SC: Verbal sale of land valid if fully or partially carried out
In an 18-page decision, the SC Third Division upheld the verbal sale of land between a man and his nephew.
The Court said it found the sale to be valid even without a written contract because the nephew had already received the land title, moved into the property, and improved it.
The case stemmed from the reclamation case filed by the man's children, who were initially unaware of the property.
According to the court, the man's children only discovered the property in 2007 when they received a notice to pay real estate taxes. They found that their cousin was living there.
For his part, the nephew said he bought the land from his uncle when he was still alive. After his uncle's death, the nephew kept paying installments to his uncle's brother.
He also presented the land title as proof.
Both the regional trial court and the Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the children while the SC reversed their decisions.
"Under the Civil Code, a sale of land must be in writing to be enforced in court. This written document serves as proof that both parties agreed to the sale. However, the sale is still considered valid even without a written contract if it has already been fully or partly carried out. In such cases, a verbal agreement can still be legally binding, and witnesses may be allowed to testify to prove that the sale happened," the SC said.
The SC added that taking possession of the land and making improvements on it are strong signs that a verbal sale had already taken place. Thus, buyers who are already living on the property can use the verbal agreement as a legal basis for their possession, even without a written contract, it added.
The decision, penned by Associate Justice Samuel Gaerlan, was promulgated in April 2025 and made public in June 2025.—LDF, GMA Integrated News
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
GMA Network
4 days ago
- GMA Network
VP Sara sees Davao-Samal bridge's potential to boost growth
Vice President Sara Duterte reaffirmed her support for the continued construction of the Davao-Samal Bridge amid legal challenges, saying the infrastructure project is crucial to unlocking the economic potential of the island and the Davao region as a whole. 'Sana ay makita ng lahat, hindi lang ng ating mga Huwes, kundi ng buong komunidad na napakalaki ng tulong ng Davao-Samal Bridge sa ekonomiya ng Davao City at ng Samal City — at siyempre na rin sa mobilization and transport ng goods and people,' Duterte told reporters. (I hope everyone — not just the judges, but the entire community — sees how much the Davao-Samal Bridge will help the economies of Davao and Samal, and in the transport of goods and people.) The multi-billion-peso bridge, initiated during the term of former President Rodrigo Duterte, is now facing uncertainty after a Supreme Court petition sought to stop its construction due to alleged environmental violations. Despite the legal roadblock, Duterte stressed its transformative potential for local trade, tourism, and daily life on the island. Duterte also outlined her vision for long-term growth in the Island Garden City of Samal (IGACOS), urging local leaders to prioritize the basics: electricity, clean water, and investor-friendly systems. 'Kailangan talaga yung regular na supply ng kuryente at access sa malinis na tubig… Basic necessities po 'yan na kailangan natin pagtulungan at unahin,' she said. (We really need regular electricity and access to clean water — these are basic necessities we must prioritize together.) 'Kailangan nilang i-review kung ano ang nagpapatagal sa proseso sa loob ng kanilang LGU para sa pagbigay ng permits,' she added. (They need to review what's causing delays in their local permit processes.) She said the city has the potential to become more competitive in tourism and commerce, provided it reduces red tape and maintains infrastructure that meets investor and resident needs. Moreover, the Vice President also promoted the Office of the Vice President's ongoing programs including 'Mag Negosyo Ta 'Day', a livelihood initiative for micro-entrepreneurs; 'PagbaBAGo', a tree-planting and education advocacy program; The Disaster Operations Center, for quick emergency response; and RIICE, which provides rapid assistance in times of urgent need. She further responded to viral reports about teachers in remote areas like the Akbual IP School in Sarangani, who cross four rivers and trek for hours to reach their students. 'Ang request nila ay para sa mga estudyante, hindi para sa sarili nila. Common ito sa mga teachers — inuuna talaga nila ang kapakanan ng kanilang mga estudyante,' she said. (Their request is for the students, not themselves. This is common among teachers — they always put their students first.) The OVP committed to delivering waterproof school bags and supplies tailored for the harsh conditions faced by these communities. 