
Fact-checking three key claims about Trump's mega-bill
How much would the bill cost?
The White House has said the bill "reduces deficits by over $2 trillion" - but senior Democrats have insisted it would actually add trillions.BBC Verify has examined various independent studies about the bill's impact and interviewed six tax experts who all agreed that it would increase the national deficit.The deficit is what happens when the US government spends more than it collects through taxes and other forms of revenue.Musk criticised lawmakers who "voted for the biggest debt increase in history" when it was being passed in the US Senate.The debt is the overall sum of money owed by the government - essentially the accumulation of past budget deficits - which means it has to borrow money and pay interest on this.Trump's mega-bill heads for final vote in overnight US House sessionA look at the key items in Trump's sprawling budget bill'Our food doesn't even last the month' - Americans brace for Trump's welfare cutsThe US national debt is currently about $36tn (£26tn) - of which about $29tn is money owed by the government to investors around the world.Larger deficits and a bigger debt can theoretically result in higher interest rates - the idea being that investors worry more about a country's capacity to pay its debts as those rise and they therefore demand higher interest payments.That can feed into higher interest rates for consumers which make things like housing and cars less affordable, and restrict business investment and therefore productivity and jobs.The current version of the bill is estimated to add about $3.3tn (£2.4tn) to the US deficit over the next 10 years, despite an initial economic boost, according to estimates from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) - the government agency which provides independent analysis of spending.
The CBO said the spending cuts proposed in the bill would be outweighed by the tax cuts.An analysis from the Tax Foundation think tank concluded that the bill "would increase economic output but worsen deficits". It projects that the bill would increase the level of US GDP by around 1% after 10 years relative to where it would otherwise be, but that it would also add $3.6tn (£2.6tn) to the deficit over the same period.Some banks have said they are in favour of the bill - with the American Bankers Association writing an open letter to lawmakers saying it provides "much needed tax relief" which would boost the economy.The experts BBC Verify spoke to said although the bill may provide some economic growth, its cost would be significantly more than this boost."Most analysis finds that the bill will produce a small, temporary, short-lived boost – but that over time the bill will actually be a drag on the economy," says Bobby Kogan, a federal budget expert at the Center for American Progress, a nonpartisan policy institute.And Mark Zandi, an economist at the financial consultancy Moody's Analytics, says: "It will result in continued massive budget deficits, and a high and rising debt load."
What impact would the bill have on Medicaid?
"We're cutting $1.7 trillion in this bill and you're not gonna feel any of it. Your Medicaid is left alone. It's left the same," Trump claimed at an event about the bill last week.However, various studies show there will be significant reductions to Medicaid under the bill.Medicaid is the government-run scheme which provides healthcare insurance for about 71 million low-income adults, children, pregnant women, elderly adults and people with disabilities.Analysis by the Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) - an independent health policy research group - found that the bill would cut $1tn (£729bn) from future Medicaid spending over the next 10 years.The White House has said the bill "removes illegal aliens, enforces work requirements, and protects Medicaid for the truly vulnerable".The CBO estimates that nearly 12 million Americans would lose health insurance by 2034 under the terms of the Senate bill - with just 1.4 million of these being people "without verified citizenship, nationality, or satisfactory immigration status"."The largest Medicaid cut in American history came in President Reagan's first year in office… These Medicaid cuts would be at least four times the size," said Mr Kogan.
What about the impact on taxes?
Trump has repeatedly said that not passing the bill would lead to massive tax rises on Americans - in part because the tax cuts passed during his first-term in office are due to expire at the end of this year."If it's not approved, your taxes will go up by 68%," the president said last week.We asked the White House for the calculations behind Trump's claim - they responded saying the bill "prevents the largest tax hike in history" but didn't answer our question on where the specific figure comes from.
The Tax Policy Center estimates that not extending tax cuts introduced under Trump in 2017 would lead to a hike of 7.5% on average.The body also says roughly 60% of tax payers would have to contribute more if they expire."The 68% figure is incorrect… It could be roughly drawn from a count of taxpayers that would see an increase in taxes, as opposed to an estimate of the actual tax increase," says Elena Patel, a tax policy expert and assistant professor at the University of Utah's business school.Overall, the tax changes in the bill would benefit wealthier Americans more than those on lower incomes, according to the Tax Policy Center analysis. About 60% of the benefits would go to those making above $217,000 (£158,000), it found."There is no question that this bill will result in a massive redistribution from the poorest to the richest," says Ms Patel.
