Coles, Woolies debate number of fake discount products
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) has launched court actions against Coles and Woolworths, alleging they broke consumer law by bumping up prices on certain products for brief periods before lowering them again as part of Woolworths' "Prices Dropped" and Coles' "Down Down" promotions.
Those promotional prices - including dairy, pet food, personal care, coffee, medicine, lollies, cereal and household cleaning products - were lower than during the price bump, but higher than or the same as the regular price, it alleges.
A Federal Court hearing in Melbourne on Friday heard disagreements over the number of sample products from both supermarkets that would be included as evidence in the trial.
Coles had agreed with 12 products - six chosen by the ACCC, three class products and three of their choosing, barrister Nicholas De Young told the court.
"We submitted and believe that was a reasonable proposal, but a minute before court, we heard they want to add an additional four," he said.
Mr De Young said the additional products could mean three or four more witnesses who will need to talk in detail about the price increase and promotional discussion journeys those items had.
He questioned what attributes the four items have that the existing 12 don't.
Woolworths had proposed six products, but barrister Ruth Higgins told the court the ACCC had submitted 20 on Thursday morning before reducing the number to 12 by that night.
"What we've been doing this morning is trying to work out why those additional products are proposed and what difference those products make," Dr Higgins said.
Barrister Michael Hodge said the ACCC had proposed a compromised position of 12 products for both companies, which would ensure everything could be captured.
Justice Michael O'Bryan urged the parties to compromise, giving them until June 13 to finalise a list of agreed items.
"If we're south of 20, or even better, south of 15, then we're in what I regard as sensible territory for conducting an efficient trial," he said.
The consumer watchdog is seeking a significant penalty for the alleged breaches, which they say took place over 15 months.
Coles and Woolworths, which control a combined two-thirds market share, deny the allegations and say the legal cases are misconceived.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Herald Sun
8 hours ago
- Herald Sun
Woolworths, Coles, Aldi and McDonald's reject US beef
Don't miss out on the headlines from Companies. Followed categories will be added to My News. Woolworths, Coles and McDonald's say they will not import US beef following Australia's loosening of biosecurity restrictions. In a contentious move, the federal government has allowed Canadian and Mexican cattle killed in the US to be imported into Australia. Following the change to this 20-year policy, the Trump administration slapped Australia with the lowest of its universal tariff rates, applying a 10 per cent levy on Australian exports. Despite the North American beef now allowed to land in Australia, consumers are unlikely to see much US beef on supermarket shelves or in fast-food restaurants. Aldi, Coles, McDonald's and Woolworths all say Australian customers will be eating homegrown beef. 'We apply an Australia-first approach, and 100 per cent of our fresh red meat is sourced directly from Australian farmers, with whom we have longstanding relationships,' a Woolworths spokesperson told NewsWire. 'We have no plans to change that approach.' Spokespeople for Aldi and Coles say there are no plans to change from 100 per cent Australian beef. Some 80 million kilos of beef are dished out by the Golden Arches each year, and McDonald's too says it will not be buying from North America. 'We'll continue to source 100 per cent Aussie beef for our menu and provide our customers with the great taste, quality, and value they know and love.' Last month, Agriculture Minister Julie Collins confirmed Australia would remove the ban on American beef from cattle originating in Canada and Mexico after a decade-long review. The US has similar, granular farm animal tracing as in Australia that largely stamps out diseases spreading from beast to beast. Regulations are more lax in Canada and Mexico. The federal opposition criticised the move, suggesting Australia had bargained away its biosecurity to get a better negotiating position with the Trump administration over the President's sweeping global tariffs. The government rejected this claim. The Nationals also called for an independent review of the US beef import rules. US Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins said Australia changing its rules was a nod to President Trump's acumen. 'This is yet another example of the kind of market access the President negotiates to bring America into a new golden age of prosperity, with American agriculture leading the way,' Ms Rollins said last month. 'It's absurd that non-scientific trade barriers prevented our beef from being sold to consumers in Australia for the last 20 years.' In the wake of President Trump's economy-rattling 'Liberation Day' tariff announcements earlier this year, countries have been scrambling to carve out exemptions or deals with the US. Australia and the US have a free trade agreement, and in 2024, the US exported twice as much to Australia as it imported from Down Under – $50.6bn versus $23.8bn. Despite the trade agreement and Australia being in a trade deficit, the US administration put its global baseline 10 per cent excise on Australian products. Australia was one of the few countries to escape with just a 10 per cent levy when the extended negotiation deadline came and went on Friday, August 1. Originally published as 'No plans': Aussie supermarkets, fast-food giants reject US beef
Perth Now
10 hours ago
- Perth Now
‘No plans': Aussie giants reject US beef
