logo
Rugby World Cups aren't adding up for major unions and there is no easy fix

Rugby World Cups aren't adding up for major unions and there is no easy fix

The Guardian15-04-2025
The starting gun has been fired on the race to host the 2035 and 2039 Rugby World Cup tournaments. Expressions of interest have been made: Spain's proposal has piqued interest, Italy's too, while the Middle East stalks along as the elephant in the room. The idea of going back to Japan within 20 years of a first World Cup in Asia is a popular proposition.
News came over the weekend, however, that South Africa has all but ruled out a bid for either edition of the tournament. South Africa threw its hat into the ring in 2011, 2015, 2019 and 2023 but was overlooked on each occasion and the SA Rugby president, Mark Alexander, was brutally honest when asked about the prospect of doing so again.
'It just brings so many other challenges to the country,' he said. 'People think it is just a sports event but so many other things have to be activated. I will tell [SA Rugby] not to do this. We are a third-world country. Our economy is not strong and we have to act responsibly. I know sport does a lot for social cohesion but I think it would be unfair on [the] government to put up guarantees.'
It is a desperate shame that the winners of the past two World Cups do not consider it financially viable to bid and the 2023 bidding process looks all the more ham-fisted now.
To recap, World Rugby introduced a process whereby a technical review of the candidates would lead to recommendation by the governing body's board. South Africa emerged as the recommended bidder but World Rugby's council ignored the recommendation and in an anonymous vote, opted for France, whose bid was based on a promise to prevent 'the death of rugby' with its financial clout.
Reflecting on the decision during South Africa's autumn tour, the centre Damian de Allende said: 'It's heartbreaking, it was in our hands and it got taken away from us. I know we won the World Cup last year but it would have been a lot more special to have hosted it and won it. I get a bit sad speaking about it because I don't know when we will host another World Cup.'
Is there any other sport in which three highest-ranked nations may feasibly never host a future World Cup? South Africa and New Zealand have won the last five World Cups between them and contested the most recent final. But at this stage it is also hard to see the tournament returning to New Zealand. The union's chief executive, Mark Robinson, admitted as much in 2022, saying it would be 'really challenging'. He rowed back on those comments a year later but with the 2027 World Cup expanding to 24 teams, New Zealand doesn't have the infrastructure to mount a realistic bid.
In Ireland's case, they were the third horse in the race for the 2023 tournament but came up short, crucially failing to gain the backing of Scotland – a neighbourly snub that still rankles. As revealed by the Guardian, a united home nations bid for the 2031 World Cup was proposed but soon shelved because, it is said, agreement on where to stage the final could not be reached.
Instead, in six years, the World Cup breaks new ground in the US. Australia – with its wealth of impressive stadiums – hosts the next edition but it is 2031 occupying minds at World Rugby at present. Executives wanted the British & Irish Lions to play in Las Vegas on the way to Australia this summer and may be heartened by the suggestion they could stop off in Sin City in 2029, on the way to New Zealand. England's fixture in Washington, in July, and another clash between the All Blacks and Ireland in Chicago later this year is further evidence of spreading the gospel.
Because World Rugby is under pressure to deliver. The 2023 World Cup proved costly for France – an expected net loss of €13m (£11.1m), according to a damning report over mismanagement released earlier this month by the French court of audit – but for World Rugby it generated record-breaking revenues of €500m (£429m).
Still, when the Irish union released its accounts last November, reporting an €18.4m (£15.8m) deficit, the chief executive, Kevin Potts, was strident in his view that the cost of competing in a World Cup, exacerbated by losing autumn internationals revenue, is a problem. 'It [the World Cup] is a value transfer from the unions to the tournament,' he said.
