logo
GPs welcome ADHD reforms but say cost and prescription barriers remain

GPs welcome ADHD reforms but say cost and prescription barriers remain

When GP Naomi Rutten found out she would soon be able to diagnose patients with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), she was "delighted".
For a long time, the diagnosis of ADHD has largely been restricted to psychiatrists and paediatricians.
Dr Rutten specialises in mental health in the South Australian town of Gawler, about an hour's drive north of Adelaide.
She has a personal investment in neurodivergence, with three neurodivergent children and her own diagnosis of ADHD.
"I've got a half a dozen patients who can't afford the assessment, so [my patients and I] are super excited," said Dr Rutten, who is also president of the Australian Society for Psychological Medicine.
"They'll be able to get diagnosed, trial some medication, and if it helps improve their function, it's going to make a world of difference to their capability to work, parent and be well in themselves."
South Australia, where Dr Rutten practices, is one of several states to recently announce changes to ADHD management, which will allow GPs to diagnose the condition and, in some cases, initiate medication in the future.
Changes in South Australia come into effect next year, while governments in NSW and Western Australia have committed to training up ADHD "specialist" GPs, and there is bipartisan support in Tasmania ahead of the state election for GP-led ADHD care.
But with so much policy change afoot, doctors have warned that patients may still face out-of-pocket costs for assessments, as well as barriers to accessing medication, without further reform.
One of the main barriers to ADHD assessments is cost, with some patients being charged thousands of dollars for appointments with psychiatrists, and others simply being priced out.
Dr Rutten says patients will probably pay much less to see a GP for an ADHD assessment, but warns these consults are unlikely to be bulk-billed.
That's because ADHD assessments require longer GP consultations, for which doctors receive a smaller reimbursement (from the government) than if they provide multiple, shorter appointments.
For example, if a GP sees 10 patients in an hour, for six-minute appointments each, they earn around $690 in rebates. But if they see a single patient for one hour, they receive $158.
As a result, Dr Rutten says GPs are financially disincentivised from providing longer appointments and more comprehensive care, and when they do, are forced to charge patients higher out-of-pocket fees.
At her own clinic, Dr Rutten's patients pay $135 out of pocket for a 70-minute appointment. She says with a thorough ADHD diagnosis likely to take two or three long appointments, patients could face up to $405 in fees.
In 2023, the federal government tripled the incentives GPs receive for bulk-billing patients.
From November, these incentives will be applied to consultations with all Australians (not just pensioners, concession cardholders, and families with children). GP practices that bulk-bill every patient will also be eligible for an additional payment.
But Dr Rutten says that for GPs to bulk-bill ADHD assessments, they need to be better reimbursed for longer appointments.
The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP), which welcomed the government's bulk-billing changes earlier this year, has also advocated for increased rebates for longer consultations, as well as an increase to mental health-related Medicare items.
ADHD Foundation director Christopher Ouizeman also wants to see GPs better compensated for the work of diagnosing and treating ADHD, to help address the current "bottleneck" of people trying to access affordable care.
"We think there should be some formalised structures in place to prevent the general public from being overcharged, and certainly to ensure that GPs are properly incentivised," Mr Ouizeman said.
But in order to improve affordability and accessibility of ADHD care, he says more investment is needed in public psychiatry and paediatric services.
It's an issue Tim Jones, a GP practising in rural Tasmania, is also passionate about. He spent two years working on a pilot program at Royal Hobart Hospital to try and improve access and timeliness of care for children with possible ADHD.
Dr Jones said the program was successful — dropping wait times for kids from two years down to less than four months — but was cut short due to lack of funding.
He believes a similar model, in which specialist GPs are placed in public outpatient clinics, could be implemented to improve access to ADHD assessments for vulnerable populations.
"The only way I can see the equity gap being fully addressed is getting more GPs working in collaborative partnerships in public healthcare services," he said.
"Private GPs and paediatricians have worked together as long as we've existed, but that has not been enough to meet the needs of the majority of our population."
Another issue consumers currently face is difficulty accessing stimulant medication when travelling between states and territories.
In Tasmania, patients are unable to get scripts filled if they are issued interstate, although there is bipartisan support to change this after the upcoming election.
Elsewhere in Australia, scripts can be filled interstate, but this is an onerous process, given stimulant medications (the most common medicine used to treat ADHD) are classified as schedule 8 or "controlled" drugs.
John Kramer, who chairs the RACGP's special interest group on ADHD, autism and neurodiversity, argues stimulant medication should be reclassified as a schedule 4 drug, with less stringent legislative controls.
Schedule 4 drugs are considered less likely to lead to misuse, abuse or dependence than schedule 8 drugs, but still require more stringent controls than regular prescription medication.
Dr Kramer says re-classifying stimulants would mean "people can move freely from state to territory and back again, and their prescriptions would be valid everywhere".
He argues any potential risks could be managed through Australia's real-time prescription monitoring service, which allows GPs to see how often a patient gets their medication dispensed, and how many repeats they have left.
However, others are more cautious.
Dr Jones argues that stimulant prescribing — and any change to it — needs to be carefully considered in adults, as adverse effects can be "significant".
The ADHD Foundation would also take a "very conservative position" on any re-classification, Mr Ouizeman said.
"I'm not sure it's the right thing to do at this stage," he said.
"Let's see how it goes with the existing [reform] frameworks, and if it's something that should be revisited later perhaps."
Doctors in some states are also waiting on information about how GPs will be able to prescribe stimulant medication going forward.
While regulations vary from state to state, GPs are generally required to "re-apply" for the right to re-prescribe stimulant medications (or make changes to prescriptions).
Currently, in South Australia, GPs can prescribe stimulant medication for patients who have been diagnosed by psychiatrists, but to do so, must apply for approval to the Drugs and Dependency Unit.
When approval is granted, it is generally only for a limited period, such as 12 months. Once this period is up, Dr Rutten must send patients back to a psychiatrist for review, leaving them further out of pocket.
She hopes the shift to allow GPs to diagnose will circumvent this problem, but these details are not yet available.
In NSW, GPs who have undergone training will be able to resupply ADHD medication to patients (without seeking re-approval) from September, with some able to initiate medication, though it's unclear when this will begin.
RACGP vice president Ramya Raman says any changes to ADHD prescribing rules will be finalised at a state and territory level, but working towards a national approach is ideal.
"I think [prescribing changes] will be part of the reform and progress that we are making," she said.
"There have already been some changes in WA, and there will probably be [further changes] moving forward if we're working towards a national consistency model."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Girl, 7, contemplates suicide, reaches our for help
Girl, 7, contemplates suicide, reaches our for help

