
State seeks three weeks to finalise policy on immersion of PoP idols ahead of Ganeshotsav
The state's advocate general, Dr Birendra Saraf, told a division bench of chief justice Alok Aradhe and justice Sandeep Marne that a series of meetings have been held—chaired by the chief minister himself—since June 9, and the policy will be placed before the court on or before July 23.
The development comes amid a batch of petitions raising concerns around the Central Pollution Control Board's (CPCB) revised guidelines, which prohibit the manufacture and immersion of PoP idols in natural water bodies. Idol manufacturers and artisan groups have challenged these guidelines, calling them a violation of their fundamental right to livelihood and their freedom to practise traditional crafts. They have argued that thousands of livelihoods depend on PoP idol making, especially in the run-up to Ganeshotsav.
On the other hand, environmental groups and petitioners have urged strict enforcement of the CPCB's ban, pointing out that PoP idols continue to be manufactured in violation of the guidelines. They warned that the delay in policy clarity, with barely weeks to go before the festival season begins in August, would create confusion among idol makers and local authorities alike.
In an earlier hearing on June 9, the High Court had clarified that while the manufacture and sale of PoP idols may continue, immersion in natural water bodies is prohibited without the court's explicit permission. 'It will be open to the petitioners and artisans to make PoP idols. However, the same shall not be immersed in natural water bodies without the leave of the court,' the bench had stated.
The issue of PoP idol immersion has been under judicial scrutiny since 2003, when the NGO Janhit Manch filed a public interest litigation seeking a complete ban on immersions in natural water sources due to environmental concerns. In 2009, the CPCB set up a committee to frame guidelines aimed at reducing pollution during religious festivals. These were revised in 2020 to prohibit immersion of PoP idols, though they did not impose a ban on their manufacture.
Adding a fresh layer to the debate, a report by the Rajiv Gandhi Science and Technology Commission (RGSTC)—a statutory body under the Maharashtra government—was submitted in court in April this year. Commissioned by Cultural Affairs Minister Ashish Shelar, the report recommended conditional permission for the use of PoP idols, provided they are painted with eco-friendly paints and immersed in large water bodies like the sea or major rivers, away from drinking water sources and animal habitats. It also suggested the adoption of 'retrievable immersion' methods that would allow the reuse of idols.
While the court said it was willing to allow time for the state to finalise its policy, it stressed the need for urgency. 'Festivals are coming up from August. We also need time to look into the policy. Hence, let the policy decision be placed before the court on or before July 23,' the bench told the government.
The next hearing in the matter has been scheduled for July 24.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
10 hours ago
- Indian Express
Shocking that well-placed educated persons ‘illegally' reside in Tardeo high-rise risking lives, BMC can't shut eyes: HC
The Bombay High Court on Thursday expressed 'shock' over how 'well-placed educated' persons continue to reside 'illegally' in the 34-storey high-rise in Tardeo in south Mumbai having no fire NOC and part-Occupation Certificate (OC), by putting lives of their families in risk. The HC questioned BMC whether it was going to 'shut its eyes' to the violations and 'casually' consider the issue. It asked the civic body to file an affidavit detailing an action proposed by it against the violations and steps to be taken against such occupiers, after which it will pass an order which will set precedent for such buildings across the city. A bench of Justices Girish S Kulkarni and Arif S Doctor was hearing a batch of pleas pertaining to the tower of Willingdon View Cooperative Housing Society, Tulsiwadi, Tardeo occupied by 50 flat purchasers of total 62 flats. On June 30, the HC had noted that there were 'glaring illegalities' in the building as it did not have any fire NOC or any approval from the Chief Fire Officer (CFO) of the BMC and there was no Occupation Certificate (OC) granted for nearly half of the floors (from 17 to 34). The HC had slammed the BMC for failing to take drastic action against 'daylight violations' and had said that prima facie the families were living 'illegally' at their own risk and consequences. On Thursday, senior advocate S U Kamdar for BMC submitted that as far as fire NOC was concerned, there cannot be any 'compromise' or 'regularisation' and the society will have to remove the offending portions and correct the same as per fire requirement. He added that in case of OC, certain approvals are required to be availed from Commissioner, after which there can be a regularisation if permissible. 'If fire NOC is non-negotiable, then what would be the status of the present residents? It is a 'serious issue' on which we really want to pass appropriate orders. What would be the stand of the corporation on a building which is being occupied without fire NOC? What should be the status of all such occupiers and what steps should be taken? Can they continue to reside? This is going to set an example to all those buildings and high-rises across the city,' the bench orally remarked. The judges added, 'We want to hear from the BMC whether it should consider this casually by saying that you (occupiers) please continue… Is BMC going to shut your eyes or are going to take some action? We want BMC to be impeccable in implementing rules and regulations.' Kamdar said that BMC had taken action and had issued several notices to the society. 'We want a statement on affidavit as to what should be done as on date when the fire NOC is not there. If clear stand is not there, we will interpret that it is a tacit approval and this appears to be the general policy of the Municipal Corporation and all buildings which are occupied without fire NOC, they can continue to do so and lives of the people can be risked in this manner,' the bench said. 'They (occupiers) are a society of well-placed educated people who continue to reside in a building, which poses such a grave risk to the lives of their families…it is shocking. We are concerned with a larger issue…. We are not going to permit any illegality to happen in any building. Because, things ought not to be looking as if it is beyond a municipal corporation to handle this situation in the city. Every time it should give an impression that SRA, MHADA, BMC or other municipal corporations are least bothered about law and everything comes to the court,' the bench added. It said it would not permit occupation without OC and suggested the flat owners make 'alternative arrangements for temporary residence.' The HC posted the matter to July 10.


