Karen explores AI's role in modern imperialism
Hao tells that this isn't a comparison she made lightly. Drawing on years of reporting in Silicon Valley and further afield to countries where generative AI's impact is perhaps most acutely felt, she makes the case that, like empires of old, AI firms are building their wealth off of resource extraction and labour exploitation.
This critique stands in stark contrast to the vision promoted by industry leaders like Altman, who portray AI as a tool for human advancement — from boosting productivity to improving healthcare. Empires, Hao contends, cloaked their conquests in the language of progress too.
A handout image of the book cover for 'Empire of AI' by Hong Kong-based American journalist and author Karen Hao
Your work has culminated in your new book 'Empire of AI'. What story were you hoping to tell?
Once I started covering AI, I realised that it was a microcosm of all of the things that I wanted to explore: how technology affects society, how people interface with it, the incentives (and) misaligned incentives within Silicon Valley. I was very lucky in getting to observe AI and also OpenAI before everyone had their ChatGPT moment; and I wanted to add more context to that moment that everyone experienced and show them this technology comes from a specific place. It comes from a specific group of people and to understand its trajectory and how it's going to impact us in the future.
How did Netflix drama 'The Crown' it influence your storytelling approach?
The title 'Empire of AI' refers to OpenAI and this argument that (AI represents) a new form of empire and the reason I make this argument is because there are many features of empires of old that empires of AI now check off. They lay claim to resources that are not their own, including the data of millions and billions of people who put their data online, without actually understanding that it could be taken to be trained for AI models. They exploit a lot of labour around the world — meaning they contract workers who they pay very little to do their data annotation and content moderation for these AI models. And they do it under the civilising mission, this idea that they're bringing benefit to all of humanity.
It took me a really long time to figure out how to structure a book that goes back and forth between all these different communities and characters and contexts. I ended up thinking a lot about 'The Crown' because every episode, no matter who it's about, is ultimately profiling this global system of power.
Karen Hao, the Hong Kong-based American journalist
Can you share an example that highlights the real-world consequences of its rise?
One of the things that people don't really realise is that AI is not magic and it actually requires an extremely large amount of human labour and human judgment to create these technologies. These AI companies will go to Global South countries to contract workers for very low wages where they will either annotate data that needs to go into training these training models or they will perform content moderation or they will converse with the models and then upvote and downvote their answers and slowly teach them into saying more helpful things.
How do you see the industry's growth balancing with sustainability efforts?
These data centres and supercomputers, the size that we're talking about is something that has become unfathomable to the average person. There are data centres that are being built that will be 1,000 to 2,000 megawatts, which is around one-and-a-half and two-and-a-half times the energy demand of San Francisco. OpenAI has even drafted plans where they were talking about building supercomputers that would be 5,000 megawatts, which would be the average demand of the entire city of New York City.
How has your perspective on AI changed, if at all?
Writing this book made me even more concerned because I realised the extent to which these companies have a controlling influence over everything now. Before I was worried about the labour exploitation, the environmental impacts, the impact on the job market. But through the reporting of the book, I realised the horizontal concern that cuts across all this is if we return to an age of empire, we no longer have democracy. Because in a world where people no longer have agency and ownership over their data, their land, their energy, their water, they no longer feel like they can self-determine their future. — Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Observer
17 hours ago
- Observer
Karen explores AI's role in modern imperialism
