logo
What a Thackeray reunion may mean for Maharashtra: Shinde braces for impact, BJP watchful, dilemma for Congress

What a Thackeray reunion may mean for Maharashtra: Shinde braces for impact, BJP watchful, dilemma for Congress

Indian Express5 hours ago
Though not formally united, the coming together of the Thackeray cousins — Shiv Sena (UBT) president Uddhav and Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) chief Raj — after two decades, has the potential to reshape the contours of Maharashtra's political landscape. The two, whose deteriorating relationship led to Raj Thackeray breaking away from the Sena in 2005, shared the stage at a 'victory rally' on Saturday to celebrate the BJP-led Mahayuti government's rollback on the 'Hindi imposition' issue.
If the Thackeray brothers forge an alliance, here is the impact it may have on the other major political players.
The most immediate and direct impact of the cousins coming together appears to be for the Eknath Shinde camp as it threatens to erode the Deputy CM's claim to the legacy of Shiv Sena founder Bal Thackeray and challenges his standing among core Marathi voters.
With Bal Thackeray's son and nephew putting up a united front, Shinde is likely to have a tough time shedding the tag of 'outsider' and 'gaddar (traitor)'. He is likely to face a major challenge on his turf — the urban pockets of Maharashtra, especially across the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) — as a united Marathi regionalist platform by the brothers will be something he will struggle to match.
That the buzz of the alliance has gained momentum just ahead of the civic body polls, including in the high-stakes Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), is also seemingly worrying Shinde, as a poor showing could severely dent his influence.
Known more for his behind-the-scenes political manoeuvring rather than his public appeal, Shinde may struggle to hold his ground as his cadre, lower-rung leaders, and grassroots workers may drift towards what is now shaping into a resurgent front led by the cousins.
Shinde's greatest concern will be the possible erosion of his clout within the ruling alliance. While Shinde has had a strategic relationship with the Maharashtra BJP, many of its leaders view him more as a temporary ally rather than a long-term partner.
Moreover, the Uddhav-Raj alliance also threatens to strain his already fragile relationship with the BJP. A day before the Thackerays' rally, the Deputy CM's 'Jai Gujarat' slogan in front of Union Home Minister Amit Shah in Pune was viewed as an expression of his anxiety about this possible new front.
Shinde has often found himself in the crosshairs of BJP leaders in his bid to expand his party, especially in urban municipalities, at the 'expense of the BJP'. Following the BJP's strong performance in last year's Assembly polls, the tensions have also increased. Many believe that the BJP may now tacitly encourage the Thackerays as a strategic ploy to undercut Shinde ahead of the Assembly elections in 2029.
However, Shinde is nothing if not a political survivor who became CM by the dint of his strategic moves, outplaying former mentor Uddhav. He will now place his bets on the internal contradictions between the Thackerays and differences between the BJP's state and central leadership to ensure he is not rendered politically dispensable.
Even in his response to the 'victory rally', Shinde targeted Uddhav but stopped shy of attacking Raj. 'One expressed desire for the good of Marathi while the other spewed bile for power … That's the difference,' he said.
Having won 132 of the state's 288 seats in the Assembly elections last year, the BJP continues to remain the most dominant political party in Maharashtra. It has a 26.77% vote share, more than double that of the second-placed Congress, which has a vote share of 12.42%.
The possible Thackeray alliance could pose a challenge to this dominance by consolidating the Marathi voter base. However, the most immediate challenge lies in the urban and semi-urban segments of the state, where a united Thackeray front could be a hurdle in the civic body polls. Even a slight shift of voters away from the BJP in cities such as Mumbai, Thane, Pune and Nashik could seriously affect the party, which has for long tried to wrest the BMC from the Shiv Sena.
A poor showing in the civic polls could create a slippery slope, weakening the BJP's momentum and offering the Thackeray alliance time to consolidate their gains, even though Assembly elections are far away.
The BJP also stands at the risk of being outflanked by the Thackerays on the Hindutva agenda as it may find it difficult to counter the combined appeal of Uddhav's 'soft Hindutva' and Raj's 'Marathi pride-laced with Hindutva', a blend that may resonate strongly with core Marathi voters.
The BJP has historically maintained a position of considerable political leverage over Raj, with its relationship with the MNS marked by fluctuating proximity. Both sides engaged in a series of informal meetings before the recent flare-up over the language row erupted.
Fadnavis, like Shinde, adopted a measured tone when responding to the Saturday rally. 'It was a victory rally for the Marathi language, but Uddhav chose to make it about politics and his removal from power. He's speaking out of frustration, as they have nothing to show despite ruling the BMC for over 25 years. In contrast, we've delivered development to the city and worked relentlessly for the Marathi manoos in Mumbai,' he said.
However, in what may be a silver lining, a Thackeray reunion may result in non-Marathi voters rallying behind the BJP, given the visible hostility of the Thackeray alliance towards non-Marathi speakers, especially North Indian migrants.
Moreover, if a Thackeray front outperforms Shinde in the civic polls, it could also give the BJP a chance to dominate the Mahayuti at the expense of a weakened Sena, a short-term benefit.
The Congress faces a fresh and far more complicated challenge if Raj joins the Opposition fold. So far, the party has maintained a studied silence despite little clarity on whether the MVA would continue in its current form if the Thackeray alliance is formalised.
At the heart of the Congress's hesitation lies Raj's anti-migrant and anti-Muslim rhetoric that may severely undermine the Congress's secular positioning, particularly outside Maharashtra, as it will struggle to justify sharing a platform with a party associated with violent street politics and divisive identity politics.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Pak 'spy' Jyoti Malhotra was invited by Kerala as state tourism influencer: RTI
Pak 'spy' Jyoti Malhotra was invited by Kerala as state tourism influencer: RTI

