Live weighing of cattle in beef factories ‘brushed under carpet'
However, none of the farm organisations contacted by the Farming Independent are aware of any processor currently offering this service, while the IBLA (Irish Beef and Lamb Association) claimed its 'members have required live weighing in lairages but have been told that their plant doesn't provide this service'.
Corley said: 'I've never seen it rolled out in any factory, but over the years, there have been a number of requests as to why this wasn't implemented.
'Our understanding was that it would be implemented, but like that, a lot of things were supposed to happen since 2019. In general, not a whole lot has improved from the power situations that factories had at the time of the agreement to what they have now. There hasn't been a whole lot of improvement or transparency.'
He said, 'there is very little transparency once cattle leave farmers for the factory', but live weighing would 'help keep factories in check' and leave farmers 'better equipped to make calculations'.
'Having an animal's live weight could be a useful tool for farmers, especially to compare kill-out percentages between factories.'
KO percentage is the carcass weight expressed as a percentage of the animal's liveweight. It is influenced by several factors, including genetics, sex, feeding system, carcass weight and conformation (cattle in Ireland are graded under the EUROP system).
Industry estimates suggest that cows generally have the lowest KO%, typically ranging from 46-58pc. Bulls tend to have the highest (50-64pc), while steers range from 48-60pc and heifers from 48-59pc. Across all categories, better conformation usually results in higher KO%.
Corley said: 'For example, if one group of bullocks killed out at 58pc in one factory, and a similar group killed out at 54pc in another, farmers could legitimately question the difference.
'Farmers would have a suspicion about factories and the amount of trim. I am sure factories could put a live weighing scales on the main crush.'
ICSA beef chair John Cleary said its members would see live weighing as a 'very positive step forward' in providing up-to-date information, especially in the area of kill-out percentages.
'Farmers would benefit hugely from extra relevant feedback from processors to better their business,' he said.
The IBLA said: 'The service has not been found to have been made available to its members or beef producers in general.
'Without a forum in place, there is no reporting to confirm if the weighing facilities have been provided.'
'Suppliers are entitled to the choice, and meat processing factories must honour the Irish Beef Sector Agreement. IBLA has written to the minister to query why Irish meat processing companies had not complied with certain conditions of the agreement.'
ICMSA livestock committee chair Michael O'Connell said it is not an issue being brought up by members, but rather grading and the Quality Payment Scheme, which has been 'proved to be biased against dairy beef cattle'.
'ICMSA believes that there are much more important issues requiring attention, particularly the long-overdue reform of the beef price grid.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
8 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Orla O'Connor to step down from her role as director of National Women's Council
She will leave the organisation in the coming months to start a new role as executive director of St Stephen's Green Trust, an independent social justice grant-maker. Ms O'Connor held different positions during her 23 years of working in the NWC, including 13 years as a director. Describing her time in the council as the 'greatest honour of her career', she said she is 'excited for her new journey ahead'. 'It has been the greatest honour of my career to lead this extraordinary organisation of almost 200 member groups from across the island and work alongside such strong and passionate feminists,' she said. "Together, we have built a powerful organisation – a place that drives real change, holds true to feminist values and makes a lasting difference to women's lives and Irish society. "I am excited for my new journey ahead as I step into my new role as executive director of St Stephen's Green Trust, and I will bring with me everything the NWC has taught me about courage, solidarity and the power of collective action,' she added. Paying a tribute to the outgoing director, the chairperson of NWC, Jennifer Okeke, described Ms O'Connor as a 'true feminist leader'. "Orla is a true feminist leader who has dedicated her life to the achievement of equality and social justice," Ms Okeke said. "During her time in the NWC, she has made an incredible contribution to the organisation and to the advancement of women's rights and equality in Ireland. "Ireland is a better place for women and girls thanks to the work of NWC under her leadership,' she added. The organisation, established in 1973 and working for women's rights and equality in Ireland, will begin the search for a new director in the coming weeks, with recruitment led by NWC's board.
