"Bringing Shame To India": X User Takes Jab At Gujaratis In Canada, Sparks Debate
Mr Madras shared an experience where a Gujarati family in Canada allegedly caused chaos with a late-night wedding procession on the streets. He felt such behaviour was unacceptable and reflected poorly on India. He noted that while all cultures have good and bad people, he believed incidents involving South Indians were rare compared to those involving Gujaratis.
"In Canada, a Gujju family celebrated a noisy wedding on the streets late in the night, creating chaos and making headlines around the world. Such behaviour is unacceptable anywhere; it should not be tolerated even in India. Unfortunately, the actions of some groups reflect poorly on India. Of course, there are both good and bad people in all cultures, but I am referring to the vast majority of Gujjus here. WHY? The incidents involving South Indians are very, very rare," he wrote on X.
See the post here:
In the US and Canada, a vast majority of Gujjus are causing havoc and bringing shame to India. Many struggle with English, don't dress appropriately, speak too loudly, cut in lines, and litter everywhere. I've witnessed their outrageous and entitled behavior firsthand. In Canada,…
— Sriram (@SriramMadras) June 10, 2025
The post quickly went viral, garnering over two lakh views and sparking a debate over racism. Many users felt that linking specific behaviours to particular communities was unwarranted and unfair. They argued that individuals, not entire communities, should be held accountable for their actions. Several users agreed, stating that comments should be restricted to the specific behaviour rather than generalising an entire group.
One user wrote, "A very Racist comment. You can't generalise. There have been episodes of every caste/race in some form or fashion. It boils down to civic sense that Indians need to inculcate big time. I am hopeful the generation ahead is changing this. They are more civilized, aware and exposed."
Another commented, "I don't believe that's true Gujjus are generally humble, warm, and grounded people. They're progressive in their thinking, yet deeply connected to their culture and traditions. You'll rarely find a community that balances business acumen, family values, and cultural pride as effortlessly as they do."
A third said, "I think this whole discussion is highly unwarranted. To link anything to a particular community is not at all right. Some people may create nuisance but that does not mean we tag a community as such. Comments should be restrictive in nature."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Print
a day ago
- The Print
Why worry about water or jobs? In New Bharat, everybody wants to be an influencer
This is the new Bharat: addicted, online, and strangely calm to its quiet collapse. 'Paani nahin hai, naukri nahin hai… par phone hai. Aur us par timepass karne ke liye waqt hi waqt,' I muttered. No water, no job, but there's a phone and endless time to kill on it. It was a sight both unsettling and clarifying. On a blistering afternoon, heavy with humidity, a group of boys and mothers stood silently along a pavement—empty cans, dented buckets, plastic jugs at their feet—waiting for the water tanker. There was no commotion, no conversation, just a strange stillness that comes not from discipline, but from resignation. Just heads bowed to their phones scrolling, swiping, escaping into lives more curated and colourful than their own. Also Read: Indians biggest consumers of AI-generated news & most comfortable with it—Reuters Institute report Influence over income In New India, Indians are reportedly spending an average of five hours daily on their phones, primarily on social media, gaming, and video streaming. And it isn't leisure anymore. It's identity. It's economy. The ambition today, whether it's a toddler or young adult, isn't to become a civil servant, doctor, engineer, or teacher. It is to go viral. In a country where unemployment is at a historic high, the national anxiety isn't about jobs — it's about reach. Aspirations have shifted from employment to engagement, from careers to content. It's no longer about building a life, but building a following, to trend. As job creation stagnates, the generation has turned to visibility for validation. Today's youth wants views, likes, and subscribers. Not power, but popularity. Not contribution, but clout. Not nation-building, but narrative-building. Even UPSC aspirants, once held up as the embodiment of India's intellectual grit, are now daily vloggers. 