Governments are leaving ‘heavy lifting' on Closing the Gap to underresourced Aboriginal groups, review finds
The review by the Jumbunna Institute for Indigenous Education and Research at the University of Technology Sydney is the first to independently assess the implementation of the Closing the Gap agreement since its establishment in 2008.
The agreement, committed to by all Australian governments and the Coalition of Peaks – a representative body of more than 80 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander community-controlled organisations (ACCOs) – aimed to reset the relationship between governments and First Nations people, with a focus on shared decision-making and structural reform.
But despite the landmark agreement and the subsequent 2020 refresh by the Morrison government the review found that states, territories and the federal government are still falling short.
'Much of the burden for that success rests too heavily on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander parties, while government parties carry a lighter responsibility,' the report states.
'The Peaks, ACCOs and communities are doing the heavy lifting while at the same time being under-resourced in comparison with governments,' it said.
The review authors consulted more than 500 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people across Australia over five months. They found that the overall architecture of the agreement was sound but was hampered by systemic failures including 'inaction' from governments, and structural racism which they said was 'baked in society'.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
One of the report's most damning findings is that racism continues to pervade every aspect of the strategy, and that governments have failed to take serious steps to address it.
'Despite the National Agreement commitment to identifying and eliminating racism, no systemic steps have been taken despite, or perhaps because, racism is a deeply rooted problem that was baked into government institutions from their very inception of this country,' the report said.
The latest government update on Closing the Gap targets shows only four are now on track. Six are improving but not on track, four are worsening, and a further four cannot be assessed.
Prof Lindon Coombes, the director of the Jumbunna Institute, said the report should prompt reflection for those leading the way to improve the lives of Indigenous Australians.
'We want this review to provide constructive feedback for all parties to the National Agreement, and to hear the voices of the people it seeks to support,' he said.
'What has become apparent is that there needs to be a consideration by all governments and the Coalition of Peaks about the nature of their relationships and how it underpins or hinders implementation.'
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
Tom Calma was the social justice commissioner at the time of the 2008 agreement. The Kungarakan and Iwaidja elder from the Northern Territory told Guardian Australia that the review's findings emphasise the need for governments to consult with a wide variety of Indigenous groups and organisations.
He said it was vital to hold Australian governments and organisations accountable for their role in improving the inequities experienced by many Indigenous people, as most Indigenous people relied on mainstream services.
'There's not enough effort being put into getting mainstream organisations and governments to do their share. There's no targets for them. All the targets are for community control sector,' Calma said.
'If we look at health alone, less than half [Indigenous peoples] use community-controlled health services. The majority use mainstream or public services.
'There's no specific reference to them being culturally competent, for them addressing the racism and discrimination within their systems … They're all issues that need to be addressed if we are going to close the health gap.'
The Victorian Aboriginal Child and Community Agency CEO, Muriel Bamblett, condemned governments for failing to address 'real progress towards closing the gap'.
'Today's review has once again highlighted that without clear accountability, and a lack of genuine partnership between Government and Aboriginal people, progress will continue to be critically slow,' she said in a statement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Social services department warned Tanya Plibersek she faces uphill battle amid ‘political polarisation'
Tanya Plibersek has an uphill battle to justify and prioritise Australia's multibillion-dollar social services system, her department has warned, against a backdrop of 'rising geopolitical tensions and political polarisation'. The Department of Social Services, which is responsible for a quarter of federal government spending, delivered the warning to the new social services minister about the flow-on effects of global uncertainty in a brief dated 13 May and obtained by Guardian Australia under freedom of information laws. Uncertainty, prompted by current conflicts, their aftermath and escalations in trade hostilities could worsen income inequality and weaken resilience, the department warned in its incoming government briefing, sent after the May federal election. 'The frequency and intensity of economic and environmental shocks are pushing more people into more vulnerable situations, increasing the risk of entrenched disadvantage,' the brief said. 'This can compound with regional vulnerabilities due to extreme weather events, industry shutdown and existing economic inequality.' There were also concerns that intergenerational inequalities were growing, with the department warning more young Australians are relying 'on family for financial support and/or housing well into adulthood' and delaying milestones including education, employment, family and home ownership. While the brief noted there had been advances in women's and First Nations people's workforce participation and the gender pay gap, the department said including people with disability, social attitudes towards LGBTQ+ people, and valuing multiculturalism and the contribution of migrants were central policy concerns. The department acknowledged a stronger focus on security and managing economic risk could place pressures on the minister to 'justify and prioritise payments, programs and services'. 'This will require increased focus on policies that demonstrate value for money and lead to improvements in employment, social inclusion and overall wellbeing,' the advice said. 