Tesla Motors Australia appeals tribunal order after owner wins case over fault model S.
Don't miss out on the headlines from Motoring. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Exclusive
A NSW mum-of-three who won a tribunal hearing that ordered Tesla to replace her $93,000 Model S 'lemon' is still waiting for the vehicle after the electric car giant lodged a last-minute appeal.
Anne Bishop, who is a passionate electric vehicle (EV) supporter, took the car manufacturer to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) in September 2024 alleging the 2015 model car she bought through their Tesla Certified Pre-Owned program in 2018 was riddled with faults.
The Tribunal instructed Tesla to refund $6649.79 in repair costs and to supply the customer with a replacement vehicle of similar value and type.
Tesla lodged a last-minute appeal against the ruling.
The appeal is set to be heard on the 14th August 2025.
MORE:Australia's brutal reaction to EVs
MORE:Staggering loss proves Cybertruck is dead
'When I bought this car, it was intended to be a once in a lifetime extravagance, a purchase designed to safeguard our growing family on the roads at a time when this was most important, and with the intention to keep the car for at least 20 years,' Ms Bishop told news.com.au.
'In February of last year, when the car broke down so comprehensively and inconveniently, two months out of warranty, all I expected was for Tesla to honour their word and pay for the repairs,' the NSW mother said.
After experiencing more than a dozen major failures in the Model S, Ms Bishop escalated her complaints through to the Tesla Owners Club of Australia, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) and NSW Fair Trading.
But with no result, she turned to the NCAT.
MORE:Musk's bombshell announcement, Tesla sinks
NSW mother Anne Bishop with her $93,000 Tesla Model S. Picture: Supplied
MORE:'Pure evil': New Tesla scandal erupts in US
At the hearing, Ms Bishop sought reimbursement for her $8,500 repair costs (from a total of $17,000), a partial refund, or ideally a replacement vehicle.
Over five and a half years of ownership, Ms Bishop said she experienced breakdowns of the car's media unit, battery failures, door handle malfunctions and, most recently, a rear drive motor failure.
In her complaint, Ms Bishop explained that comments made by Tesla chief executive officer Elon Musk 'regarding the longevity, durability and quality of engineering and manufacturing in Tesla cars' prompted her to purchase the car.
Ms Bishop sourced independent expert opinion as evidence for the NCAT.
MORE:Musk, Tesla smashed by China 'military' ban
'I intend to never purchase another Tesla product again.' Picture: Supplied
MORE:China hammers another nail in Tesla's coffin
In a comment made outside of court, two automotive experts advised Ms Bishop that the car sold to her by Tesla was a 'lemon'.
Both experts stated it was unreliable and unacceptable quality but most importantly unsafe to drive.
'It didn't seem unreasonable to expect a car I was paying close to six figures for, 'certified pre owned' from the manufacturer, that had originally sold for $165,000 and with the kind of promises made by Tesla's CEO, to comfortably exceed the durability of an entry-level car originally worth 1/10th of that price,' Ms Bishop said.
In its ruling, the tribunal found Ms Bishop's vehicle had suffered a 'succession of issues affecting essential components', concluding that a reasonable consumer would not have purchased the car had they known of its condition.
Elon Musk said Tesla 'won't forget' early adopters who 'took a risk'. Picture: Jim WATSON / AFP
NCAT determined that the issues constituted a 'major failure' under Australia Consumer Law.
'The bottom line is that the applicant is left with a Vehicle which has, over the period of ownership, been unreliable and has suffered an ongoing series of faults to expensive components,' NCAT said in its ruling.
Ms Bishop said she initially felt 'tremendously relieved that this entire nightmare' was finally over.
'I also felt justified in seeing the matter through, not only due to financial necessity, but also by now as a matter of principle and to set a precedent for other Tesla owners dissatisfied with poor quality and poor service.' Ms Bishop said.
