PBF seeks 18pc GST exemption on yarn, fabric
PBF Chairman South Punjab, Malik Talat Suhail emphasised that the Export Finance Scheme (EFS), introduced to phase out subsidies and promote exports, has instead proven detrimental to the textile sector. Under EFS, imported raw materials are exempted from both sales tax and customs duty, while local inputs continue to be taxed at 18%.
Though this tax is technically refundable, in practice, only 60–70% of refunds are released. The refund process is plagued by delays, manual processing, and high costs—issues that disproportionately harm small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs).
This imbalance has led many exporters to favor imported inputs, causing serious damage to local suppliers. As a result, Pakistan's import of cotton, yarn, and greige fabric surged by $1.5 billion in FY 2025, climbing from $2.19 billion to $3.64 billion. In contrast, textile exports rose by only $1.4 billion, and net textile exports are projected to decline from $14.0 billion to $13.6 billion. Over 120 spinning mills and more than 800 ginning factories have shut down, while protests from loom workers in Faisalabad are growing. SMEs are particularly vulnerable, as they face multiple tax payments at every stage of production and have limited access to cheaper imported alternatives, unlike larger firms.
The current situation has placed severe pressure on the country's foreign exchange reserves, especially as the number of commercial import licenses has tripled—from 800 to 2,400.
Meanwhile, local cotton production has fallen to a historic low of just 5 million bales, with further declines anticipated. Due to a lack of government support and declining demand, many farmers are abandoning cotton cultivation in favor of more water-intensive crops, placing further stress on national water resources.
The PBF also warned that the collapse of the cotton economy is stripping rural areas of $2–3 billion in income, with women cotton-pickers among the hardest hit. 'Pakistan is currently the only country imposing an 18% sales tax on cottonseed and cotton feed, driving farmer income below the cost of production and hitting the poorest segments of society the hardest.'
Rising unemployment and declining rural earnings are further exacerbating the economic crisis.
The Forum stressed that if current policies are not revised, Pakistan could lose $4–6 billion in potential foreign exchange earnings. Instead, the country continues to rely on expensive foreign loans to cover rising import costs, worsening the trade deficit, unemployment, and tax collection shortfalls. International partners have also taken notice.
The United States has signaled that, unless Pakistan addresses its trade imbalance, it may impose a 29% tariff on all Pakistani exports. Though the US has offered to export up to 1.5 million bales of cotton and has invited a Pakistani trade delegation for discussions, the crumbling of local spinning capacity raises the critical question: who will consume the cotton if domestic mills shut down?
The PBF South Punjab chief has urged the government to immediately delist cotton, yarn, and fabric from the current EFS policy. He further stated that maintaining GST on local cotton while exempting imports under the EFS is effectively a 'Pakistan-unfriendly policy'. It undermined local production, weakens the economy, and benefits only opportunistic importers. Without urgent reforms, the country risks facing a deepening economic crisis driven by misguided policy decisions.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
9 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PCDMA chief exposes rampant EFS exploitation
KARACHI: Salim Valimuhammad, Chairman of the Pakistan Chemicals & Dyes Merchants Association (PCDMA), has exposed rampant exploitation of the Export Facilitation Scheme (EFS), with fraudulent practices reportedly costing the national treasury a staggering Rs 25 billion. The veteran trade representative warned that the scheme, designed to boost exports, has instead become a pipeline for duty evasion and revenue leakage. Presenting import-export data analysis, Valimuhammad revealed that under Chapters 27 to 32 of chemicals & dyes - particularly 3204 - imports surged by 80% between 2023-2024 while corresponding exports showed no growth. 'This glaring discrepancy proves large-scale duty-free imports are being diverted to local markets instead of being used for export production,' he stated in a press release. The PCDMA chief provided a detailed breakdown showing that just for Chapter 3204 imports, the government should have collected approximately Rs 6 billion in Customs duty and Rs 18 billion in sales tax, totalling Rs 24-25 billion in potential revenue. However, actual collections remained alarmingly low, indicating massive leakage in the system. Valimuhammad proposed urgent reforms to curb EFS misuse, including immediate processing of 18% sales tax rebates and Customs duty refunds upon receipt of export remittances to improve cash flow for genuine exporters. His key recommendation was imposing a complete ban on duty-free imports under EFS without valid export Letters of Credit (LCs). Highlighting the scheme's distortive impact on trade, the PCDMA chairman noted a 25% decline in association membership over two years as regular importers couldn't compete with industries availing duty-free raw materials. 'While importers pay customs duty, income tax and additional sales tax, some industries get completely tax-free imports under EFS - this discriminatory treatment is destroying level playing field,' he argued. 'Dozens of legitimate importers of chamicals & dyes have been forced to shutter their businesses completely as a direct result of these scheme violations.' Expressing frustration over official inaction, Salim Valimuhammad revealed that despite submitting detailed budget proposals to FBR highlighting EFS anomalies and suggesting corrective measures, the association has received no response. He made a direct appeal to Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb and FBR Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial to immediately restrict EFS benefits only to actual export production and completely disallow duty-free imports without verified export LCs. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
