Anti-loitering order back in effect in Montreal's metro
Cyclists can now bring their bikes on REM trains until July 4, 2025. (Graham Hughes/The Canadian Press)
Loitering is once again banned from Montreal's metro network, and the 'move-along' order will be in place until the end of April 2026, the Société de transport de Montréal (STM) announced Wednesday.
The STM said the measures, which were in place for six weeks in the spring, yielded positive results regarding safety and maintenance.
But advocates for the homeless population say it could harm those who have nowhere else to go.
The rules 'led to a noticeable increase in the sense of safety among both customers and employees, as well as a reduction in service interruptions caused by disruptive behaviour,' said Éric Alan Caldwell, chair of the STM board of directors in a news release.
He said that reimplementing the measures in the summer will give the city time to plan for the winter months when some homeless people take refuge from the cold in metro stations.
'We recognize, however, that this is not an ideal solution. The real solution will be a tangible and sustainable response to help the vulnerable, including more funding for resources, all year long,' said Caldwell.
The STM said 'physical measures,' mainly partitioning off access to certain areas and making open spaces smaller, will be in place at eight stations:
Charlevoix
Peel
Places-des-Arts
Beaudry
Pie-IX
Bonaventure
Place-d'Armes
Côte-Vertu
The STM's anti-loitering rules were implemented mid-March after a reported surge in service interruptions and criminal behaviour, including drug use, that led to some customers feeling less safe in the metro.
During the six-week period when the anti-loitering order was in effect from March to April, crimes and offences went down by two per cent, people being escorted out at closing time went down by 17 per cent, there was a 30 per cent reduction in service disruptions, and the reported sense of safety went up by eight points (all compared to April 2024), according to the STM's report.
Impact on homeless population
By bringing back and extending the move-along order, the STM wants to collect more data on the impact of anti-loitering orders on its operations and 'maintain stability' and hygiene standards.
Advocates for Montreal's homeless population say they are worried the measure will only increase their vulnerability.
The Réseau d'aide aux personnes seules et itinérantes de Montréal (RAPSIM)'s director, Annie Savage, said intervention workers reported losing contact with people with whom they had built a trusting relationship.
'In the long term, these measures undermine essential prevention and support efforts carried out by the community, contributing to increased vulnerability and need among people experiencing homelessness,' she said in a statement.
The RAPSIM said women will be the most impacted by the STM's order, since many of them hide in the metro to conceal their homelessness and feel safer in busy areas.
'These spaces offer them relative protection from harassment, intimidation, theft and street violence, to which they are particularly exposed,' they said.
The STM has said it wants to refer homeless people who spend time in the metro network to appropriate resources, like Mission St. Michaels.
But RAPSIM says those are stretched thin and are often overflowing which means people will simply be displaced.
Savage says the STM is losing an opportunity to put its resources toward inclusive resources by instead using a chunk of its budget to increase surveillance and security.
She pointed to an initiative in Philadelphia, which turned a metro station into a shelter where people can rest, have coffee, do their laundry and receive essential care.
The STM stressed that the move-along order will not be applied systematically and its special constables will take several factors into consideration during interventions to avoid tension.
In its report, the STM requested Montreal open 24/7 high-threshold resources near Berri-UQAM and Bonaventure stations, increase funding for Mission St. Michaels services and ensure emergency accommodations from early November to late April 'for more sustainable solutions.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Did Trump make Canada Day great again? Some observers say, in a way, yes
Just a few years ago, Canada Day was going through a serious identity crisis. Calls to #CancelCanadaDay were trending in 2021 after preliminary findings from a ground-penetrating radar survey at a former residential school in British Columbia had found some 200 potential unmarked graves at the now-national historic site. In 2017, protesters with Idle No More descended on Parliament Hill, calling for a national day of action called UNsettling Canada 150 on the country's 150th birthday. Enter, Donald Trump and his threats to annex Canada if the country doesn't voluntarily become the 51st state — something that's dominated headlines this year. "There is a switch this year suddenly," said historian Matthew Hayday. The threat to Canadian sovereignty has galvanized Canadians, the University of Guelph department chair said. This year, he expects celebrations with "the whole rhetoric of 'elbows up' and championing Canada." Trump's taunts and very real tariffs may be driving a resurgence of patriotism, but while some Torontonians are heading to Ottawa to celebrate, some Indigenous people say their concerns remain and shouldn't be forgotten. "July first can, in some ways, be a microcosm of a given year of what the national mood looks like," Hayday said. A day shaped by tensions Earlier this year, Canadians across the country were boycotting American products and cancelling vacations plans to the U.S. Those sentiments may not be as potent now, but for many the sentiment lingers. Yao Ameyaw told CBC Toronto he's still avoiding spending money south of the border, and he'll be travelling to Ottawa for Canada Day. "There is a bit of bad blood whether spoken or not, between us and America," he said. Patrick Shea and his wife will also be heading from Toronto to the nation's capital. He agrees Canada-U.S. relations have "reinvigorated [Canadians] sense of nation and our sense of belonging together," but hopes the tensions die down soon. "It may pass like a kidney stone, but it's going to pass." For Tira Cardinal, who is Indigenous, the holiday is an opportunity to spend time with friends, but she won't be celebrating. "I'm going to be wearing an orange shirt on Canada Day," she said, adding that she isn't surprised Indigenous issues aren't front of mind for many Canadians this year. "People hop on the bandwagon for a lot of things. Unfortunately, I think that's how people in society are going to be." Brianna Olson-Pitawanakwat, a member of the member of Wiikwemkoong Unceded First Nation, said she'll be spending the day