India Today

time29 minutes ago

  • India Today

Pak 'spy' Jyoti Malhotra was invited by Kerala as state tourism influencer: RTI

Jyoti Malhotra, a travel vlogger from Haryana's Sirsa now under arrest on espionage charges, was once hosted by the Kerala government as part of its influencer campaign to promote tourism in the to news agency ANI, a Right to Information (RTI) query revealed that Malhotra was among 41 social media influencers whose trips were fully funded by the state government under an initiative to market Kerala as a global tourist destination. The state bore the cost of their travel, accommodation and food, and even engaged a private agency to assist the influencers with video shoots during their Tourism Minister PA Mohammad Riyas defended the decision, saying the government had no knowledge of Malhotra's alleged espionage links at that time. "We had no clue about any such connections when she was invited. It has all come out only now," Riyas said, questioning whether anyone would believe that the government or the department would have knowingly facilitated her visit if they had known. "People know about it. Do you think the ministers or the government in Kerala would arrange everything for her to carry out espionage? This was a standard practice the tourism department has followed for years," he said. The minister also urged to verify how influencers are shortlisted, stressing that neither the ministers nor the government directly handle such invitations."It's a serious issue and everyone should exercise more caution. Please check the procedure," he the BJP has criticised the Pinarayi Vijayan-led Left government, questioning why the backgrounds of influencers invited for the campaign were not thoroughly vetted beforehand."RTI reveals Pakistani spy Jyoti Malhotra visited Kerala on Left government invite & was state guest in a sense courtesy Tourism Dept. So Bharat Mata is blocked and Pak Spies are given RED CARPET by Left? Tourism Minister Mohammad Riyas is son in law of Vijayan. He should be sacked.. and investigated," BJP spokesperson Shehzad Poonawalla said in a post on who was arrested on May 16, just days after Operation Sindoor, was among 41 social media influencers engaged by the Kerala Tourism Department between January 1, 2024, and May 21, 2025, official RTI documents have revealed. During the state-sponsored promotional campaign, she travelled to Kannur, Kozhikode, Kochi, Alappuzha, and Munnar, with the government covering her travel costs and providing her an honorarium for the assignment.- EndsMust Watch

Supreme Court agrees to hear pleas against voter roll revision in poll-bound Bihar
Supreme Court agrees to hear pleas against voter roll revision in poll-bound Bihar

India Today

time29 minutes ago

  • India Today

Supreme Court agrees to hear pleas against voter roll revision in poll-bound Bihar

The Supreme Court on Monday agreed to hear petitions challenging the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar. The matter will now be heard on Thursday (July 10).The pleas, filed by the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD), the Congress, Mahua Moitra of the Trinamool Congress, the Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) and the People's Union for Civil Liberties, sought a pause in the electoral roll revision June 24, the Election Commission issued instructions to carry out an SIR in Bihar, to weed out ineligible names and ensure only eligible citizens are included in the electoral rolls. In a statement, the Election Commission made it clear that while voters were required to "submit their documents anytime before July 25, 2025", those who failed to do so would get an opportunity "during the claims and objections period".Senior advocate and Congress leader Abhishek Manu Singhvi sought an urgent hearing into the matter. The Supreme Court then said it would hear the pleas on Thursday and gave time to the parties to file the lawyers for the respective parties said, with the July 25 deadline approaching, the names of lakhs of people "will be deleted from electoral rolls". They said the revision exercise will largely affect women and the this, Trinamool Congress MP Mahua Moitra, who filed the plea, called it Satyameva Jayate (truth alone triumphs). "Bihar SIR petition allowed in Supreme Court... Hearing on Thursday. Satyameva Jayate," she wrote on RJD MP Manoj Jha sought the top court's immediate intervention in the poll body's voter rolls' revision OPPOSITION IS PROTESTING AGAINST POLL BODY'S EXERCISE?The Opposition has vehemently criticised the poll panel's process, which seeks to cover nearly eight crore voters by July 25, questioning the timing of the exercise. They alleged that the move would lead to disenfranchisement of over two crore leader Tejashwi Yadav, Bihar's Leader of Opposition, has questioned why, unlike the previous revision, which took place in 2003 across the country, the current exercise was being carried out only in the of the INDIA bloc, of which the RJD is a part, have also held parleys with Election Commission officials in Delhi and Patna to share their the BJP-led NDA defended the exercise, accusing the Opposition of trying to come up with an "excuse ahead of a certain defeat in elections".According to the Election Commission, the exercise was necessitated by rapid urbanisation, frequent migration, young citizens becoming eligible to vote, non-reporting of deaths and inclusion of the names of foreign illegal poll panel said that with the exercise, it wanted to ensure the integrity and preparation of error-free electoral which has 243 Assembly seats, is likely to go to the polls in October-November this year.- EndsMust Watch IN THIS STORY#Supreme Court#Bihar

