Overseas students using higher education as ‘backdoor' to stay in UK
The current model is 'not working' as individuals are using the student visa as a route to longer-term migration, the report has suggested.
In May, the Labour Government announced plans to reduce the graduate visa route, which allows overseas students to live and work in the UK for up to two years after their studies, to 18 months.
Under changes introduced by the former Conservative government in January 2024, international students in the UK have been banned from bringing dependants with them since – apart from some postgraduate research courses or courses with government-funded scholarships.
But the report said the changes do not go 'far enough' and it called for bolder action to ensure study at UK universities is not 'a migration backdoor'.
The paper said: 'Most fundamentally, the purpose of student migration should be to study, not to provide a backdoor route to longer term migration or settlement.
'Yet increasingly studying in the UK has become a pathway for widespread and sustained immigration.'
The number of international students in the UK increased by 66% between 2014/15 and 2023/24, the report suggested.
Two in five (40%) of those who arrived on student visas transferred to a different visa type within one year in 2023 – up from just 3% in 2019, according to the paper.
Zachary Marsh, research fellow in education at Policy Exchange and author of the report, said: 'UK universities must return to the business of selling education, not immigration.
'Whilst international students can provide valuable economic benefits, the current system drives migration by those who have no interest in study but instead see the student and graduate visa as an open door to working in the UK.
'The Government and universities must go further to clamp down on those gaming the system.
'A more muscular approach is needed to restore public confidence that international students are good for our universities and wider economy and society.'
The report has also suggested that overseas students 'may be crowding out UK students' at some universities.
Shadow education minister Neil O'Brien is due to address a Policy Exchange event in London on Wednesday on higher education and migration to coincide with the launch of the think tank's report.
Mr O'Brien is expected to say: 'It's not just taxpayers who are losing out.
'The current system isn't working for too many students, who are promised great things but find themselves having to pay back huge sums on very low wages.
'Too many students are being ripped off and we have to ask whether there are better uses of taxpayers' money that will leave young people better off.'
Tim Bradshaw, chief executive of the Russell Group, a group of 24 research-intensive universities, said: 'In an increasingly competitive global market, the UK needs to maintain an attractive offer for international students.
'This includes the graduate visa route, which allows international graduates to remain in the UK to work and contribute to the economy for a period after their studies.
'We know that international student recruitment, like any immigration policy, needs to be robust and fair to maintain people's trust in the system.
'Our universities are committed to working with Government to eliminate any abuse of the system and ensure places go to those who are here to study and meet the standards needed to succeed on their course.'
A Government spokesperson said: 'A series of measures have already been laid out in the Immigration White Paper to restore control over the system, including reducing the graduate visa from two years to 18 months.
'We will also ensure international graduates move into graduate level roles. This is what the Graduate route was created to facilitate access to, and will also help meet the UK's workforce needs, as part of our Plan for Change.
'We will also crack down further on abuse of our immigration system by strengthening requirements for universities, requiring tighter enforcement on visa approvals, course enrolments and student completions whilst continuing to welcome international students that support our world-leading universities.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
32 minutes ago
- The National
John Swinney: SNP will protect welfare system despite what Labour does
I firmly believe that investing in social security is key to reducing the number of children born into poverty and building a brighter future for the next generation, coupled with ensuring people can access the support they need, when they need it. This is in stark contrast to the approach being taken by the UK Government. Despite the last-minute concessions they have made to their welfare reforms, if the UK Government presses ahead with cuts to disability support, they risk plunging more people into poverty and introducing a two-tier system. That is unconscionable. I want to reassure families that we will not take forward harmful welfare changes in Scotland. READ MORE: Richard Murphy: Benefits boost the economy. It's the rich who are the problem The additional powers secured by the Scottish Government following the 2014 referendum have allowed us to take a different approach to social security and protect people from the worst of UK Government austerity. We have used these new powers to build a social security system that is unashamedly built on fairness, dignity and respect for those who need our support. Since becoming First Minister, I have worked tirelessly to ensure resources are directed towards those who need them most. This year, we're investing £6.9 billion in our social security system – which is almost £1.3bn more than we receive from the UK Government for social security through the block grant. This includes investment of £638 million in our package of benefits and payments only available in Scotland, one of which is the Scottish Child Payment. That payment is forecast to be supporting the families of around 330,000 children this year. SNP leader John Swinney has pledged to end the two-child benefit cap in Scotland (Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire) We're also working at pace to build the systems needed to mitigate the UK Government's two-child benefit cap for families – a cap which has been kept in place by the current UK Government. Our new benefit – the Two Child Limit Payment – will begin accepting applications in March next year. These measures will help provide much-needed support to families who need it most, especially during this ongoing cost of living crisis. Investing in tackling poverty also brings wider benefits across society and provides value for money for taxpayers. READ MORE: Labour's £46-billion problem: How to find the 'record-high' missing tax Keeping families out of poverty and providing support in line with our cost of living guarantee means that our economy is able to grow. More people are able to work and take advantage of opportunities to access training. Growing the economy in turn helps us deliver public services, including the NHS, for the benefit of everyone in Scotland. Meanwhile, the UK Government's approach to cutting vital benefits demonstrates our starkly different values when it comes to social security. Scotland's Adult Disability Payment will not be cut, and we will not attempt to balance the books at the expense of disabled people. My government will continue to unashamedly protect and invest in the social security system. We will not cast aside those most in need of our support.
