‘Intellectual dishonesty': Congress after Centre claims India is among most equal countries
'By doctoring data, the [Narendra] Modi government cannot simply wish away the stark reality of what is staring us in the face: growing and deepening inequalities, driven by its mindset and policies,' Congress MP Jairam Ramesh said on X.
His remarks came after a Press Information Bureau release published on Saturday cited data from the World Bank to claim that India ranked fourth globally in income equality with a Gini Index of 25.5.
The Gini Index is used to measure income inequality. It ranges in value from 0 to 100, with a score of 0 indicating perfect equality in a country and a score of 100 signifying maximum inequality where wealth is concentrated in fewer hands. The higher the Gini Index, the more unequal the country.
The PIB release claimed that extreme poverty had dropped in India to 2.3% in 2022-'23. '171 million Indians moved out of extreme poverty between 2011–23,' it added.
This interpretation has been criticised as being flawed, as the PIB compared India's consumption-based Gini Index with the income-based figures of other countries.
Consumption inequality refers to the disparity in spending or consumption levels among individuals or households within a society. It is generally lower than income inequality in most countries because those with higher incomes tend to save more. As a result, consumption data, though still unequal, tends to appear more balanced than income data.
On Monday, Ramesh said that when World Bank released its report for India in April, the Congress had identified 'warning signs' about poverty and inequality flagged in the report, including that government data was underestimating inequality.
Three months after its release, the 'Modi government's drumbeaters and cheerleaders in the 'Press (mis)Information Bureau' issued a press release…making the 'staggeringly out-of-touch' claim that India is among the world's most equal societies,' added the Rajya Sabha MP.
He alleged that the Union government was not only 'negligent' in its analysis of the World Bank report, but that it was also 'outright intellectually dishonest'.
'India is not the 4th most equal society, it is actually the 40th most unequal society in the world,' said Ramesh.
He added: 'Such fraudulent analysis, being published through the auspices of the PIB, reveals one of two things: a disturbing lack of talent in this government, or an equally disturbing lack of intellectual integrity.'
Ramesh also demanded that the PIB issue a clarification on the origins of the press release and retract it immediately.
There has been a 'dangerous trend of such random ad-hoc statements and declarations' coming from the Union government, Ramesh said.
'In May 2025, we saw a similar flurry of incoherent and diverging statements from NITI Aayog officials on the size of the Indian economy,' he claimed. 'The political leadership's penchant for distortion and propaganda has clearly trickled down to officials as well.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
29 minutes ago
- Hans India
No CM faced wrath of people like Revanth Reddy, says KTR
Hyderabad: BRS working president KT Rama Rao on Monday said that no other chief minister than Revanth Reddy has faced so many abuses and insults across the villages in the history of Telugu states. Ridiculing the criticism of KCR by Revanth Reddy, Rama Rao said if he was sitting in the CM's chair it is because of the BRS chief. He made these comments while addressing a group of Congress leaders and workers from Medak who joined the BRS party at Telangana Bhavan. Stating that the Siddipet was once known for pigs and donkeys, the BRS leader said that donkeys have now left from Medak except for one or two and these two would also leave soon. Lashing out at the chief minister, Rao said, 'We have seen NT Rama Rao, YS Rajasekhara Reddy, K Rosaiah and KCR. No one faced the wrath of the people like Revanth Reddy. It is all drainage when he opens his mouth,' said KTR. He said that the chief minister promised loan waiver of Rs 2 lakh. The CM claimed waiving loans worth Rs 50,000 crore but washed off his hands by waiving just Rs 12,000 crore to Rs 13,000 crore. He assured RythuBandhu of Rs 15,000 for three crops but he gave just Rs 12,000 and wanted the farmers to celebrate and boasted that he will win 100 seats, said KTR. Taking objections to the language used by the chief minister against the leader of opposition, KTR said, 'Revanth should not forget that today he was sitting in the CM's post only because of KCR. We were in power for ten years but never talked irresponsibly. Is this IndirammaRajyam? Booking cases against people who post against the government.' Senior leader T Harish Rao said that earlier people used to say Siddipet means pigs and Medak means lots of donkeys. Now these places have been developed amazingly. There is Ramayampet Degree College, SC, ST Residential schools, KCR modernized the Ghanapuram canal. He ensured that even the last ayacut gets water. While KCR gave RythuBandhu in between cropping season, Revanth Reddy is giving in between the voting season. Lashing out at Irrigation Minister, Harish Rao said that Uttam Kumar Reddy always lies. 'Is it not a lie that you are cheating by not turning on the motors in Kalwakurthy while the gates are being lifted in Pothireddypadu and taking Krishna water? Isn't it true that lakhs of cusecs are going in Godavari? It is like the Revanth administration is sending water to Andhra and funds to Delhi,' said Harish Rao.