News.com.au

time35 minutes ago

  • News.com.au

Girl, 7, contemplates suicide, reaches our for help

A seven-year-old girl made a phone call late one night telling a stranger she was thinking about killing herself. That call saved her life. The little schoolgirl, who is still in regular contact with her professional counsellor at Kids Helpline, is just one of 4000 Australian children aged five to nine who reach out for help every year. 'That's a lot of really young people who have the courage to ask for help,' Kids Helpline CEO Tracy Adams told 'We take our role to provide them with free, professional support any hour of the day extremely seriously,' she said. 'I really celebrate that they have that courage and absolute ability to recognise in themselves that they need to talk to someone and help them through what's worrying them. 'The fact they understand themselves well enough to do that is very special. They should never feel not worthy and not valued. We have built a whole service for children and young people, not anyone else, so that's how much we value them.' Last year the service carried out 135,000 counselling responses to people from the age of five to 25. Three per cent of all those contacts were made from children between five and nine years old. Bullying is one of the key issues affecting the young children who reach out. The epidemic is claiming lives of children turning to suicide as an escape. This month a 10-year-old girl died in her bedroom on the NSW South Coast. 'We are not going to solve the bullying issue if we don't engage with young people,' Ms Adams said. 'It's really about building respect, celebrating diversity and helping students and young people to embrace their differences, celebrate them rather than feeling like differences make children a target.' Ms Adams said the support service, which is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week, not only helps young people but 'walks beside families who have suffered great tragedy'. One such family is Kellie and Mat O'Brien from Sydney who lost their 12-year-old daughter Charlotte to suicide last year. The O'Briens are holding a Charlotte's Wish charity event in August this year to raise much needed funds for the service so no child ever has their call unanswered. 'In the wake of our unimaginable loss, we are honouring her legacy by channelling our heartbreak into action,' Mat O'Brien said. 'We aim to strengthen Kids Helpline's capacity to engage, inform, and support children, young people, parents, carers, and educators. It's crucial for everyone to have access to the right support, at the right time, in the right way, and at no cost – 24/7,' he said. 'Our goal is to create a stronger safety net for children and young people, enabling them to access the right support when they need it most. We truly want no child or young person to feel alone, unheard, or helpless in the face of bullying. 'By working together to honour Charlotte, we believe we can create lasting change in the lives of children, young people, and their families.' Mr O'Brien said that while bullying is a complex issue, doing nothing isn't an option.' The charity is also having a Giving Day on Thursday, hoping to raise $500,000 to allow for another 9000 counselling contacts a year.

