Why MAGA's ideologues can't always get what they want
I should offer a little definitional clarity and political nuance. Make America Great Again means different things to different people. The Trump coalition is not monolithic, it contains factions that do not necessarily consider themselves to be MAGA. But as shorthand, MAGA is an identifiably distinct bloc on the right, and it's the dominant faction in the broader GOP coalition. Its internal diversity notwithstanding, it still has a worldview or ideology. And the MAGA faithful are increasingly frustrated by the fact that Trump doesn't always share, or prioritize, that ideology.
They believed that if you could just 'let Trump be Trump' he would follow their conception of MAGA. In Ronald Reagan's first term, many movement conservatives were frustrated by what they perceived as the Gipper's drift toward centrism. They blamed moderates in the administration. 'Let Reagan be Reagan' became a rallying cry on the right.
'It's a piece of conventional wisdom on the new American right that Donald Trump struggled in his first term because he hired the wrong people — old-think Bush Republicans, figures like Rex Tillerson and Steven Mnuchin, who didn't have a populist bone in their bodies,' the news website Semafor's Ben Smith offers in an astute analysis.
As a result, Smith continues, 'Trump's most passionate supporters weren't going to make that mistake again. They created initiatives like American Moment, Project 2025, and others aimed at grooming and credentialing a cadre of MAGA appointees. When Trump took office, the America Firsters moved en masse into the Department of Defense. Big Tech avengers seized the antitrust apparatus. Conspiracy-minded podcasters took over the FBI.
'And yet — just as Trump often ignored his conventional advisers in the first term, he's stunned loyalists by sweeping aside this carefully assembled apparat in 2025.'
Trump said as much to the Atlantic magazine last month: 'I think I'm the one that decides' what 'America first' means.
'It turns out that personnel isn't policy,' the executive director of the American Conservative, Curt Mills, 'glumly' told Smith. The idea that 'personnel is policy' is another Reagan-era mantra; put Reaganites in important positions and you'll get Reaganite policies. Putting Trumpists in powerful positions doesn't yield the same results.
Immigration hawks have been panicking over the president's suggestion that farm and hotel workers should be excluded from his deportation schemes. As Trump told Fox News, 'I'm on both sides of the thing.' Foreign policy 'restrainers' were beclowned by his support of Israel's strikes on Iran and his apparent about-face on helping Ukraine.
On China, Trump's been a hawk as promised, except when he hasn't, allowing NVIDIA to sell chips to China, and ignoring the law by refusing to sell or shutter TikTok.
Then there's the Jeffrey Epstein fiasco, which has bedeviled Trump for weeks. It's intensity and durability can best be explained by the fact that it divides those who define Trumpism as loyalty to Trump and those who believe that loyalty would be, must be rewarded by a cleansing of corrupt globalist elite — or something.
In short, there is no 'Trumpism' that is an analogue to Reaganism. Reaganism is a philosophical approach. What defines Trump's reign is better understood as a psychological phenomenon both as an explanation of his behavior and of his fans' cultish and performative loyalty. To the extent Trump has a philosophy it is to follow his instincts, which are most powerfully informed first by his own ego but also the dramaturgy of professional wrestling, reality TV and Norman Vincent Peale's prosperity gospel.
He's said many times that he considers unpredictability a virtue in itself, which by definition means he is going to disappoint anyone who expects philosophical coherence. When Trump was a bull in a China shop, the people most excited by the sound of breaking vases and dishware assumed there was a broader method to the madness. But now the same people are learning that Trump won't be saddled by his fans any more than he is by norms.
This was always going to be the case (as I noted in 2017), but what adds to MAGA's frustration is that anyone can see and copy the bull-handling techniques that are most likely to work. Compliment him, call him 'daddy,' celebrate his genius and expertise, and you too can manipulate him with at least moderate success.
Perhaps most significant, it's becoming clear that a movement defined by loyalty to a mercurial personality is bound to split apart once that personality leaves the stage — if not sooner.
X: @JonahDispatch
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The president repositioned two nuclear submarines in response to a remark from a Russian official.
President Donald Trump's former national security adviser has bashed the president for getting drawn into nuclear brinkmanship with Russia. Trump announced Friday that he had repositioned two nuclear submarines in the region after an incendiary remark from a Kremlin official. 'I think it's a very risky business for a lot of reasons,' John Bolton told CNN. 'It's really just very ill-advised to have the president responding to somebody like that.'
Yahoo
4 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump Was Asked About His Press Secretary's Performance. His Answer Took A Weird Turn.
