HSBC executive's fraud conviction voided by US appeals court
NEW YORK (Reuters) -A U.S. appeals court on Thursday voided the 2017 fraud conviction of a former HSBC executive who spent two years in prison for "front-running" a British oil and gas exploration company's $3.5 billion currency trade.
In a 3-0 decision, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan said Mark Johnson's conviction was tainted because the Supreme Court in an unrelated case later repudiated a fraud theory that underlay it.
The appeals court also expressed "grave doubt" Johnson could have been convicted under an alternative theory that he defrauded HSBC client Cairn Energy, now known as Capricorn Energy.
A spokesman for the U.S. attorney's office in Brooklyn declined to comment.
"We are delighted that justice has finally been achieved for Mark Johnson," his lawyer Alexandra Shapiro said in a statement. "Mr. Johnson carried out the Cairn transaction consistent with industry practice and in violation of no law or rule."
Johnson, a British father of six in his late 50s, had been the head of HSBC's global foreign exchange cash trading desk.
He was the first banker tried in the United States on currency rigging charges, following global probes into the multitrillion-dollar per day currency market.
According to prosecutors, Cairn had retained Johnson and another former HSBC executive in 2011 to convert $3.5 billion into British pounds sterling as it prepared to sell an Indian subsidiary.
Prosecutors said the executives quietly bought pounds for HSBC's own accounts before completing Edinburgh-based Cairn's trade, reaping a profit of about $7 million, court papers show.
A jury convicted Johnson of wire fraud and conspiracy after a four-week trial. The appeals court upheld the conviction in 2019.
But on Thursday, the appeals court said a 2023 Supreme Court ruling, Ciminelli v U.S., meant Johnson could not be convicted of denying Cairn a right to control its assets by reneging on a promise not to ramp up the pound's price.
Circuit Judge Guido Calabresi also said evidence that Johnson breached duties to Cairn by misappropriating its confidential information for his own benefit was "weak," and it was unlikely a jury would convict Johnson on that basis alone.
"We find ourselves--at the very least--in 'virtual equipoise' as to whether any jury, presented only with the misappropriation theory, would convict Johnson," Calabresi wrote. "That is more than enough to leave us with grave doubt."
The appeals court returned the case to U.S. District Judge Nicholas Garaufis, who oversaw the trial.
The case is Johnson v. U.S., 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 24-1221.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New York Post
17 minutes ago
- New York Post
Border Patrol dog retires after stopping more than 400 pounds of illegal drugs from entering US
He gave drug dealers a ruff time. A Border Patrol dog named Milan is retiring after an impressive career where he stopped more than 400 pounds of illegal drugs from entering the US. The 8-year-old German Shepherd sniffed out more than 122 pounds of marijuana, 253 pounds of cocaine, 45 pounds of ecstasy and 5 pounds of meth at the ports of Miami during his six-year career. 5 Milan worked for six years with US Customs and Border Protection. 'He's a wild dog,' Michael Schwank, his handler with US Customs and Border Protection, told The Post. 'All he wanted to do was work.' Schwank, who called Milan his work partner, said the duo found contraband on a quasi-daily basis, from small amounts of coke and ecstasy to gallons of drugs filled with liquid coke and meth. 'He worked long days in the hot sun and he did his job very well,' Robert Misseri, co-founder of Paws of War, the Long Island-based organization helping to find Milan a new home, told The Post. 'He was a highly respected canine.' 5 Schwank and Milan were partners at USCBP. Milan had to retire from USCBP when he started showing signs of intervertebral disc disease, a common condition in dogs where one or more of the discs between vertebrae in the spine become damaged. Schwank couldn't adopt Milan, he said, because he's got his hands full with two young children at home. 'It was very difficult to say goodbye. if I was in under different circumstances, I would definitely keep him. It choked me up,' he said. 5 Milan routinely sniffed out packages being shipped out of the Miami airport for concealed drugs. Paws of War, who pairs animals with veterans and first responders, is paying for Milan's medical bills, now and in the future. It's trying to find him a home with a current or former canine handler. 'These dogs don't know anything other than work,' said Misseri. 'What he thinks his play is searching for drugs. The person that we want him to wind up with will role play with him. We have a whole kit of what they use when they train, so something will smell like a certain type of drug.' 5 Milan sniffed out more than 400 pounds of illegal drugs at the ports of Miami during his six-year career. Tam Nguyen / NYPost Design Milan's training alone, at the USCBP's Canine Center in El Paso, took two years. 'These dogs sacrifice their entire lives to doing good,' said Misseri. 'I don't think anyone will know the true scale of what he's done in terms of lives saved, by intercepting these dangerous drugs. These dogs can sniff things out that, to this day, we don't have the technology that surpasses their scent.' Customs and Border Protection Officer Program Manager Alexander Hernandez called Schwank and Milan 'an incredible team' and 'laser-focused' on protecting our nation's borders. 5 Milan's foster home recently threw him a birthday party. Border Patrol started using dogs in 1986, amid a surging number of illegal migrants and drugs at the border. Today, the agency has more than 530 enforcement canine teams deployed throughout the country.