'We get some funding over the following years out of World Rugby but it doesn't match what it costs us. It's also being used to develop the game globally. It's not working and World Rugby are aware that we and other unions are challenged by this and we need to look, is there a better way? We certainly can't continue to have World Cups every four years that are having such a major impact in that year on our finances.'
That view was echoed by the Rugby Football Union chief executive, Bill Sweeney, after record losses were announced at a similar time. 'We're right in the middle of this conversation,' Sweeney told the Business of Sport podcast. 'We feel that in many ways you could say that the losses we make in that fourth year are subsidising the investment by World Rugby into the growth of the emerging nations because the revenue shift for us is about £45m in that fourth year, we make a big loss in that fourth year.
'It's the same for the other unions as well, so the Six Nations and Sanzaar are saying this doesn't make any sense. The blue riband event where we're generating an awful lot of value, we're getting a very small percentage of the overall profit being generated from that event. I can see it from World Rugby's point of view because they're saying, 'our remit is to grow the game globally', so we've got to invest in emerging markets but at the moment it is creating some real financial hardship and difficulties for the tier one unions.'
It is quite the conversation but as Sweeney suggests, how can World Rugby justify cutting funding of the have-nots to give more to the haves? The only viable solution appears to be to ensure World Cups generate more revenue, hence the American gold rush before a likely return to Europe in 2035. The smart money is on Japan in 2039 after 2019 was, at the time, the most lucrative tournament in history.
It also brings us back to the elephant in the room. Suffice it to say, World Rugby will pay close attention to the Nations Championship finals in 2028, which are slated for Qatar. But the Middle East could not stage a World Cup in the traditional September-October slot due to heat and domestic leagues would have something to say about moving it to winter. Equally, the Six Nations has been intransigent to moving dates in the past and World Rugby would struggle to countenance a tournament in which the hosts do not take part. At present the Gulf nations are nowhere near competitive enough.
All that said, against the backdrop outlined by Potts and Sweeney, the response to the Middle East question by World Rugby's chief executive, Alan Gilpin, makes all the more sense. 'Any region that wants to invest in the game, we're going to take those conversations seriously.'
Northampton's Henry Pollock has emerged as the popular candidate to fulfil the role of potential British & Irish Lions bolter – a concept that is anachronistic yet sums up why there is still so much to love about these quadrennial tours. The head coach, Andy Farrell, was not at Franklin's Gardens to watch his performance against Castres last Saturday, however. Instead, after taking in another Leinster demolition job on Friday night, he made his way to Galway for Connacht's Challenge Cup clash against Racing 92. Perhaps he was casting an eye over Bundee Aki, maybe having a look at Mack Hansen. The irresistible narrative is that he was running the rule over his son Owen, scoping out whether the 33-year-old is back to form after a lengthy injury layoff. Or maybe Andy Farrell was at Connacht simply as a father, enjoying the simple pleasure of watching his son in action. Either way, with only three more weekends of fixtures before Farrell names his squad, the intrigue is set to skyrocket.
England outlasted Ireland to stay on course for the grand slam in the Women's Six Nations, reports Sarah Rendell.
Northampton set up a Champions Cup rematch with Leinster after an emphatic win against Castre, writes Robert Kitson.
And Bath's quest for trophies stepped up with a dominant Challenge Cup victory against Gloucester. Daniel Gallan was watching.
England will host Scotland at Welford Road on Saturday in the Women's Six Nations – so let's take a trip back to 1999, when the two teams met in the Five Nations, at Richmond RFC. England won 34-7 on their way to the grand slam.
To subscribe to the Breakdown, just visit this page and follow the instructions.
And sign up for The Recap, the best of our sports writing from the past seven days, delivered to your inbox every Friday at noon BST.a
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Zoe Aldcroft: World Cup success for England can herald change in women's rugby
Zoe Aldcroft: World Cup success for England can herald change in women's rugby

