Latest news with #MarcelDionne

Time of India

Reddit debates the best NHL players who never tasted Stanley Cup glory

NHL (via Getty Images) For each Stanley Cup champion, there's a generational star that, despite brilliance, never got to hoist Lord Stanley's chalice. A new Reddit thread posed the agonizing but intriguing question: Who are the greatest NHL players ever not to have won a Cup? What ensued was an impassioned snowslide of hockey fandom, heartache, and some legendary monikers. Here are the greatest and most argued names of that thread — players whose excellence never received the ring it was due. Pavel Bure: The Russian rocket Reddit made one thing clear: Pavel Bure was a force. Nicknamed The Russian Rocket, Bure amazed with speed, flash, and scoring ability that dropped jaws. 'Bure was the most exciting player in the nhl between gretzky and mcdavid,' a user shared. 'All time favorite player. Bure was electric,' another said to which a user replied, 'My all-time favourite player too (I'm from Vancouver lol).' 'When I think of players that stood out from the pack, Bure always comes to mind,' a user said. Most signed off that Bure was a man before his time. His speed was supernatural, and supporters compared him to skating like McDavid — very high praise in any generation. Injuries unfortunately abbreviated his tenure, but his reputation as one of the most dynamic players of all time remains unassailable. The NHL's Top 10 CUPLESS Players EVER 🏆 Marcel Dionne: The overlooked great If there's one player whose name jumped out with the sheer dominance and heartbreaking absence of playoff success, it's Marcel Dionne. 'This is the answer. A not well enough known generational talent,' one user wrote. 'Marcel Dionne played 1,348 regular season games and 49 playoff games,' another fan said, 'He ranks 6th in all time goals and points.' Even though one of the greatest scorers in NHL history, Dionne never reached the second round. Fans dubbed him the most underrated superstar ever — and on Reddit, that injustice apparently still hurts. Paul Kariya: The artist The love for Paul Kariya runs deep. An icon of skill and sportsmanship, he was a foundational piece of the '90s and early 2000s NHL identity. 'Favorite player as a kid. Sent a letter and got an autographed pic back. Mailman folded in the mailbox,' a Reddit user shared. His comeback from a crushing blow to score during the 2003 Finals is one of the greatest and saddest moments in hockey history. No Stanley Cup, but forever respected. Jarome Iginla & Joe Thornton: The 'what if' era kings Several users cited Jarome Iginla and Joe Thornton as the greatest players of their generation who did not have a championship. 'J. Iginla & J. Thornton are probably the biggest two from the last "era" or so. Both had their chances,' a Reddit user commented. 'And Iginla kept going to the wrong teams which was the frustrating part,' Both came agonizingly close. Iginla's 2004 Calgary near-miss, Thornton's 2016 San Jose Finals loss. Dominant leaders, face of franchises, and alas, Cup-less legends. Henrik Lundqvist: King without a crown Though he didn't win the thread, Henrik Lundqvist had a consistent stream of good wishes. 'Marcel Dionne, Jerome Iginla, Joe Thornton, Dale Hawerchuk, Pavel Bure, Alexander Mogilny, Sedin twins, Roberto Luongo, Henrik Lundqvist… have all been mentioned,' a user shared. Lundqvist was a wall for more than a decade. His Vezina-winning performance in goal made him an equal of any other in the league, and fans think his legacy richly deserved a Cup. Honorable mentions From Reddit Mats Sundin Dale Hawerchuk Alexander Mogilny Pat LaFontaine Roberto Luongo The Sedin Twins Also read: NHL Awards to spotlight season's top performers during Game 4 broadcast of Stanley Cup Final If only hockey were fair, each name on this list would've had at least one parade. But greatness isn't always in Cups. The players Reddit cheered for weren't simply gifted — they were icons, game-changers, and adored. That's what makes this list stand out — not merely ability, but unforgettable magic on the ice.