Birth Control Pill Classified Carcinogenic: What We Know
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
The most commonly used and prescribed birth control pill in the U.S. was classified by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) at the World Health Organization (WHO) as carcinogenic.
In 2008, the IARC released its report on combined oral contraceptives, which determined that the female birth control pills were a Group 1 carcinogen—placing them in the highest hazard classification, alongside tobacco, alcohol and asbestos.
While the classification was made over a decade ago, viral posts on social media have claimed that the birth control pill has only just been deemed a human carcinogen.
To shed light on the what the classification means and why such pills are still widely in use, Newsweek spoke to the IARC and various experts in the field to get to the bottom of the issue.
How Many Women Use Birth Control Pills?
Many women between the ages of 15 and 49 use birth control pills in America. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) say that 14 percent of American women in this age range use the pills, although other sources put the number at 25 percent.
There are three types of widely prescribed oral contraceptive pills: the combined estrogen-progesterone pill, the progesterone-only pill, and continuous or extended-use pills. Of these pills, the combined pill is the most commonly used by women in America.
Combined oral contraceptives are taken to help prevent pregnancy, by stopping ovulation from happening as well as via other means, and may also be taken in the treatment of anemia by reducing menstrual bleeding, avoiding pain from endometriosis, and managing acne and other hormone-related issues.
A file photo shows birth control pills.
A file photo shows birth control pills.
Tim Ireland/Press Association via AP
What Does The WHO Classification Mean?
The IARC's 2008 classification of combined oral contraceptives, shared with Newsweek, detailed that there was "sufficient evidence" they can "cause cancer of the breast, in-situ and invasive cancer of the uterine cervix, and cancer of the liver."
However, the report added that for cancer of the endometrium, ovary, and colorectum, "there is evidence suggesting lack of carcinogenicity."
While there has been serious alarm raised on social media platforms like TikTok about birth control pills in light of the classification, the IARC told Newsweek that it "conducts hazard identification only," meaning whether "an agent is capable of causing cancer at least at some exposure levels or circumstances."
This means the IARC does not "conduct a risk assessment," which would assess "the chance of an agent causing cancer at a given exposure level or circumstance."
There has previously been "confusion and other common misconceptions" about the classifications the IARC provides, a spokesperson told Newsweek, prompting the program to share a report in 2019 to explain how its classification system works, and what they each mean.
The Group 1 classification, which the combined oral contraceptive pill was placed in, is described in the report as when there is "convincing evidence that the agent causes cancer in humans."
However, the report notes that a Group 1 classification, or any other given by IARC, "does not measure the likelihood that cancer will occur at a particular level of exposure to the agent."
This means that while the IARC found that combined oral contraceptives are carcinogenic to humans, this does not determine how high the risk of developing cancer is by taking the pill at the usually prescribed dose.
Other Findings on Carcinogenicity of Birth Control Pills
Other researchers have found links between the combined contraceptive pill and an increased risk of developing breast cancer, but also that the pill may prevent endometrial and ovarian cancers in some cases—prompting researchers to determine the pill has a "net protective effect" after a study revealed their use prevented cancer in more cases than increased the risk.
"More recent evidence has clarified that if there is an increase in breast cancer, the magnitude of the increase is small and is limited to recent users, meaning that the risk dissipates over time after stopping oral contraceptives," Dr. Daniel Grossman, a professor of obstetrics, gynecology and reproductive sciences and director of the Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health, at University of California, San Francisco, told Newsweek.
A study by the Royal College of General Practitioners' Oral Contraception, which followed over 45,000 women for up to 44 years found that "most women who choose to use oral contraceptives do not expose themselves to long-term cancer harms; instead, with some cancers, many women benefit from important reductions of risk that persist for many years after stopping."
Another study by U.K. Biobank of over 250,000 women found that oral contraceptives "can dramatically reduce women's risk of ovarian and endometrial cancer, whereas their effect on lifetime risk of breast cancer is limited."
Why Is the Combined Birth Control Pill Still in Use?
Questions have been raised online about why the combined birth control pill is still being used when they are categorized at the same level of carcinogenicity as tobacco.
"Packaging for hormonal contraception includes warnings about their most common risks," Dr. Eleanor Schwarz, a professor at the Philip R Lee Institute for Health Policy Studies at the University of California, San Francisco, told Newsweek.
She added that the number of patients "harmed by contraceptive pills is truly like a drop of water compared to the ocean of suffering and premature deaths that are cigarette-related."
"The balance is generally favorable re: cancer, and is also favorable with respect to health benefits and overall mortality," Carolyn Westhoff, a professor of obstetrics and gynecology at Columbia University, told Newsweek.
"Combined oral contraceptives are well known to slightly increase risk of several cancers and they also decrease the risk of other cancers," she added. "In contrast, smoking has no health benefits."
