I tried the most popular peanut butter brands, and the best one is a classic
When I mentioned to friends that I would be testing this pantry staple, they were all quick to offer opinions. (It turns out everyone thinks they know the best store-bought peanut butter!) They also had lots of questions: Would I try creamy peanut butter? Crunchy? Organic? Salted? Because there are so many options, I stuck with creamy only (both conventional and organic) from peanut butter brands that are available in supermarkets across the country. I tasted them by the spoonful without jelly or bread to interfere with the flavor and mouthfeel.
As a culinary school grad who has worked in restaurants and written about food and cooking, I can appreciate the difference between old-school creamy peanut butter and the organic, all-natural version. I bought options across the spectrum from most processed to least, and the one that creamed the competition? Well, let's just say the brand is synonymous with peanut butter.
To narrow down the pool, I stuck with smooth peanut butter, ranging from processed to natural. When it came to tasting, I decided the best approach was to be a purist: Just open the jar, breathe in the aroma and dig in with a spoon. No bread, no jelly, no celery sticks.
Jif Creamy Peanut Butter: As close to Skippy as you can get, Jif is a strong runner-up. It's creamy and rich, but the flavor isn't quite as craveable. It contains the same hydrogenated vegetable oil as most other conventional/processed peanut butter and has the same thick and spreadable texture you expect. It was yummy!
Peter Pan Creamy Peanut Butter: This was my first encounter with Peter Pan, but I know the brand has a cult following. Peter Pan has been around since 1920, at first under a different name but then coined "Peter Pan" as a nod to the character and the play. Like the other processed peanut butter, it spreads beautifully and feels lighter, but the intense sweetness was off-puting to me.
Justin's Classic Creamy Peanut Butter: I was so disappointed in Justin's, having tried and enjoyed the brand's almond and cashew butters. This was the worst-tasting natural peanut butter with little flavor to speak of and a hint of bitterness, plus grit. This peanut butter contained peanuts and palm oil.
365 by Whole Foods Market Unsweetened Creamy Peanut Butter: Made from only peanuts and salt, this was the least thick and creamy of the all-natural bunch. It's almost drippy in texture. The flavor was nutty enough and had a good kick of salt, but it's not winning medals.
Good & Gather Organic Peanut Butter: Another organic and all-natural option, Target's house brand spread contains only dry roasted peanuts. When shopping, I didn't realize that this is unsalted, which gave it a real disadvantage. The texture was smoother than others, though.
Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter: This alternate version of the classic Skippy is okay. Like some "natural" peanut butter, it has added palm oil, which keeps the oil and solids from separating and needing to be stirred. For my money, and if I'm going to submit to the sheer heaven that is processed peanut butter, I prefer the original Skippy.
Teddie All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter: This natural option contains only peanuts and salt and is thicker than some of the others. It has an earthy, authentic peanut flavor that would likely make a good addition to dips or sauces.
Now that you know which spread to buy, here's how to take your PB (or PB&J) sandwiches to the next level.
Got some sticky questions? We've got answers!
As far as snacking goes, peanut butter pairs perfectly with crunchy raw veggie sticks (celery, carrots and jicama all work) and sliced apples or banana. It's also delightful on top of rice cakes or as a dip for pretzels.
We recently tested a variety of nut butter to come up with a list of the healthiest nut butter, which included two tasty peanut butter options — Big Spoon Roasters Peanut Crunchy Peanut Butter and One Trick Pony SIlky Smooth Peanut Butter.
