Fact check: Are France's working conditions among Europe's worst?
"In a study carried out at the end of 2021 and published in 2022 (...) France is in 36th position, right at the bottom with Albania, in terms of working conditions," Delgènes told Public Sénat, the official TV channel of the upper house of the French Parliament.
His statements have prompted a flood of reactions on social media.
It comes as the issue of precarious working conditions comes to the fore in France.
Over the past two and a half months, five young workers and trainees aged between 15 and 19 have been killed in workplace accidents, raising questions about the country's labour conditions.
We took a closer look at the data to verify the claims made by Delgènes.
France trails most European counterparts
The claims are based on a 2021 study by Eurofound, a Dublin-based agency that conducts research into living and working conditions in European countries.
Its most recent survey into European working conditions, known as EWCS, dates from 2021. Updated fieldwork from 2024 is expected to be made public later this year.
The research looks at working conditions in 36 European countries, including all 27 European Union member states.
It includes a 'job quality index', which combines data points on aspects such as health, safety, work satisfaction and more to measure the degree to which workers are strained in the workplace.
The results suggest that more workers in France are exposed to 'extremely strained' or 'highly strained' conditions than in most other countries.
Only in Serbia, Montenegro, Slovakia and Poland do more workers have 'extremely strained' or 'highly strained' conditions, according to the findings.
France not in 36th position 'with Albania'
When we also consider those who cited 'moderately strained' conditions, France ranks penultimately, with only Slovakia scoring worse, and Albania faring slightly better.
The research therefore does not place France "right at the bottom, with Albania in terms of working conditions" as Delgènes asserts.
When we look only at workers citing "extremely strained", or the most severe conditions, France ranks 30th, above other EU member states such as Croatia and Cyprus as well as the United Kingdom.
Concerns over health and safety
The data, however, does place France behind most of its European counterparts when it comes to labour conditions.
Data provided by Eurostat, the EU's statistical office, confirms the trend.
According to the latest estimates, only Malta ranks worse than France in terms of the incidence of fatal accidents recorded in the workplace.
These concerns have been augmented recently with the tragic deaths of five young workers in their place of work in the space of just two and a half months. According to estimates, two people die in the workplace in France every day.
The French government is examining a proposal to sanction employers responsible for workplace issues, such as through fines and criminal prosecutions, according to a document recently seen by French media, including Le Monde.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
20 minutes ago
- France 24
US-EU tariff talks progress as Trump announces Japan deal
In an attempt to slash his country's trade deficits, Trump has vowed to hit dozens of countries with punitive tariff hikes if they do not hammer out a pact with Washington by August 1. While the Trump administration earlier promised "90 deals in 90 days" as it delayed the imposition of higher duties in April, Washington has so far unveiled just five agreements including with Japan and the Philippines. The others are with Britain, Vietnam and Indonesia, the latter of which the White House noted would ease critical mineral export restrictions. Negotiations remain ongoing with major US trading partners China, Canada, Mexico and the European Union. Washington and Brussels signaled negotiations were moving along, with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz voicing optimism that "decisions" may be coming soon. Several EU diplomats added that the bloc was examining a US proposal involving a 15 percent tariff -- and sectoral carve-outs still to be decided. EU trade chief Maros Sefcovic was expected to speak with US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick on Wednesday. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, meanwhile, told Bloomberg Television: "I think that we are making good progress with the EU." Separately, representatives from China and the United States will meet next week in Swedish capital Stockholm to further negotiations before an August 12 deadline agreed in May. Beijing and Washington imposed tit-for-tat levies on each other's exports this year, reaching triple-digit levels, before agreeing to lower these temporarily until mid-August. As the clock ticks down, China said Wednesday it would seek to "strengthen cooperation" with Washington, and confirmed vice premier He Lifeng would attend the talks. 'Massive deal' For now, Trump was touting Washington's agreement with Japan as "a massive deal." He said on his Truth Social platform Tuesday that under the deal, "Japan will invest, at my direction, $550 Billion Dollars into the United States, which will receive 90% of the Profits." Bessent told Bloomberg Television that Japan received a 15 percent tariff rate, down from the 25 percent threatened, as "they were willing to provide this innovative financing mechanism." "They are going to provide equity credit guarantees and funding for major projects in the US," Bessent said. Japanese exports to the United States were already subject to a 10 percent tariff, and this would have spiked to 25 percent come August 1 without a deal. Duties of 25 percent on Japanese autos -- an industry accounting for eight percent of Japanese jobs -- were also already in place, plus 50 percent on steel and aluminum. Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba said the autos levy had now been cut to 15 percent, sending Japanese car stocks soaring, with Toyota and Mitsubishi up around 14 percent each. The Nikkei rose 3.5 percent. "We are the first (country) in the world to reduce tariffs on automobiles and auto parts, with no limits on volume," he told reporters. Japan's trade envoy Ryosei Akazawa, who secured the deal on his eighth visit to Washington, said the 50 percent tariffs on steel and aluminum would remain. Akazawa also said increased defense spending by Japan -- something Trump has pressed for -- was not part of the agreement. Trump added Tuesday that Japan agreed as well to "open their Country to Trade including Cars and Trucks, Rice and certain other Agricultural Products, and other things." Rice imports are a sensitive issue in Japan, and Ishiba's government -- which lost its upper house majority in elections on Sunday -- had previously ruled out any concessions. Japan currently imports 770,000 tons of rice tariff-free under its World Trade Organization commitments, and Ishiba said it would import more US grain within this. Ishiba said Wednesday that the deal does not "sacrifice" Japan's agricultural sector. Tatsuo Yasunaga, the chair of the Japan Foreign Trade Council, welcomed the trade deal but said the business community needed to see details to assess its impact. Other US trading partners are watching closely as the August 1 deadline approaches. The Philippines' deal announced Tuesday only saw levies cut by one percentage point, to 19 percent, after Trump hosted President Ferdinand Marcos. China on Wednesday said it supported "equal dialogue" following the announcement of the Japan-US deal. burs-raz-bys/acb © 2025 AFP
