logo
Concerns rise over retirement of top judges without extensions

Concerns rise over retirement of top judges without extensions

The Star10-07-2025
THE recent retirement of Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat and Court of Appeal President Datuk Abang Iskandar without term extensions has triggered significant concern both domestically and abroad.
We express our deep concern and urge the government to provide a clear and transparent explanation for its decision not to extend the terms of these two top judicial leaders.
Upholding judicial independence, fairness, and institutional credibility must remain a national priority.
Under Article 125(1) of the Federal Constitution, judges who reach the age of 66 may be granted a six-month extension, subject to the approval of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong.
Historically, several Chief Justices — including Tun Richard Malanjum and Tan Sri Arifin Zakaria — were granted such extensions.
However, in this case, while several other senior judges were extended, the two highest judicial office holders were excluded, without public explanation or clarity on evaluation standards — an unusual and troubling development.
Malaysia's judicial system now faces a structural challenge:
- As of July 2025, more than nine judges from the Federal Court and Court of Appeal have retired;
- Over 20 high-ranking judicial positions are currently vacant, including the two top posts, with no official successors announced;
- The average case resolution period now ranges from 12 to 18 months, and prolonged vacancies at the top risk further backlog and delay in the delivery of justice.
The judiciary is not merely a legal institution; it is the benchmark by which citizens assess whether a nation is just, accountable, and governed by the rule of law.
When citizens witness the departure of the country's highest-ranking judges without sufficient explanation, it inevitably leads to questions:
Has political interest overridden institutional processes? Is there an attempt to influence the direction of the judiciary through key appointments?
We must stress:
"Justice must not only be done, it must be seen to be done."
A lack of clear, objective reasoning behind the government's decision will not only strain the boundary of trust between the executive and judiciary but also undermine public confidence in the legal system, potentially damaging Malaysia's international reputation and investor perception.
Therefore, we call for the following actions:
- The government must immediately disclose the rationale behind the non-renewal of both judicial leaders, including whether an independent evaluation was conducted, whether the Conference of Rulers was consulted, and whether a consistent standard was applied;
- Judicial appointments and extensions must be institutionalised and standardised through a transparent, objective, and independent mechanism, insulated from political influence;
- A bipartisan Parliamentary Special Committee or Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI) should be established to investigate any possible political interference in judicial appointments;
- All top judicial vacancies at the Federal Court and Court of Appeal must be filled urgently, to ensure institutional continuity and protect every citizen's right to timely justice.
True national stability is not built on the centralisation of power, but on the credibility of institutions and the realization of justice.
The judiciary is the people's final line of defence. It must never be subjected to political manipulation, nor become a pawn in power struggles.
Malaysia must not regress.
DATUK DR MONNA ONG SIEW SIEW
Chairperson, National Policy and People's Livelihood Research advisory Committee
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Kuala Lumpur rally: Police receive 60 reports ahead of Saturday event
Kuala Lumpur rally: Police receive 60 reports ahead of Saturday event

The Sun

time3 minutes ago

  • The Sun

Kuala Lumpur rally: Police receive 60 reports ahead of Saturday event

KUALA LUMPUR: The Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM) has received 60 reports nationwide as of last Wednesday regarding the upcoming rally scheduled for this Saturday in the federal capital. Acting Kuala Lumpur police chief Datuk Mohamed Usuf Jan Mohamad stated that between 10,000 and 15,000 participants, including NGOs, students, and the public, are expected to attend. Participants will gather at five main locations: the National Mosque, Pasar Seni, Sultan Abdul Samad Masjid Jamek, Kampung Baru Masjid Jamek, and a shopping complex before moving to Dataran Merdeka. Mohamed Usuf assured that additional police and public service personnel will be deployed to ensure safety at key transit points, including LRT, MRT, and Monorail stations. 'Organisers and participants must comply with all regulations and laws during the assembly,' he said, emphasising the right to peaceful assembly under the Federal Constitution. Prohibited items include weapons, sharp objects, firecrackers, and provocative banners. Police anticipate traffic congestion but confirmed no road closures. Over 2,000 personnel will be deployed for security. The public can contact the Kuala Lumpur Police Hotline at 03-2115 9999 for inquiries. – Bernama