Time of India
31 minutes ago
- Time of India
Dramatic Inside Video: Chaos Aboard Ship ‘Magic Seas' After Houthi Attack
BRICS Rejects Double Standards On Terror After PM Modi Blasts Pak Over Pahalgam Attack, China Backs PM Narendra Modi issued a bold and emotional call to end global double standards on terrorism at the 17th BRICS Summit held in Brazil. Citing the recent Pahalgam terror attack in Jammu & Kashmir, which claimed 26 lives, Modi declared the assault as "an attack on all humanity" and demanded unified global action against terrorism in all forms. What shocked many was the unanimous support from BRICS, including China, for India's stance—a sharp contrast to the SCO Defence Meet, where India's Defence Minister Rajnath Singh refused to sign a joint statement lacking reference to the same attack. Modi warned that nations silently supporting terrorism must pay a price, and called for sanctions, not silence. The joint BRICS declaration backed India, slamming terror financing, safe havens, and urging zero tolerance.#brics #pahalgamattack #pmmodi #narendramodi #modiinbrics #modispeech #india #pakistan #china #indiachina #unitednations #terrorism #iranattack #rajnathsingh #sco #geopolitics #toi #toibharat #bharat #trending #breakingnews #indianews 27.7K views | 22 hours ago
Time of India
31 minutes ago
- Time of India
India highlights 4000% solar growth, backs climate finance push at BRICS environment meet
New Delhi: India has recorded a 4000 per cent increase in its installed solar energy capacity over the past decade and is on track to meet its Net Zero target by 2070, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Monday while addressing the BRICS Leaders' Session on Environment, COP-30, and Global Health, hosted under Brazil's chairmanship. Modi said India was the first country to achieve its Paris Agreement commitments ahead of schedule, and that climate change and environmental protection remained top priorities. 'In our culture, the Earth is respected as a mother. That's why, when Mother Earth needs us, we always respond. We are transforming our mindset, our behaviour, and our lifestyle,' he said. The Prime Minister noted that India had launched several key initiatives aligned with climate goals, including Mission LiFE (Lifestyle for Environment), 'Ek Ped Maa Ke Naam', the International Solar Alliance, the Coalition for Disaster Resilient Infrastructure, the Green Hydrogen Mission, the Global Biofuels Alliance, and the Big Cats Alliance. Referring to the upcoming COP-30 being hosted by Brazil later this year, Modi said the discussion on environment within the BRICS forum was relevant and timely. He said India had taken steps to bridge the gap between the Global North and South during its G20 presidency and that the country had achieved consensus among member nations on the Green Development Pact . 'To encourage environment-friendly actions, we also launched the Green Credits Initiative,' Modi said. 'Despite being the world's fastest-growing major economy, India is the first country to achieve its Paris commitments ahead of schedule,' he added. On climate justice , the Prime Minister said, 'For India, climate justice is not just a choice, it is a moral obligation. India firmly believes that without technology transfer and affordable financing for countries in need, climate action will remain confined to climate talk.' He said developed countries had a special responsibility to help bridge the gap between climate ambition and financing. 'We take along all nations, especially those facing food, fuel, fertilizer, and financial crises due to various global challenges,' he said. He said sustainable and inclusive development of humanity could not be achieved as long as double standards persisted in the global framework. Modi extended support to the 'Framework Declaration on Climate Finance ' being released at the BRICS session, calling it a 'commendable step'. The Prime Minister also linked the environment discussion to global health challenges. 'The health of the planet and the health of humanity are deeply intertwined,' he said, adding that the COVID-19 pandemic had shown that viruses do not require visas and solutions cannot be based on passports. 'Shared challenges can only be addressed through collective efforts. Guided by the mantra of 'One Earth, One Health,' India has expanded cooperation with all countries,' Modi said. He said India had established the world's largest health insurance scheme, Ayushman Bharat , which now covers over 500 million people. 'An ecosystem for traditional medicine systems such as Ayurveda, Yoga, Unani, and Siddha has been established,' he said. He also mentioned that Digital Health initiatives were helping expand access to healthcare in the remotest parts of the country and that India would be happy to share its experiences in these areas. The Prime Minister welcomed BRICS's emphasis on health sector cooperation and said the BRICS Vaccine R&D Centre launched in 2022 was a significant step. 'The Leader's Statement on 'BRICS Partnership for Elimination of Socially Determined Diseases' being issued today shall serve as new inspiration for strengthening our collaboration,' he said. Modi said India would assume the BRICS chairmanship next year and would focus on strengthening cooperation under the theme of 'Building Resilience and Innovation for Cooperation and Sustainability.' 'Just as we brought inclusivity to our G-20 Presidency and placed the concerns of the Global South at the forefront of the agenda, similarly, during our Presidency of BRICS, we will advance this forum with a people-centric approach and the spirit of 'Humanity First,'' he said. The Prime Minister concluded by congratulating Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva for the successful conduct of the summit.
