logo
IRR warns Parliament against expropriating SARB

IRR warns Parliament against expropriating SARB

The Star9 hours ago
The Institute of Race Relations has made written and oral submissions to Parliament in opposition to the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) Amendment Bill.
The Bill, tabled by Economic Freedom Fighters leader Julius Malema in 2018, is moving forward to a committee vote on 'desirability'. The IRR warned that it is undesirable, uneconomical, unfunded, unconsidered, and unconstitutional.
To start, the Bill expropriates the shareholders of the SARB without compensation, which is a direct violation of constitutionally protected property rights.
The shares are worth an estimated R20 million, so no one can seriously claim that the Bill would expropriate these shares without compensation to save the fisc money.
Rather, the real purpose of such an exercise is to try to set a precedent that any shares in the country can be expropriated without compensation, including trillions of rands worth of stock and bond securities that depend on SARB's prudent monetary management.
So extreme is the Bill's threat of expropriation without compensation that even the government and members of the ANC have voiced public opposition to it. Treasury official Christopher Axelson, representing the government, spoke out at length in opposition to this danger and other dangerous aspects of the Bill before Parliament.
Says IRR Fellow Gabriel Crouse: 'The effort to expropriate rural landowners in the hinterland is death to property rights by a thousand cuts. Expropriating SARB shareholders without compensation poses the same threat, only faster, like an atom bomb.'
SARB's 802 shareholders make very little money from those shares, with dividends limited to R1,000 per annum, but do get to elect seven of the SARB's 15 directors.
This decentralised, minority input provides a public-private engagement mechanism that has helped implement the 'primary object' of the SARB, which is 'to protect the value of the currency', according to the Constitution.
SARB is arguably the most successful government institution at hitting its target. Over the last quarter of a century, it has largely succeeded in maintaining inflation within the 3% - 6% target range that was nominated for it by the then-minister of finance back in 2000.
Most of South Africa's thousands of other organs of state have, by stark contrast, been riddled with ongoing state capture, often taking them well beyond the point of bankruptcy.
Most organisations where the state is the 'sole shareholder' are so badly off that President Cyril Ramaphosa's first, second, and third presidential terms have included repeated calls for 'reform' through 'public-private partnerships' that increase the role of the private sector.
So why, in this local environment, would anyone want to make the same overburdened state the 'sole shareholder' of one of the only bastions of excellence, namely SARB?
Malema, the Bill's sponsor, leaves no room for mystery about it. Malema openly calls for total nationalisation of the land, banks, and mines, which would be significantly easier if the SARB were captured, and forced to abandon its mandate temporarily by stocking rampant inflation.
That sudden loosening of monetary policy would produce what luminary SARB Governor Lesetja Kganyago has warned would be a 'deep depression'. It would also create enough chaos to facilitate a deeper round of state capture.
Crouse concludes: 'This is a test for the GNU. The MK, EFF, and Action SA signalled support for the Bill in Parliament. If the ANC joins those parties in keeping the Bill alive to spite its investment-friendly GNU partners, this will damage government unity. More importantly, it dangles a threat over everyone's prospects, and the lifesavings of those who have any.'
Institute of Race Relations I Joburg
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Former Deputy President David Mabuza remembered for dedication to public service
Former Deputy President David Mabuza remembered for dedication to public service