Woolworths, Coles and McDonald's say they will not import US beef following Australia's loosening of biosecurity restrictions. In a contentious move, the federal government has allowed Canadian and Mexican cattle killed in the US to be imported into Australia. Following the change to this 20-year policy, the Trump administration slapped Australia with the lowest of its universal tariff rates, applying a 10 per cent levy on Australian exports. Despite the North American beef now allowed to land in Australia, consumers are unlikely to see much US beef on supermarket shelves or in fast-food restaurants. Aldi, Coles, McDonald's and Woolworths all say Australian customers will be eating homegrown beef. 'We apply an Australia-first approach, and 100 per cent of our fresh red meat is sourced directly from Australian farmers, with whom we have longstanding relationships,' a Woolworths spokesperson told NewsWire. 'We have no plans to change that approach.' Spokespeople for Aldi and Coles say there are no plans to change from 100 per cent Australian beef. Some 80 million kilos of beef are dished out by the Golden Arches each year, and McDonald's too says it will not be buying from North America. A government decision has ended an effective 20-year ban on US beef coming into Australia. NewsWire / Nikki Short Credit: News Corp Australia 'We'll continue to source 100 per cent Aussie beef for our menu and provide our customers with the great taste, quality, and value they know and love.' Last month, Agriculture Minister Julie Collins confirmed Australia would remove the ban on American beef from cattle originating in Canada and Mexico after a decade-long review. The US has similar, granular farm animal tracing as in Australia that largely stamps out diseases spreading from beast to beast. Regulations are more lax in Canada and Mexico. The federal opposition criticised the move, suggesting Australia had bargained away its biosecurity to get a better negotiating position with the Trump administration over the President's sweeping global tariffs. The government rejected this claim. Agriculture Minister Julie Collins has spent the first few weeks of the new parliament defending the department staff and biosecurity experts who have signed off on the new import regimen. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia The Nationals also called for an independent review of the US beef import rules. US Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins said Australia changing its rules was a nod to President Trump's acumen. 'This is yet another example of the kind of market access the President negotiates to bring America into a new golden age of prosperity, with American agriculture leading the way,' Ms Rollins said last month. 'It's absurd that non-scientific trade barriers prevented our beef from being sold to consumers in Australia for the last 20 years.' In the wake of President Trump's economy-rattling 'Liberation Day' tariff announcements earlier this year, countries have been scrambling to carve out exemptions or deals with the US. Australia and the US have a free trade agreement, and in 2024, the US exported twice as much to Australia as it imported from Down Under – $50.6bn versus $23.8bn. Despite the trade agreement and Australia being in a trade deficit, the US administration put its global baseline 10 per cent excise on Australian products. Australia was one of the few countries to escape with just a 10 per cent levy when the extended negotiation deadline came and went on Friday, August 1.
News.com.au
10 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘No plans': Aussie supermarkets, fast-food giants reject US beef
Woolworths, Coles and McDonald's say they will not import US beef following Australia's loosening of biosecurity restrictions. In a contentious move, the federal government has allowed Canadian and Mexican cattle killed in the US to be imported into Australia. Following the change to this 20-year policy, the Trump administration slapped Australia with the lowest of its universal tariff rates, applying a 10 per cent levy on Australian exports. Despite the North American beef now allowed to land in Australia, consumers are unlikely to see much US beef on supermarket shelves or in fast-food restaurants. Aldi, Coles, McDonald's and Woolworths all say Australian customers will be eating homegrown beef. 'We apply an Australia-first approach, and 100 per cent of our fresh red meat is sourced directly from Australian farmers, with whom we have longstanding relationships,' a Woolworths spokesperson told NewsWire. 'We have no plans to change that approach.' Spokespeople for Aldi and Coles say there are no plans to change from 100 per cent Australian beef. Some 80 million kilos of beef are dished out by the Golden Arches each year, and McDonald's too says it will not be buying from North America. 'We'll continue to source 100 per cent Aussie beef for our menu and provide our customers with the great taste, quality, and value they know and love.' Last month, Agriculture Minister Julie Collins confirmed Australia would remove the ban on American beef from cattle originating in Canada and Mexico after a decade-long review. The US has similar, granular farm animal tracing as in Australia that largely stamps out diseases spreading from beast to beast. Regulations are more lax in Canada and Mexico. The federal opposition criticised the move, suggesting Australia had bargained away its biosecurity to get a better negotiating position with the Trump administration over the President's sweeping global tariffs. The government rejected this claim. The Nationals also called for an independent review of the US beef import rules. US Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins said Australia changing its rules was a nod to President Trump's acumen. 'This is yet another example of the kind of market access the President negotiates to bring America into a new golden age of prosperity, with American agriculture leading the way,' Ms Rollins said last month. 'It's absurd that non-scientific trade barriers prevented our beef from being sold to consumers in Australia for the last 20 years.' In the wake of President Trump's economy-rattling 'Liberation Day' tariff announcements earlier this year, countries have been scrambling to carve out exemptions or deals with the US. Australia and the US have a free trade agreement, and in 2024, the US exported twice as much to Australia as it imported from Down Under – $50.6bn versus $23.8bn. Despite the trade agreement and Australia being in a trade deficit, the US administration put its global baseline 10 per cent excise on Australian products.
