SA losing nearly R30bn to illicit cigarettes as Sars tools face delays, says Godongwana
Efforts by the South African Revenue Service (Sars) to curb the illicit cigarette trade have been hampered by delays, with South Africa losing nearly R30 billion over the last five years.
This was revealed by Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana in a parliamentary reply.
EFF MP Thapelo Mogale asked the minister to disclose the total revenue lost as a result of cigarette smuggling and the illicit trade.
He also requested information on the measures introduced to tackle the issue and how effective these have been in recovering lost tax income and ensuring offenders are prosecuted.
Godongwana on illicit cigarette trade losses
In his written reply, Godongwana said illicit trade and smuggling are 'hard to reliably quantify' given their covert nature.
However, he pointed out that the illicit cigarette trade has become a major economic and enforcement issue, with estimates indicating that as much as 70% of cigarettes sold in the country are illegal.
This has resulted in annual tax revenue losses exceeding R27 billion.
ALSO READ: Illicit tobacco sales a drag on excise tax collections
The minister explained that according to Sars data, revenue from tobacco and cigarette products dropped from R13.4 billion in 2015-16 financial year to R9.4 billion in 2024-25, a 29.6% (R4 billion) decline over ten years.
The most notable drop, of 44.9%, occurred in 2020-21 due to the cigarette ban during the Covid-19 lockdown.
Sars measures against illicit cigarette trade
Sars, Godongwana highlighted, has implemented a multifaceted strategy to combat the scourge of illicit trade of tobacco and cigarettes.
He said the tax authority has adopted a long-term strategic approach that includes frontline interventions, targeted audits, and the use of advanced technology.
Regarding frontline operations, the minister explained that seizures of illicit cigarettes are being conducted at various ports of entry by customs border operations teams, in collaboration with other government agencies.
These efforts also extend to inland areas.
'This ensures that Sars does not only focus on revenue recoveries, but [also on] removing illicit goods from circulation.'
READ MORE: SA loses R30 billion in revenue due to illicit trade in cigarettes and liquor
He emphasised that compliance audits are prioritised, covering the entire value chain, to ensure adherence to relevant laws.
'This methodology enables an end-to-end audit of the entire value chain and ensures that a company is scrutinised from the point of raw material supply, its entry into the manufacturing warehouse, to calculating how many cigarettes could be produced at any given time, considering the appropriate yield and capacity analysis.'
Godongwana pointed out that Sars has integrated data and advanced technologies to monitor the tobacco supply chain and detect illicit activities.
This involves the use of CCTV surveillance at manufacturing facilities to monitor production and prevent tax evasion.
However, this initiative has faced delays due to legal challenges from certain industry stakeholders.
'As a stop-gap measure, Sars intends placing inspectors at these factories, on a full-time basis, depending on the availability of funding and budget.
'In addition, cigarette counters were made mandatory for all licensed manufacturers to assist Sars with production statistics.'
Investigations and arrests
Another tool in the fight against illicit trade is Sars' criminal investigation unit, which was established to probe complex tax evasion schemes.
Godongwana said the unit continues to investigate cases involving tax non-compliance, smuggling, diversion, ghost exports, and misdeclarations, especially in high-risk industries such as tobacco and cigarettes.
The minister revealed that international trade agreements and tools are being used to improve intelligence sharing and strengthen enforcement against illicit trade.
He highlighted specific enforcement successes, including arrests and prosecutions.
READ MORE: JMPD cracks down on illicit cigarette smuggling in Brixton
The Sars criminal investigation unit has handed 129 customs and excise-related cases to the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) over the past five years.
Currently, 105 of these are on the NPA roll, with 33 currently on trial and 72 awaiting trial dates.
Eight of these cases specifically involve illicit cigarettes and tobacco.
Four are currently on trial, while the remaining four are pending trial dates.
