Meta wins copyright case over AI training, but legal questions remain
Meta, the parent company of Facebook, has won a copyright lawsuit filed by authors including Sarah Silverman and Ta-Nehisi Coates. The authors accused Meta of using pirated copies of their books without permission to train its AI model, Llama. However, US District Judge Vince Chhabria ruled that the plaintiffs failed to provide adequate evidence that Meta's AI system harmed the market for their works.
While the ruling was in Meta's favor, the judge clarified that this case does not confirm that training AI with copyrighted content is legal. Instead, it highlights that the plaintiffs didn't present the right legal arguments.
Chhabria emphasized that in many circumstances, using copyrighted materials without permission to train AI would be unlawful. This nuanced stance contrasts with another San Francisco judge's ruling earlier this week in favor of AI firm Anthropic, which deemed such usage fair use.
The fair use doctrine is a crucial defense for AI companies, allowing limited use of copyrighted materials without explicit permission. Meta welcomed the decision, describing fair use as vital to building transformative AI systems.
Meanwhile, the authors' legal team criticized the judgment, citing an 'undisputed record' of Meta's large-scale use of copyrighted works.
The broader copyright battle between AI companies and creators continues to intensify. Companies like OpenAI, Microsoft, and Anthropic face multiple lawsuits from writers, journalists, and publishers over the use of copyrighted materials in AI training.
Judge Chhabria warned of a future where AI-generated content could flood the market, undermining the value of original human-created works and disincentivizing creativity. Despite the legal win, the debate over AI's use of protected content is far from over.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
33 minutes ago
- Time of India
Central Sector Scholarship Scheme 2025: CBSE asks students to apply by 31 October
Central Sector Scheme of Scholarship 2025. (AI Image) Central Sector Scholarship 2025: The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) has issued a public notice inviting applications from eligible students for the Central Sector Scheme of Scholarship for College and University Students (CSSS) for the academic year 2025–26. The scholarship is sponsored by the Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Education, and aims to support meritorious students from economically disadvantaged backgrounds in pursuing higher education. The online application process is now open on the National Scholarship Portal ( Students seeking fresh applications or renewals for 1st year (2024), 2nd year (2023), 3rd year (2022), and 4th year (2021) are encouraged to submit their applications online. The last date to apply for both fresh and renewal scholarships is October 31, 2025. Scholarship aims to support students in higher education The Central Sector Scheme of Scholarship is designed to provide financial assistance to deserving students to help meet part of their daily expenses during their graduation and postgraduation studies. Under this scheme, selected undergraduate students receive Rs 12,000 per annum for the first three years, while postgraduate students are awarded Rs 20,000 per annum. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 3.5, 4.5 BHK Homes starting at ₹4.89 Cr.* Hero Homes Learn More Undo Read the official notice here CBSE has asked all students affiliated with its institutions to apply through the National Scholarship Portal within the stipulated deadline. The board emphasised that all applications must be verified by the respective institutions. In cases where verification is required, students must present their original documents to their institute authorities. Institutional verification is mandatory The board has also issued a directive to the Nodal Officers of respective institutions to ensure timely verification of applications. Officers are expected to verify, flag defects, or reject applications as necessary via their institute login on the portal. Failure to complete this process may result in applications being marked as invalid. "All the candidates are advised to apply online within the stipulated time and get their online applications verified by the institutions (if required show the original documents to institute), else the application would be treated as INVALID," CBSE stated in its official notice. Application process available only through online portal To apply, students must visit and complete the online application process. It is crucial that both fresh applicants and those seeking renewal follow the specified procedure carefully to avoid rejection. Students and institutions are advised to adhere strictly to deadlines and verification requirements to ensure the successful processing of scholarship applications under the CSSS scheme. Is your child ready for the careers of tomorrow? Enroll now and take advantage of our early bird offer! Spaces are limited.
