Rezoning row raises questions on stewardship
Its key application in governance is that stewards are entrusted to discharge responsibilities in an accountable and transparent manner.
Officials exercise power on behalf of an entity; they are custodians of its resources and not owners.
This trust must extend to all stakeholders – not just shareholders or members – but also to the broader community with a legitimate interest.
According to a report in StarMetro on May 26, 2025, Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL) said the landowners of the 120-year-old Vivekananda Ashram had requested its site be zoned as 'main commercial'.
With the Kuala Lumpur Local Plan 2040 (KLLP 2040) now gazetted and due to come into force on June 11, the key players involved in the ashram's rezoning must reflect on the cardinal principle of stewardship.
The Vivekananda Ashrama Kuala Lumpur was incorporated as a Company Limited by Guarantee in 1934.
Its core mission is described as 'involved in educational, spiritual, cultural and welfare activities'.
There had been public appeals to rezone the site for educational and welfare use – appeals entirely in line with the organisation's stated purpose.
The board of trustees' 2014 plan to build a 23-storey tower over the heritage site triggered public backlash and led to the building's heritage gazettement in 2016.
The fact that this gazettement was challenged by the trustees and that they have now accepted 'main commercial' zoning speaks volumes.
Even so, the ashram remains a cherished institution with deep intergenerational significance to the wider community.
The 876 objections submitted from across the country and abroad, as well as the high participation in the public hearing, reflect this.
DBKL's decision to rezone the 0.4ha heritage site is surprising.
The agency had access to detailed presentations during the public hearing and subsequent submissions from the Save Vivekananda Ashram Brickfields community.
Yet, it appears to have treated the board as just another landowner, without weighing the broader implications of its stewardship responsibilities.
Was the entire community engagement process merely a performative exercise?
It would be a welcome surprise if DBKL reconsidered its decision and rezoned the site as 'public facilities' before June 11.
Is that too much to ask of those who govern a 'City for All'?
The community must continue playing its stewardship role. Section 17 of the Federal Territory (Planning) Act 1982 [Act 267] provides a mechanism to alter the gazetted KLLP 2040.
This avenue remains open for the board to submit an application to rezone the site as 'Public Facilities'.
Meanwhile, the community must remain vigilant.
Any proposed commercial development should be monitored to ensure full compliance with National Heritage Department guidelines and that all necessary approvals are obtained.
At a minimum, the trustees should share their plans and adopt a more inclusive stewardship model.
No matter how dwarfed the ashram may become by future soulless structures, its legacy as a monument to the contributions of Malaysia's pioneer generation will endure.
Jayanath Appudurai
Kuala Lumpur
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
14 hours ago
- The Star
DBKL launches endowment fund
Dr Zaliha (second from left) and Maimunah (third from left) launching the endowment fund together with Ismadi and Nor Azlina at Insitut Latihan DBKL in Cheras. — LOW BOON TAT/The Star To strengthen fiscal security and ensure sustainable development, Kuala Lumpur City Hall's (DBKL) has launched an endowment fund. It operates on a 'plural funding' model, combining resources from the government and external parties. Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Federal Territories) Datuk Seri Dr Zaliha Mustafa said over the past three years, DBKL's budget had risen by nearly 9%, from RM2.604bil in 2023 to RM2.835bil in 2025. 'The fiscal deficit has widened from RM275.9mil in 2024 to RM325.9mil in 2025. 'More than 62% of DBKL's revenue relies on assessment tax, creating a high dependency on a single source,' she said during the launch of the endowment fund at Institut Latihan DBKL, Cheras. The fund was developed based on the results of a joint study with Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM) from last year to early this year. It was established as an alternative financial source to support community development, education, social welfare and environmental conservation in Kuala Lumpur. Dr Zaliha said, 'Besides carrying out functions like urban development and maintenance, DBKL also assists the Federal Territories Department in handling state-like functions such as social welfare, transportation and local community services. 'The burden of these support functions is amounting to over RM140mil annually and increasing each year.' Kuala Lumpur mayor Datuk Seri Maimunah Mohd Sharif, who was at the launch, said the fund was established as a long-term instrument to support various initiatives in the city in accordance with Section 39(d) of the Local Government Act 1976 (Act 171). 'As of July 2025, we have received RM115,000 from six contributors namely Bank Simpanan Nasional, Mah Sing Group Bhd, TSLaw Land, KLCC Property Holding, Bank Muamalat and Koperasi CoopBank Pertama. 'I hope that more companies, organisations and individuals will contribute towards the DBKL Endowment Fund for the mutual benefit and well-being of the city's residents,' she said. Also present were DBKL executive director (socioeconomic development) Ismadi Sakirin and executive director (management) Nor Azlina Mohd Saad.