Godongwana added that 32 customs and excise cases have resulted in successful convictions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
11 hours ago
- The Citizen
‘Barrelling towards collapse': Concerns mount as Godongwana puts pressure on Morero to fix Joburg's finances
The finance minister's intervention should not be taken lightly, according to the DA. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has given Johannesburg Mayor Dada Morero a two-week deadline to address the city's escalating financial troubles. The City of Joburg continues to struggle financially, despite an increased budget of R89 billion for the 2025/2026 financial year. Adding to the crisis, the metropolitan municipality has been without a Finance MMC since African Independent Congress (AIC) councillor Margaret Arnolds vacated the position a month ago following her re-election as council speaker. Godongwana demands action from Morero over City of Joburg's finances The situation has become so dire that Godongwana sent a strongly worded letter to Morero on 30 July, reprimanding the mayor for failure to address unnecessary spending and repeated non-compliance with the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA). The municipality incurred R1.4 billion in unauthorised expenditure, R22 billion in irregular expenditure, and R705 million in fruitless and wasteful expenditure in the last fiscal year. ALSO READ: Joburg mayor Dada Morero survives motion of no confidence According to the Sunday Times, Godongwana has set a 14 day deadline for Morero to propose a plan addressing the financial issues and to hold accountable those responsible for the mismanagement. The letter warns that failure to act may lead to National Treasury invoking Section 216(2) of the Constitution, which would allow the department to withhold grant funding from the city. DA warns of collapse The Democratic Alliance (DA) has expressed concern over the developments, emphasising that the minister's warning was 'no empty threat' and should not be taken lightly. 'Johannesburg's R89 billion budget is funded through a mix of grants, loans, revenue collection and conditional grants. 'Conditional grants, which form a significant portion of the city's funding, can only be spent on what they are intended for. 'If Treasury pulls back or suspends these funds, as the minister warns in his letter, the city's ability to deliver the little basic services it is currently able to deliver, will collapse entirely,' DA Joburg caucus leader Belinda Kayser-Echeozonjoku said in a statement on Sunday. READ MORE: ActionSA-ANC slams Zille's plans for Joburg: 'They do not believe in black excellence' Kayser-Echeozonjoku claimed that the DA had consistently warned both Morero and the national about the 'financial rot' in Joburg. 'The DA has sent letters to the National Treasury, outlining that those heading up key departments were not doing their jobs, and warning of a total lack of consequence management in Joburg. 'Leaving the ANC in Joburg to do as they please will now come back to bite residents. We are pleased, however, to see that the minister of finance agreed with the DA's summation of what's been going on,' she said. She also warned that the city is 'barrelling towards collapse under the ANC, faster than ever before'. 'The ANC has proven, time and again, that it cannot govern Johannesburg responsibly. 'The city's finances are in freefall, service delivery is grinding to a halt, and now the very funding that keeps Johannesburg afloat is under threat.' Auditor-General flags long-standing issues Earlier this year, the Auditor-General raised red flags over Johannesburg's ongoing failure to improve its audit processes. The official from the Auditor-General's Gauteng office revealed in Parliament that the city has faced long-standing issues related to financial health, including poor debt collection, declining revenue, and recurring compliance problems. In addition, the Auditor-General expressed concern over inadequate investment in infrastructure, pointing out that the lack of funding for both maintenance and new projects has had a negative impact on service delivery. City of Joburg's 'bomb squad' Morero in June appointed a special 'bomb squad' team to address the city's ongoing service delivery issues. The 12-member team, led by ANC veteran Snuki Zikalala, will serve for the next two years. The unit's objectives include deployig rapid response teams to areas experiencing service delivery crises and provide oversight for the mayor. NOW READ: Morero's vision to make Johannesburg a world-class African city
Eyewitness News
12 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Treasury threatens to stop funding Joburg municipality if it doesn't get its finances in order
JOHANNESBURG - National Treasury has threatened to stop grant funding to the Johannesburg municipality if it doesn't get its finances in order. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has written to the Joburg Mayor Dada Morero, saying he needs to do more to curb the city's wasteful, irregular and unauthorised expenditure. The letter, dated the 30th of July, has sounded alarm bells among the opposition in the city. Like most municipalities, the City of Johannesburg receives grant funding from the National Treasury. This funding goes towards capital projects like roads, water and electricity infrastructure. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana said he's unhappy how some of these funds are being spent by the city. The Minister highlights the fact that in the 2023/24 financial year, the city racked up over 22 billion in unauthorised, irregular, fruitless and wasteful expenditure. Democratic Alliance (DA) Johannesburg caucus leader Belinda Kayser-Echeozonjoku said the city cannot afford to lose any funding. 'Funding that keeps our Johannesburg's finances and services running. Without it, our R89billion budget will collapse and residents will pay the ultimate price.' The DA said Mayor Dada Morero is not the right man to lead Johannesburg.
The South African
14 hours ago
- The South African
Malema: 'EFF has never been in the pockets of criminals'
EFF leader Julius Malema firmly denied that criminals have captured the Economic Freedom Fighters. Speaking on Saturday at the party's 3rd Central Command Team meeting of the 3rd National People's Assembly in Bela-Bela, Limpopo, Malema said the EFF has consistently been at the forefront of demanding accountability from the state. The Central Command Team is the EFF's highest decision-making body between the National People's Assemblies. According to IOL , Malema criticised President Cyril Ramaphosa for allegedly failing to act on warnings from the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA). He said the EFF called for an inquiry after NPA head Shamila Batohi claimed 'sinister forces' had captured the institution. 'It was the EFF that wrote to the president, demanding an inquiry into Batohi's claims. Instead of acting, he coerced her into withdrawing her remarks, calling it a misuse of language,' Malema said. Malema also pointed to the EFF's 2024 parliamentary motion to establish an ad hoc committee to investigate extortion rings targeting businesses and residents. He said the ANC, DA, and IFP, which govern the provinces worst hit by extortion, the Eastern Cape, Western Cape, and KwaZulu-Natal, rejected the proposal. 'Extortionists and criminal syndicates celebrated that day, as their political protection worked in their favour,' Malema said. Malema praised KwaZulu-Natal Police Commissioner Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi for exposing the links between criminal cartels and political figures. 'It took Mkhwanazi breaking ranks for the truth the EFF has always spoken to finally be taken seriously,' he said. Malema reiterated that the EFF remains independent. 'We have never been and will never be in the pockets of criminals. When we gave other parties the chance to stand against crime, they refused,' he said. Malema reaffirmed his support for Mkhwanazi and said the EFF would welcome him to join the party if he loses his position in the SAPS. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
