Low-calorie diets linked to surprising mental health effect, new research shows
A new study, published in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention and Health, investigated how the adoption of restrictive diets could instigate depressive symptoms.
Using the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, researchers analyzed nearly 29,000 adults who reported their dietary habits and also completed a mental health questionnaire.
Rates Of Dementia Are Lower In People Who Eat This Specific Diet, Research Shows
Nearly 8% of these adults reported depressive symptoms.
Compared to those who did not follow a specific diet, those who stuck to a calorie-restrictive diet — including overweight individuals — saw an increase in depressive symptom severity, the study found.
Read On The Fox News App
People who followed a nutrient-restricted diet saw a larger increase in symptoms, while men who followed any diet reportedly showed "higher somatic symptom scores" compared to non-dieters.
The researchers concluded that there are "potential implications of widely followed diets on depressive symptoms, and a need for tailored dietary recommendations based on BMI and sex."
Judith S. Beck, PhD, president of the Beck Institute for Cognitive Behavior Therapy in Pennsylvania, reacted to these findings in an interview with Fox News Digital.
The expert, who was not involved in the research, noted that it only showed an association between low-calorie diets and depression.
10 Best Diets Of 2025 As Chosen By Nutrition Experts
"This is an important distinction, [because] correlation does not equal causation, and having a few depressive symptoms does not mean you have the condition of depression," she said.
Beck noted that depression and negative emotions can also be caused by multiple cognitive, emotional or behavioral factors that are "more directly associated with depressive symptoms."
Certified holistic nutritionist Robin DeCicco in New York City commented that most Americans would benefit from losing weight, as 70% of Americans are overweight or obese, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
This can be done by reducing the intake of sugary drinks and processed foods, and learning how to incorporate more whole foods like lean protein, vegetables, fruits and nuts, recommended DeCicco, who also was not involved in the study.
This Weight Loss Plan Performs Better Than Traditional Dieting, Study Finds
The nutritionist also warned against following fad diets.
"It's not sustainable or healthy to follow these trends because, most often, they are not educating the public on the type of nutrients you need to function mentally and physically, which is why it doesn't surprise me that people can experience depressive and cognitive-affective symptoms when losing weight."
The quality of calories "matters dramatically," DeCicco noted.
"While weight loss is about calories in and calories out, it's also about the type of calories and what we need for fuel, protection against disease, and mental and physical satisfaction," she said.
"Food has the power to help us or harm us, and if we're not eating certain foods known to promote mental well-being, we will definitely suffer from cognitive impairment and unstable mood."
As an example, cutting out fats because they're high in calories — like salmon, avocado, olive oil and nuts — also cuts out nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids, which can reduce inflammation, prevent disease and improve cognition, mood and brain health, DeCicco noted.
"If someone wants to lose weight but also has a health history of cognitive decline or is diagnosed with depression, it is even more important to emphasize the food groups mentioned above," DeCicco added.
Click Here To Sign Up For Our Health Newsletter
Beck echoed the importance of eating in a "very healthy way," while also recommending that people consider cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT).
For more Health articles, visit foxnews.com/health
"CBT helps people learn the cognitive (thinking) and behavioral skills they need to eat as healthily as possible given their circumstances, and to change their thinking so they can make long-term changes in their eating and improve their overall health," she said.
Fox News Digital reached out to the study researchers for comment.Original article source: Low-calorie diets linked to surprising mental health effect, new research shows
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNET
2 minutes ago
- CNET
6 Foods That Science Says Are More Hydrating Than Water