Therefore, the reason the birth control pills remain available despite the carcinogen classification is because of "the overall low additional risk of breast cancer associated with oral contraception use," Dr. Abigail Liberty, a professor of obstetrics and gynecology, at Oregon Health & Science University's School of Medicine, told Newsweek.
She added that they also have potential benefits for ovarian cancer prevention and management of menstrual disorders, as well as contraception.
Combined oral contraceptives also have notes listed beside them on the American Cancer Society website to highlight that those medicines have been associated with some cancer protection and some cancer risk, Liberty said.
"It is incredibly important that providers discuss risks of all medications with their patients, but without fearmongering and with the utmost respect for the patient's perception of risk," she added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
2 hours ago
- Politico
US contractors say their colleagues are firing live ammo as Palestinians seek food in Gaza
Gaza's more than 2 million Palestinians are living through a catastrophic humanitarian crisis. Since Hamas attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, setting off the 21-month war, Israel has bombarded and laid siege to the strip, leaving many teetering on the edge of famine, according to food security experts. For 2 1/2 months before GHF's opening in May, Israel blocked all food, water and medicine from entering Gaza, claiming Hamas was stealing the aid being transported under a preexisting system coordinated by the United Nations. It now wants GHF to replace that U.N. system. The U.N. says its Gaza aid operations do not involve armed guards. Over 57,000 Palestinians in Gaza have been killed since the war erupted, according to the territory's Health Ministry, which does not distinguish between civilians and militants. GHF is an American organization, registered in Delaware and established in February to distribute humanitarian aid during the ongoing Gaza humanitarian crisis. Since the GHF sites began operating more than a month ago, Palestinians say Israeli troops open fire almost every day toward crowds on roads heading to the distribution points, through Israeli military zones. Several hundred people have been killed and hundreds more wounded, according to Gaza's Health Ministry and witnesses. In response, Israel's military says it fires only warning shots and is investigating reports of civilian harm. It denies deliberately shooting at any innocent civilians and says it's examining how to reduce 'friction with the population' in the areas surrounding the distribution centers. AP's reporting for this article focuses on what is happening at the sites themselves. Palestinians arriving at the sites say they are caught between Israeli and American fire, said the contractor who shared videos with the AP. 'We have come here to get food for our families. We have nothing,' he recounted Palestinians telling him. 'Why does the (Israeli) army shoot at us? Why do you shoot at us?' A spokesperson for the GHF said there are people with a 'vested interest' in seeing it fail and are willing to do or say almost anything to make that happen. The spokesperson said the team is composed of seasoned humanitarian, logistics and security professionals with deep experience on the ground. The group says it has distributed the equivalent of more than 50 million meals in Gaza in its food boxes of staples.
7 hours ago
Former CDC officials warn proposed budget cuts could cost American lives in 2026
Proposed funding cuts to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in the fiscal year 2026 federal budget will lead to significant negative health impacts for millions of Americans, a coalition of former federal health officials said. These proposed funding cuts are not related to the " big, beautiful bill" that is making its way through Congress. The press conference was organized by CDC Alumni and Friends and Fired But Fighting, an informal network of public health advocates. The latter has created a website that lays out the proposed budget cuts to the CDC. The former officials spoke out during a press conference on Wednesday noting that the proposed budget would slash CDC's budget by more than half (54%), taking it from $9.3 billion to $4.2 billion. "Instead of investing in these lifesaving programs, the current budget leaves the American people to pay the price tag with both their lives and money," said Brian King, a former health official at the CDC and Food and Drug Administration, who worked on tobacco prevention. State and local health departments would also be greatly impacted by the proposed cuts with over half of their budgets coming from federal dollars, the advocacy group notes. Roughly 80% of the CDC's annual domestic budget is provided to these smaller, local health departments. About $4.7 billion was provided in 2023 alone in grants to support health departments, hospitals, universities and nonprofits across the country, the group said. As a result of cuts to CDC funding for local health departments, "Americans will be sicker and more will be losing their lives unnecessarily," Dr. Tom Farley, a former health commissioner of Philadelphia and New York City, predicted. One of the largest cuts would be to chronic disease prevention, the former officials noted, including tobacco prevention, HIV prevention and injury prevention, which includes drownings -- a leading cause of death in young kids. "Successful [HIV prevention] programs that Americans have depended on for decades to help protect their own health and the health of their families and their local communities now risk being irreversibly damaged," said Dr. John Brooks, a former CDC official in charge of the agency's response to COVID, mpox and HIV.