As language politics heats up, looking back at Nagari Pracharini Sabha, which fought for recognition to Hindi
As language politics heats up, looking back at Nagari Pracharini Sabha, which fought for recognition to Hindi

Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • Indian Express

As language politics heats up, looking back at Nagari Pracharini Sabha, which fought for recognition to Hindi

Politics over Hindi and its 'imposition' is heating up again in Maharashtra, with the Thackeray cousins Uddhav and Raj coming together on a pro-Marathi language platform, even as the state government has withdrawn its decision to make Hindi the default third language in primary schools. Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin has also commented on the row, saying the BJP 'has been forced to back down in Maharashtra, where they govern, due to fear of people's uprising.' More than a century ago, Hindi too had to fight for inclusion in official use, over then-dominant Persian. In this process, an organisation called Nagari Pracharini Sabha played a prominent role. After decades of dormancy, the Nagari Pracharini Sabha is active again, and has begun republishing books from March this year. Here's a brief history of the Sabha. During Mughal rule, Persian was used as the official language in India. With the arrival of the British, the language equation changed. In 1832, the Court of Directors of the East India Company declared that justice should be administered in a language that common people could understand. As a result, Indian languages began to replace Persian. By 1861, in regions such as the North-Western Provinces and Oudh, the languages used in courts and government offices had become English, Urdu, and Persian. In some areas, the official languages were English, Persian, and Urdu, along with local scripts. Hindi had not yet emerged clearly, as it lacked a comprehensive vocabulary accessible to all. In the 1890s, the Devanagari script began to replace the Persian script. This shift is credited to British civil servant Antony MacDonnell. Scholar Alok Rai writes in his well-known book Hindi Nationalism that Maharaja Lakshmeshwar Singh of Darbhanga, Bihar, introduced Hindi as an official language in his region on July 14, 1888. However, his love for Hindi was influenced by the slogan 'Hindi, Hindu, Hindustan.' The Nagri Pracharini Sabha was founded in this milieu, by three Hindi scholars —Shyam Sunder Das, Pandit Ramnarayan Mishra, and Thakur Shivkumar Singh— on January 16, 1893. The organisation decided to throw its weight behind the cause of making Hindi the language of courts and government offices. It was also decided that an authoritative dictionary for Hindi would be compiled. From 1908 onwards, the Nagari Pracharini Sabha began sending people to villages, towns, and cities at its own expense to collect words and their meanings. These collectors documented words, synonyms, and local versions in use on paper. The collected words were then organised systematically and written down. This intense work continued for 21 years. In 1929, the Sabha published a comprehensive Hindi dictionary in 11 volumes, titled Shabd Sagar. The forewords to this dictionary were written by Acharya Ramchandra Shukla and Shyam Sunder Das. Acharya Shukla's 'History of Hindi Literature', published by the Sabha, is regarded as essential reading for understanding Hindi literature. In 1896, the largest Hindi library in the country, the Arya Bhasha Pustakalaya, was founded. At a time when English, Urdu, and Persian dominated the linguistic landscape, the Nagari Pracharini Sabha launched a tireless movement to promote Hindi. Although the movement was apolitical, it gained such influence that prominent freedom fighter Bal Gangadhar Tilak also lent support to Hindi. After independence After independence, the Sabha's patron was India's first Prime Minister, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru. The oldest and most authoritative journal on Hindi research, Nagari Pracharini Patrika, has been published since 1896. Under the Sabha's patronage, the iconic Hindi magazine Saraswati, edited by Pandit Mahavir Prasad Dwivedi, began publication in 1900. Vyomesh Shukla, the current pradhan mantri (head) of the Sabha, said, 'Initially founded in Banaras, the Nagari Pracharini Sabha expanded to Haridwar and New Delhi. In Haridwar, Swami Satyadev Parivrajak donated land and oversaw the construction of its building. During this period, the Hindi movement spread to various towns, where local units were established and affiliated with the Banaras-based Sabha.' From the 1970s, the organisation's work began to flag as politics came to dominate language and literature. Issues over which management committee was actually in charge of the Sabha eventually reached the Allahabad High Court, which in February last year gave a verdict in favour of the Vyomesh Shukla-led group. Under the new leadership, the Sabha has published a complete reprint of Acharya Ramchandra Shukla's History of Hindi Literature in March this year. It has also published a collection of Hindi poems by Amir Khusrau.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store