President Donald Trump gave his press secretary, Karoline Leavitt, some rather specific compliments during a Friday interview with NewsMax's Rob Finnerty. When asked his opinion on her performance in his administration during the exchange, Trump commented on Leavitt's face and lips. 'She's become a star,' he said. 'It's that face. It's that brain. It's those lips, the way they move. They move like she's a machine gun.' After realizing Leavitt was in the room, Trump doubled down, 'She's a star.' He continued to say Leavitt is a 'great person,' and added, 'I don't think anybody has ever had a better press secretary than Karoline. She's been amazing.' Leavitt, who started working for the Trump administration in 2019 as a White House intern and correspondence office staffer, made history in January 2025 when she became the youngest press secretary ever at just 27 years old. That same day, during a White House press conference on peace treaties, Leavitt also gushed over her boss, stating, 'It's well past time that President Trump was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize.' 'President Trump has brokered on average about one peace deal or ceasefire per month during his six months in office,' she said. She pointed to Trump's involvement in defusing diplomatic standoffs across several global hotspots, including efforts between Thailand and Cambodia, Israel and Iran, Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, India and Pakistan, Serbia and Kosovo, and Egypt and Ethiopia. Related... 'Depths Of Cringe': Critics Slam Karoline Leavitt Over 'Disgraceful' Trump Demand 'Oh, My God! Why Are You Like This?!?': Karoline Leavitt Blows Meyers' Mind In Spoof Presser Yikes: Karoline Leavitt Is Asked If Trump Is Serious About Blocking Commanders Stadium Deal
Chicago Tribune
5 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
It's Trump's economy now. The latest financial numbers offer some warning signs.
WASHINGTON — For all of President Donald Trump's promises of an economic 'golden age,' a spate of weak indicators this week told a potentially worrisome story as the impacts of his policies are coming into focus. Job gains are dwindling. Inflation is ticking upward. Growth has slowed compared with last year. More than six months into his term, Trump's blitz of tariff hikes and his new tax and spending bill have remodeled America's trading, manufacturing, energy and tax systems to his own liking. He's eager to take credit for any wins that might occur and is hunting for someone else to blame if the financial situation starts to totter. But as of now, this is not the boom the Republican president promised, and his ability to blame his Democratic predecessor, Joe Biden, for any economic challenges has faded as the world economy hangs on his every word and social media post. When Friday's jobs report turned out to be decidedly bleak, Trump ignored the warnings in the data and fired the head of the agency that produces the monthly jobs figures. 'Important numbers like this must be fair and accurate, they can't be manipulated for political purposes,' Trump said on Truth Social, without offering evidence for his claim. 'The Economy is BOOMING.' It's possible that the disappointing numbers are growing pains from the rapid transformation caused by Trump and that stronger growth will return — or they may be a preview of even more disruption to come. Trump's aggressive use of tariffs, executive actions, spending cuts and tax code changes carries significant political risk if he is unable to deliver middle-class prosperity. The effects of his new tariffs are still several months away from rippling through the economy, right as many Trump allies in Congress will be campaigning in the midterm elections. 'Considering how early we are in his term, Trump's had an unusually big impact on the economy already,' said Alex Conant, a Republican strategist at Firehouse Strategies. 'The full inflationary impact of the tariffs won't be felt until 2026. Unfortunately for Republicans, that's also an election year.' The White House portrayed the blitz of trade frameworks leading up to Thursday's tariff announcement as proof of his negotiating prowess. The European Union, Japan, South Korea, the Philippines, Indonesia and other nations that the White House declined to name agreed that the U.S. could increase its tariffs on their goods without doing the same to American products. Trump simply set rates on other countries that lacked settlements. The costs of those tariffs — taxes paid on imports to the U.S. — will be most felt by many Americans in the form of higher prices, but to what extent remains uncertain. 'For the White House and their allies, a key part of managing the expectations and politics of the Trump economy is maintaining vigilance when it comes to public perceptions,' said Kevin Madden, a Republican strategist. Just 38% of adults approve of Trump's handling of the economy, according to a July poll by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs. That's down from the end of Trump's first term when half of adults approved of his economic leadership. The White House paints a rosier image, seeing the economy emerging from a period of uncertainty after Trump's restructuring and repeating the economic gains seen in his first term before the pandemic struck. 'President Trump is implementing the very same policy mix of deregulation, fairer trade, and pro-growth tax cuts at an even bigger scale – as these policies take effect, the best is yet to come,' White House spokesman Kush Desai said. The economic numbers over the past week show the difficulties that Trump might face if the numbers continue on their current path: 'The economy's just kind of slogging forward,' said Guy Berger, senior fellow at the Burning Glass Institute, which studies employment trends. 'Yes, the unemployment rate's not going up, but we're adding very few jobs. The economy's been growing very slowly. It just looks like a 'meh' economy is continuing.' Trump has sought to pin the blame for any economic troubles on Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell, saying the Fed should cut its benchmark interest rates even though doing so could generate more inflation. Trump has publicly backed two Fed governors, Christoper Waller and Michelle Bowman, for voting for rate cuts at Wednesday's meeting. But their logic is not what the president wants to hear: They were worried, in part, about a slowing job market. But this is a major economic gamble being undertaken by Trump and those pushing for lower rates under the belief that mortgages will also become more affordable as a result and boost homebuying activity. His tariff policy has changed repeatedly over the last six months, with the latest import tax numbers serving as a substitute for what the president announced in April, which provoked a stock market sell-off. It might not be a simple one-time adjustment as some Fed board members and Trump administration officials argue. Of course, Trump can't say no one warned him about the possible consequences of his economic policies. Biden, then the outgoing president, did just that in a speech last December at the Brookings Institution, saying the cost of the tariffs would eventually hit American workers and businesses. 'He seems determined to impose steep, universal tariffs on all imported goods brought into this country on the mistaken belief that foreign countries will bear the cost of those tariffs rather than the American consumer,' Biden said. 'I believe this approach is a major mistake.'
