Justice Minister defends deportation of children to Nigeria
Jim O'Callaghan said it would not be a 'good idea' to prevent the deportation of children as it would have a 'very significant impact' on the number of people seeking asylum in Ireland.
Advertisement
He was speaking after five children and nine women were among 35 people deported from Ireland to Nigeria on Wednesday night.
The minister said the move, which was the third chartered flight used for deportations this year, was 'value for money' at a cost of 324,714 euro.
Speaking on Friday, Mr O'Callaghan said: 'Can I just say it's not a pleasant part of the job, but it is a very important part of the job.
'In order to have a functioning immigration system, there has to be a consequence for people who are in the country unlawfully, whether they have overstayed a work permit, or whether they sought asylum and have not been granted asylum.
Advertisement
'I've heard the commentary in respect of children being deported.
'I think the system will become untenable if we introduce rules or a new policy that says children cannot be deported.'
He added: 'It's an unpleasant part of the job, but I think if I introduced a policy like that, the effect would be that we'd be an outlier in Europe, and that people would know that if they came to Ireland seeking asylum with children, that irrespective of the outcome, they couldn't be removed.
'It would have a very significant impact in the number of people coming to Ireland seeking asylum. So I don't think it's a good idea.'
Advertisement
The minister said Ireland is a 'very fair country' in allowing people seeking asylum to integrate into communities.
'The alternative is that we would do what they do in some countries and don't allow any form of integration – we allow people to integrate.
He added: 'But I suppose a consequence of the asylum process is if you apply and you're refused there has to be a consequence, and if there isn't a consequence then what's the point in having the whole system in place in the first place?
'I can understand the concern that people have about it, but I just say the system will become untenable if a rule was introduced which said that children could not be deported.
Advertisement
'It would mean that people could come to Ireland with children in the knowledge that no matter what the outcome, they would never be required to leave.'
Mr O'Callaghan said his message to people was that they had to comply with the law.
'If you receive a deportation order, you have to comply with it. It's not meaningless. It means something.
'If you get a deportation order, and if you have children, you've got to get your circumstances in order, and that requires you to leave.'
Advertisement
Speaking at Leinster House earlier on Friday, Sinn Féin TD Eoin O Broin said that the international protection system needs to be 'compassionate', 'human rights-based', and 'timely'.
He said: 'Nobody should be waiting three, four or five years for the final decision to be made, and then when people are refused, not just refused in the first instance, but refused on appeal, they need to be safely returned to their country of origin.
'So that's the way the system should work. Obviously, we've expressed enormous concern in the way in which the government is operating the current system.'
Ireland
Total of 120 new garda recruits sworn in at ceremo...
Read More
He added: 'There's far too much privateering, very poor-quality accommodation for adults and children awaiting the decisions. The decisions are taking far, far too long, and I know that from working with people inside the process.
'Where people are refused and are to be returned to the country of origin, it needs to be done in a compassionate and a safe manner.