IOL News

time2 hours ago

  • IOL News

Former Deputy President David Mabuza remembered for dedication to public service

Former deputy president David Mabuza died on Thursday at the age of 64. Image: GCIS The death of former Deputy President David Dabede Mabuza has drawn heartfelt tributes from the highest ranks of South Africa's Parliament. Leading the expression of condolences, the Speaker of the National Assembly, Thoko Didiza, along with the Chairperson of the National Council of Provinces, Refilwe Mtshweni-Tsipane, recognised Mabuza's significant contributions to the nation and his unwavering commitment to public service. In a statement issued by Parliament's spokesperson Moloto Mothapo, he said Mabuza played a critical role in fostering better coordination between Parliament and the Executive. "He remained committed to parliamentary accountability, consistently availing himself to answer questions in the National Assembly and the National Council of Provinces, and engaging in oversight processes with diligence and respect," said Mothapo. Mabuza, in his capacity as Chairperson of the Inter-Ministerial Committee on Land and Agriculture, he oversaw the implementation of key recommendations made by the Presidential Advisory Panel on Land Reform and Agriculture, appointed in 2018. Mothapo said Mabuza's leadership contributed to the development of crucial policy instruments such as the Land Court Act—which provided for the appointment of full-time judges to adjudicate land-related matters—as well as the Land Beneficiary and Allocation Policy and the Land Donation Policy. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading "Mr Mabuza also held several key public offices throughout his career. As a Member of the Executive Council in Mpumalanga, he was entrusted with portfolios including Education, Housing, Transport, and Agriculture. He also served as a Member of Parliament, further exemplifying his lifelong dedication to public service. The Presiding Officers stated: "We pay homage to former Deputy President Mabuza, an exemplary leader and patriot who dedicated his life to the service of our people. His passing is a profound loss not only to his family and comrades, but to the nation as a whole. "Parliament honours his legacy of humility, service, and commitment to the ideals of our constitutional democracy. May his life's work continue to inspire future generations. Parliament extends its deepest sympathies to his family, friends, the African National Congress, and all those whose lives he touched," they said. Inkatha Freedom Party leader Velenkosini Hlabisa described Mabuza as a leader who dedicated his life to the betterment of others. "From humble beginnings, he rose to occupy one of the highest offices in the land, carrying with him the hopes of many and a profound sense of duty to his country. He served with quiet resolve and a deep commitment to the people of South Africa. "In this time of sorrow, we honour his contribution to our democratic journey and to the cause of justice, dignity, and development for all South Africans. His legacy will live on in the lives he impacted and in the work he undertook with humility and purpose," he said. Hlabisa said the country has lost a leader who was both pragmatic and driven by purpose. "While we may have differed politically, the IFP acknowledges and honours the contribution of former Deputy President Mabuza to our country's democratic cause," said Hlabisa. Herman Mashaba, President of ActionSA remembered Mabuza as a significant figure in South African political life, having served the country in various senior roles, including as Premier of Mpumalanga. "His contributions and influence spanned decades and will leave a lasting mark on our country's democratic journey. While varying reflections on his legacy will no doubt unfold in the days to come, ActionSA simply wishes to extend compassion to his family as they begin this difficult mourning journey. We pray for their strength, peace and comfort during this time of loss, said Mashaba. Leader of Good Party and Minister of Tourism Patricia de Lille, served alongside Mabuza during the 6th administration when he was deputy president. "He was an exemplary chair of intergovernmental forums, his meetings were marked by punctuality, clarity of purpose, and firm outcomes. I personally admired his respect for time and process, and it is a discipline we can all learn from in public service," said de Lille. SUNDAY TRIBUNE

Former Deputy President David Mabuza remembered for dedication to public service
Former Deputy President David Mabuza remembered for dedication to public service