Over 60 police reports lodged nationwide over planned rally in KL
Over 60 police reports lodged nationwide over planned rally in KL

The Star

time33 minutes ago

  • The Star

Over 60 police reports lodged nationwide over planned rally in KL

KUALA LUMPUR Over 60 police reports have been lodged across the country on a rally scheduled to take place on Saturday (July 27) here. Acting Kuala Lumpur police chief Datuk Mohamed Usuf Jan Mohamad said 10,000 and 15,000 people are expected to join the rally. He said participants are expected to gather at five main locations, namely the National Mosque, Pasar Seni, Sultan Abdul Samad Masjid Jamek, Kampung Baru Masjid Jamek and a shopping complex in the capital before moving to Dataran Merdeka. "To ensure the safety of public service users, personnel of public service operators and police will be increased at several stations," he said in a statement on Wednesday (July 23). Mohamed Usuf said among the stations involved are the LRT stations at KL Sentral, Masjid Jamek, Pasar Seni, Dang Wangi, Plaza Rakyat and Bandaraya; as well as MRT and Monorail stations such as Muzium Negara, Merdeka, Bukit Bintang, Imbi, Raja Chulan, Bukit Nanas, Medan Tuanku and Chow Kit. He said police expect traffic congestion heading towards the city centre due to participants entering affected areas but there will be no road closures. "Organisers and participants are advised to comply with all existing regulations and laws during the assembly in line with the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly as provided for under the Federal Constitution," he said. Mohamed Usuf also warned participants not to carry weapons or sharp objects; set off firecrackers or flares, display provocative banners, give defamatory speeches, bring their children or disobey instructions of authorities. "Strict action will be taken against any individual or group that causes chaos, riots or excessive provocation," he said. The public can contact the Kuala Lumpur police hotline at 03-2115 9999 or the nearest police station for any inquiries. On July 18, Mohamed Usuf said that police had received notification on the gathering from the organisers. He said police would deploy more than 2,000 personnel to provide security for the gathering on July 26. – Bernama

KL Saturday Rally: Police Receive 60 Reports
KL Saturday Rally: Police Receive 60 Reports

Barnama

timean hour ago

  • Barnama

KL Saturday Rally: Police Receive 60 Reports

KUALA LUMPUR, July 23 (Bernama) -- The Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM) has received 60 police reports from across the country as of last Wednesday, regarding the assembly scheduled to take place this Saturday in the federal capital. Acting Kuala Lumpur police chief Datuk Mohamed Usuf Jan Mohamad said the rally is expected to be attended by between 10,000 and 15,000 participants, involving a combination of non-governmental organisations (NGOs), students and the general public. He said participants are expected to gather at five main locations, namely the National Mosque, Pasar Seni, Sultan Abdul Samad Masjid Jamek, Kampung Baru Masjid Jamek and a shopping complex in the capital before moving to Dataran Merdeka. "To ensure the safety of public service users at the maximum level, personnel of public service operators and police will be increased at several stations involved," he said in a statement today. Mohamed Usuf said among the spots involved are the LRT stations at KL Sentral, Masjid Jamek, Pasar Seni, Dang Wangi, Plaza Rakyat and Bandaraya; as well as MRT and Monorail stations such as Muzium Negara, Merdeka, Bukit Bintang, Imbi, Raja Chulan, Bukit Nanas, Medan Tuanku and Chow Kit. He said police expect traffic congestion heading towards the city centre due to the increase in the number of assembly participants entering the affected areas, but no road closures would be carried out. "Organisers and participants are advised to comply with all existing regulations and laws during the assembly in line with the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly as provided for under the Federal Constitution. These provisions should be used prudently," he said. Commenting further, Mohamed Usuf said that among the prohibitions during the assembly included carrying weapons or sharp objects, firecrackers or flares, provocative banners, slanderous speeches, bringing children and actions against the instructions of the authorities. "Strict action will be taken against any individual or group that causes chaos, riots or excessive provocation," he stressed.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store