'A day in my life as a UPSC student' videos include 5 am alarms, lemon water, reading The Hindu, and skincare routines. If the exam fails, the breakfast still gets monetised. Even ambition now comes with a referral code. This is not satire — it's economy. Dadis and Nanis have become wellness influencers with their nuskas, guided by tech-savvy grandchildren. Turmeric milk, cold-pressed oil, chanting for clear skin. They're charming, wholesome, algorithmically gold. Even the at-home mother is no longer invisible. She is now the home aesthetic queen. Her hair-wash day is edited like a film trailer. Her tadka is content. Her candle-lit dinner with her husband is a captioned moment of gratitude. She's a 'momfluencer'. Middle-aged men once chasing sarkari naukris now host podcasts. Even rickshaw pullers might run a YouTube channel. Because in today's India, if you can't be employed, you can still be seen. And crucially, these aren't just hobbyists or bored teens. They're professionals — doctors, consultants, coders, bankers, journalists. The digital hustle is mainstream. So mainstream, in fact, that influencers now have their own tax bracket. The government may not know how to generate jobs, but it knows how to tax performance. Today, everyone's online, everyone's performing. This is no longer just content. It's a belief system. One reel at a time. Also Read: Child influencers on Instagram aren't cute. The race for likes robs them of innocence A new culture of distraction Meanwhile, society frets about sanskars — values lost, respect eroded. But sanskars haven't disappeared; they have simply been outsourced to the algorithm. Today's unemployed are not idle. They're uploading. Hustling to go viral. Performing for an audience they can't see, but desperately want to impress. Eleven years on, the government that came riding on hope and the promise of 'newness' has certainly delivered something new — not progress, but a shift. A new mood. A new vocabulary. A culture where words like optics, reach, and influence matter more than truth, clarity, or consequence. Bharat today is not a nation of thinkers or builders. It is a stage where the applause is silent, the imagined audience endless. That moment on the pavement—young boys and mothers, parched, waiting for water that may never arrive, eyes locked on their phones—wasn't unusual. That's the unsettling part. There was no protest, no urgency. No jobs, no outrage. Just stillness. And brightly lit screens. The new Bharat is fully online, curated and restless to perform. In it, ambition doesn't rise. It refreshes. The quiet dignity of waiting for something better has been replaced by the anxious thrill of being seen. And yet, in this constant thrum of likes and loops, you can feel it — a subtle corrosion. Not of economy, but of imagination. Not of politics, but of purpose. So I leave you, too, in the end, to wonder — when the feed goes quiet, when the likes stop coming, when the flicker fades from the screen and the noise dissolves into silence, what will any of us do? When there is no scroll to chase, no audience to perform for, no curated life to escape into — what will remain of us? And more importantly, what will we return to? Shruti Vyas is a journalist based in New Delhi. She writes on politics, international relations and current affairs. Views are personal. (Edited by Asavari Singh)
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
2 days ago
- Business Standard
Dalit Kitchens of Marathwada: Shahu Patole's book on the taste of casteism
Food is a critical part of any culture. It locates you. It shapes how you're seen and how you see yourself. It carries histories, hierarchies, and inheritances premium Amritesh Mukherjee Listen to This Article Dalit Kitchens of Marathwada by Shahu Patole Published by HarperCollins India 386 pages ₹380 We Indians love our food. Every corner of the country has its own chorus of spices, snacks, and signatures, all competing for attention, all offered up with a certain swagger; our culinary culture is often described as a mosaic of traditions, a glorious testament to our eternal diversity. But what of the dishes you never see on Instagram and that no one frames as heritage? What of the food that's never found on tourist trails? Food is a critical part of any culture. It
Indian Express
2 days ago
- Indian Express
How buffalo is integral to India's cultural imagination
Buffaloes are found in ponds, rivers, marshes, and wetlands meant for rice cultivation. Cows, on the other hand, prefer drier jungle areas. India has both dry jungles and wet river basins. Dry areas are meant for wheat and millet cultivation, while wet areas are for rice cultivation. Cows and bulls thus represent two different ecosystems of India. Nomads move around with cows, while farmers are linked to buffaloes, who do not enjoy moving away from their watery habitat. Bulls are castrated and used as bullocks for pulling carts and for tilling hard soil. Male buffaloes do not need to be castrated. They can be controlled by nose rings. Some buffaloes can also be used as pack animals and used to till flooded rice fields. While most Indians focus on cows, we often overlook