Summers continue to get hotter and hotter each year, and staying cool has become more difficult than ever. Staying hydrated isn't easy during a heat wave, but it does ensure that your body can continue to cool you down, without going into shock. Dehydration can show up quickly, especially if temperatures are soaring, or the humidity is delivering moist, muggy days. Keeping yourself hydrated is crucial during heatwaves, and you can do it by snacking on the right foods. Drinking is the recommended way to rehydrate yourself, but if it's too humid outside, it can be almost impossible to catch up. Water alone doesn't replenish salt or other minerals either. Thankfully, there are foods full of water and electrolytes that can help you to replenish your body's minerals, and satisfy your thirst at the same time. These are the top hydrating foods to focus on this summer. How to tell if you're hydrated Hydration needs vary based on your size, activity level and how much you sweat. Gabriela Barreto, a registered dietitian and sports nutritionist says there are two indicators of hydration level: your thirst and the color of your urine. "Drinking to thirst can be appropriate for most individuals to maintain their hydration levels and as for urine, you're looking for a pale yellow color," says Barreto. She says the only times you shouldn't be concerned about the color of your urine are during your first pee of the morning because it tends to be dark, or if you are taking vitamin B supplements, which make urine more likely to appear bright yellow. Barreto recommends that besides food and water, a hydration supplement such as Skratch can benefit individuals with active jobs and people who work out or spend a lot of time in the heat outdoors. "Utilizing a hydration product can be useful to increase your body's water stores," she says. "I recommend a hydration product with 300 to 500 milligrams of sodium and preferably about 20 grams of carbohydrates." Keep in mind an electrolyte drink without carbohydrates will help with rehydration, too, just not as efficiently. So make sure to read the labels first to choose the best option for your needs. A glass is water is not the only option if you are foods are most hydrating? Most foods contain some amount of water, but it probably won't surprise you to learn that fruits and vegetables are at the top of the list. To get the most out of these hydrating fruits and vegetables, make sure you follow standard dietary guidelines. Barreto says, "Dietary guidelines recommend two to three servings of fruit and three to four servings of vegetables for most adults." There are no specific guidelines for hydrating fruits and veggies, but by eating the daily recommended amount of produce you will be adding to your hydration, she says. It is estimated that 20% to 30% of fluid needs can come from food, including fruits and veggies. By combining certain foods, you can boost your hydration. "When looking to adequately rehydrate, carbohydrates, fluid and sodium are key," says Barreto, adding, "Carbohydrates are important for optimizing water and sodium absorption in the body." Watermelon and other melons Watermelon isn't just a fruit that is synonymous with summer, it's also highly hydrating. It's made up of 92% water and has antioxidants, important nutrients like vitamins A and C, magnesium, fiber and lycopene (a pigment found in red, yellow or orange-colored fruits and vegetables). Other melons such as cantaloupe are also made up of 90% water and are a good source of potassium, folate, as well as vitamins A and C. Barreto says one hydrating recipe to try is a cucumber and watermelon salad with lime, mint and salty feta. As previously mentioned, the sodium and carbohydrates will help the body easily absorb the water from the fruit. Barreto points out that for this reason, you'll also notice some sports dietitians recommend sprinkling some salt on your watermelon. Cucumbers Cucumbers are made up of 95% water and consist of vitamins like vitamin K, magnesium and potassium. This refreshing veggie can be easily added to salads, sandwiches, water or eaten on its own. Its high water content also makes it a low-calorie vegetable and is an ideal food to add to your diet if you're looking to lose weight and feel full longer. Squash This versatile vegetable does well as an addition to soups, stir-fries, salads and as a side. Popular summer squashes like zucchini are a good source of vitamin C, potassium and fiber and are made up of 94% water. The high water and fiber content will keep you full and hydrated for an extended period. Strawberries This popular summer fruit is full of antioxidants, vitamins and minerals like vitamin C, manganese and folate. It's an easy fruit to add into smoothies, yogurt, salads or eat on its own. Strawberries are made up of 91% water, making them the perfect fruit to quench your thirst and satisfy your sweet tooth. Many seasonal fruits and vegetables can help keep you hydrated. Getty Images Lettuce and other leafy greens Make a salad out of lettuce and other greens like lettuce, watercress, spinach or bok choy, which have high water content and provide lots of vitamins and minerals. Lettuce consists of 96% water and has folate, fiber and vitamins K and A. Spinach is high in iron, folic acid, calcium and vitamins C and A. Watercress, meanwhile, provides 100% of the recommended dietary intake for vitamin K, which is an essential nutrient for blood clotting and maintaining healthy bones. Bok choy is abundant in vitamins K and C, which means any combination of these greens is guaranteed to provide you with a salad full of nutrients. Citrus fruits If you enjoy oranges, grapefruits, limes and other citrus fruits, then eat up. Citrus fruits tend to be made up of about 80% water, making them good options for hydration. They are also high in vitamin C and fiber and are good for supporting your immune system. They're even versatile enough to add to fruit salads, eat on their own, add to water or salads and even as a marinade for proteins, such as chicken or fish.
Forbes
4 minutes ago
- Forbes
Who Are Family Caregivers Of Seniors And People With Disabilities?