'Achieving this will require reforms to be disciplined and have a robust evidence base, taking advantage of opportunities to improve productivity and impact. It will also require unlocking existing opportunities in sectors experiencing employment growth such as the care and support economy.' A government spokesperson said it is 'absolutely devoted to delivering on our election commitments', including expanding paid parental leave to six months and cracking down on financial abuse in domestic violence. 'The government appreciates candour and frank and fearless advice from its departments and agencies,' the spokesperson said. The department is responsible for approximately $198bn, or 25%, of all commonwealth expenditure in 2025-26, which will increase to $206bn over the next four years. The majority of its spending, about $153bn, is on personal benefits. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion In a more detailed breakdown of the challenges Australia is facing, the department noted social cohesion was declining 'rapidly' after peaking during the Covid-19 pandemic, referencing studies by the Scanlon Institute. Loneliness in certain cohorts, such as young men aged between 15 and 24, could see them targeted by extremist groups, which can be linked to misogyny and violence against women, the briefing noted. Community concern about the inadequacy of income support payments was also addressed, with the brief acknowledging that increases to rent support payments since 2023 have failed to address housing stress for many recipients. The department stated that low- and middle-income taxpayers are 'subsidising the retirement incomes of seniors with significant wealth in addition to their homes' under social security reform. The age pension is provided to couples with incomes of almost $100,000 a year or assets of almost $1.05m, in addition to their principal home, which can be of unlimited value, the department noted. 'Age pensioners generally maintain or grow their assets in the last five years prior to their death. By contrast, a single job seeker without children who has more than $11,500 in liquid assets must wait 13 weeks before any income support becomes payable,' the department said.
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Fixing Australia's broken environment laws hold key to productivity, ex-Treasury head says
Fixing the nation's broken environment protection laws is the most important reform the Albanese government can pursue to boost productivity, and holds the key to meeting climate and housing targets, according to former treasury secretary Ken Henry. Henry, now the chair of the Australian Climate and Biodiversity Foundation, will use a speech to the National Press Club as a rallying cry to federal parliament to finally agree on a rewrite of the quarter-century old Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation (EPBC) Act. 'We have had all the reviews we need. All of us have had our say. It is now up to parliament. Let's just get this done,' Henry will say in Wednesday's speech, according to extracts supplied to Guardian Australia. The environment minister, Murray Watt, is designing a new package of federal nature laws after Anthony Albanese shelved the earlier version ahead of the election amid lobbying from miners and the Western Australian government. In the speech, Henry will cast EPBC reform as critical to boosting productivity – the economic priority of Labor's second term. 'Reforming our broken environmental laws is an obvious lever to enhance resilience and lift moribund productivity growth. And reforms provide an opportunity to dramatically cut the cost to government,' he will say. 'Of course, I can think of other reforms to boost productivity. Some even harder, though none more important. And if we can't achieve environmental law reform, then we should stop dreaming about more challenging options.' Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Henry is best known as the author of the 2010 tax review for the Rudd government, which inspired the short-lived mining super profits tax. He has also advocated for a carbon price as the least economically damaging method to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The idea of a carbon price has again been put on the agenda as the Productivity Commission examines options to lower the cost of hitting climate targets. In submissions to the inquiry, the Australian Council of Trade Unions said the commission should examine 'carbon pricing policies' for different parts of the economy, and the Australian Energy Council called for a carbon price to be modelled to help inform emission reduction policies. With most large-scale infrastructure developments requiring approval under the EPBC Act, from renewable energy projects to housing estates, Henry will argue the government will fail to reach its targets of net zero by 2050 and building 1.2m homes by 2030 without 'high-quality' national nature laws. 'These projects, be they windfarms, solar farms, transmission lines, new housing developments, land-based carbon sequestration projects, new and enhanced transport corridors or critical minerals extraction and processing plants, must be delivered quickly and efficiently,' Henry will say. 'And they must be delivered in a way that not only protects, but restores, nature.' The prospects for Labor's housing target are already under renewed scrutiny after Treasury officials conceded it 'will not be met' in advice to Jim Chalmers accidentally released to the ABC and published this week. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion The government has recommitted to establishing a federal environmental protection agency but Watt has yet decide the scope of its powers. The fate of the main recommendation from Graeme Samuel's review of the EPBC Act – national environmental standards – is also unclear as the minister continues consultation with industry and green groups. However, Watt has signalled a desire to pursue the reforms in one package, rather than in multiple tranches as attempted by his predecessor, Tanya Plibersek. In the speech, Henry will back a streamlined approach before outlining what he considers the key elements for new nature laws. These include specific changes to preserve matters of national environmental significance, a suite of national standards, an independent EPA and 'genuine cooperation' between the commonwealth, state and territories. Henry will also call for a rethink of how the principle of ecologically sustainable development (ESD) is applied under federal nature laws. 'It cannot be applied project by project, in the manner anticipated by the act. Project by project application of ESD is simply nuts,' he will argue. 'It is time we stopped pretending we have the cognitive discipline to choose a sustainable balance among economic, social and environmental goals, project by project.'