how important buffaloes are to India's economic ecosystem, and how they play a key role in rituals, art and culture. Buffaloes are depicted on Harappan seals, indicating they were domesticated and were part of the Harappan civilization over 4,500 years ago. This was the river buffalo, whose milk was curdled and churned into butter that was made into ghee. Buffaloes were also used for meat (even today India is a major exporter of buffalo meat), and their bones were used for making tools. The buffalo is found on the famous Pashupati seal facing the hermit who wears buffalo-horns on his head. Buffalo horns are also found on other seals, indicating power and virility. Around 3,500 years ago, in the Rig Veda (4.18.13), the mighty Indra, energised by the Soma drink, is equated with a wild buffalo. About 2,000 years ago, in Tamil Sangam poetry, Kuruntokai 65, the buffalo in a lotus pond is equated with an uncouth man who doesn't appreciate the refined girl he is about to marry. This indicates how integral the buffalo was to India's cultural imagination, from North to South India. The Mahisha Jataka, illustrated on the walls of Ajanta, speaks of a gentle buffalo who tolerates the mischief of a monkey. He refuses to punish the monkey for his irritating and incorrigible behaviour, even though he is advised to do so by the tree spirit or yaksha. One day, the gentle buffalo is away and his place is taken by another buffalo. The monkey, without realising it is another buffalo, plays the same tricks and is trampled to death. In Jain mythology, the buffalo is the emblem of the 12th Tirthankara Vasupujya. The Jain Yakshi Jwalamalini is shown riding a buffalo. As per one story, the Yakshi was a devout Jain in her previous life, who fed Jain monks, but her husband treated her badly. So she was reborn as a Yakshi and she rides a buffalo who was her husband reborn. The buffalo plays a very important role in Hindu mythology. It is the vahana (vehicle) of Yamraj, the god of death. The buffalo is also popular as the demon Mahisha who is slain by the many-armed goddess Durga. The oldest image of this goddess killing the demon was found in Rajasthan and dated to 100 BC. Many terracotta images from the Kushan age show the goddess killing the buffalo with her bare hands. Later, the image gets more elaborate. The goddess is shown riding her lion and killing the buffalo by pinning him down with her feet. Such images are found in the Gupta, Chalukya, and Pallava temples. Now they are part of the Navaratri celebrations held every autumn across India. In folk festivals across Deccan, a young male buffalo (reda) is offered to the goddess as a sacrifice. The offering of buffalo to the goddess is also meant to make her happy so that the children are safe from tiger attacks. When one buffalo is sacrificed, its leg is put in its mouth and presented to the goddess. This practice is found in Nepal, too. At the same time, a new male calf is chosen and fattened up the whole year to be offered to the goddess the following year. Such rituals ensure the fertility of the earth: with new life replacing old life. In Kerala, the local god Ayyappa, son of Hara (Shiva) and Hari (Vishnu), defeats Mahishi, the sister of Mahisa. In Maharashtra, there is worship of Mhaso-ba the buffalo-god, husband of the village goddess. It seems that while the buffalo suitor of the goddess is killed, she chooses the bull-riding Shiva as her husband. Many folk goddesses of the Deccan region have young male priests called Potraj or the buffalo king, who lead processions in honour of the goddess. The Potraj is dressed like a fierce man with whips, and found in processions such as Bonalu, celebrated in the Telangana region of Andhra Pradesh. This figure is sometimes identified as the son of Kali, and sometimes as her husband, while he calls himself her servant. What does the depiction of buffaloes on Harappan seals and on the famous Pashupati seal indicate? How does the buffalo feature in Jain and Hindu mythologies, and how does it indicate that buffaloes are integral to India's cultural imagination? What does the changing depiction of the buffalo in Hindu mythology – from a demon killed by the many-armed goddess Durga to being part of Navaratri celebrations – tell us? How does the ritual of buffalo sacrifice in folk festivals across Deccan reflect beliefs about fertility and protection? How do the stories of Mahishi in Kerala and Mhasoba in Maharashtra reflect regional variations in the portrayal of buffalo? (Devdutt Pattanaik is a renowned mythologist who writes on art, culture and heritage.) Share your thoughts and ideas on UPSC Special articles with Subscribe to our UPSC newsletter and stay updated with the news cues from the past week. Stay updated with the latest UPSC articles by joining our Telegram channel – IndianExpress UPSC Hub, and follow us on Instagram and X.