The Sun
2 days ago
- The Sun
DBKL launches endowment fund for Kuala Lumpur's fiscal sustainability
KUALA LUMPUR: The Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL) has launched an endowment fund aimed at securing long-term financial sustainability for the city. The initiative marks a shift from traditional fiscal models, positioning DBKL as a pioneer among local authorities in Malaysia. Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Federal Territories) Datuk Seri Dr Zaliha Mustafa commended the move, highlighting the growing financial challenges faced by DBKL. 'In managing a complex city like Kuala Lumpur, relying solely on the annual budget is no longer sufficient,' she said in a Facebook post. The fund addresses a projected deficit of RM325.9 million in 2025, driven by increasing public needs and rising operational costs. Beyond infrastructure and maintenance, which cost nearly RM1 billion annually, DBKL also funds social programmes, including welfare assistance, amounting to over RM140 million per year. Zaliha emphasised the fund's innovative approach, describing it as a model of 'shared stewardship' where government, residents, and private entities collaborate for urban development. The initiative also makes DBKL the first local authority in Malaysia to receive tax relief approval from the Inland Revenue Board (IRB). She urged corporations, individuals, and communities to contribute, framing donations as investments in Kuala Lumpur's future. 'Every contribution not only helps support the people's needs but also plants the seeds for a more sustainable and just future,' she added. – Bernama
The Star
3 days ago
- The Star
Commuters hope new rail service enhances transborder mobility
Just arrived: The new RTS Link train has a white livery with red and blue accents, inspired by the harmonious colour palettes of Malaysia, Johor and Singapore's flags. — THOMAS YONG/The Star THE unveiling of the new Rapid Transit System Link (RTS Link) train has commuters eagerly looking forward to the start of the cross-border rail service between Johor Baru and Singapore. Among them is 23-year-old Khairul Anuar, who travels about two hours to his work place in Singapore daily. 'After looking at photos of the RTS Link train, I am looking forward to riding it once it is operational. ALSO READ: Cross-border RTS Link train rolls in for testing 'Having the rail system will definitely make my daily commute to work faster and more efficient compared to my current mode of travel by bus,' he told StarMetro. He added that the biggest benefit would be more rest as he would not need to leave his home so early to beat the traffic congestion on the Causeway. Khairul expects to spend less time commuting to work. 'Right now, I have to leave my house at 8am if my work shift starts at 11am. 'With the RTS Link, I hope to enjoy at least an extra hour of sleep in the morning.' Operations and retail executive Ngoi Chee Kein, 26, said affordability would be a key factor in encouraging usage. 'While I welcome the development as it is a much-needed boost to travel, I hope the ticket price will be affordable, especially since many Malaysians commute daily. 'It should be set between S$2 (RM6.60) and S$4 (RM13.20), which is roughly the current bus fare,' he said. Ngoi expressed hope that the rail system would be reliable. Ngoi hopes the RTS Link ticket will be affordable. 'My main concern is whether RTS Link will have technical issues in the future, because people will be relying on it as their main daily mode of transport,' he said, adding that alternative transport such as shuttle buses should be made available in case of emergencies. For Lis Raman, 49, the RTS Link will offer a long-awaited alternative to traditional cross-border travel options. 'I am looking forward to using the service, which is long overdue. 'It can reduce travel hassle and improve quality of life,' said the Singapore-based training, research and development director, who travels to Johor Baru weekly via private hire car. She currently spends RM50 to RM70 a week for her trips and said she would be willing to pay slightly more for added convenience. 'I do not mind a 10% to 15% increase, as it is an excellent trade-off for mental and physical health gain,' she said. Lis does not mind paying 10% more for added convenience. Lis said she would prefer the RTS Link to operate round-the-clock to accommodate late-night travellers. 'This level of flexibility is no longer alien in some well-developed countries. 'I would use the RTS Link for all my ad-hoc journeys,' she said. Her concerns, however, lie in possible disruptions and maintenance issues. 'I hope there will be adequate parking for people who choose to park and ride and efforts made to prevent vandalism. 'I also want to know if there is any enforceable contingency plan in place from the management should the RTS Link service be disrupted,' she said. Despite their concerns, all three agree that the RTS Link promises to reshape the daily commute and offer a more comfortable and efficient travel option across the Causeway, one of the busiest border crossings in the world. – By YEE XIANG YUN