Tesla argued that repairs were conducted under warranty where possible and noted that some failures occurred after warranty expiration.
The Tesla S 2019 was very popular in Australia.
However, NCAT found that the list of issues justified a solution beyond warranty terms under consumer guarantee rights.
At the hearing, Ms Bishop, who has remained supportive of electric vehicles, indicated that she preferred a replacement vehicle rather than a full refund.
Tesla was ordered to replace the vehicle but the auto giant lodged a last-minute appeal.
'When several weeks had passed with no word from Tesla after receiving the order from NCAT, I emailed them, in the hopes of negotiating the details necessary to finalise the matter in accordance with the order,' Ms Bishop said.
'I never received the courtesy of a response, but a week later a law firm filed a Notice of Appeal with NCAT.'
The matter remains unresolved.
Tesla Australia did not respond to requests for comment.
Originally published as Exclusive: Tesla escalates battle after tribunal order
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
14 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Sting in the tail for some workers in super boost
Workers are being urged to check with their pay packets to ensure an increase to the super guarantee doesn't result in their pay being docked. As the final increase to Australia's super guarantee comes into effect, employers will be required to devote a record 12 per cent of workers' salaries into their super for the first time. For most workers on an award agreement, it's happy days, with employers forced to tip in extra super without any reduction in their take-home pay. But there's a sting in the tail for a minority of workers who are on a total remuneration package including super, because it could mean less take-home pay. In fact, for up to 40 per cent of Australians who have an individual pay arrangement with their employer that pays superannuation as part of their salary package, the 0.5 per cent could result in a reduction in take-home pay. CPA Australia's Superannuation Lead, Richard Webb said while the super guarantee was positive for a majority of workers, some would cop a pay cut from July 1. 'If your employment contract includes a total remuneration package including super, this could mean less take-home pay at the end of the month,' he said. 'However, for those on award or enterprise agreements, your pay agreement is more likely to be a salary, which means the change will not affect your take-home pay. 'It's a good idea to check with your employer to see how they view the changes and what it means for you. Otherwise, you might get a shock if your take-home pay is a little less than expected.' Nearly 30 years after the Hawke-Keating Government introduced superannuation starting at just 1 per cent, around 14 million workers are set to secure the new boost. New Treasury analysis shows that millions of Australians will be better off at retirement as a direct result as the super guarantee lifts from 11.5 to 12 per cent. 'These reforms will make a meaningful difference for millions of Australians who work hard on low and award wages, and Australians working towards a well-deserved, dignified retirement,'' Treasurer Jim Chalmers said. 'Under Labor, inflation is down substantially, real wages are up, unemployment is low, our economy is growing, debt is down and interest rates are falling, but we know people are still under pressure. 'All the progress we have made together means we are well placed and well prepared at a time of global economic uncertainty and volatility. 'Since we've come to government, we've increased the superannuation guarantee four times, and this means an extra $98,000 at retirement for a 30 year old earning the average full-time income.' For example, a worker at age 30 earning the average full-time income (around $103,000) will have an extra $21,000 at retirement as a result of this 0.5 percentage point increase alone. However, Treasurer Jim Chalmers said taking into account all of the Albanese Government's increases to the Superannuation guarantee (from 10 per cent to 12 per cent), this worker will have an extra $98,000 at retirement.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Road weary Sh**box Rally drivers roll into Darwin for charity auction finale
