, its main bread-and-butter comes from two SUV, the entry-level ZS and the subject of this test, the range-topping HS. Cracking the segment Currently in its second generation having debuted last year, the HS enters a congested market segment flooded by products from its countrymen, as well as legacy brands such as Toyota, Volkswagen, Kia, Hyundai and Mazda. The latest Chinese product to enter the premium space, the arrival of the flagship HS Luxury for the weeklong stay raised more questions than answers pertaining not only to the change in products from the People's Republic becoming upmarket and no longer perceived as bargains, but its unique selling point compared to its opposition. Styling, sorted Finished in a slightly underwhelming colour called Sterling Silver, the HS still strikes an impression on first glance. Rear facia design has elements from the Audi Q8. Appearing subtly evil with a wraparound honeycomb grille, outstretched bonnet and elongated LED headlights seemingly derived from the Volkswagen Lamando – coincidentally made by Wolfsburg through its joint venture with SAIC – the HS' pose goes further with a side profile similar from some angles to the Jaguar F-Pace. Mounted on 19-inch alloy wheels, the rear appears more compact with an upwards moving lower glasshouse, and an indented look to the slimline LED light clusters connected by a full-width light bar. Flagship HS Luxury rides on 19-inch alloy wheels. Reminiscent of the Audi Q8, the HS sticks to its premium aspiration by being eye-catching and stylish, yet despite its malevolent finish, arguably not as distinctive as some of its countrymen. Interior not over-the-top The same applies to the interior, which is, once again, a traditional Chinese affair dominated by a pair of 12.3-inch displays on top of the dashboard, physical shortcut buttons for select functions below the infotainment display, and generally soft-touch materials. Interior conforms to the minimalistic design approach, but without going overboard on the tech front. Incorporating MG's take on minimalist interior design, the HS retains a traditional gear lever, though the non-floating centre console, which includes a pair of cupholders and a wireless smartphone charging pad, will require constant upkeep due to its piano key black finish. Solid in feel, built quality-wise, and sporty thanks to the red stitch work, the HS' imitation leather seats offer more than sufficient support as, aside from being comfortable, feature heating and electric adjustment. Despite appearing dated on the graphics front, the infotainment isn't a disaster or minefield to use. In a significant departure from other Chinese products, the HS' seats drop all the way to the bottom, thus providing a clear view of the instrument cluster and not akin to 'sitting above' the steering wheel as in a light truck. What's more, the infotainment system lacks the series' of sub-menus and while comparatively low-tech on the graphics front, works reasonably slick in addition to being Apple CarPlay compatible, but not Android Auto which required the use of a third-party dongle plugged into the USB port. Front seats are comfort-focused and feature electric adjustment, as well as heating. Less of a success was the delayed reaction of the oddly shaped, but still physical, volume button on the steering wheel, the quality of the eight-speaker sound system, and the infotainment being the interface for the dual-zone climate control. Practicality and spec Winning back ground, space in the rear leaves little to be desired as, apart from legroom, the standard panoramic sunroof doesn't encroach on headroom. Boot space is impressive at 507-litres. At the same time, practicality doesn't disappoint either, as opening the electric tailgate reveals a substantial 507-litre boot that increases to 1 484-litres with the 60/40 split rear seat folded. In Luxury spec, the HS' list of specification items, aside from those mentioned, includes keyless entry and push-button start, rain sense wipers, folding heated mirrors and four USB ports. Dropping the rear seats unlocks a total of 1 484-litres. On the safety and driver assistance side, MG has left little to chance, though with the option of having most of the systems switched off completely until being reactivated by the driver and 'lost' each time the engine is shut down. Applicable also to the Driver Attention Alert module, mounted awkwardly on the A-pillar, the HS Luxury's suite of systems comprises; Rear passenger space lacks for little on both leg-and-headroom fronts. seven airbags; tyre pressure monitor; front and rear parking sensors; 360-degree surround-view camera system; traction control; Auto High Beam Assist; Adaptive Cruise Control; Croner Brake Control; Electronic Stability Control; Hill Hold Control; Front and Rear Collision Warning; Blind Spot Monitoring; Lane Keep Assist; Lane Departure Warning; Rear Cross Traffic Alert; Reverse Automatic Braking; Lane Change Assist On the move Up front, another familiarity resides in the use of a 1.5-litre turbocharged petrol engine connected to a seven-speed dual-clutch gearbox. Set to be joined later by a more powerful 2.0-litre unit, power is rated at 125 kW and torque at 275 Nm, predictably directed to the front wheels only. Vocal, with the noise being audible even at the national limit, the engine feels laggy low-down, yet isn't hobbled by the now infamous Chinese vehicle throttle calibration and transmission mismatch. While, admittedly, still not fully rectified, the combination is more sorted and once up to speed with the initial lag gone, the HS is responsive despite tipping the scales at a rather heavy 1 602 kg. That being sad, the transmission