When journalist Karen Hao first profiled OpenAI in 2020, it was a little-known startup. Five years and one very popular chatbot later, the company has transformed into a dominant force in the fast-expanding AI sector — one Hao likens to a 'modern-day colonial world order' in her new book, 'Empire of AI: Dreams and Nightmares in Sam Altman's OpenAI'. Hao tells that this isn't a comparison she made lightly. Drawing on years of reporting in Silicon Valley and further afield to countries where generative AI's impact is perhaps most acutely felt, she makes the case that, like empires of old, AI firms are building their wealth off of resource extraction and labour exploitation. This critique stands in stark contrast to the vision promoted by industry leaders like Altman, who portray AI as a tool for human advancement — from boosting productivity to improving healthcare. Empires, Hao contends, cloaked their conquests in the language of progress too. A handout image of the book cover for 'Empire of AI' by Hong Kong-based American journalist and author Karen Hao Your work has culminated in your new book 'Empire of AI'. What story were you hoping to tell? Once I started covering AI, I realised that it was a microcosm of all of the things that I wanted to explore: how technology affects society, how people interface with it, the incentives (and) misaligned incentives within Silicon Valley. I was very lucky in getting to observe AI and also OpenAI before everyone had their ChatGPT moment; and I wanted to add more context to that moment that everyone experienced and show them this technology comes from a specific place. It comes from a specific group of people and to understand its trajectory and how it's going to impact us in the future. How did Netflix drama 'The Crown' it influence your storytelling approach? The title 'Empire of AI' refers to OpenAI and this argument that (AI represents) a new form of empire and the reason I make this argument is because there are many features of empires of old that empires of AI now check off. They lay claim to resources that are not their own, including the data of millions and billions of people who put their data online, without actually understanding that it could be taken to be trained for AI models. They exploit a lot of labour around the world — meaning they contract workers who they pay very little to do their data annotation and content moderation for these AI models. And they do it under the civilising mission, this idea that they're bringing benefit to all of humanity. It took me a really long time to figure out how to structure a book that goes back and forth between all these different communities and characters and contexts. I ended up thinking a lot about 'The Crown' because every episode, no matter who it's about, is ultimately profiling this global system of power. Karen Hao, the Hong Kong-based American journalist Can you share an example that highlights the real-world consequences of its rise? One of the things that people don't really realise is that AI is not magic and it actually requires an extremely large amount of human labour and human judgment to create these technologies. These AI companies will go to Global South countries to contract workers for very low wages where they will either annotate data that needs to go into training these training models or they will perform content moderation or they will converse with the models and then upvote and downvote their answers and slowly teach them into saying more helpful things. How do you see the industry's growth balancing with sustainability efforts? These data centres and supercomputers, the size that we're talking about is something that has become unfathomable to the average person. There are data centres that are being built that will be 1,000 to 2,000 megawatts, which is around one-and-a-half and two-and-a-half times the energy demand of San Francisco. OpenAI has even drafted plans where they were talking about building supercomputers that would be 5,000 megawatts, which would be the average demand of the entire city of New York City. How has your perspective on AI changed, if at all? Writing this book made me even more concerned because I realised the extent to which these companies have a controlling influence over everything now. Before I was worried about the labour exploitation, the environmental impacts, the impact on the job market. But through the reporting of the book, I realised the horizontal concern that cuts across all this is if we return to an age of empire, we no longer have democracy. Because in a world where people no longer have agency and ownership over their data, their land, their energy, their water, they no longer feel like they can self-determine their future. — Reuters
Observer
20 hours ago
- Observer
Mayer announces candidacy for FIA president
SILVERSTONE ENGLAND: American Tim Mayer announced on Friday that he would stand against incumbent Mohammed Ben Sulayem in a December vote for president of the FIA, motorsport's world governing body. The 59-year-old, a former Formula One steward and son of former McLaren principal Teddy Mayer, left the FIA last November. He said then that he had been fired via text message by an assistant to Ben Sulayem. The FIA dispute that he was sacked by text. "What I see is a failure in leadership right now," he told a press conference at a hotel near the British Grand Prix circuit Silverstone, adding that he had been working on his campaign for six months. He described his bid as a Herculean task with the deck stacked in Ben Sulayem's favour, given recent statute changes, and only five months to campaign and win votes from member federations. Mayer did not say who would be on his presidential list, a requirement for standing, which he admitted still had some open positions. He said he had good support from Motorsport UK and had informed Stefano Domenicali, chief executive of Liberty Media-owned Formula One, of his plans. "The job now is to go out and explain to lots of small clubs around the world ... why we can do a better job," said Mayer. "Explaining how we can bring value and restructure the FIA to do a better job. "I do feel restructuring needs to happen." Ben Sulayem, an Emirati, has already announced he is seeking a second term and until Friday had no declared opponent, with Spain's double world rally champion Carlos Sainz Sr. recently deciding not to stand. Mayer said he would have stood even if Sainz had decided to run. He also dismissed any suggestion of a conflict of interest regarding the historic family connection with McLaren. The FIA is the governing body for F1, the world rally championship and Formula E among other series. — Reuters