After eight days on the road, a fleet of cheap and cheerful clunkers pulls into the Darwin Showgrounds covered in rust, dust, flags and fur. The weary and relieved drivers honk their horns and rev their engines as they roll to a stop — but the fun isn't over yet. Saturday is auction day, and some of these beloved "shitboxes" are about to find their forever homes. "I'm not going to say too much about her because she's got to be auctioned off," said Nicole from Coffs Harbour on the NSW Mid-North Coast, patting the boot of her Ford Focus. Organisers estimate over 500 drivers took part in the winter 2025 edition of the Shitbox Rally, driving from Perth to Darwin in cars worth less than $1,500 apiece. "We've built a really unique community. We've put strangers together only eight days ago, and now they're lifelong friends," founder James Freeman said. But while the showgrounds are bursting with pride and camaraderie, the fundraiser was born from tragedy. The latest event brought in more than $2.6 million for cancer research, taking the overall amount raised by Shitbox Rally events to nearly $57 million over the past 15 years. "The motivation is a heartbreaking personal story — I lost both of my parents to cancer within 12 months," Mr Freeman said. For Carmen and Brendan from Werribee in Victoria, the cause is close to home in more ways than one. "I was affected by cancer; 14 years ago I had breast cancer," Carmen said. "We've had family and friends who were all affected by cancer. If we can help support cancer researchers, then this is going to a very good cause." Their car, a repurposed taxi named Olaf the Shitbox, had seen them through four rallies before it died coming into Darwin on Friday night. "It's served us well over the past four years," Brendan said. Also among the rally's entrants was Finnish ambassador to Australia Arto Haapea, driving The Happiest Car in the World, a blue Toyota Camry adorned with flags, rainbows, and Finnish cartoons. "The fact that we can do something like this for a common cause is the biggest inspiration for me to take part," he said. "I've got my own history of cancer in my early twenties, so I know what it means to have first-class research." As the auction begins, buyers gather to bid for cars, and Darwin local Michael ends up taking home two. "I'm pretty stoked; the first one has got a set of golf clubs on top, which is probably worth more than the car, so that's nice," he said. While some of the cars might be on the brink of collapse, many entrants are already turning their minds to the next event — a spring rally from Alice Springs to Brisbane. "Being Australians, we have a tendency to want a challenge and also to self-deprecate, to laugh at ourselves and the situation," Mr Freeman said. "All of that is moulded together with this particular challenge — this particular rally."
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
First-home buyers battle for $640k Glenroy townhouse
A Glenroy couple who brought their newborn son home to 6 Sunbeam St — and later built a backyard deck with help from Dad — have sold their first home under the hammer for $640,000. Matt and Shani Panopoulos had owned the two-bedroom townhouse for eight and a half years, having paid $580,000 in 2017 as first-home buyers. All five auction bidders on Saturday were also first-home buyer hopefuls. Why Sydney buyers are flocking to Melb Tragic side of Aus housing crisis exposed The young family were thrilled to see it go to another buyer starting their journey. 'We bought it in winter, brought our son home in winter, and now we're handing it over in winter, it feels like a full-circle moment,' Mrs Panopoulos said. Their favourite feature was a custom-built deck added with Shani's father, who had mates with spare materials. It became the family's second living area. 'We had coffee there in the mornings, summer dinners, and a little play area for our son,' she said. 'It's a space that really became the heart of our home.' During Covid lockdowns, the second bedroom doubled as a home office, and the parkland across the road became their daily retreat. 'It was perfect,' she said. 'We had nature just across the street and somewhere peaceful to clear our heads. I don't think we realised how lucky we were until we really needed it.' The couple have since upsized closer to extended family, but said they would miss the quiet, neighbourly street and the strong sense of community Glenroy offered. 'It was the perfect first home, easy to care for, beautifully designed, and in a great spot close to everything,' Mr Panopoulos said. 'We were very lucky to find it.' Ray White Glenroy agent Abdullah El Hosari handled the sale and said interest was strong from the start, with the final result soaring $90,000 above the top of the $500,000-$550,000 price guide. 'There's no body corporate, and it's been so well looked after,' Mr El Hosari said. 'You could feel the love and care the moment you walked in.' Mr El Hosari added that limited supply in the winter market had helped fuel strong demand. Ray White Victoria and Tasmania chief auctioneer Matt Condon sold the home under the hammer to a first-home buyer in front of a crowd of onlookers.