Irish Independent
13 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Live weighing of cattle in beef factories ‘brushed under carpet'
The Irish Beef Sector Agreement, which followed the 2019 beef protests, states that 'lairage weighing services will be provided on request, which may incur a nominal charge'. However, none of the farm organisations contacted by the Farming Independent are aware of any processor currently offering this service, while the IBLA (Irish Beef and Lamb Association) claimed its 'members have required live weighing in lairages but have been told that their plant doesn't provide this service'. Corley said: 'I've never seen it rolled out in any factory, but over the years, there have been a number of requests as to why this wasn't implemented. 'Our understanding was that it would be implemented, but like that, a lot of things were supposed to happen since 2019. In general, not a whole lot has improved from the power situations that factories had at the time of the agreement to what they have now. There hasn't been a whole lot of improvement or transparency.' He said, 'there is very little transparency once cattle leave farmers for the factory', but live weighing would 'help keep factories in check' and leave farmers 'better equipped to make calculations'. 'Having an animal's live weight could be a useful tool for farmers, especially to compare kill-out percentages between factories.' KO percentage is the carcass weight expressed as a percentage of the animal's liveweight. It is influenced by several factors, including genetics, sex, feeding system, carcass weight and conformation (cattle in Ireland are graded under the EUROP system). Industry estimates suggest that cows generally have the lowest KO%, typically ranging from 46-58pc. Bulls tend to have the highest (50-64pc), while steers range from 48-60pc and heifers from 48-59pc. Across all categories, better conformation usually results in higher KO%. Corley said: 'For example, if one group of bullocks killed out at 58pc in one factory, and a similar group killed out at 54pc in another, farmers could legitimately question the difference. 'Farmers would have a suspicion about factories and the amount of trim. I am sure factories could put a live weighing scales on the main crush.' ICSA beef chair John Cleary said its members would see live weighing as a 'very positive step forward' in providing up-to-date information, especially in the area of kill-out percentages. 'Farmers would benefit hugely from extra relevant feedback from processors to better their business,' he said. The IBLA said: 'The service has not been found to have been made available to its members or beef producers in general. 'Without a forum in place, there is no reporting to confirm if the weighing facilities have been provided.' 'Suppliers are entitled to the choice, and meat processing factories must honour the Irish Beef Sector Agreement. IBLA has written to the minister to query why Irish meat processing companies had not complied with certain conditions of the agreement.' ICMSA livestock committee chair Michael O'Connell said it is not an issue being brought up by members, but rather grading and the Quality Payment Scheme, which has been 'proved to be biased against dairy beef cattle'. 'ICMSA believes that there are much more important issues requiring attention, particularly the long-overdue reform of the beef price grid.'
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
No Name Clubs: Helping Cork teenagers navigate modern life
'IF YOU'D asked me a year ago, 'would you get up on stage and be confident talking to the person on stage?', I'd tell you 100% no, because I wouldn't have had the confidence,' says Jake Costin. Nevertheless, when the 17-year-old from St Joseph's No Name Club in Cork's Mayfield saw one of his pals on stage at the organisation's annual Youth Awards in 2024, he turned to his leaders and said, 'I want to do this next year. I feel like I could do it'. Jake Costen pictured at the St. Joseph's No Name club in Mayfield. Picture Chani Anderson Costin was subsequently nominated by his club members to represent them at the 2025 awards, and in the space of that year, such was his growth in confidence and ability that he went on to win Host of the Year at this year's event, an accolade awarded yearly to two No Name Club members who have made an outstanding contribution to their club and local community. 'As soon as I said 'I'm putting my name forward', [my No Name] leaders and my peers were giving me advice and helping me,' says Costin, whose prize is a three-year college scholarship and a trip to Croatia in July to represent No Name Club through the Erasmus+ programme. He says that being a member of No Name is 'massively enjoyable' and 'a huge confidence booster', and recent research has shown just what a valuable resource the youth-led, volunteer-supported social clubs are for young teenagers as they navigate the difficulties of 21st century life. Jake McCarthy and Emily O'Brien pictured playing games at the St. Joseph's No Name club in Mayfield. Picture Chani Anderson The research, conducted by No Name over several months of last year, drew on surveys and focus groups with members, volunteers, staff, and board members, and compared findings with national data relating to the same demographic as No Name membership (15 to 18-year-olds). A whopping 93% of members reported increased confidence and self-esteem, while 81% said that their mental well-being had improved from being part of No Name. Olivia Meade and Jake Costen pictured playing bingo at the St. Joseph's No Name club in Mayfield. Picture Chani Anderson In contrast, a 2021 study of 4,400 Irish teenagers conducted by researchers at RCSI University of Medicine and Health Sciences, found that more than 29% of the adolescents described their mental health as 'bad' or 'very bad'. No Name Club, which was founded in 1978, is clearly doing something right. The organisation's ethos has always been to help safeguard young people's 'right to enjoy life, feel respected, and to mature without a reliance on alcohol and other drugs'. Having such boundaries seems to be a key factor in its success, with 96% of members feeling reduced peer or societal pressure to use alcohol or other substances. WATCHING THE GROWTH Natasha Walshe organises the games for a group of teenagers at the St. Joseph's No Name club in Mayfield. Picture Chani Anderson Natasha Walshe, now 30 joined St Joseph's No Name Club in 2011, when she was in transition year. 