12 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Farmers demand end to GST on local cotton
Listen to article Following the government's decision to impose 18% General Sales Tax (GST) on imported cotton and yarn in the amended Finance Bill 2025, farmers and industry groups are now urging authorities to abolish GST on locally produced cotton and its by-products. Pakistan Kissan Ittihad (PKI) President Khalid Mahmood Khokhar has strongly opposed the continued taxation of domestic cotton, saying it unfairly targets local growers and further erodes already thin profit margins. While the Pakistan Business Forum (PBF) welcomed the tax on imported cotton to help restore balance in the textile value chain, it warned that domestic producers still bear the brunt. "Local spinners are still subject to GST, which they recover from farmers, effectively treating them as withholding agents. This is unjust and must be corrected," said PBF South Punjab Chairman Malik Talat Suhail. Cotton farmers, already burdened by soaring production costs, are finding it harder to keep cultivating. According to PKI, cotton output has dropped from 14.8 million bales in 2011-12 to under 7.5 million bales in 2024-25 — a decline of nearly 50%. Meanwhile, imports now exceed 5 million bales, and exports have nearly vanished. One major issue is the widening gap between input costs and output prices. In 2010-11, cotton fetched Rs5,500-6,000 per maund, or about $70 at the exchange rate of Rs85 per dollar. Now, in 2024-25, the price is around Rs7,600 per maund, equal to just $27 due to currency depreciation. This marks a 250% fall in dollar terms, while input costs have skyrocketed. Fertiliser prices have more than tripled in a decade. A 50kg bag of DAP (Diammonium Phosphate), once priced at Rs3,236, now costs Rs12,900 (298% rise). NP (Sarsabz Nitrophos) has jumped from Rs2,108 to Rs8,100 (284%), Urea from Rs1,035 to Rs4,230 (309%), and SOP (Sulphate of potash) from Rs2,807 to Rs10,000 (256%). These hikes have put over 90% of small and medium farmers under severe financial strain. Energy prices have also surged. Diesel has climbed from Rs85 per litre in 2012 to Rs264 in 2025. Electricity for irrigation has risen from Rs4 per unit to Rs42 — a 950% increase. Labour costs are up too, with cotton-picking charges rising from Rs100 per maund in 2010-11 to Rs1,000 per maund today. In response, PKI has outlined urgent reforms. These include abolishing the 14% GST on tractors to support mechanisation and removing the 18% GST on locally made tractor-mounted implements. They also demand removal of GST on "Khal Banaula," a key cotton by-product used in livestock feed. PKI has called for the creation of a Commodity Price Commission to ensure fair pricing and a guaranteed 25% return on farmer investments. They further propose a flat electricity rate of Rs10 per unit for irrigation tube wells and the timely export of surplus produce to stabilise prices and reduce losses. PBF echoed these concerns, stressing that taxes on cottonseed and cottonseed cake — exempt in most cotton-producing countries — hurt farmers and shift cultivation toward water-intensive crops, threatening both agriculture and water security. Both organisations warn that without bold reforms, Pakistan risks becoming a net importer of cotton.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Weekly Cotton Review: Mixed trend persists on improved trading
KARACHI: The cotton market witnessed a mixed trend. Trading activities showed improvement. The spot rate recorded a decline of Rs 200 per maund. In the recent budget, the government has fulfilled the long-standing demand of APTMA by discontinuing the Export Facilitation Scheme (EFS) on imported cotton, yarn, and fabric. This move has provided a level playing field for the local industry to compete internationally, earning appreciation from industrial circles. Recent rains in Sindh and Punjab have led to the partial closure of ginning factories, affecting production activities. However, experts suggest that while the rainfall will benefit the cotton crop, standing water in the fields could pose a risk of damage. Earlier, the crop had already suffered due to extreme heat, prompting farmers to remain vigilant about weather fluctuations. On another front, discussions were held between the leadership of China and APTMA to promote bilateral trade. Both sides emphasized maximizing benefits from the Free Trade Agreement (FTA) to further strengthen trade relations between the two countries. Joint measures in this regard are currently under consideration. Sohail Talat, Chairman of the Pakistan Business Forum (PBF) and the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI), has demanded the revival of the cotton industry in South Punjab. He declared that the struggle to eliminate taxes on cotton would continue until the government meets their demands. Ahsan-ul-Haq, Chairman of the Ginners Forum, stated that Pakistan's agriculture sector, particularly cotton crops, is facing severe damage due to the inefficiencies of the Meteorological Department. He emphasized the need for better weather forecasting and policy interventions to protect farmers' livelihoods. The Pakistan Cotton Ginners Association (PCGA) had demanded the removal of taxes on Khal and Banola, but