IOL News

time2 hours ago

  • IOL News

Former Deputy President David Mabuza remembered for dedication to public service

Former deputy president David Mabuza died on Thursday at the age of 64. Image: GCIS The death of former Deputy President David Dabede Mabuza has drawn heartfelt tributes from the highest ranks of South Africa's Parliament. Leading the expression of condolences, the Speaker of the National Assembly, Thoko Didiza, along with the Chairperson of the National Council of Provinces, Refilwe Mtshweni-Tsipane, recognised Mabuza's significant contributions to the nation and his unwavering commitment to public service. In a statement issued by Parliament's spokesperson Moloto Mothapo, he said Mabuza played a critical role in fostering better coordination between Parliament and the Executive. "He remained committed to parliamentary accountability, consistently availing himself to answer questions in the National Assembly and the National Council of Provinces, and engaging in oversight processes with diligence and respect," said Mothapo. Mabuza, in his capacity as Chairperson of the Inter-Ministerial Committee on Land and Agriculture, he oversaw the implementation of key recommendations made by the Presidential Advisory Panel on Land Reform and Agriculture, appointed in 2018. Mothapo said Mabuza's leadership contributed to the development of crucial policy instruments such as the Land Court Act—which provided for the appointment of full-time judges to adjudicate land-related matters—as well as the Land Beneficiary and Allocation Policy and the Land Donation Policy. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading "Mr Mabuza also held several key public offices throughout his career. As a Member of the Executive Council in Mpumalanga, he was entrusted with portfolios including Education, Housing, Transport, and Agriculture. He also served as a Member of Parliament, further exemplifying his lifelong dedication to public service. The Presiding Officers stated: "We pay homage to former Deputy President Mabuza, an exemplary leader and patriot who dedicated his life to the service of our people. His passing is a profound loss not only to his family and comrades, but to the nation as a whole. "Parliament honours his legacy of humility, service, and commitment to the ideals of our constitutional democracy. May his life's work continue to inspire future generations. Parliament extends its deepest sympathies to his family, friends, the African National Congress, and all those whose lives he touched," they said. Inkatha Freedom Party leader Velenkosini Hlabisa described Mabuza as a leader who dedicated his life to the betterment of others. "From humble beginnings, he rose to occupy one of the highest offices in the land, carrying with him the hopes of many and a profound sense of duty to his country. He served with quiet resolve and a deep commitment to the people of South Africa. "In this time of sorrow, we honour his contribution to our democratic journey and to the cause of justice, dignity, and development for all South Africans. His legacy will live on in the lives he impacted and in the work he undertook with humility and purpose," he said. Hlabisa said the country has lost a leader who was both pragmatic and driven by purpose. "While we may have differed politically, the IFP acknowledges and honours the contribution of former Deputy President Mabuza to our country's democratic cause," said Hlabisa. Herman Mashaba, President of ActionSA remembered Mabuza as a significant figure in South African political life, having served the country in various senior roles, including as Premier of Mpumalanga. "His contributions and influence spanned decades and will leave a lasting mark on our country's democratic journey. While varying reflections on his legacy will no doubt unfold in the days to come, ActionSA simply wishes to extend compassion to his family as they begin this difficult mourning journey. We pray for their strength, peace and comfort during this time of loss, said Mashaba. Leader of Good Party and Minister of Tourism Patricia de Lille, served alongside Mabuza during the 6th administration when he was deputy president. "He was an exemplary chair of intergovernmental forums, his meetings were marked by punctuality, clarity of purpose, and firm outcomes. I personally admired his respect for time and process, and it is a discipline we can all learn from in public service," said de Lille. SUNDAY TRIBUNE

EFF asks Ramaphosa for clarity on new lotto operator and alleged ties to Mashatile
EFF asks Ramaphosa for clarity on new lotto operator and alleged ties to Mashatile

The Citizen

time3 hours ago

  • The Citizen

EFF asks Ramaphosa for clarity on new lotto operator and alleged ties to Mashatile