'Magpapagawa kami ng special kind of bag para sa kanila na waterproof,' Duterte said. (We will have a special kind of waterproof bag made for them.) On her father's mayoral return In the same interview, she also addressed the scenario in which her father, former President Rodrigo Duterte, might not be able to take his oath as Davao City mayor by June 30. In that case, Vice Mayor Baste Duterte would assume the position as acting mayor. Asked about a recent survey showing her as a frontrunner in the 2028 presidential race with Senator Bong Go as a possible running mate, she replied: 'Nakuratan ko sa imoha… Pwede dili na lang sa ta anang survey-survey karon kay layo pa gyud kaayo nang 2028,' she said with a laugh. (I was surprised by that… Let's skip the surveys for now because 2028 is still too far away.) 'Ang pagpapasalamat ko ay 'yung patuloy na pagtitiwala ng taong bayan sa Tanggapan ng Pangalawang Pangulo,' she added. (I'm thankful for the continued trust of the people in the Office of the Vice President.)—LDF, GMA Integrated News
GMA Network
4 days ago
- GMA Network
SC: Verbal sale of land valid if fully or partially carried out
A land sale made through a verbal or written agreement can be valid and binding as long as it has been partly or fully carried out, the Supreme Court (SC) has ruled. In an 18-page decision, the SC Third Division upheld the verbal sale of land between a man and his nephew. The Court said it found the sale to be valid even without a written contract because the nephew had already received the land title, moved into the property, and improved it. The case stemmed from the reclamation case filed by the man's children, who were initially unaware of the property. According to the court, the man's children only discovered the property in 2007 when they received a notice to pay real estate taxes. They found that their cousin was living there. For his part, the nephew said he bought the land from his uncle when he was still alive. After his uncle's death, the nephew kept paying installments to his uncle's brother. He also presented the land title as proof. Both the regional trial court and the Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the children while the SC reversed their decisions. "Under the Civil Code, a sale of land must be in writing to be enforced in court. This written document serves as proof that both parties agreed to the sale. However, the sale is still considered valid even without a written contract if it has already been fully or partly carried out. In such cases, a verbal agreement can still be legally binding, and witnesses may be allowed to testify to prove that the sale happened," the SC said. The SC added that taking possession of the land and making improvements on it are strong signs that a verbal sale had already taken place. Thus, buyers who are already living on the property can use the verbal agreement as a legal basis for their possession, even without a written contract, it added. The decision, penned by Associate Justice Samuel Gaerlan, was promulgated in April 2025 and made public in June 2025.—LDF, GMA Integrated News
GMA Network
21-06-2025
- GMA Network
SC releases list of 2025 Bar Exams local testing centers
The Supreme Court's Office of the 2025 Bar Chairperson (OBC) has issued the list of local testing centers (LTCs) for the 2025 Bar Examinations. Fourteen LTCs were selected from various parts of the country to make it easier for the Bar applicants, according to Bar Bulletin No. 3 signed by SC Associated Justice Amy Lazaro-Javier, chairperson of the 2025 Bar Examinations, and released on Friday. The 14 LTCs are as follows: Metro Manila University of Santo Tomas San Beda University-Mendiola New Era University Manila Adventist College San Beda College-Alabang University of the Philippines-BGC Ateneo de Manila University School of Law Luzon Saint Louis University University of Nueva Caceres Visayas University of San Jose-Recoletos Dr. V. Orestes Romualdez Educational Foundation Central Philippine University Mindanao Ateneo de Davao University Mindanao State University-Iligan Institute of Technology Lazaro-Javier said Bar applicants will be informed of their final LTC assignment through their Bar Applicant Registration System and Tech Assistance (BARISTA) accounts on Tuesday, June 24. Applicants with questions about the venue assignment may contact the OBC Help Desk at or call (02) 8552 9690. The SC also reminded the public to check the following site and links to get true and accurate information about the 2025 Bar Exams: Facebook: Instagram: Twitter/X: Threads: Viber: 2025 BAR EXAMINATIONS (Official) —KG, GMA Integrated News