'We will continue to raise our concerns with the government, but the system has to work. It has to work fairly efficiently, but ultimately the decisions have to be enforced.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Auto Car
28 minutes ago
- Auto Car
Why the government's new industrial strategy is good news for car makers
Close Three months ago, Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders boss Mike Hawes said it 'felt like you were being punched on all sides'. But the government's new UK Modern Industrial Strategy is one of a number of developments that makes Hawes 'a bit more optimistic' about the future. An automotive-specific trade deal with the Trump administration – the only one signed and in force of its kind in the world – is another reason for hope. People have even stopped asking him about Brexit… Hawes credits this government, and in particular business secretary Jonathan Reynolds, for giving meaningful support to the industry.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Ukraine war briefing: US moving ‘with haste' to enable weapons shipments to Kyiv, says Washington
The US is moving to get weapons to Ukraine quickly under President Donald Trump's plan for Europe to buy arms and is weighing selling Patriot air defence systems from its own stocks, Washington's envoy to Nato has said. 'We are all moving with haste to facilitate this and get this done, and, you know, I think things are actually moving very quickly,' the US ambassador to Nato, Matthew Whitaker, told journalists on Thursday. 'But I can't verify a date that this will all be completed.' Trump on Monday announced a deal with Nato chief Mark Rutte for European states in the alliance to buy US weaponry – particularly advanced Patriot systems – and give it to Kyiv, but questions have been raised over where the systems will come from and how soon they can get to Ukraine amid Russian bombardments. Nato's supreme commander in Europe said separately that preparations were under way to ship the first Patriot systems to Ukraine under the scheme. US general Alexus Grynkewich said there was an 'ongoing conversation' about whether the US would sell Patriots already available in its own military stockpiles. The Swiss government, meanwhile, said delivery of US Patriot systems to Switzerland would be delayed as Washington reprioritised to provide more support to Ukraine. The moves came as Trump's effort to take credit for the additional weapons headed to Ukraine at Europe's expense created mild friction in EU-US relations, with the EU foreign policy chief, Kaja Kallas, saying: 'If we pay for these weapons, it's our support.' Donald Trump's decision to ramp up arms shipments to Ukraine is a signal to Kyiv to abandon peace efforts, Russia said, vowing it would not accept the 'blackmail' of Washington's new sanctions ultimatum. Trump on Monday set a 50-day deadline for Moscow to reach a ceasefire or face sanctions, while also promising more weaponry for Kyiv. Russia's foreign ministry condemned the move, with spokesperson Maria Zakharova saying: 'It is obvious that the Kyiv regime consistently perceives such decisions by the collective west as a signal to continue the slaughter and abandon the peace process.' Russian troops have taken control of three villages in three different parts of the frontline running through Ukraine, the defence ministry claimed on Thursday. Official Ukrainian reports of activity along the 1,000km (600-mile) front disputed part of the Russian account, particularly concerning a key village in the south-east. The Russian defence ministry report named the three captured settlements as Kamianske in the south-eastern Zaporizhzhia region, Dehtiarne in north-eastern Kharkiv region and Popiv Yar in Donetsk region. The battlefield reports from either side could not be independently verified. Ukrainian military spokesperson Vladyslav Voloshyn told the media outlet that holding Kamianske, south-east of the region's main town of Zaporizhzhia, was important to keep that city safe from attack. Russian lawmakers have advanced a bill that would outlaw opening or searching for content online judged 'extremist', such as songs glorifying Ukraine and material by feminist rock band Pussy Riot. Critics say the law, which has drawn a rare backlash from across Russia's political spectrum, would stifle internet freedom. The legislation threatens fines of up to 5,000 rubles ($64) on anyone found to have deliberately searched for or gained access to material listed as extremist by the justice ministry. More than 5,000 entries are on the list, including webpages, political slogans, books, artworks and music albums. Slovakia will stop blocking the approval of the 18th package of European Union sanctions against Russia on Friday, the prime minister said. Robert Fico said on Thursday that Slovakia had achieved as much as it could at this point, after blocking the EU's approval of the sanctions multiple times to demand guarantees against damages it fears from a separate EU plan to end all gas imports from Russia from 2028. EU countries' ambassadors would meet on Friday morning to approve the new sanctions. The European Commission last month proposed the 18th package of sanctions against Russia for its 2022 invasion of Ukraine, aimed at Moscow's energy revenue, banks and military industry.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Ukraine-Russia war latest: Zelensky and Trump consider drone ‘mega-deal' as Putin's troops advance on frontline
Donald Trump and Volodymyr Zelensky are considering a deal that involves Washington buying battlefield-tested Ukrainian drones in exchange for Kyiv purchasing weapons from the US. The Ukrainian president said his latest talks with Mr Trump focused on a deal that would help each country bolster its aerial technology. Ukrainian drones have been able to strike targets as deep as 800miles (1,300km) into Russian territory. 'The people of America need this technology, and you need to have it in your arsenal," Mr Zelensky told the New York Post. The Ukrainian leader said drones were the key tools that have allowed his country to fight off Russia 's invasion for more than three years. "We will be ready to share this experience with America and other European partners," he said. Ukraine was also in talks with Denmark, Norway and Germany, Mr Zelensky said. On the battlefront, Russia said its troops have taken control of three villages in three different parts of the frontline running through Ukraine, a claim Kyiv denies.