Malema says the EFF reserves the right to pursue legal remedies with regard to the awarding of the National Lottery Licence. EFF leader Julius Malema has demanded clarity from President Cyril Ramaphosa on the awarding of the National Lottery Licence to Sizekhaya Holdings and the company's alleged political ties to Deputy President Paul Mashatile. Trade, Industry and Competition Minister Parks Tau awarded the eight-year licence to Sizekhaya in May, handing over the reins from long-term operator Ithuba. Sizekhaya Sizekhaya is part-owned by Bellamont Gaming, a company co-owned and co-directed by Mashatile's sister-in-law Khumo Bogatsu and prominent KwaZulu-Natal (KZN) businessman Moses Tembe. Tembe is also the chair of the consortium, while Sandile Zungu – another prominent KZN businessman – holds directorship. Furthermore, Zungu is a stakeholder in Goldrush, a gambling company that has shares in Sizekhaya. 'Grave concern' In the letter, Malema expressed 'grave concern' over the apparent politics of patronage and the 'intricate web of familial and political connections'. He said the EFF had previously cautioned against this appointment due to, among other things, Zungu and Tembe's affiliation with the ANC. 'The involvement of the Deputy President adds a troubling dimension to this matter. It has come to light that Khumo Bogatsu – a co-owner of Bellamont Gaming, which is also a shareholder in Sizekhaya Holdings – is the twin sister of South Africa's Second Lady, Humile Mashatile, the wife of Deputy President Paul Mashatile,' Malema wrote. 'Furthermore, Ms Bogatsu is engaged to businessman Sbu Shabalala, who is a cousin of Moses Tembe, the lead figure in Sizekhaya and co-owner of the Goldrush Consortium.' Malema said these links suggest the awarding of the lottery licence may have been influenced, which constitutes state capture. ALSO READ: Tau vows to investigate after Mashatile's sister-in-law linked to multi-billion lotto operator licence Malema demands answers from Ramaphosa He proceeded to demand answers to the following questions: Are you aware of the extent of political ties involved in the appointment of Sizekhaya Holdings as the National Lottery operator? If you are aware, do you support the decision made by Minister Tau despite serious procedural irregularities, conflicts of interest, and the defiance of parliamentary oversight? Have you personally engaged Deputy President Mashatile on this matter, and if so, what explanation has he provided regarding the involvement of his immediate family in a multi-billion-rand public contract? In light of the State Capture Commission and your stated anti-corruption stance, what is your position on politically exposed persons and their close relatives benefiting from government contracts or public licences such as this one? Possible legal action Malema said the EFF believes the National Lottery must serve the developmental interests of South Africans, not those of the political elite. 'The level of political entanglement in this deal, compounded by Minister Tau's refusal to be held accountable, undermines the legitimacy of this award and sets a dangerous precedent for future public procurement.' He said his party reserves the right to explore legal options, including approaching the courts to 'compel disclosure of the appointment process and, where necessary, to have these appointments reviewed and set aside on grounds of irrationality, procedural irregularity, or breach of public governance principles'. Mashatile addresses allegations Mashatile has denied suggestions of political interference and argued that Bellamont Gaming was not doing business with the Presidency. He said it was unfair to question why his relatives were conducting business. 'There are so many people who know me in this country – family, children, cousins and friends. Where must they do business, in Zimbabwe? Out of this country,' Mashatile asked during an interview with Sowetan on Tuesday. 'They can do business, as long as I'm not involved, not because they know me. Because once you say Mr Mashatile is capable of influencing, even if he is sitting in his house, it's unfair. You must be able to say he went there to interfere.' ALSO READ: WATCH: Mashatile denies family tied to multibillion-rand lottery deal Bosa requests transparency EFF is not the only party that has expressed concern over the awarding of the licence. In May, Musi Maimane's Bosa called for full transparency from Tau, requesting a list of adjudicators and consultants involved in the lottery tender process. The party also asked for their disclosures and declarations of interest, as well as a report to parliament outlining the evaluation criteria and scoring of each bid. 'South Africans have a right to know whether this process has been conducted above board or whether it is tainted by insider influence or political interference,' the party said in a statement. 'We will not allow South Africa's public resources, or the hopes of the vulnerable communities who depend on lottery funding, to be hijacked by cronyism or corruption.' DA asks Tau to appear before committee The DA also requested Tau and the National Lotteries Commission to appear before the Parliament's trade and industry portfolio committee to answer questions concerning the licence. During the meeting on 24 June, Tau said he would investigate the conflict-of-interest allegations concerning Sizekhaya – much to the DA's dissatisfaction. 'The DA is astounded that Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition, Parks Tau, came to Parliament today to effectively admit to committee, that he had failed in his executive duties to properly oversee the appointment of the new Lottery Operator Sizekhaya Holdings,' DA MP Toby Chance said in a statement following the minister's appearance. 'It is Tau's duty to ensure that conflicts of interest between the bidders and government are picked up, and his lack of awareness of possible links between Deputy President Paul Mashatile, his family and shareholders in Bellamont Gaming is simply unacceptable.' Watch the meeting here: NOW READ: Ithuba poised to run Lottery for next year — despite legal concerns

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store