does become flustered when asked to suddenly shift down, highlighting the need for paddle shifters, however, it thankfully lacks the typical dual-clutch 'box drag at low speeds. On the ride front, the HS offers a compliant, comfortable and well dampened setup, but with another equally familiar Chinese vehicle foible of an overly electric and lifeless steering feel. Providing the biggest surprise was fuel consumption, which, after seven days and 330 km, displayed a best of 7.7 L/100 km on the instrument cluster in mixed driving conditions. Conclusion As much as it doesn't set a new benchmark for premium Chinese SUVs, the MG HS is an honest entrant that doesn't do anything spectacularly good, nor untowardly bad. Comparable to the GAC Emkoo, it doesn't go overboard on the tech front and makes being an uncomplicated, well-equipped and practical SUV its main focus points. Priced at R534 900, or R499 900 in the case of the Comfort that loses a few nice-to-haves, the HS 1.5T Luxury represents a compelling buy in a fiercely competitive segment. However, an unproven track record of the 'new MG' and safe bet of other legacy or proven Chinese brands could well relegate it to a niche player. As such, only time will tell. NOW READ: Prices revealed as MG officially relaunches in South Africa
Eyewitness News
2 days ago
- Eyewitness News
'Win-win' and still pushing: Reactions to Trump tariffs
TOKYO - Some nations reacted with relief Friday after US President Donald Trump announced tariffs that in some cases were lower than threatened and delayed by a week to 7 August. But others - including Switzerland and chip powerhouse Taiwan - still hope to negotiate lower rates, and uncertainty remains over transshipments and levies on Japanese cars. Trump's announcement does not cover export giant China - currently in negotiations on a trade deal ahead of a 12 August deadline - but here is how other economies reacted: THAILAND: 'MAJOR SUCCESS' The 19% levy for Thailand and Cambodia - fresh from border clashes that killed over 40 people - is a let-off from the threatened 36%. Thailand called it a "major success" and a "win-win approach aimed at preserving Thailand's export base and long-term economic stability". The US trade deficit with Thailand hit $45.6 billion in 2024. Its main exports include machinery, vehicles and auto components. CAMBODIA: 'BEST NEWS' Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Manet called it "the best news for the people and economy of Cambodia to continue to develop the country". The major manufacturer of low-cost clothing for Western brands was initially menaced with a tariff of 40%. Neighbouring Vietnam concluded an agreement with Washington at the beginning of July on a rate reduced to 20%. WHAT ABOUT TRANSSHIPMENTS? But Washington also intends to impose a 40% surcharge on goods transported to the United States via third countries - known as transshipments. This could hurt in particular nations in Southeast Asia, whose production chains are closely linked to China. Many Cambodian factories, for example, are Chinese-owned and the White House has accused the kingdom of allowing Chinese goods to stop over on the way to US markets, skirting steeper rates imposed on Beijing. Experts however are unclear on how Washington will define these "transshipment" goods. TAIWAN: STILL PUSHING Taiwanese President Lai Ching-te called its 20% tariff announced by Trump "temporary... with the possibility of further reductions should an agreement be reached." The US president had threatened to hit the island with a 32% tax and possible duties on the island's huge semiconductors shipments. Soaring demand for Taiwan's AI chips industry has fuelled its trade surplus with Washington, putting it in the crosshairs of Trump's tariff blitz. Washington "needs Taiwan in supporting resilient supply chains, in supporting manufacturing and some high-end technologies," Vice President Hsiao Bi-khim said recently. SWITZERLAND: 'GREAT REGRET' Switzerland expressed "great regret" that it was hit with 39% - up from the threatened 31% - despite its "very constructive position". The levy - more than double the European Union's 15% - appeared to catch the rich Alpine nation off guard. Switzerland ranks sixth in terms of direct investment in the United States, with pharma giants Roche and Novartis announcing major spending plans in recent months. JAPAN: CAR CONFUSION A tariff of 15% agreed last week between Japan and Washington - down from a threatened 25% - is due to be applied from 7 August. But Japanese auto exports were already being hit by a 25% rate, and Tokyo wants to know when this will be lowered too. "We continue to urge the US to take prompt measures to implement the agreement, including lowering tariffs on automobile and auto parts," Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba said Friday. Confusion also surrounds Trump's claim that Japan - as a "signing bonus" - will invest $550 billion in America, which will recoup 90% of the profits. MALAYSIA: 'POSITIVE OUTCOME' Malaysia also achieved a lower tariff of 19% - down from 25% - which the government called a "positive outcome". "This decision by the United States reflects the strong and enduring economic ties between our two nations," Trade and Industry Minister Zafrul Abdul Aziz said. SRI LANKA: 'HAPPY' Sri Lanka also expressed relief that it will face a 20% hit, a sharp reduction from the 44% originally floated, and expressed hope of a further cut. "We are happy that our competitiveness in exports to the US has been retained," finance ministry official Harshana Suriyapperuma told reporters. Around 40% of Sri Lanka's $5.0 billion of garment exports last year went to the United States.