The Independent
4 hours ago
- The Independent
Young Indigenous leaders in Colombia's violent Cauca gather to resist violence and elect new voices
Adriana Pazu wiped away tears as she remembered a colleague who was shot dead earlier this year by an armed dissident group for defending their land. Pazu, an Indigenous authority from the Nasa territory of San Francisco, Toribío, was attending an Indigenous youth assembly this week in Las Delicias, Cauca, a region long affected by conflict. Despite years of threats and an official security detail, Pazu's colleague Edgar Tumiña was killed — months after one of his bodyguards was killed in an earlier attack. 'He gave everything to protect this land and our youth,' Pazu said, her voice breaking. 'Now, there are only a few of us left, holding onto this responsibility.' She said she's prepared to carry on, even at great personal risk. 'I've told my family — I'm willing to give my life for this fight. Not with weapons, but by guiding, by speaking, by defending life and territory,¨ she told The Associated Press during the assembly. ¨If death comes, it won't scare me. What scares me is leaving these young people unprotected.' In a region where natural resources are often exploited for illegal mining, deforestation and logging, confronting that illegal activity can be dangerous. It's especially so in regions like Cauca, where violent groups frequently target Indigenous children and teenagers for recruitment. Pazu's journey began years ago as a semillero leader — part of a weekend school where Indigenous youth are nurtured like seeds to grow into future leaders and defenders of their communities. These semilleros offer a sanctuary — teaching traditional Nasa culture, nonviolent resistance, community rituals, arts, and self-defense — empowering youth with identity, skills, and solidarity to protect their lands and heritage. 'Youth process' High in the mountains of northern Cauca, the Indigenous reserve of Las Delicias sits in a region long scarred by violence. Its cemetery holds the body of Breiner David Cucuñame, a 14-year-old community member killed three years ago in a confrontation with dissidents from the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), the leftist guerilla group that signed a peace agreement with the government almost a decade ago. Although one of many, Cucuñame's death became a symbol of the risks facing Indigenous youth and their deep commitment to defending their land. That legacy is one reason Las Delicias was chosen to host this year's Indigenous youth assembly, the event's 39th session. Brightly painted chiva buses — traditional, open-sided vehicles common in rural Colombia — carried hundreds of young people from across Cauca's Nasa territories up narrow mountain roads to the reserve. They gathered to elect new leaders, share ancestral knowledge, and strategize how to protect their lives, culture, and land amid growing threats. 'We chose Las Delicias because it's been hard-hit … a young person was murdered. We want to show that there's still a youth process there,' said Jhoiner Medina, 30, the outgoing leader of the Cauca youth movement. Targeted assassinations Violence in Cauca, and many other regions, intensified after Colombia's 2016 peace deal, as criminal groups and dissident factions moved to claim territory and control drug trafficking routes once held by demobilized FARC rebels. Medina said children and teens have been the most affected. 'Armed groups have continued to recruit children and adolescents, and we are trying to offer alternatives through art, culture, and political training,' he said. The violence was evident in Las Delicias. Just below the cemetery where Cucuñame is buried, three burned-out military and police vehicles sit where residents set fire to them last year after a government operation that destroyed a drug lab. Authorities say residents were pressured by armed groups. But some in the community say distrust of official forces runs deep in this conflict-ridden region. According to Elizabeth Dickinson, senior analyst for the International Crisis Group, Indigenous communities in Cauca are among Colombia's most organized and socially cohesive — a strength that has made them a direct target of armed and criminal groups since the 2016 peace deal. These groups, vying for control over trafficking routes and illicit economies, have sought to fracture the communities' social fabric through targeted assassinations of traditional leaders, economic coercion, and infiltration of youth culture, Dickinson told AP. Dickinson described youth movements as 'crucial' to resisting recruitment and preserving cultural autonomy. 'It brings us together' Held every two years, the youth assembly draws as many as 600 youth from across the region to elect new leaders, evaluate progress, and develop strategies to protect their communities from violence. It also serves as a space to celebrate cultural identity through dance, music, and traditional practices — which organizers say are increasingly threatened by globalization and displacement. Jhony Baicue Camago, 14, from the López Adentro Indigenous reserve in Cauca, spent four years in a semillero and now serves in the Indigenous Guard. He said the assembly is a vital space for young people to speak out, especially amid threats such as forced recruitment, sexual violence and extortion by armed groups. Camago, who hopes to become a nurse, said cultural traditions like dance and music help unify and empower his community. 'When we play the drums, when we dance, there's a strength. It brings us together,' he said. But the dangers are real. Camago said he knows young people who have been recruited — and raped — by armed groups. 'They use us as mere bait,' he said. 'They send us to the front lines of the war.' ___ The Associated Press' climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at