7 hours ago
Military honors bestowed on Illinois veteran identified nearly a decade after death
CHICAGO -- Standing near the gravestone for the relative he never met, Mark Bailey accepted the crisply folded American flag from the Army officer, hugged it to his chest and closed his eyes. Though the person he called his aunt — born Reba Caroline Bailey — had been estranged, missing for decades and died in 2015 as an unidentified ward of the state, he felt connection and a sense of closure. 'I want to let Reba know we're part of the circle and part of the family,' he said. Mark Bailey was among dozens of attendees at an unusual funeral service with military honors this week for an Illinois veteran with memory problems so severe that they died an unnamed person. The ceremony became possible because of an extraordinary cold case investigation that identified the 75-year-old postmortem. Investigators unearthed the mystery of how the Women's Army Corps veteran ended up homeless in Chicago with few recollections of their own life, aside from identifying as a man named Seven. 'I never knew I had this family member,' said Mark Bailey's 19-year-old son Cole, who also drove from central Illinois for the service. 'It's nice to know I have somebody that's been found and isn't lost anymore.' Since the investigation's conclusion, the numbered cement cylinder that marked the unidentified grave has been replaced with a rectangular plague with a cross that reads: 'Reba Caroline Bailey, PFC US Army.' The case of Seven Doe, the name appearing in some official records, came to Cook County Sheriff Tom Dart's office in 2023. The unidentified body belonged to a person who died of natural causes in an assisted living facility. They were a ward of the state, unable to remember a legal name or family. The cause of death was heart disease with diabetes and dementia as contributing factors and the body was buried in a section for unclaimed people at Mount Olivet Catholic Cemetery on Chicago's Far South Side. The medical examiner marked it as the 4,985th case of the year and put the number on the headstone. In 2023, investigators ran fingerprints taken postmortem and found a 1961 Army record for the veteran, formerly of Danville, about 140 miles (225.31 kilometers) south of Chicago. The search for close living relatives came up short; five siblings and an ex-husband had all died. The family members they did locate had only heard stories of a relative who had disappeared. After making the identification, detectives ordered a new headstone with the same name on military records. It was quietly installed last year. Commander Jason Moran, who oversees the sheriff's missing persons unit, said it was rewarding to make sure the identified veteran got the benefit of a funeral with military honors. 'It's just a privilege to be able to help families and really close the story,' said Moran, whose work on other high-profile cold cases has gained notoriety. Several generations of the Bailey family have told stories about what happened to their missing relative since leaving the military to get married. They've wondered about the possibility of children or their relative's gender identity. Some believe that there was a family dispute but the stories about its origins vary from the decision to join the military to sexual orientation. Family members tried to find their missing relative over the years, including Amanda Ingram, who would have been a great-niece. She maintains a meticulous family tree with Census records and photos. 'It's amazing how somebody can just disappear like that and not know what happened,' Ingram said this week. 'I'm pretty sure we're never going to know the details.' On a winter day in the late 1970s, a person wearing a military-style jacket and aviator cap was curled up on the porch of St. Francis Catholic Worker House in Chicago. Residents who stayed there at the time told the Associated Press that the person asked to be called Seven, spoke in the third person and identified as a man. Seven quickly became the house cook. The meals drew crowds to the neighborhood where several homeless advocacy groups operated, according to former residents' accounts. Investigators have tried to explain the memory loss and floated theories about brain damage related to a 1950 car accident that killed Bailey's mother or to military service. That included stints at Fort Ord in California, a polluted former Army base, and Fort McClellan in Alabama, formerly used for chemical weapons training, and where the federal government has acknowledged potential exposure to toxins. Neither family, investigators nor residents of the worker house figured out the meaning behind the name Seven. Ingram, who lives in Alabama, couldn't make the ceremony this week. But she asked volunteers from an Illinois chapter of Daughters of the American Revolution to attend on her behalf. 'Everybody who comes to visit that cemetery will pass by it and know who she was,' said Ingram, whose detailed family trees include records using Bailey's birth name. Mark Bailey said he and his son wanted to bring something to the service that would honor both parts of their long-lost relative's life. They had heard their relative had an affinity for the Cubs and looked for a jersey with the number '7' on it, but settled on a blue team cap. They set it on the headstone. The service held Tuesday included prayers, a 21-gun salute and a bugler playing taps — a chilling, 24-note salute that is traditionally played at funerals of U.S. military veterans. Attendees included Cook County sheriff's investigators and Archdiocese of Chicago staff. 'I just wish the rest of them could be identified as well,' Mark Bailey told those attending while pointing to the rows of unidentified graves. Cook County Sheriff Tom Dart said the ceremony left him nearly speechless, saying the Illinois veteran deserved military honors and a flag from the U.S. president 'instead of being forgotten and left as an anonymous number somewhere.' Relatives said they planned to eventually display the flag at the American Legion in Potomac, near where the Bailey family has roots. Mark Bailey said the acknowledgement of military service was particularly meaningful with so many veterans in the extended family. He hoped the memory would stay with his son Cole, who plans to enlist. 'For him, it'll be something he'll have forever,' he said.