'I went up on a Monday night and brought a couple of friends. It was great because it was really whatever we needed at the time. We went on outings or had activities like boot camp. Then, when we were in sixth year, sometimes we just went up and had the space to do our homework; it wasn't like a homework club, but that's what we needed at the time and that's what they gave us the space to do. I think that's a real example of the youth-led part of the organisation. It's whatever you need it to be on a given night.' Walshe has had various roles in the club since she 'aged out', and, in addition to being a volunteer and the secretary of St Joseph's, she serves as a board member of the national organisation. Emily O'Brien pictured at the St. Joseph's No Name club in Mayfield. Picture Chani Anderson What has kept her invested for so long is, she says, 'tradition and change', citing the recent Youth Awards as an example: 'There's always that bit of tradition, and a lot of things are still the same, but it's always changing; there are always interesting new young people to see on stage. So while the core of the No Name Club stays the same, each year is different. Each group brings something different. But everything is rooted in that ethos of positive social events without alcohol and drugs.' For Walshe, volunteering is a life-affirming, enriching experience. 'Watching the growth of the young people is unbelievable,' she says. 'In my club, in the Youth Council, they have so many good ideas and such a positive attitude. Their enthusiasm really rubs off on you.' Jake McCarthy pictured at the St. Joseph's No Name club in Mayfield. Picture Chani Anderson Given the hugely positive findings of the recent research, what does she think is key to No Name fostering such confidence, self-esteem and community in its members? 'A big part of it is we take everybody as they are. If you're coming to us and you're already a confident person and ready to be up on stage and are just raring to perform, we have the space for that. But if you're a quieter person, less outgoing, you're treated the same, first of all. But you are met where you are.' Ewan Stockley pictured at the St. Joseph's No Name club in Mayfield. Picture Chani Anderson No Name is a safe space for all young people. 'Whether it is people who are part of the LGBTQI+ community or people from disadvantaged areas or people living with disabilities. We're not one-size-fits-all all. We're very much everybody can come to us, and I think that's very important.' No Name Club board member Edith Geraghty's first involvement with the organisation was in the early 2000s, when she and her late husband Seamus set up Erris No Name Club in Belmullet, Co Mayo. She taught drama and her teenage students were bemoaning the lack of a place 'to hang out'. The club is still thriving today, while Geraghty has since had various roles within the organisation. MEETING PEOPLE WHERE THEY ARE Part of the reason for No Name's longevity, she believes, is down to its ability to evolve and pivot to meet the requirements of its members. 'For example, consent. It was a big thing that was coming up, so we sent our staff to train with the National Youth Council of Ireland on consent so that they could then deliver that best practice back into the club. If anything comes up like that, we're able to pivot and meet it in terms of training.' The training No Name offers is never finger-wagging, but rather seeks to educate and empower. 'As teenagers, they're at that time in life when they want their peers and they need a peer group,' says Geraghty. 'There's also an assumption that we break down, which is that everybody is drinking. When you actually sit down and talk to teenagers, they're not, but they think all the others are. [The club] gives them a peer group, so when they go out and socialise they're able to say 'no, we're not drinking tonight. We're in the No Name Club'. And that's extremely valuable. And once they get the confidence that brings, it tends to stay with them.' Jake Costen and Olivia Meade pictured at the St. Joseph's No Name club in Mayfield. Picture Chani Anderson The research found No Name members out-performed the national average on several key metrics, from well-being to alcohol and drug misuse. For example, 54% of 17/18-year-olds reported they aren't drinking alcohol compared to the national average of 18%; while 96% of all club members stated they aren't engaging in substance misuse. 'We put the structure in place. We put the boundaries in place, they know what they can and cannot do,' says Geraghty. 'But within that space, they get to make all the decisions. They get to choose what they want to do.' Three years ago, Geraghty became grievously ill. While in hospital, and being told she 'wouldn't make it', she was Zoomed, FaceTimed, and visited by all the young people she'd known in Erris No Name Club, as well as all those she'd met travelling to clubs countrywide as a No Name development officer. 'They came to see me and to tell me that under no circumstances was I to die. It's not often you get a chance to realise that you've had an impact. 'It was such a marvellous, life-affirming thing for them to do.' A few months after she finally left hospital, Geraghty, who lives with severe complications from her illness, took up a seat on the No Name board. 'I have never missed an event since. The organisation has wrapped itself around me. They have gone above and beyond. The support that they've given me has been absolutely outstanding. I always describe No Name Club as a family and that's what we are.' See Cobh No Name Club is currently looking for a venue. If you can help, please email admin@