‘Well-over six-figures': Young Aussie reveals the grim cost of her health battle
‘Well-over six-figures': Young Aussie reveals the grim cost of her health battle

News.com.au

time6 hours ago

  • News.com.au

‘Well-over six-figures': Young Aussie reveals the grim cost of her health battle

Madeline Lebski went from being financially stable and working full-time, to struggling to pay her bills because she was so sick that she couldn't get out of bed. Ms Lebski was only 27 when she got sick. She went from living in Byron Bay and embracing a healthy lifestyle to being bedridden and unable to go out with her friends, let alone hold down a job. 'I was just feeling a bit burnt out and then I took a month off, and didn't get out of bed for five years,' the now 36-year-old told Ms Lebski never imagined she would become disabled. She had always been healthy with no pre-existing conditions, and her biggest health concern used to be catching the yearly flu. When her health fell apart in 2018, she sought answers, but they weren't easy to obtain and it was also expensive. 'Every GP I went to said I had a virus and to go home and rest. I even showed up at the emergency department once, and they wouldn't admit me, and I said I needed to see a doctor for psychiatric issues,' she said. She was diagnosed with chronic fatigue and, years later in 2022, was diagnosed with mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), a condition where certain cells inappropriately release chemical mediators that cause a range of issues. In Ms Lebski's case, the symptoms were brain fog, painful periods, fatigue, nausea, daily headaches, anxiety, depression and panic attacks. Living with that chronic disease was incredibly hard; there was so much 'medical trauma' involved and her whole life became limited overnight. 'I was thinking, will I ever travel again? Will I ever work again? I lost a lot of friendships because you can't go and be social,' she said. 'It is an invisible condition so people don't really understand.' The young Aussie explained that, once she started looking for medical specialists to try and figure out what was happening with her body, the expenses were 'crazy' and became debilitating. 'Medicare didn't cover anything I needed. It didn't cover much of the specialist appointments or alternative therapies,' she said. 'The financial stress of it exacerbates the condition. If you're in a stressful of a state you can't focus on being well.' Ms Lebski did everything she could to self-fund the cost of her ill-health. She even sold her perfume business for $80,000. 'I ended up selling my business because I needed the money. I sold that and it paid for me to exist for the next 18 months,' she said. When that cash ran out, she turned to Centrelink, but she wasn't eligible for payments because she lived with her boyfriend. 'I was at my wits end. I remember just breaking down on the phone to Centrelink. My partner earned like $60,000 at the time, and they were like 'It is too bad, there's nothing we can do'.' she said. The rub was that a $60,000 salary was barely enough to support two people, let alone when one of those people needed to attend special appointments that could cost over $600 per hour. 'I made multiple attempts at trying to get on Centrelink, at one point, my parents were like, 'what if you study online?' Just so I could basically get Centrelink.' She completed a graphic design course that cost $5000, making her eligible for Centrelink, and received some income for a period. However, she is not sure if it was worth it. The cash flow helped at the time, but she was left with a $5000 debt at the end of it. Things got so dire that her parents had to dig into their own funds reserved for their retirement to keep her afloat. 'They've had to use their personal savings (including) getting money out of their superannuation,' she said. 'It is hard because they're in their early 70s, they've worked incredibly hard, and this is a period of life where they should be able to enjoy that,' she said. Ms Lebski said, 'as a family, we would have easily spent well-over six-figures' just on her health, and she even moved back to her home state of Tasmania to get more support from her family. It has been seven years since Ms Lebski's health declined, and she's finally in a place now where she can work full-time and manage her condition. 'Thankfully all the time and money I have invested has paid off in my case. I work part-time and that is where I see myself sitting while my body is recovering,' she said. It has been such a journey and a struggle, but there have also been positive things that have happened along the way. The 36-year-old is thankful to have found a community online and has been sharing her story in the hopes of helping others feel less alone and isolated. Social media has helped her find 'community and some visibility', enabling her to make friends and connections, even when she was bedridden. Despite her complex experience with Australia's health system, she still also feels 'incredibly lucky' that we have Medicare. 'I think we are incredibly lucky for what we do have access to and I do really mean it,' she said. 'Even right now I'm on a mental health care plan and I'm so grateful for that, but I do think it is very restrictive and there's no nuance to what disability looks like,' Ms Lebski said. She also can't help but feel this general sense of being 'behind' everyone else because she spent so many years sick. 'In another life I would have hoped that working on my business and selling it would have been something I would have bought a home with …. but that isn't the case,' she said. 'We live in rental and have a housemate to share the costs. I'm 36 and I would have loved to be able to plan for some things.'