Some dogs absolutely love peanut butter as a treat, but dogs don't benefit from the added salt and sugar that humans may enjoy, so choose a peanut butter that's all-natural and unsalted, like Teddie All-Natural Unsalted Smooth Peanut Butter.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
20-06-2025
- Chicago Tribune
Elgin News Digest: Hanover Township launches respite program for caregivers; Elgin police doing walk-and-talks on fireworks fines, safety
Hanover Township has launched a respite program for local caregivers through its Caregiver Resource Center. Using $20,724 in funding from the nonprofit AgeOptions, the township can connect caregivers with such services as in-home day relief, in-home overnight assistance and out-of-home care, according to a news release. 'Respite services provide assistance to caregivers to prevent burnout and offer an opportunity to recharge and rest,' township Supervisor Brian McGuire said in the release. Respite services are available for anyone caring for a township resident who is at least 60 years old or has Alzheimer's disease or dementia. Parents over 55, grandparents or a caregiver who is 60 or older caring for a township youth with severe disabilities can also apply as can caregivers who are 60 or older and providing care to someone with a severe disability between the ages of 19 and 59, the release said. To schedule an intake appointment, call 630-483-5660. Elgin police officers are conducting fireworks walk-and-talks in areas of the city with high numbers of fireworks-related complaints. The outreach efforts will continue over the next few weeks as a way to share safety information about the dangers and consequences of illegal fireworks, according to an Elgin Police Department social media post. Setting off fireworks in the city carries a minimum fine of $150 for a first offense and goes as high as $1,500 after a fourth offense in a 12-month period, according to city ordinances. To make a fireworks complaint, call 847-289-2700 or fill out the online fireworks complaint form at Greenheart Exchange, a 40-year-old nonprofit international student exchange program, is seeking families in and around East Dundee willing to house students from China July 27 through Aug. 10. Tammy Zilinski, area coordinator for Green Exchange, said 14 high school students with J-1 visas and a male adult chaperone will be coming to the area for a two-week immersive language and culture program at Fox Valley Baptist Church in East Dundee, where her husband, Phil, is pastor. Housing is still needed for more than half of the students and for the chaperone, Zilinski said. 'A host family will need to make sure that their student is at Fox Valley Baptist for language camp from about 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. each day,' she said. 'We are happy to help with carpooling if we find groups of families in one area.' Host families will provide three meals a day and a suitable place to sleep, which can be a room shared with another child of the same gender and close in age. A background check is required as part of the application, which can be found at For more information, call Zilinski at 847-489-8426. Symond-Madison Funeral Home in Elgin is raising money to cover the cost of installing a grave marker for Cpl. Eriverto Ortiz, a Korean War vet buried at Bluff City Cemetery. Ortiz was killed in combat in September 1950, but his remains could not be recovered at the time. They were positively identified in 2023 and returned to his family in October 2024 for burial in Elgin. The U.S. government is providing the grave marker free of charge but does not pay the $3,000 installation expense, which includes a permit fee and marker foundation, according to the post about the fundraising effort. To make a contribution, go to
Newsweek
12-06-2025
- Newsweek
Pictures Show Chinese Jet Buzzing US Ally From Aircraft Carrier
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A patrol aircraft dispatched by Japan—a treaty ally of the United States—was intercepted by fighter jets launched from a Chinese aircraft carrier operating in the wider western Pacific. Newsweek has contacted the Chinese Defense and Foreign Ministries via email for comment. Why It Matters China, which has the world's largest navy by hull count—deployed both of its two aircraft carriers in active service beyond the First Island Chain on Saturday. The island defense line, comprising Japan, Taiwan, and the Philippines, is in place to keep China's forces in check. In April, Beijing's state media released undated footage showing a Chinese J-15 flying close to a U.S. F/A-18 carrier-based fighter over an undisclosed maritime location. Aerial intercepts—if conducted in an unsafe or unprofessional manner—can lead to midair collisions, resulting in the loss of aircraft and aircrew. In 2001, a U.S. intelligence plane and a Chinese fighter jet collided near China, killing a Chinese pilot. What To Know On Wednesday, the Japanese Defense Ministry reported an "unusual approach" by Chinese military aircraft toward the Maritime Self-Defense Force, stating that a P-3C patrol aircraft had two encounters with J-15 fighter jets—launched from the aircraft carrier CNS Shandong—over the weekend while flying in international airspace over the Pacific Ocean. A Chinese J-15 fighter jet flies alongside a Japanese P-3C patrol aircraft over the Pacific Ocean on June 8, 2025. A Chinese J-15 fighter jet flies alongside a Japanese P-3C patrol aircraft over the Pacific Ocean on June 8, 2025. Japanese Defense Ministry In the first incident, which occurred between 10:30 a.m. and 11 a.m. local time on Saturday, Chinese fighter jets were spotted flying as close as 45 meters (147 feet) from the Japanese aircraft at the same altitude, which was conducting an unspecified surveillance mission. The following day, between 2 p.m. and 3 p.m. local time, Chinese fighter jets launched from the Shandong intercepted the Japanese aircraft for a second time, passing in front of it at a much greater distance—900 meters (2,952 feet)—while maintaining the same altitude. One of the photos taken from the Japanese aircraft shows a Chinese fighter jet flying with a missile visible beneath its wing. Another photo shows a jet flying alongside the Japanese plane. The horizontal distance between them in the photos remains unknown. A Chinese J-15 fighter jet flies near a Japanese P-3C patrol aircraft over the Pacific Ocean on June 8, 2025. A Chinese J-15 fighter jet flies near a Japanese P-3C patrol aircraft over the Pacific Ocean on June 8, 2025. Japanese Defense Ministry While there was no damage to the Japanese aircraft and no injuries were reported among its crew in either incident, Tokyo's Defense Ministry expressed serious concerns, stating that the Chinese fighter jets' "abnormal" aerial maneuvers could lead to an accidental collision. According to an earlier press release from the Japanese Defense Ministry, the Shandong was tracked operating with four Chinese naval vessels in the Philippine Sea on Saturday—341 miles southeast of Japan's southwestern island of Miyako—during an eastward voyage. The press release also revealed that the Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force had deployed a P-3C patrol aircraft to monitor and gather intelligence on the Chinese vessels. Two days later, the Shandong conducted flight operations involving its fighter jets and helicopters. What People Are Saying Senior Captain Wang Xuemeng, spokesperson for the Chinese People's Liberation Army (PLA) Navy, said in a statement on Tuesday: "This [dual aircraft carrier deployment] is a routine arrangement included in the annual training plan, aiming to improve the Chinese PLA Navy's ability to fulfill missions. The training complies with relevant international law and practice, and is not targeted at specific countries or entity." Lin Jian, spokesperson for the Chinese Foreign Ministry, said at a press conference on Tuesday: "Let me reiterate that Chinese naval vessels' activities in those waters are fully consistent with international law and international practices. Our national defense policy is defensive in nature. We hope Japan will view those activities objectively and rationally." What Happens Next Such close aerial encounters between Japanese and Chinese military aircraft are likely to continue as China's two aircraft carriers operate in waters near Japan's more remote islands.
