Diddy gets standing ovation from inmates after court victory
'They all said: 'We never get to see anyone who beats the government,'' attorney Marc Agnifilo told The Associated Press in a weekend interview days after a jury acquitted Combs of sex trafficking and racketeering conspiracy charges.
Combs, 55, remains jailed at a federal lockup in Brooklyn after his conviction on prostitution-related charges, which could put him in prison for several more years. Any sentence will include credit for time already served. So far that's almost 10 months.
After federal agents raided his homes in Los Angeles and Miami in March 2024, Agnifilo said he told Combs to expect to be arrested on sex trafficking charges.
The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including deadly Texas floods, Australian woman attacked by a lion, and Elon Musk's new political party. (Source: 1News)
ADVERTISEMENT
'I said: 'Maybe it's your fate in life to be the guy who wins,'' he recalled during a telephone interview briefly interrupted by a jailhouse call from Combs. 'They need to see that someone can win. I think he took that to heart.'
Blunt trial strategy works
The verdict in Manhattan federal court came after a veteran team of eight defence lawyers led by Agnifilo executed a trial strategy that resonated with jurors. Combs passed lawyers notes during effective cross-examinations of nearly three dozen witnesses over two months, including Combs' ex-employees.
The lawyers told jurors Combs was a jealous domestic abuser with a drug problem who participated in the swinger lifestyle through threesomes involving Combs, his girlfriends and another man.
'You may think to yourself, wow, he is a really bad boyfriend,' Combs' lawyer Teny Geragos told jurors in her May opening statement. But that, she said, 'is simply not sex trafficking'.
Agnifilo said the blunt talk was a 'no brainer".
Defence attorney Marc Agnifilo, speaks outside Manhattan federal court July 2, 2025, in New York. (Source: Associated Press)
ADVERTISEMENT
'The violence was so clear and up front and we knew the government was going to try to confuse the jury into thinking it was part of a sex trafficking effort. So we had to tell the jury what it was so they wouldn't think it was something it wasn't,' he said.
Combs and his lawyers seemed deflated Tuesday (local time) when jurors said they were deadlocked on the racketeering count but reached a verdict on sex trafficking and lesser prostitution-related charges. A judge ordered them back to deliberate Wednesday.
'No one knows what to think,' Agnifilo said. Then he slept on it.
Morning surprise awakes lawyer
'I wake up at three in the morning and I text Teny and say: "We have to get a bail application together," he recalled. 'It's going to be a good verdict for us but I think he went down on the prostitution counts so let's try to get him out'.
He said he 'kind of whipped everybody into feeling better' after concluding jurors would have convicted him of racketeering if they had convicted him of sex trafficking because trafficking was an alleged component of racketeering.
Agnifilo met with Combs before court and Combs entered the courtroom rejuvenated. Smiling, the onetime Catholic schoolboy prayed with family. In less than an hour, the jury matched Agnifilo's prediction.
ADVERTISEMENT
The seemingly chastened Combs mouthed 'thank you' to jurors and smiled as family and supporters applauded. After he was escorted from the room, spectators cheered the defence team, a few chanting: 'Dream Team! Dream Team!' Several lawyers, including Geragos, cried.
'This was a major victory for the defence and a major loss for the prosecution,' said Mitchell Epner, a lawyer who worked with Agnifilo as a federal prosecutor in New Jersey over two decades ago. He credited 'a dream team of defence lawyers' against prosecutors who almost always win.
Agnifilo showcased what would become his trial strategy — belittling the charges and mocking the investigation that led to them — last September in arguing unsuccessfully for bail. The case against Combs was what happens when the 'federal government comes into our bedrooms,' he said.
In this courtroom sketch, Sean "Diddy" Combs reacts after he was convicted of prostitution-related offenses but acquitted of sex trafficking and racketeering charges. (Source: Associated Press)
Lawyers gently questioned most witnesses
During an eight-week trial, Combs' lawyers picked apart the prosecution case with mostly gentle but firm cross-examinations. Combs never testified and his lawyers called no witnesses.
Sarah Krissoff, a federal prosecutor in Manhattan from 2008 to 2021, said Combs' defence team 'had a narrative from the beginning and they did all of it without putting on any witnesses. That's masterful'.