LeMonde
3 hours ago
- LeMonde
Merz and Macron discuss NATO and EU-US trade issues
French President Emmanuel Macron met German Chancellor Friedrich Merz in Berlin on Wednesday, July 23, as they sought to present a united front on the US-EU trade row, NATO security and other pressing issues. Macron and Merz, who took power in May, have been at pains to boost the partnership at the heart of the European Union as US President Donald Trump has rocked transatlantic ties. Macron said bilateral "convergence (...) whether it concerns defense, security, the energy transition, or artificial intelligence and quantum technology, is absolutely key to gaining efficiency, critical mass and cooperation." Paris and Berlin, along with London and Warsaw, have pushed efforts to support Ukraine against Russia and build up the defense capabilities of NATO's European member states. Merz and Macron during their working dinner were also to discuss the EU-US trade dispute after Trump threatened 30% tariffs against the bloc if no deal is reached by August 1. Greeting Macron, Merz voiced optimism, saying that, as senior-level talks were being held, "we are hearing in these minutes that there could possibly be decisions." Macron emphasized the shared European desire "to provide stability and have the lowest possible tariffs, but also, of course, to be respected as the partners that we are." 'Energy restart' The two leaders also have to discuss several bilateral stumbling blocks, ranging from joint defense projects to energy. There has been disagreement over a combat aircraft to be made jointly by France, Germany and Spain. The head of French defense company Dassault, Eric Trappier, suggested on Tuesday that the viability of the project was in doubt. Merz said that they would talk "about common foreign and security policy, and we will talk about the joint projects that we both discussed some time ago and on which we are working intensively." Another tricky area is energy: France relies heavily on nuclear power, which Germany has decided to phase out as it shifts increasingly to solar and wind. Paris wants Berlin to commit to "technology neutrality" and effectively classify nuclear energy as climate-friendly. Germany's previous coalition government of the Social Democrats and Greens rejected this, but Merz's centze-right CDU/CSU may be more open to the idea. In a joint newspaper article in May, both leaders pledged a "restart in energy policy" and "equal treatment at the EU level for all low-emission energies."
Euronews
3 hours ago
- Euronews
Defence and tariffs top the agenda at Merz and Macron working dinner
French President Emmanuel Macron flew into Berlin on Wednesday for discussions over a working dinner with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz. Merz said the two leaders were set to discuss tariff negotiations between the EU and the US, as the deadline for 30% blanket tariffs on European goods rapidly approaches. A deal with the US is, however, thought to be imminent. Joint defence policy is also expected to be high on the agenda, especially amid rising tensions surrounding the Future Combat Air System (FCAS) fighter jet that is planned to be built in Europe in a partnership between France, Germany and Spain. The jets are expected to ready by the end of the decade and enter service in 2040. Defence dominates the agenda Conflict is at risk of boiling over regarding the fighter jets, as the three companies, France's Dassault, Airbus Germany and the Spanish company Indra Sistemas are technically competitors, with the Dassault reportedly looking to dominate the process. The German-French MGCS (Main Ground Combat System) tank project could also potentially run into problems. French-German relations expert at the DGAP (German Council of Foreign Relations) Jacob Ross told Euronews he believes that Macron wants to stick with FCAS, as it is an important flagship of his security and European policy since 2017. However, Macron is fast losing influence, given he is to step down after 2027. Next year, as the presidential pre-election campaign begins, he will be viewed as largely out of the picture. Ross says that this has factored into the demands for renegotiation on FCAS, which the German chancellor is unlikely to accept. "It would make him look weak and cause a lot of discontent in German politics and the administration, which in many places continues to think and decide in a very transatlantic manner and is rather suspicious of France," Ross explained. "If FCAS fails, it could trigger a domino effect. This is because the twin project, MGCS, which is closely linked to FCAS, would then certainly also be on the brink of collapse," he added. This is particularly critical, given that Germany and the EU are trying to replace the US' contributions to Ukraine after the re-election of US President Donald Trump, who has largely turned his attention away from Europe. The Franco-German 'power couple' relationship Ties between France and Germany were seen as frosty during Olaf Scholz's chancellorship. However, experts agree that the "power couple", as they are often referred to, have improved their relations. Defence, interior and foreign ministers from the two countries have met often following the new German government's election just two months ago. "However, the chancellor, the president, and all other responsible parties know that a good image and communication alone are worth nothing. This is a first step, very similar to German domestic policy - the mood must be turned around and optimism regained," Ross said. Alongside defence policy, energy, trade deals and other European policies are also likely to have been on the working dinner's agenda.