Mint
13 hours ago
- Mint
‘Picture abhi baaki hai': Nitesh Rane slams Aaditya Thackeray over ‘chose silence' remark in Disha Salian death case
Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Aadtiya Thackeray on Thursday refused to comment after police told the Bombay High Court that there was no foul play in celebrity manager Disha Salian's death and that it was a suicide. Thackeray, who has been targeted by the opposition in the Disha Salian death case after her father Satish Salian sought an FIR to be filed against the Sena leader, said he has chosen silence despite attempts to defame him, ANI reported. On Thursday, when reporters asked Thackeray on the Vidhan Bhavan premises about the police affidavit about no foul play in the death case, he said, "For the last five years, certain individuals have tried to tarnish my image. I never responded to them at that time and I will not respond now either." Responding to Thackeray's comments, Fisheries and Port Development Minister Nitesh Rane, however, said Salian will get justice as "picture abhi baaki hai" (the film is not over yet). The ANI report quoted Rane as saying, "The news being reported is based on the SIT affidavit dated June 17. However, Disha Salian's father has since filed another affidavit challenging it. So, the case is not over yet." Using a popular film dialogue, the BJP leader said, "Picture abhi baaki Salian will get justice." Salian died on June 8, 2020, after falling off the 14th floor of a residential building in Malad area of Mumbai. The city police had then registered an Accidental Death Report (ADR). The Mumbai Police on Thursday told the Bombay High Court that former celebrity manager Disha Salian had committed suicide and no foul play was found in her death, even as her father Satish Salian reiterated she was gangraped and murdered. According to a PTI report, the police said in its affidavit that Disha had jumped off the window of a flat of her own volition, and the postmortem report mentioned no signs of sexual and/or physical assault on her body. The affidavit was filed before the high court last month. She was under tremendous mental stress due to a dispute with her family and also because her business deals were not working out, the affidavit added. The report also said that she was drunk at the time of the incident. Foul play was ruled out by her fiancé, who was with her at the time of the incident. Disha Salian's father, Satish Salian, filed a petition in the High Court in March this year, seeking a probe by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) into his daughter's death and an FIR against Shiv Sena (UBT) MLA Aaditya Thackeray. In the plea, he claimed his daughter was found dead under mysterious circumstances in June 2020. He alleged that she was raped and murdered and subsequently there was a politically orchestrated cover-up to protect certain influential persons. The petition came up for hearing on Wednesday before a bench headed by Justice AS Gadkari, which posted it for further hearing on July 16. (With inputs from agencies)


India Today
16 hours ago
- India Today
Aaditya Thackeray should avoid filmy people: Shiv Sena MLA on Disha Salian case
Amid fresh political sparring over the Disha Salian death case, Shiv Sena leader and minister Deepak Kesarkar on Thursday said Aaditya Thackeray 'should also realise that he needs to stay away from these filmy people', claiming such associations had 'defamed' the Shiv Sena (UBT) MLA.'He got defamed because of them. It means he knew them, and their pictures together are also coming out,' Kesarkar told reporters. His remark came after the Mumbai Police informed the Bombay High Court that its Special Investigation Team (SIT) had found no foul play in Salian's part of the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena, added, 'We have not accused anyone involved in the investigation. However, when CCTV footage is missing, doubts arise. So, it should be ensured that the footage is available. One should always have a clean image in politics.' His remarks come amid a political face-off over the case, with Shiv Sena (UBT) and its allies demanding apologies from BJP and Shinde camp leaders for dragginga Aditya Thackeray's name into the Thursday, Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut sought a public apology from Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis and Maharashtra Minister Nitesh Rane. 'The police report has clearly stated that Aaditya Thackeray had no involvement in Disha Salian's death. Yet, power was misused to malign his image and humiliate him,' said also warned, 'Everyone who made baseless allegations should issue a public apology. Those defaming others for political gains will pay a heavy price one day.'advertisementDisha Salian, a former celebrity manager, died after falling from the 14th floor of a Mumbai high-rise on June 8, 2020. Police initially registered an Accidental Death Report. However, her father Satish Salian later claimed she was gangraped and murdered, and moved the Bombay High Court in March this year seeking a CBI probe and an FIR against Aaditya an affidavit to the court, the Mumbai Police stated that Salian died by suicide and that the postmortem found no signs of sexual or physical assault. They also said she had been under stress due to family issues and professional setbacks. Her fianc, who was present at the time, reportedly ruled out any foul of State for Home Yogesh Kadam clarified that while the SIT had submitted its findings, 'no closure report' has yet been filed and investigation is still NCP (SP) MLA Rohit Pawar came to Thackeray's defence, alleging that BJP leaders and ministers from the Shinde camp had used 'foul and offensive language' against him. He called it a 'deliberate attempt to mislead the public for political mileage'.BJP leader and former minister Sudhir Mungantiwar rejected the allegations of political misuse, saying, 'Police conduct investigations based on evidence and facts. The opposition should not harbour prejudice against the state government.'The Bombay High Court has listed the matter for further hearing on July 16.- Ends(With inputs from PTI)Must Watch