What do you want BBC Verify to investigate?
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Donald Trump flees to Scotland as backers admit Epstein files could lead to impeachment
Despite Trump's best efforts to distract the world away from the Epstein files, some of his most loyal supporters in Washington are starting to look ahead to the possibility of a third impeachment Donald Trump will be hoping for a few days of peace in Scotland this weekend - while back home his backers have started to talk about whether the Epstein files could lead to his downfall. The US President touches down in Glasgow this evening for a four-day golf holiday - visiting his clubs in Ayrshire and Aberdeenshire, as well as meeting with Scottish First Minister John Swinney. Meanwhile in Washington, despite the President's best efforts at distraction, the Epstein scandal refuses to go away. Privately, even some of the President's most loyal supporters in Washington are privately discussing the possibility that the revelations to come could lead to him being impeached for a third time. Such a bombshell move would most likely have to wait until after the midterm elections, where Democrats hope to retake one or both chambers of Congress. Were Trump to be removed from office, his Vice President JD Vance would take power - a situation many supporters are warming to. "It's really, really bad," a source told the Mirror last night. "This Epstein stuff has impeachment written all over it." The latest revelations suggest he was informed months ago that he was named multiple times in the files that are still being withheld from publication by his Justice Department. While being named in the files does not implicate him in any wrongdoing, it's something he's appeared to deny was the case in front of cameras in recent weeks. As well as enjoying rounds of golf at Turnberry, his favourite of the courses he owns, Trump will cut the ribbon on a new course at his Aberdeenshire links on Tuesday. Before that, he'll sit down with Keir Starmer for a meeting on Monday morning - when they're expected to discuss some of the final small print of the trade agreement between the UK and US, which aims to avoid some of Trump's outlandish blanket tariffs. It's understood the pair will have lunch at Turnberry before flying together to the Aberdeen course - but Mr Starmer is not expected to do any golfing. Scottish First Minister John Swinney, on the other hand, is expected to join Trump for the first round of golf in Aberdeen on Tuesday morning. Nigel Farage has so far remained silent about whether he'll meet with the US President while he's in Scotland - as he has during previous visits. Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said the US President would get a "warm welcome" from the UK when he arrives. But protests are expected at his courses, as well as in Glasgow, Aberdeen and Edinburgh over the weekend. Get Donald Trump updates straight to your WhatsApp! As the world attempts to keep up with Trump's antics, the Mirror has launched its very own US Politics WhatsApp community where you'll get all the latest news from across the pond. We'll send you the latest breaking updates and exclusives all directly to your phone. Users must download or already have WhatsApp on their phones to join in. All you have to do to join is click on this link, select 'Join Chat' and you're in! We may also send you stories from other titles across the Reach group. We will also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose Exit group. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. The Stop Trump Coalition have announced demonstrations tomorrow (SAT) in both Edinburgh and Aberdeen to coincide with the visit. And campaign group Everyone Hates Elon posted a video of pranksters adding a sign to the entrance of Trump's golf resort in Turnberry, saying it was "twinned with Epstein Island". It's the first of several similar stunts the viral group is expected to perform over the weekend. Scottish Police are expected to be stretched with requests for officers from other forces in the UK. The Scottish Police Federation said policing will be "seriously affected" by the trip - though Mr Swinney insisted the visit would not put forces in a "detrimental position."


The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
DOJ meeting with Ghislaine Maxwell set for today over Epstein saga
News of the meeting date comes as President Donald Trump continues to try and contain the growing backlash over the Epstein saga and his administration's recent decision not to release Epstein investigative files in the custody of the Justice Department. DOJ officials did not immediately respond to a USA TODAY request for comment. Who is Ghislaine Maxwell? DOJ turns to Jeffrey Epstein's ex-partner The meeting comes as many Trump supporters, Democratic lawmakers and even some Republicans demand the release of more information about the accused sex trafficker, who died in prison in 2019 while awaiting trial on sex-trafficking charges. Maxwell is also reportedly set to meet on Aug 11. with congressional lawmakers after the House Oversight Committee subpoenaed her on July 23. In a social media post Tuesday, Blanche - who is Trump's former personal defense lawyer - said that if "Ghislane Maxwell has information about anyone who has committed crimes against victims, the FBI and the DOJ will hear what she has to say." This is a developing story and will be updated.