Powys County Times

time25 minutes ago

  • Powys County Times

Zoe Aldcroft: World Cup success for England can herald change in women's rugby

England captain Zoe Aldcroft believes a successful run at the World Cup can herald a 'change in women's rugby' similar to the team's memorable defeat of France at the Allianz Stadium in 2023. A 38-33 win to land a fifth-straight Six Nations title capped the Red Roses' first standalone fixture played at the home of English rugby, watched by a crowd of over 58,000, a record for a women's match. It marked a significant stride forward from the attendances of between 10,000 and 15,000 the team had typically drawn at previous editions when playing at smaller club-rugby grounds, and the skipper believes that another watershed moment awaits. Ready to represent. Your #RedRoses for #RWC2025! 🌹 @O2 | #WearTheRose — Red Roses (@RedRosesRugby) July 24, 2025 John Mitchell's side open their home tournament on August 22 against the United States at Sunderland's Stadium of Light as they look to win back the trophy they last lifted in 2017 and to put to bed memories of the agonising 34-31 defeat to New Zealand four years ago that kept them from retaining the title. Aldcroft, who was appointed captain in January and is amongst the 32 players named in Mitchell's World Cup squad on Thursday, also thinks the example of England's women footballers in being crowned European champions on home soil three years ago proves the scale of the transformation possible if the team can become world champions at the Allianz Stadium on September 27. The tournament promises to offer a stark contrast to when the 28-year-old made her international debut in 2020. 'It was out in America and it was boiling hot,' said Aldcroft. 'There were no stands so people were just stood on the side of the pitch, I think there must have been about 30 people, if that. 'One of the most special games (for England) was the France game a couple of years ago. That was a moment when it felt like a real change in women's rugby. 'I think what the Lionesses are doing has been incredible, that you can see the country getting behind them. That's something that we want to achieve and build the momentum. 'Hopefully going into this tournament we'll be able to create that momentum and we'll get a packed out stadium here at Twickenham. That would be unbelievable. The same feelings would apply again about a change in women's rugby that is to come.' There were few surprises in Mitchell's squad with centre Emily Scarratt set to play a record fifth World Cup whilst scrum-half Natasha Hunt, who was a surprise omission when the team finished as runners-up four years ago, is also in. Current World Rugby player of the year Ellie Kildunne has also been named and she too anticipated a potentially pivotal moment in the growth of the women's game. 'I feel like it's been feeling big for the past three years,' said Kildunne. 'Since the last World Cup it's almost been everything that people have been talking about. 'It's not that I'm bored or people talking about it, I just actually want to play to show people everting that's been spoken of. 'We don't know what to expect, we're only focussing on ourselves and how we're playing, but the journey we're going to be on in the next few months, to see the rise and the crowds coming in, how much social media starts talking about women's rugby for the first time. That's something to be really excited about. 'It's not necessarily something that we're really focused on, but we're prepared for what's to come without knowing what that is.'

Zoe Aldcroft: World Cup success for England can herald change in women's rugby
Zoe Aldcroft: World Cup success for England can herald change in women's rugby