the government has yet to take action. This delay has caused significant unrest among cotton growers, who are already struggling with financial and operational challenges. The local cotton market witnessed mixed trends in cotton prices over the past week. While prices in Sindh remained relatively weak, the Karachi Cotton Association's Spot Rate Committee reduced the spot rate by PKR 200 per maund, closing it at PKR 16,300 per maund. The supply of phutti (seed cotton) increased in both Sindh and Punjab, leading to the resumption of operations in several ginning factories. However, due to the distribution of phutti among a larger number of factories, many are operating only partially. The recent rains in Sindh and Punjab have discouraged ginners from purchasing large quantities of phutti, which is expected to disrupt the arrival of phutti and affect cotton quality. The government has discontinued the Export Facilitation Scheme (EFS) for cotton, yarn, and fabric in the budget and imposed an 18% sales tax on imported cotton, yarn, and fabric. This fulfills APTMA's long-standing demand for a level playing field, which is expected to benefit cotton farmers and encourage textile mills to purchase local cotton, thereby boosting domestic trade. According to a report, the sales tax on imported cotton, yarn, and fabric—as well as local cotton—may be reduced from 18% to 10%. However, confirmation of this news will only be possible after the official notification is issued. Meanwhile, the Pakistan Cotton Ginners Association (PCGA) remains concerned as its demand for the removal of taxes on cotton by-products, such as cottonseed oil and cake, has not been met. The Pakistan Kissan Ittehad has also raised its concerns and urged the government to address PCGA's demands. Sohail Talat, Chairman of the Pakistan Businesses Forum (PBF) and FPCCI, emphasized that the struggle to eliminate taxes on cotton will continue until the demands are met. The rate of cotton in Sindh is in between Rs16,200 to Rs 16,500 per maund, while the rate of phutti is in between Rs 7,500 to Rs 8,200 per 40 kg. In Punjab, cotton prices stood at Rs 16,700 to Rs 16,800 per maund. The rate of Phutti is in between Rs 7,800 to Rs 8,400 per 40 kg. However, prices of Banola have declined. The Spot Rate Committee of the Karachi Cotton Association reduced the spot rate by Rs 200 per maund, closing it at Rs 16,300 per maund. Karachi Cotton Brokers Forum Chairman Naseem Usman said that international cotton prices showed a mixed trend, with New York cotton futures trading between 66.00 to 69.00 cents per pound. According to the USDA's weekly production and sales report, 27,300 bales were sold for the 2024-25 season. Pakistan remained the top buyer, purchasing 9,200 bales, followed by Vietnam with 7,700 bales, and Japan in third place with 2,500 bales. For the 2025-26 season, sales reached 64,700 bales. Vietnam led with 34,300 bales, followed by El Salvador with 15,300 bales, and Malaysia in third place with 8,000 bales. Chinese Consulate General and All Pakistan Textile Mills Association (APTMA) leadership have resolved to upsurge bilateral trade, take maximum advantage of Free Trade Agreement (FTA) and to explore possibilities of joint ventures in textile industry. Zhao Shiren Consul General of China, Li Haoteng, Commercial Counsellor and Wang Yaqiang, Vice Consul visited APTMA office on Tuesday and discussed in detail prospects, ways and means to increase volume of trade and joint ventures in textile industry. Dr Gohar Ejaz, Patron-in-Chief APTMA and Chairman APTMA Kamran Arshad welcomed the Chinese Consul General at APTMA. They were accompanied by Syed Ali Ahsan, former Chairman APTMA, Zonal Management Committee members including Haroon Ellahi, Muhammad Ali, Faisal Jawed, Ahsan Shahid, Ismail Fareed, Habib Anwar, leading textile exporters, Secretary General APTMA Shahid Sattar and Secretary General North Mohammad Raza Baqir. Speaking on the occasion, Zhao Shiren said both China and Pakistan enjoy strong economic and cultural relations and China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) is an example of this robust relationship between both the countries. He highly appreciated the role of APTMA in general and of Dr Gohar Ejaz in particular in expansion of bilateral economic relations. He enumerated highly plausible services rendered by Dr Gohar Ejaz in cementing relation between China and Pakistan not only as Commerce Minister but also in his private capacity. He also spoke volume about community and welfare services being performed by Gohar Ejaz Foundation for poverty alleviation, medical services, educational and research uplift and industrialization of the country. Consul General highlighted expansion of bilateral trade since the signing of China-Pakistan Free Trade Agreement (FTA) in 2006 and resolved to further uplift the said volume by taking maximum benefits from FTA. He noted that balance of trade is presently in favour of China and assured of his help to not only expand trade volume but also to bridge the gap in balance of trade. He informed that textile goods falling in more than 800 HS tariff lines of customs chapters 50 to 63 enjoy duty free status under FTA on import into China from Pakistan. He emphasised Pakistani textile industry to avail duty free regime widely liberalized for Pakistani textile products since implementation of Phase II of FTA in 2020. According to reports, cotton has been cultivated on 3.128 million acres in Punjab and 1.005 million acres in Sindh. The expected yield per acre is estimated at 170 kg. Punjab is projected to produce 4.898 million bales, while Sindh is expected to yield 2.519 million bales. The total anticipated cotton production for both provinces stands at 7.417 million bales. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