The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Trump spars with Powell but backs off firing threat in clash at Fed
"I don't think it's necessary," Trump said. The president's rare presidential visit to the Federal Reserve building came as Trump has accused Powell of potential fraud related to the ballooning cost of the agency's $2.5 billion headquarters renovation of two historic buildings on the National Mall. Trump and several White House advisers requested the tour to inspect the work firsthand. More Trump news: Trump to visit Federal Reserve, ups pressure campaign on Jerome Powell But it was Powell pushing back at Trump before the tour got underway when the president claimed the project had swelled to $3.1 billion. "It went up a little bit - or a lot," Trump said to Powell, both men wearing white hard hats. Powell shook his head in disagreement. "I'm not aware of that, Mr. President. I've not heard about that from anyone at the Fed." How much did the renovatioin cost? Trump's visit to Fed is latest twist in feud over interest rates that has long history The president handed him a sheet of paper. Powell took a glance and then informed the president that his dollar figure also included the cost of renovating the Martin Federal Building, which was completed in 2020. "You're including the Martin renovation. You just added in a third building. That's what that is," Powell said. "I know, but it's a building that's being built," Trump said. Powell responded: "No, it was built five years ago. We finished Martin five years ago." Fed's explanation for cost overruns The original cost of the current renovation was estimated at $1.9 billion in 2019 before increasing to $2.5 billion. The Fed said the more than 33% increase was due to design changes, costs of materials, equipment, labor, and other "unforeseen conditions" such as more asbestos than anticipated and toxic contamination in the soil. Powell told Trump that the Fed does not foresee additional cost overruns and expects the renovation to be completed in 2027. "We're well along, as you can see," Powell said. 'No, I'm not talking about that': Trump denies plans to fire Fed Chair Jerome Powell despite what he told Republicans Though Trump has recently fixated on the cost of the Fed's renovation, the president has for months criticized Powell for keeping interest rates steady and ignoring his calls to lower them, mocking him as "too late" for not acting. "Well, I'd love him to lower interest rates. Other than that, what can I tell you?" Trump said when asked if there's anything Powell can do to get Trump to back off his criticism. "The country is booming and the interest rates are a final little notch." Powell has cited anticipated rising inflation from Trump's massive tariffs on imports as a reason to keep the rates unchanged. Inflation accelerated in June, the Labor Department announced July 15, with prices rising by 2.7% over the past 12 months. It was the highest annual inflation rate since February. Trump says cost overruns are not something to be fired over Trump and Powell toured the facility for less than an hour. They were joined by Republican Sens. Tim Scott of South Carolina and Thom Tillis of North Carolina, White House officials, Bill Pulte, chairman of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, construction professionals, and Trump-appointed members of the National Capital Planning Commission. Before they began, Trump was asked by a reporter what he would do during his long career as a real estate developer with project managers who exceeded their construction budgets. "Generally speaking, what would I do? I'd fire him," Trump said, later pointing to expensive underground garage parking and basement expansions as unnecessary add-ons. But after the tour was finished, Trump took a very different tone. He told reporters he saw a "very luxurious situation taking place" with the renovation, calling the meeting "very productive" and insisting there was no tension and that he doesn't envision firing Powell. "I don't want to put that in this category," Trump said when asked whether the project is a "fireable offense." Trump later said that he believes Powell will "do the right thing" and lower interest rates. "It may be a little 'too late' as the expression goes. But I believe he's going to do the right thing." Trump nominated Powell as Fed chair in 2017. He was confirmed by the Senate in January 2018 for a four-year term, and again in 2022 after former President Joe Biden renominated him for the post. Even though Powell's term as chairman ends in 2026, his term as a member of the Fed's board runs through the end of 2028. Reach Joey Garrison on X @Joeygarrison.