Miami Herald
11-06-2025
- Miami Herald
China Releases Photos of Aircraft Carriers Beyond First Island Chain
China released photos showing its aircraft carriers conducting "training exercises" in the western Pacific beyond the first island chain, which is intended to keep its navy in check. "The training complies with relevant international law and practice, and is not targeted at specific countries or entity," a Chinese navy spokesperson said in a statement on Tuesday. The first island chain-comprising Japan, Taiwan and the Philippines-is one of three Pacific island defense lines established by the United States, utilizing its own territories as well as those of its allies and partners, with the goal of restricting China's naval activities. The Chinese navy, the largest in the world by hull count, deployed its aircraft carriers-CNS Liaoning and CNS Shandong-to the eastern side of the first island chain simultaneously for the first time over the weekend, challenging the U.S.'s naval dominance in the region. Meanwhile, the Liaoning became China's first aircraft carrier to be spotted operating in waters east of the second island chain, which stretches from Japan to New Guinea-north of Australia-via Guam, the westernmost U.S. territory that serves as a military hub. Senior Captain Wang Xuemeng, a spokesperson for the Chinese navy, confirmed in the statement that both the Liaoning and the Shandong had been deployed to the western Pacific Ocean in recent days to test their capabilities in "far-sea defense and joint operations." The spokesperson said the dual aircraft carrier deployment was a "routine arrangement included in the annual training plan," which sought to improve the ability of the Chinese navy-officially known as the People's Liberation Army Navy-to fulfill its missions. Official photos show both Chinese aircraft carriers launching J-15 fighter jets at an undisclosed location in the western Pacific Ocean during both day and night. A supply ship attached to one of the aircraft carriers was seen providing supplies to a destroyer. However, it remains unclear whether the Liaoning and the Shandong were operating in the same vicinity. They were last tracked underway on the eastern and western sides of the second island chain, respectively, according to a map published by Newsweek. Japan, a U.S. ally that tracks and monitors the Chinese navy, has made a "proper request" to China through diplomatic channels regarding the activities of the Chinese aircraft carriers, Japanese Defense Minister Gen Nakatani said at a news conference on Tuesday. "China intends to improve the operational capability of its two aircraft carriers and its ability to conduct operations in distant seas and airspace," the minister said, adding that Japan had both the will and the ability to deter unilateral attempts to change the status quo by force. Lin Jian, a spokesperson for the Chinese Foreign Ministry, said on Tuesday: "Let me reiterate that Chinese naval vessels' activities in those waters are fully consistent with international law and international practices. Our national defense policy is defensive in nature. We hope Japan will view those activities objectively and rationally." Japanese Defense Minister Gen Nakatani said on Tuesday: "In any case, the Ministry of Defense and the Self-Defense Forces will continue to closely monitor the movements of the Chinese Navy vessels, including these two aircraft carriers, and will take all possible measures to conduct surveillance activities." China's dual aircraft carrier deployment comes as two U.S. aircraft carriers-USS Nimitz and USS George Washington-are underway in separate areas of the western Pacific Ocean. Related Articles China Makes Childbirth Change Amid Falling Birth RateVideo Shows Chinese 'Militia' Ship Near US Ally's Disputed TerritoryMap Shows China's Visa-Free 'Circle of Friends'Satellite Photo Shows US Aircraft Carrier in Pacific Rivalry With China 2025 NEWSWEEK DIGITAL LLC.