New York Post
17 minutes ago
- New York Post
Child, 9, who died at Hersheypark was ‘beloved' member of Bhutan community
The 9-year-old girl who died in a wave pool at Hersheypark is a 'beloved' member of the Bhutanese community in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. The victim, who has not been publicly identified, was pulled 'limp' from the water on Thursday, and later died at a hospital despite lifeguards' attempts to save her, according to reports. 'It is with profound sorrow and heavy hearts that the Bhutanese Community in Harrisburg (BCH) shares the heartbreaking news of the untimely passing of a beloved 9-year-old girl, a resident of our Harrisburg-based Bhutanese community,' the organization said in a statement. Advertisement The girl was a 'beloved' member of the Bhutanese community in Harrisburg, according to a report. Tribune News Service via Getty Images 'The child tragically lost her life in a devastating incident that occurred at Hersheypark,' the group's chairman, Tilak Niroula, said in a statement. The fatality was the first at Hersheypark since 1977. Advertisement The death was the first at the theme park since the 1970s. Tribune News Service via Getty Images 'At just nine years old, she was full of promise, innocence, and joy — a light in the lives of all who knew her. Her sudden and tragic departure has left a deep void in our hearts and the community she was so warmly a part of,' Niroula said, according to WGAL. 'Our entire community is grieving alongside the family during this unimaginably difficult time. Words cannot fully capture the depth of our pain, but we are united in our mourning and committed to standing with the family in love, prayer, and support.' Hundreds of comments from grieving members of the Bhutanese community flooded the BCH Facebook page. 'Very, very shocking news to all of us. What a tragedy has befallen us,' one person wrote. Hersheypark officials insisted the facility and its water park area, known as the Boardwalk, is safe. 'There were over 100 E&A-trained lifeguards in the Boardwalk at the time of the incident. There were 10 lifeguards specifically dedicated to the wave pool at the time of the incident. The specific lifeguards stationed at the wave pool received the highest level of training and certification,' park officials said in a statement. Niroula, speaking in Bhutanese in a video posted to Facebook, urged parents to stay vigilant. 'Please make sure to stay close and attentive when your children are in or near swimming pools or any body of water,' a caption accompanying the video read. 'Even a moment of distraction can lead to heartbreaking consequences.' The wave pool remained closed Saturday, Hersheypark said.


UPI
an hour ago
- UPI
Trump delivers immigration message on Scotland visit
1 of 3 | President Donald Trump played golf in Scotland Saturday morning, teeing it up at his Trump Turnberry golf resort ahead of meetings with European lawmakers and delivering a message after leaving the White House on Friday (pictured). Photo by Will Oliver/UPI | License Photo July 26 (UPI) -- President Donald Trump played golf in Scotland Saturday morning, teeing it up at his Trump Turnberry golf resort ahead of meetings with European lawmakers and delivering a message. "I say two things to Europe: Stop the windmills. You're ruining your countries. I really mean it, it's so sad. You fly over and you see these windmills all over the place, ruining your beautiful fields and valleys and killing your birds," Trump told reporters after arriving on Friday. "On immigration, you better get your act together. You're not going to have Europe any more," he said. Trump is scheduled to discuss trade during a Monday meeting with British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Scottish First Minister John Swinney. He is also expected to meet with European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen during the four-day visit to Scotland. The delegation will start arriving Saturday and include European trade commissioner Maros Sefcovic, as well as von der Leyen, who Trump referred to as a "highly respected woman." U.S. officials and their EU counterparts are continuing attempts to reach a deal before an Aug. 1 deadline that will see 30% reciprocal tariffs take effect on all EU member states. The United States and Britain reached a deal in June on tariffs between the two countries, although Trump and Starmer were expected to iron out details during their meeting. Protestors demonstrated against Trump's visit in both Edinburgh and Aberdeen Saturday morning, including outside the Trump-owned golf course. He will also visit another of his privately-owned courses, Trump International Scotland in Aberdeenshire, during the trip. "We are really excited, across this whole weekend, there's so many campaign groups turning out in the streets, taking in action in their communities or at rallies like this. It's kind of like a carnival of resistance," demonstrator Anita Bhadani told the BBC outside of the U.S. Consulate General's office in Edinburgh Saturday, after helping to organize the Stop Trump Coalition. The coalition said its purpose is to "defeat the politics of Trumpism, and to promote an alternative, democratic vision of the world based on peace, social justice and international cooperation."