Labor defends not calling ‘horrific' South Australia algae bloom a national disaster
Labor defends not calling ‘horrific' South Australia algae bloom a national disaster

News.com.au

timea day ago

  • News.com.au

Labor defends not calling ‘horrific' South Australia algae bloom a national disaster

The Albanese government has defended its response to the toxic algae bloom devastating South Australia's coastline, saying it does not fit the definition of a national disaster. A $14m funding request from the state government to combat the outbreak of toxic algae – which became known to authorities in March – was approved by the federal government this week. The bloom has caused significant damage to a variety of marine life, bringing industries such as tourism and fishing to a grinding halt, and leaving animal carcasses washed up on beaches within an hour of Adelaide. The Albanese government's response to the algae crisis has come under increasing scrutiny in recent weeks, with Nationals leader David Littleproud accusing Labor of being 'flat-footed'. Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young has repeatedly called for the bloom to be classified as a national disaster, claiming the response would have been much swifter had Bondi Beach been impacted and that current legislation was not 'fit for purpose'. 'This is a catastrophe, an environmental disaster and an increasingly a community disaster. I am disappointed (Environment Minister Murray Watt) stopped short of declaring a disaster,' she told the ABC on Monday. Questioned about Labor's response to the algal bloom on Tuesday, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke said a 'legislated, formalised list of events' would have to occur for it to be classified as a national disaster. 'That doesn't change the fact that it's an environmental disaster. It doesn't change the fact that all eyes of the nation are on it,' he told ABC News Breakfast. 'That doesn't change the fact that for the people of South Australia, what they are seeing … carcasses washing up onto their beaches, it's absolutely horrific.' Mr Burke said what mattered was that Mr Watt was 'there on the ground' on Monday. 'The Premier of SA (Peter Malinauskas) made statements as well yesterday. We're working cooperatively,' he said. Mr Watt said on Monday the funding would be allocated towards both short- and long-term measures faced by South Australians, such as beach clean-ups, community awareness campaigns, and ongoing investment in scientific research. 'There will need to be some further discussions between ourselves and the South Australian government about exactly the details of how that funding is used,' he said. 'The reality is, we are in uncharted waters here.' Mr Malinauskas said it was important to recognise the unprecedented nature of the bloom, which had ballooned across thousands of square kilometres of ocean. 'We've never seen an algal bloom of this size and scale in the history of our country's coastline … I think it's reasonable to assume that it won't be the first incident of its type in this country,' he said. 'The type of investment that was announced yesterday will go a long way in better understanding how we can prepare and plan for these types of events into the future.' Mr Malinauskas told the ABC he wanted to be 'really clear' the bloom was a 'natural disaster'. 'There are over 400 different species of marine life that have been killed off or had deaths as a result of this algal bloom,' he said. 'It's been with us for a while (and) it's starting to affect various parts of the aquaculture industry here in South Australia. 'It's always going to be better if we have state and federal governments working collaboratively together and that's very much what Minister Watt demonstrated yesterday, which we welcome.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store