ADVERTISEMENT
Ironically, Agnifilo expanded the use of racketeering laws as a federal prosecutor on an organised crime task force in New Jersey two decades ago, using them often to indict street gangs in violence-torn cities.
Where to get help for sexual violence. (Source: 1News)
'I knew the weak points in the statute,' he said. 'The statute is very mechanical. If you know how the car works, you know where the fail points are.'
He said prosecutors had 'dozens of fail points'.
'They didn't have a conspiracy, they just didn't,' he said. 'They basically had Combs' personal life and tried to build racketeering around personal assistants.'
Some personal assistants, even after viewing videos of Combs beating his longtime girlfriend, Casandra 'Cassie' Ventura, had glowing things to say about Combs on cross examination.
Once freed, Combs likely to reenter domestic abusers' programme
ADVERTISEMENT
For Combs, Agnifilo sees a long road ahead once he is freed as he works on personal demons, likely reentering a programme for domestic batterers that he had just started before his arrest.
'He's doing OK,' said Agnifilo, who speaks with him four or five times daily.
(Source: Breakfast)
He said Combs genuinely desires improvement and 'realises he has flaws like everyone else that he never worked on'.
'He burns hot in all matters. I think what he has come to see is that he has these flaws and there's no amount of fame and no amount of fortune' that can erase them," he said. 'You can't cover them up."
For Agnifilo, a final surprise awaited him after Combs' bail was rejected when a man collapsed into violent seizures at the elevators outside the courtroom.
'I'm like: 'What the hell?'' recalled the lawyer schooled in treating seizures.
ADVERTISEMENT
Agnifilo straddled him, pulling him onto his side and using a foot to prevent him from rolling backward while a law partner, Jacob Kaplan, put a backpack under the man's head and Agnifilo's daughter took his pulse.
'We made sure he didn't choke on vomit. It was crazy. I was worried about him,' he said.
The man was eventually taken away conscious by rescue workers, leaving Agnifilo to ponder a tumultuous day.
'It was like I was getting punked by God,' he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
an hour ago
- 1News
Person killed after getting sucked into plane engine at Italian airport
The airport in the northern Italian city of Bergamo briefly suspended flights overnight due to a runway incident that local media said involved someone running onto the tarmac, getting sucked into an airport engine and dying. The Bergamo Milan airport authority said all flights were suspended at the Bergamo-Orio al Serio airport from 10.20am to noon local time 'due to a problem that occurred on the taxiway.' An investigation was underway. Video footage posted on Corriere della Sera's website showed a body bag on the tarmac next to the aircraft, with fire crews nearby. Car of the victim being towed away (Source: Reuters) The newspaper, citing unnamed airport officials, said someone ran onto the tarmac as a plane was taking off, got sucked into the engine and died. ADVERTISEMENT The plane, an Airbus A319 of the Volotea airline, was flying from Orio to Asturias, Spain. The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including Australian doctor speaks about first meeting with Erin Patterson, why Donald Trump's swearing about Vladimir Putin, and how science could bring the moa back. (Source: 1News) LaPresse news agency, quoting unnamed investigators, said suicide was suspected. The airport's fire station, first aid station and border police refused to comment on the incident.
1News
an hour ago
- 1News
Man arrested after Auckland police car ramming
A 44-year-old man is facing charges after he was alleged to have repeatedly rammed a police car yesterday morning. Relieving Counties Manukau East Area Commander, Inspector Rakana Cook said police had been investigating since the stolen vehicle was seen running a red light near Carbine Rd in Mt Wellington shortly before 2.30am. "One of our frontline units signalled this vehicle to stop, and after driving erratically it came to a stop," he said. "It's at this point the four-wheel drive was allegedly used to repeatedly ram our patrol vehicle before fleeing the scene." He said no police staff were injured during the incident. ADVERTISEMENT A police patrol car with extensive damage after it was repeatedly rammed by a stolen vehicle in Auckland. (Source: NZ Police ) "Our inquiries led a team of police to an address on Puhinui Rd in Papatoetoe yesterday evening, locating the person of interest,' he said. "The man attempted to flee on foot from our staff but he was all out of options.' The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including Australian doctor speaks about first meeting with Erin Patterson, why Donald Trump's swearing about Vladimir Putin, and how science could bring the moa back. (Source: 1News) The 44-year-old man was arrested, and would face serious charges in the Manukau District Court today. "Those charges include two counts of assault with a blunt instrument, resisting police, failing to stop, unlawfully taking a vehicle and reckless driving," Cook said. "We have no tolerance for such reckless and violent behaviour directed at our staff."