North Wales Chronicle

time25 minutes ago

  • North Wales Chronicle

Zoe Aldcroft: World Cup success for England can herald change in women's rugby

A 38-33 win to land a fifth-straight Six Nations title capped the Red Roses' first standalone fixture played at the home of English rugby, watched by a crowd of over 58,000, a record for a women's match. It marked a significant stride forward from the attendances of between 10,000 and 15,000 the team had typically drawn at previous editions when playing at smaller club-rugby grounds, and the skipper believes that another watershed moment awaits. Ready to represent. Your #RedRoses for #RWC2025! 🌹@O2 | #WearTheRose — Red Roses (@RedRosesRugby) July 24, 2025 John Mitchell's side open their home tournament on August 22 against the United States at Sunderland's Stadium of Light as they look to win back the trophy they last lifted in 2017 and to put to bed memories of the agonising 34-31 defeat to New Zealand four years ago that kept them from retaining the title. Aldcroft, who was appointed captain in January and is amongst the 32 players named in Mitchell's World Cup squad on Thursday, also thinks the example of England's women footballers in being crowned European champions on home soil three years ago proves the scale of the transformation possible if the team can become world champions at the Allianz Stadium on September 27. The tournament promises to offer a stark contrast to when the 28-year-old made her international debut in 2020. 'It was out in America and it was boiling hot,' said Aldcroft. 'There were no stands so people were just stood on the side of the pitch, I think there must have been about 30 people, if that. 'One of the most special games (for England) was the France game a couple of years ago. That was a moment when it felt like a real change in women's rugby. 'I think what the Lionesses are doing has been incredible, that you can see the country getting behind them. That's something that we want to achieve and build the momentum. 'Hopefully going into this tournament we'll be able to create that momentum and we'll get a packed out stadium here at Twickenham. That would be unbelievable. The same feelings would apply again about a change in women's rugby that is to come.' There were few surprises in Mitchell's squad with centre Emily Scarratt set to play a record fifth World Cup whilst scrum-half Natasha Hunt, who was a surprise omission when the team finished as runners-up four years ago, is also in. Current World Rugby player of the year Ellie Kildunne has also been named and she too anticipated a potentially pivotal moment in the growth of the women's game. 'I feel like it's been feeling big for the past three years,' said Kildunne. 'Since the last World Cup it's almost been everything that people have been talking about. 'It's not that I'm bored or people talking about it, I just actually want to play to show people everting that's been spoken of. 'We don't know what to expect, we're only focussing on ourselves and how we're playing, but the journey we're going to be on in the next few months, to see the rise and the crowds coming in, how much social media starts talking about women's rugby for the first time. That's something to be really excited about. 'It's not necessarily something that we're really focused on, but we're prepared for what's to come without knowing what that is.' After the tournament opener on Wearside, England move on to face Samoa in Northampton before concluding the group stage against Australia in Brighton.

Evan Ferguson scores FOUR on Roma debut alongside World Cup winner as Italian giants win 9-0
Evan Ferguson scores FOUR on Roma debut alongside World Cup winner as Italian giants win 9-0

Scottish Sun

timean hour ago

  • Scottish Sun

Evan Ferguson scores FOUR on Roma debut alongside World Cup winner as Italian giants win 9-0

He has already smashed his tally for last season Four-guson Evan Ferguson scores FOUR on Roma debut alongside World Cup winner as Italian giants win 9-0 Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) EVAN FERGUSON scored FOUR goals on his debut for new club AS Roma. The Premier League star bagged himself a perfect hat-trick on his first showing for I Giallorossi. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 Evan Ferguson notched four goals on his debut for AS Roma, including a perfect hat-trick Credit: Getty 3 Ferguson joined the Italian outfit on loan with a £32million buy option Credit: Getty Ferguson lined up alongside World Cup winner Paulo Dybala in Roma's second pre-season contest of the year. He also notched an assist to accompany his four goals, making it five goal contributions for the day. The Italian giants won 9-0 against newly promoted Serie D side UniPomezia. Ferguson, 20, was once one of the Premier League highest-rated young talents. He joined Roma earlier this month on a season-long loan from Brighton. The deal includes a buy option worth around £32million. Ferguson broke through with the Seagulls in 2021, making his first team debut in the Carabao Cup at the age of 16. He was once valued at over £100million thanks to his promising first seasons in the Premier League, drawing interest from the likes of Chelsea and Man Utd. CASINO SPECIAL - BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS 3 Ferguson is looking to turn around a lacklustre season which saw him score only one league goal Credit: Getty But the Ireland international subsequently fell out of favour on the South Coast before an unfulfilling loan spell with West Ham further stalled his career. He scored one goal in 21 Premier League appearances last season between his spells with Brighton and West Ham. European giants release 'absolute worldie' third shirt but it leaves fans divided as others compare it to tennis kit He has already quadrupled that number since arriving in the Italian capital.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store