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Meta may face daily fines over pay-or-consent model, EU warns
HighlightsMeta Platforms may incur daily fines if European Union regulators determine that its proposed changes to the pay-or-consent model do not adhere to an antitrust order issued in April. The European Commission has warned that continuous non-compliance with the Digital Markets Act could lead to penalties amounting to 5% of Meta's average daily worldwide turnover. Meta Platforms has criticized the European Commission for allegedly discriminating against the company, asserting that its user choice model remains a legitimate business structure in Europe. Meta Platforms may face daily fines if EU regulators decide the changes it has proposed to its pay-or-consent model fail to comply with an antitrust order issued in April, they said on Friday. The warning from the European Commission , which acts as the EU competition enforcer, came two months after it slapped a 200-million-euro ($234 million) fine on the U.S. social media giant for breaching the Digital Markets Act (DMA) aiming at curbing the power of Big Tech. The move shows the Commission's continuing crackdown against Big Tech and its push to create a level playing field for smaller rivals despite U.S. criticism about the bloc's rules mainly targeting its companies. Daily fines for not complying with the DMA can be as much as 5% of a company's average daily worldwide turnover. The EU executive said Meta's pay-or-consent model introduced in November 2023 breached the DMA in the period up to November 2024, when it tweaked it to use less personal data for targeted advertising. The Commission has been scrutinising the changes since then. The model gives Facebook and Instagram users who consent to be tracked a free service that is funded by advertising revenues . Alternatively, they can pay for an ad-free service. The EU competition watchdog said Meta will only make limited changes to its pay-or-consent model rolled out last November. "The Commission cannot confirm at this stage if these are sufficient to comply with the main parameters of compliance outlined in its non-compliance Decision," a spokesperson said. "With this in mind, we will consider the next steps, including recalling that continuous non-compliance could entail the application of periodic penalty payments running as of 27 June 2025, as indicated in the non-compliance decision." Meta accused the Commission of discriminating against the company and for moving the goalposts during discussions over the last two months. "A user choice between a subscription for no ads service or a free ad supported service remains a legitimate business model for every company in Europe - except Meta," a Meta spokesperson said. "We are confident that the range of choices we offer people in the EU doesn't just comply with what the EU's rules require - it goes well beyond them." "At a time when there are growing voices across Europe to change direction and focus on innovation and growth, this signals that the EU remains closed for business."
India.com
an hour ago
- India.com
After 6000 job cuts, Microsoft plans another layoff in July, CEO Satya Nadella says 'If you're going to use...'
After 6000 job cuts, Microsoft plans another layoff in July, CEO Satya Nadella says 'If you're going to use...' Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella is calling on the industry to think seriously about the real impact of artificial intelligence (AI) especially the amount of energy it uses. This comes as AI is quickly changing the tech world. Speaking at Y Combinator's AI Startup School, he said that tech companies need to prove that AI is creating real value for people and society. 'If you're going to use a lot of energy, you need to have a good reason,' Nadella said. 'We can't just burn energy unless we are doing something useful with it.' His comments come as AI is praised for pushing innovation forward, but also criticized for using massive amounts of electricity and possibly making social gaps worse. For Microsoft, one of the biggest companies building AI tools, this is a big concern. A report in 2023 estimated that Microsoft used about 24 terawatt-hours of power in a year. That's as much electricity as a small country uses in the same time. But Nadella believes AI should be judged by how well it helps people in real life. 'The real test of AI,' he said, 'is whether it can make everyday life easier—like improving healthcare, speeding up education, or cutting down on boring paperwork.' He gave the example of hospitals in the U.S., where simple things like discharging a patient can take too long and cost too much. He said if AI is used for this task, it could save time, money, and energy. Microsoft's AI push comes with job losses Even as Microsoft have big plans for AI, the changes have not come without a cost, especially for workers. Over the past year, the company has laid off more than 6,000 employees. Microsoft said these job cuts were part of 'organisational changes' needed to stay strong in a fast-changing business world. That fast-changing world is being shaped by artificial intelligence and cloud computing. Microsoft, working closely with its AI partner OpenAI, is putting AI at the center of its future plans. But as the company shifts toward more automation and AI-driven tools, it's also reorganizing teams, often leading to people losing their jobs. Microsoft is reportedly preparing for another round of job cuts and this time in its Xbox division. The layoffs are expected to be part of a larger corporate reshuffle as the company wraps up its financial year. If these cuts go ahead, it would be Microsoft's fourth major layoff in just 18 months. The company is facing increasing pressure to boost profits, especially after spending USD 69 billion to acquire Activision Blizzard in 2023.