Newsroom
7 hours ago
- Newsroom
Mushroom murder could mean life behind bars
It is the triple-murder case that captivated a global audience – a sleepy Australian town, a family Sunday lunch, and a deadly beef Wellington. Now, after a marathon two-month trial involving more than 50 witnesses, four days of closing arguments and seven days of jury deliberations, Erin Patterson has been found guilty of murdering her former in-laws, Don and Gail Patterson, and family friend Heather Wilkinson during a family meal at her home in Leongatha, Victoria. All three died within days of the Sunday roast, in July 2023. Heather's husband, pastor Ian Wilkinson, survived after spending weeks in intensive care. Erin's former husband, Simon Patterson – thought to be the real target – was asked to join them for lunch but declined the invitation. In today's episode of The Detail, Australian Channel Seven's chief reporter Chris Reason, who covered the case, explains why it's attracted global attention, and gives insight into what happened inside the courtroom. 'Everyone is saying this is the biggest crime story since the Azaria Chamberlain case, back in the 1980s … but instead of going from 'a dingo took my baby', we have gone to 'a mushroom killed my in-laws'. 'It's the unique murder weapon – death cap mushrooms, what the hell, where has that come from, no one has ever heard of that before – that alone pricked ears here and internationally,' he says. 'It is something extremely unique and fascinating about the way these people died.' Since day one, Patterson, a Lego-obsessed mother-of-two, has maintained her innocence. She pleaded not guilty to multiple counts of murder and attempted murder in the small Latrobe Valley, Victoria courthouse, about two hours' drive south of Melbourne. During the trial, prosecutors said Patterson lured her guests to her home by telling them she had cancer (which was later proven by the police to be untrue). She then knowingly served them a meal laced with deadly death cap mushrooms. The dish, they say, was carefully planned – a calculated act of revenge following a breakdown in family relationships. But her defence painted a vastly different picture: a woman devastated by what she insisted was a tragic accident. They argued that Erin bought the mushrooms from an Asian grocery store, believing them to be safe, and had no idea what she was serving. Patterson took the stand during her trial and, for eight gruelling days, gave evidence. 'She said, 'Let me get on the stand, I want to explain myself',' says Reason. '[That was] a massive flag there, that raised doubt for a lot of people – what murderer would willingly put themselves through that? And that thought would have gone through the jury. 'It was a masterstroke from Erin, and from her defence. 'They put her up, and she was in the box for eight days, now eight days of constant questioning by two of the brightest minds in the legal community down here is extremely intense … and she was difficult, she was defiant, she was defensive, she was awkward in some places … she was a clinical woman, she was an argumentative woman, everyone was wrong except for her. She was cold and calculating.' It took the jury seven days to deliberate before finding her guilty. Reason says he was surprised when the verdict came back – and surprised by the verdict itself. 'At the point where we had the jury sitting into its sixth day, I suddenly started to think 'This is going to be hung, this jury is gridlocked, and this is going to be bad news for everybody concerned. 'I was surprised … for a long time this has been really one of those cases where it pulls you one way, then it pulls you the other … you genuinely think 'Hang on, she's guilty as hell', then you see some other evidence and you think the opposite, 'No, she must be innocent of these charges'. He said Patterson showed no remorse or reaction as the guilty verdicts were read out. 'Nothing, nothing, nothing, and nothing as the four guilty verdicts came down. She remained unmoved, unemotional, no response at all.' Now an inmate in Victoria's largest female prison, the seemingly everyday mum will likely be sentenced next month as a triple murderer, but she also has the option to appeal the decision. Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here. You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter.