Daily Mirror
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
One year in power - charts show how Labour have lived up to election promises
Twelve months on from the General Election on July 4, 2024, we have examined Keir Starmer's record against key pledges made by Labour before it went into Government Keir Starmer celebrates his first full year in No10 tomorrow, but has he delivered on the promises which won Labour a landslide victory? Twelve months on from the General Election on July 4, 2024, we have examined the Government's record against key pledges in the Labour manifesto. Surveys show that the Government's approval ratings have fallen more in the first year than any other since John Major 's in 1992/93. Opinion polls have even put Labour behind Reform UK, which has just five MPs. The prime minister insists that Labour is on track to deliver its manifesto, here we show what the official data shows to some of the pledges in the manifesto and the 'first steps to change'. Only the pledges that can be tested against publicly available data have been included. NHS During the 2024 general election, Keir Starmer revealed his 'first steps for change' - six key promises alongside a picture of him with his shirt sleeves rolled up. The first of those was to 'deliver economic stability', while the second was to 'cut NHS waiting times'. The health service had fallen into a state of permanent crisis under the Conservative government. Every month there were 10s of thousands of patients waiting in A&E for over 12 hours to be treated, while waiting lists repeatedly reached record highs. So how are things 12 months on? A&E waiting times Back in June 2024, the last month of the Tory government, only 60.5% of attendances at Type 1 major A&Es in England waited less than four hours from arrival to admission, transfer or discharge. That was up from 59.7% in May. In May of this year - the latest for which figures are available - 61.2% of attendances at major A&Es were seen within four hours. A small improvement over the course of the year but still a long way short of the 79.1% in May of 2019 (the last May before the pandemic), and even further behind the 91.4% of May 2015 when the Conservative government came to power. Waiting lists NHS waiting lists have been steadily falling under the Labour government. There were a total of 7.62 million on the waiting list when Keir Starmer came to power. That's since fallen to 7.39 million. The waiting list had reached as high as 7.76 million under the Tories in September 2023. That's compared to 4.45 million just before the pandemic, and 3.37 million in May 2015 when the Conservative government came to power. Verdict NHS waiting times have fallen. However, whether they've fallen by enough for voters to feel the benefit is another matter. The government will no doubt be hoping to see more improvements before the next election. VAT on private school fees Labour's pledge to put VAT on private school fees came into effect in January 2025. There were a total of 582,477 pupils in private schools in England during the 2024/25 academic year, according to the Department for Education's annual census. That's 11,000 fewer than a year earlier. That's higher than the government's prediction of 3,000 pupils in the first year. The number of pupils attending private schools is now higher than before the pandemic though. A total of 576,857 attended independent schools in the 2019/20 academic year. Private school pupils now make up 6.4% of the total school population, a slightly lower proportion than last year, when it was 6.5%. This is the first time since the Covid-19 pandemic that independent school pupil numbers have fallen, however they had been steadily falling in the years leading up to the pandemic. The number of pupils in independent schools fell by 6,411 between 2017/18 and 2019/20 academic years. Verdict Pledge met House building Labour pledged to build 1.5 million new homes over the course of the parliament. That works out at around 300,000 a year, or 25,000 a month. The latest official house building data shows that a total of 86,000 new homes have begun to be built during the first three quarters of the Labour government, which covers from July 2024 to March 2025. That works out at an average of 9,555 a month, less than half the rate required to meet the target. The number of houses that have started to be built under the Labour government is much higher than in the same period of 2023/24 under the Conservatives. Between July 2023 and March 2024, just 62,860 new homes were started. Verdict Some progress but improvement needed Small boats Another of Labour's 'first steps for change' was to launch a new Border Security Command with hundreds of new specialist investigators and use counter-terror powers to smash criminal boat gangs. There's no public data available for these staff numbers, or the number of gangs being 'smashed', but we can see how the number of people crossing the Channel has changed compared to previous years. Data on small boat crossings suggests all is not going to plan, however. There have been 19,982 arrivals by small boats as of July 2 this year. That's more than at the same point of any of the previous seven years for which we have data. By 26 June 2024, a total of 13,195 people had made the perilous journey across the Channel, which had been the previous record. At the same point in 2023 the total was 11,278, and in 2022 it was 12,206. Verdict Needs improvement Reduce backlog of rape cases Labour said during the campaign that they would 'fast-track rape cases, with specialist courts at every Crown Court location in England and Wales.' Despite this though, the number of rape cases in the Crown Court backlog has continued