rallying around her community and highlighting their resilience and resistance. She's the co-founder of the Native Arts Society in Toronto, an art gallery and studio space dedicated to celebrating and showcasing Indigenous artists, many of whom are survivors of residential schools or the Sixties Scoop. "[They] are struggling with displacement, and deserve to be honoured on this day," Olson-Pitawanakwat said. "There's been a big push with what's happening south of the border for Canada to kind of relish in this hyper-nationalism. I think it's really important to recognize that like the boundaries of what we call Canada today would not exist without Indigenous peoples." Recent bills could move the pendulum of public opinion Already, the surge in patriotism — and protectionism — has led to threats against Indigenous sovereignty, Olson-Pitawanakwat said. She compares Bill 5 in Ontario to Stephen Harper's Bill C-45, a controversial omnibus bill that made changes to the Indian Act, the Environmental Protections Act and Navigation Protection Act to make it easier for pipelines to be approved on Indigenous land without the consent of affected First Nations. That 2012 bill was part of what sparked the Idle No More movement that drove protests across the country and calls for Canada Day to be cancelled. Olson-Pitawanakwat says, like C-45, the Ford government's Bill 5 will also allow the government to expedite and approve energy project in Indigenous territories without local approval, namely when it comes to mining in the Ring of Fire. "We cannot approve these things without free, prior-informed consent," Olson-Pitawanakwat said. Similar tensions are playing out at national level, too. Prime Minister Mark Carney has signalled Bill C-5 could be used to greenlight and fast-track new energy projects, including pipelines, mines and other resource-related initiatives. There's already fear and pushback in some Indigenous communities about what it'll mean for the consultation process — though both Carney and Ford have vowed their governments will consult. "Right now, there is a lot more leeway for various actors to do things in the name of Canada," Hayday said. And as a result, "Indigenous concerns more broadly are kind of getting shunted," he said. With the pendulum in one direction, this could be the moment that it starts to move the other way, Olson-Pitawanakwat said.
CTV News
9 hours ago
- CTV News
Prince Edward wraps up P.E.I. visit with military parade
Hundreds packed the streets of downtown Charlottetown Saturday morning for a rare royal sighting. Prince Edward wrapped up his visit to Prince Edward Island — the first stop on a week-long Canadian tour — with a parade marking a military milestone. The Duke of Edinburgh spent three days on the Island celebrating the 150th anniversary of the P.E.I. Regiment. 'In times of emergency and in times of strife, they will be the first ones to support you,' he said, standing outside Charlottetown City Hall, addressing 80 unit members and the crowd gathered. The parade moved through the city centre to the sound of drums beating and brass blaring, tanks trailing behind, as the Union Jack waved from front porches. 'I've always liked the royals,' said David Windsor MacNevin, who says he was just two years old when King George VI and Queen Elizabeth visited in 1939. Some shared their first impressions of the Duke. 'I think the Crown is an important part of our history and traditions, and it's fun to see him in action,' said Wayne Scott. 'He's obviously very personable.' Several people had the chance to meet Prince Edward at a regimental ball the night before. 'Very approachable, very down to earth, incredibly charismatic. It was a very enjoyable experience,' said Sarah Jane Crabb, whose husband is a retired military member. Others stood by to cheer on loved ones. 'My husband is in that jeep right over there,' said Sharon Birt-Gallant, pointing towards him. 'I'm so proud to be a Canadian. It's unbelievable.' For two visitor from Florida, it was lucky timing. 'We just happened to be on the cruise that's docked today. And we heard that the prince was in town,' said tourist Kevin Holmwood. 'To be able to be here and see this — what a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity,' added Jennifer Holmwood. The day carried deeper meaning for those in uniform. The royal recognition, they said, was more than symbolic — it was a nod to their dedication. 'It was an honour, really. I've never got to play in front of royalty before, so that was really cool,' said Cpl. Isabelle McNeill, a musician in the P.E.I. Regiment band. 'It definitely raises the spirits of the regiment to have our colonel-in-chief being here and joining us,' added Cpl. William Carson. Next on the royal itinerary: Toronto, followed by Ottawa for Canada Day.
CTV News
11 hours ago
- CTV News
Thousands of tourists arriving in Ottawa for Canada Day activities, festivals
It's a very busy and energetic weekend in the nation's capital with thousands of tourists arriving for activities and festivals. The Canada Day weekend is kicking off with programming right across the city and in the suburbs. In Barrhaven, the Canada Day event is featuring plenty of rides and a larger midway. The event is free and runs until July 6. 'Our midway is bigger. We got some more rides for the older people and some great new rides for the younger people,' said Darrell Bartraw, the event organizer. 'We got a little bit for everybody. Lots of games and lots of rides.' Downtown in the historic Byward Market, dozens of vendors are set up with items to buy or food to eat, a DJ playing a set and shoppers picking up Canada Day shirts for the big day. 'This is awesome. We've got music going over there. There's people all over the place. The sun is shining. I love it. It's like Canada Day is back to where it should be post-COVID, rocking in the market,' said Mark Campaigne, an Ottawa resident. Music from the final weekend of the Ottawa Jazz Festival will soon be filling the air for another night. 'This is my first outing in like three weeks so I'm very grateful that we're in between clouds,' said Marianne Bournes, an Ottawa resident. 'The jazz festival has been with us for so long now and everything down at Lansdowne is awesome.' The vendors are also ready for the crowds. 'The weather was pretty hot, so I managed to put in some misting fans,' said Vincent Gobuyan, who runs Green Papaya Thai. Visitors from near and far are spending time in the capital. 'We're actually doing the Pokemon fest here, walking around Confederation Park and City Hall with my son who is seven,' said Natalie Le Claire, who is visiting from Kingston. Some are also travelling across the border to take in all the festivities. 'We love, the citizens of Canada, they're so lovely,' said Robin Rubens, who is visiting with her family from Miami, Florida.