A daughter with her father. The typical family caregiver is a 50-something woman who spends 27 hours a week caring for an aging parent who has two or more serious medical conditions, and is doing so with little outside assistance, according to a new survey by the National Alliance for Caregiving and AARP. While that describes a typical caregiver, many different family members serve as caregivers, and many kinds of people are being helped. For example, the survey, called Caregiving in the US, found that 4 million children under age 18 are helping to care for relatives with physical or cognitive limitations. The study is valuable because it is the fifth in a series going back to 1997. Strikingly, while it shows some important changes, the basic story remains the same: Millions of Americans are struggling to care for relatives who increasingly need help with their daily activities, from bathing to shopping. Counting Caregivers The new study estimates that in 2024, about 63 million people were caring for aging parents, spouses, or children with disabilities and serious illnesses. That's an increase of 16 million in the past decade. The survey counts anyone who has provided 'ongoing care over the past year to adults or children with complex medical conditions or disabilities.' It defines family caregiving 'as providing ongoing supports and management of complex care tasks for children and adults with chronic, disabling, or serious health conditions.' About 41 million of those being cared for are age 65 or older. Other research has come up with somewhat lower estimates. For example, Jennifer Wolff and colleagues at the Bloomberg School of Public Health at Johns Hopkins University, estimated 24 million family members were caring for older adults in 2022, up from 18 million a decade earlier. Similarly, in 2023 the Bureau of Labor statistics estimated 37 million family members were providing care for older adults. Why the differences? Different years. Surveys ask different questions. And all these studies are based on self-reporting by individuals, and family members may characterize their roles differently. Sometimes, for example, a daughter won't call herself a caregiver. She is just…a daughter. Caregivers, she may believe, are the people who are paid to assist others. Who Are They? Like other studies, the NAC/AARP survey found that while most family caregivers are women, about 40% are men, a ratio that has not changed much in recent years. More than half are adult children caring for parents or grandparents. About 15% care for spouses or partners. Forty percent of family caregivers live with those receiving care, a big increase from a decade ago when the share was only about 34%. Much is said about the 'sandwich generation' who care for both young children and aging parents. The new study finds about 30% of all family caregivers also have young children or grandchildren living with them. Not surprisingly, caregivers under age 50 are most likely to be caring for both young children and older adults. Nearly half of that group are sandwich generation caregivers. About two-thirds of working-age caregivers are employed and half of them say caregiving affects their ability to work, reporting they go in late, leave early, or take time off to provide care. What Do They Do? Only about one-third of family caregivers have paid help, most often they are people who work themselves and who have relatively high incomes. Those providing care for very long durations are most likely to hire aides to assist them, as are nearly half of those caring for loved ones with dementia. About one-third of family caregivers report assisting loved ones for five years or more. Three-quarters say they provide 20 hours or more of care a week and one-quarter report 40 hours or more, or the equivalent of a full-time job. More than half provide the kind of medical care that normally would be done by a nurse. But only about one-in-five say they have been trained to do these tasks. Most act as care navigators for their loved ones: 70% monitor their health conditions, two-thirds communicate with their doctors, and nearly 60% advocate for care recipients' needs with providers, community services, or government agencies. Regrettably, care coordination isn't getting easier, despite growing attention to the need. Only about 70 percent of those surveyed say they are included in care planning, with younger caregivers even less likely to be involved. About 58% say coordinating care with health professionals is easy, down from 65% in 2015, and from 59% in 2020. Similar to other surveys, respondents are looking most of all for financial support. Roughly 70% favor such assistance, though higher-income caregivers prefer tax credits while those with lower incomes favor direct payments. About one-in-four would like respite services, while one-in-three identify emotional support and professional assessment of their needs. A Worsening Problem The NAC/AARP report may vary from others in the details. But whatever the numbers, it is fair to say that a lot of Americans—tens of millions—are caring for their loved ones. They are making enormous financial, emotional, and physical sacrifices to do it. Their numbers are increasing rapidly as the population ages and more people of all ages with disabilities remain at home, and for longer. And they are getting remarkably little support from the health care system or the government. That's especially true of those who care for people who do not qualify for government programs such as Medicaid. The problem is bad and getting worse, no matter how you count it.
New York Times
4 minutes ago
- New York Times
UnitedHealth Will Cooperate With Federal Probe of Its Medicare Billing Practices
After months of unconfirmed reports about a potential federal probe into its Medicare business, UnitedHealth Group, the giant health care conglomerate, announced Thursday morning that it was cooperating with the U.S. Department of Justice and responding to both formal criminal and civil requests. UnitedHealth said it had 'proactively reached out' to the Justice Department after news reports of a government investigation had surfaced, according to an unsigned company statement. The Justice Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The probe appears to focus on the private insurance plans that UnitedHealth offers as an alternative to traditional Medicare. The company is the largest supplier of these Medicare Advantage plans, which are sold to millions of older Americans and to people with disabilities. The business has become a critical source of revenues to UnitedHealth as Americans have increasingly chosen to enroll in these plans instead of the government's program. But UnitedHealth, along with other major insurers, has come under sharp scrutiny from federal officials. Government investigators have claimed that the company has overbilled Medicare, and regulators have been looking into whether it also inappropriately boosted payments by diagnosing enrolled patients with additional conditions, logging them as sicker than they are. Medicare pays UnitedHealth more when patients are sicker. UnitedHealth owns UnitedHealthcare, the insurer that sells the Medicare Advantage plans, and also operates a vast network of doctors through its Optum unit. Many of these doctors treat patients who are enrolled in the company's plans. The Wall Street Journal has been investigating whether UnitedHealthcare was increasing Medicare payments by inappropriately coding patients with diagnoses. It recently reported that prosecutors had been interviewing former employees. Medicare officials have already cracked down on some potentially abusive practices. But the probe by the Department of Justice signals a broader interest by regulators into this historically lucrative business, which contributes significantly to the company's $400 billion in annual revenues. The Justice Department inquiry comes at a difficult time for UnitedHealth, which has been reeling from a series of challenges, including the brutal murder in December of its top insurance executive, Brian Thompson. In May, the company abruptly replaced its chief executive with its former chief executive, Stephen Hemsley, after the company reported disappointing results. Its stock has plummeted, and on Thursday the share price was down in early trading. In its statement, the company expressed 'full confidence in its practices,' and that it was 'committed to working cooperatively with the Department through the process.' It added that the company had 'a long record of responsible conduct and effective compliance' and that it was conducting an independent review of its practices. UnitedHealth 'is committed to maintaining the integrity of its business practices and serving as reliable stewards of American tax dollars,' the company said.