to grow. There were a total of 1,294 cases of rape in the Crown Court backlog in England and Wales before the Covid-19 pandemic hit the country. That shot up during lockdown, doubling to 2,580 cases by March 2022. It has only continued to rise ever since. By the time Labour came to power there were 4,686 outstanding Crown Court cases in England and Wales. That has since increased to 5,486 cases at the end of March, the latest month for which figures are available. It's a similar story too for all offences, not just rape. There were a total of 40,903 cases in the Crown Court backlog in March 2020. By the time Labour came to power there were 70,978 outstanding Crown Court cases, and a total of 76,957 as of March 2025. Verdict Needs improvement 2030 ban on petrol and diesel car sales There were almost 1.3 million fully electric cars registered on UK roads at the end of December 2024. That's almost 200,000 more than before the general election. However, the number of electric cars on our roads has been steadily increasing for some time. Back in January 2022 there were just 441,200 on our roads, three times fewer than today. The availability of public charging points could become an issue, with some parts of the country far better served than others. There were a total of 193,098 public electric vehicle charging points across the UK in January, according to figures from the Department of Transport. Just 49 public electric vehicle charging points in the whole of the East Hampshire local authority, which works out as 33 vehicles per charging point. That's a higher rate than in any local authority in the UK. Meanwhile, Melton in Leicestershire has 29 per charging point, as do North Kesteven and St Albans. Meanwhile, London has the most electric car-friendly infrastructure in the country. Three of the capital's boroughs have more than one public charging point for every electric car registered there. Hammersmith and Fulham has more public electric charging points than any local authority in the UK - 2,668 - which works out at 0.6 cars per charger. Southwark has 0.8 cars per charger, as does Hackney. Coventry is the most electric car-friendly council outside of the capital. The city's 2,272 public charging points works out as 0.6 cars per charger, the joint lowest rate in the country. Verdict Making progress
Daily Record
37 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Scottish Labour MP calls for third UK Government U-turn over Waspi women compensation
Douglas McAllister said "an apology is not enough" and urged his party's government to "get around the table with the Waspi women and avoid years of court battles". A Scottish Labour MP has called for the UK Government to make a third U-turn and compensate Waspi women. Douglas McAllister said "an apology is not enough" and urged his party's government to "get around the table with the Waspi women and avoid years of court battles". The SNP also called for the UK Government to go for a hat trick of U-turns and pay the women. The Labour Government decided against reimbursing women born in the 1950s affected by the changes to state pension age. This was despite a recommendation from the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman's (PHSO) to give the women between £1,000 and £2,950 each. It would have costed between £3.5 and £10.5 billion, according to the UK Government. It comes after Labour was recently forced into U-turns over its winter fuel payment and disability benefit cuts. West Dunbartonshire MP McAllister said during a debate in the House of Commons on Thursday: "The UK Government were right to recognise the injustice suffered by Waspi women in the statement to the House on 17 December, and to apologise for the maladministration that affected women across the UK. "Of course, the steps set out by the Government to ensure this does not happen again are welcome, but we must learn the lessons and always set a clear timetable for notice of any future state pension age changes. "However, an apology is not enough. I urge my Government colleagues to look again at the ombudsman's report and all its recommendations. "Ignoring key elements of the report, by refusing to comply with its instructions and refusing to set up a compensation scheme for maladministration, not only undermines its role and function, but is unprecedented and sets us on a very dangerous path." He added: "I suggest that we should avoid unnecessary court action. Let us get around the table with the Waspi women and avoid years of court battles, similar to other scandals over the past few decades. "Let us urgently review and explore what schemes this Government can consider, and offer financial redress to the 1950s women who deserve justice and to be properly compensated for past Government maladministration." Some Scottish Labour MPs suggested earlier this year that they would vote against the Government on Waspi compensation if they get the chance in the Commons. More than 330,000 women were impacted in Scotland - 5,000 of which were in McAllister's constituency. The welfare reforms U-turn earlier this week came after a potential rebellion from backbench Labour MPs. SNP MSP Clare Haughey said: 'Labour's U-turns on Winter Fuel Payments and disability cuts show they can be forced into doing the right thing. The SNP will continue to hold Sir Keir Starmer's government to account – and now is the time for Westminster to do the right thing for WASPI women. 'Over 330,000 women in Scotland have been left in the dark by unfair and poorly communicated Westminster changes to their pensions. Labour promised action, but now they've gone silent. 'After one year in office, Labour need to deliver justice for the WASPI women in Scotland and across the UK.'