Observer
20 hours ago
- Observer
Reforms and Oman Vision 2040 drive recovery, confidence
MUSCAT: Just a few years ago, Oman faced one of the most challenging periods in its fiscal history, grappling with plunging oil prices, mounting public debt and global disruptions that pushed the nation into a deep deficit. Today, however, Oman is on a different path — one defined by recovery, economic reforms and renewed confidence in its future. A June 2025 report by Bahrain-based regional asset manager and investment bank SICO BSC, titled 'Rise of Oman: An Example of Fiscal Prudence,' confirms that Oman ended 2024 with a budget surplus of approximately RO 1 billion. At the same time, the country succeeded in reducing its public debt to RO 15.3 billion, equivalent to just 36.5 per cent of GDP, down from a high of 64 per cent in 2020. The seeds of recovery were planted in 2015 when Oman faced a record budget deficit of RO 4.6 billion. In response, the government implemented aggressive cost-cutting measures. Fuel subsidies were reduced, saving RO 479 million, while electricity subsidies were trimmed by RO 386 million. Defence spending was slashed by RO 350 million and civil ministry budgets were tightly managed. After His Majesty Sultan Haitham bin Tarik assumed leadership in 2020, Oman accelerated its fiscal reforms. The government focused on diversifying its revenue sources and enforcing strict control over expenditures, even during the Covid-19 pandemic. A major milestone was the introduction of VAT in April 2021, which raised RO 301 million in its first year. Between 2020 and 2023, tax and fee revenues increased by approximately 70 per cent, helping reduce dependence on oil revenues. The government's restraint in public sector hiring and wages also played a role. Over the past decade, public sector salaries and benefits have remained largely flat, allowing the state to avoid long-term financial burdens and maintain greater fiscal flexibility. Oman also benefitted from rising oil prices after 2021. While other Gulf states cut production under OPEC+ agreements, Oman maintained strong export volumes, allowing it to capitalise on market conditions. By 2024, Oman had reduced its budget breakeven oil price to $55 per barrel, down from $100 in 2014. This fiscal strength was recognised internationally when Oman's credit rating was upgraded to investment grade (BBB-) in September 2024, a move that is expected to reduce borrowing costs and improve investor confidence. Looking ahead, the 2025 budget projects a modest deficit of RO 620 million, largely due to cautious oil price assumptions. However, analysts — including those at SICO — believe Oman could record another surplus if oil prices remain favourable. To fund priority projects, the government plans to raise RO 750 million through new bonds and sukuk this year. With its finances stabilised, Oman is preparing for a new phase of strategic development aligned with Oman Vision 2040. Key projects include Sultan Haitham City ($2.6 billion), HyDuqm Green Hydrogen Hub ($7.5 billion) and later phases of green hydrogen expansion ($27 billion). Other major initiatives include the Duqm Green Steel Plant, the now-operational Duqm Refinery and revitalisation of Al Khuwair Downtown. Real estate and tourism projects in Yiti, a new UAE–Oman rail network and renewable energy projects such as the Ibri III Solar Plant and five wind power plants are also in the pipeline. 'These projects are not just about infrastructure,' the SICO report notes. 'They're a catalyst for national growth and investor confidence'. Oman is also planning for the long term by broadening its tax base. A domestic minimum top-up tax will be introduced in 2025, followed by the rollout of personal income tax in 2028, representing a major policy shift in the Gulf. At the same time, Oman's capital markets are positioned for growth. Despite returning just 15 per cent over the past decade, the market achieved 10 per cent annualised returns in the past five years. With stocks trading at a forward price-to-earnings ratio of 9.5x, there is potential for market re-rating. The launch of the Tanmia Liquidity Fund in May 2024 is expected to further deepen investor participation. Oman's transformation from fiscal fragility to financial resilience did not happen by chance. It required tough decisions, steady leadership and a focus on long-term stability. As SICO concludes, 'The fiscal consolidation achieved over the past five years provides a strong foundation for Oman to accelerate its ambitious development agenda'.
