Reddit debates the best NHL players who never tasted Stanley Cup glory
For each Stanley Cup champion, there's a generational star that, despite brilliance, never got to hoist Lord Stanley's chalice. A new Reddit thread posed the agonizing but intriguing question: Who are the greatest NHL players ever not to have won a Cup? What ensued was an impassioned snowslide of hockey fandom, heartache, and some legendary monikers.
Here are the greatest and most argued names of that thread — players whose excellence never received the ring it was due.
Pavel Bure: The Russian rocket
Reddit made one thing clear: Pavel Bure was a force. Nicknamed The Russian Rocket, Bure amazed with speed, flash, and scoring ability that dropped jaws.
'Bure was the most exciting player in the nhl between gretzky and mcdavid,' a user shared.
'All time favorite player. Bure was electric,' another said to which a user replied, 'My all-time favourite player too (I'm from Vancouver lol).'
'When I think of players that stood out from the pack, Bure always comes to mind,' a user said.
Most signed off that Bure was a man before his time. His speed was supernatural, and supporters compared him to skating like McDavid — very high praise in any generation. Injuries unfortunately abbreviated his tenure, but his reputation as one of the most dynamic players of all time remains unassailable.
The NHL's Top 10 CUPLESS Players EVER 🏆
Marcel Dionne: The overlooked great
If there's one player whose name jumped out with the sheer dominance and heartbreaking absence of playoff success, it's Marcel Dionne.
'This is the answer. A not well enough known generational talent,' one user wrote.
'Marcel Dionne played 1,348 regular season games and 49 playoff games,' another fan said, 'He ranks 6th in all time goals and points.'
Even though one of the greatest scorers in NHL history, Dionne never reached the second round. Fans dubbed him the most underrated superstar ever — and on Reddit, that injustice apparently still hurts.
Paul Kariya: The artist
The love for Paul Kariya runs deep. An icon of skill and sportsmanship, he was a foundational piece of the '90s and early 2000s NHL identity.
'Favorite player as a kid. Sent a letter and got an autographed pic back. Mailman folded in the mailbox,' a Reddit user shared.
His comeback from a crushing blow to score during the 2003 Finals is one of the greatest and saddest moments in hockey history. No Stanley Cup, but forever respected.
Jarome Iginla & Joe Thornton: The 'what if' era kings
Several users cited Jarome Iginla and Joe Thornton as the greatest players of their generation who did not have a championship.
'J. Iginla & J. Thornton are probably the biggest two from the last "era" or so. Both had their chances,' a Reddit user commented.
'And Iginla kept going to the wrong teams which was the frustrating part,'
Both came agonizingly close. Iginla's 2004 Calgary near-miss, Thornton's 2016 San Jose Finals loss.
Dominant leaders, face of franchises, and alas, Cup-less legends.
Henrik Lundqvist: King without a crown
Though he didn't win the thread, Henrik Lundqvist had a consistent stream of good wishes.
'Marcel Dionne, Jerome Iginla, Joe Thornton, Dale Hawerchuk, Pavel Bure, Alexander Mogilny, Sedin twins, Roberto Luongo, Henrik Lundqvist… have all been mentioned,' a user shared.
Lundqvist was a wall for more than a decade. His Vezina-winning performance in goal made him an equal of any other in the league, and fans think his legacy richly deserved a Cup.
Honorable mentions From Reddit
Mats Sundin
Dale Hawerchuk
Alexander Mogilny
Pat LaFontaine
Roberto Luongo
The Sedin Twins
Also read:
NHL Awards to spotlight season's top performers during Game 4 broadcast of Stanley Cup Final
If only hockey were fair, each name on this list would've had at least one parade. But greatness isn't always in Cups. The players Reddit cheered for weren't simply gifted — they were icons, game-changers, and adored.
That's what makes this list stand out — not merely ability, but unforgettable magic on the ice.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Ozzy Osbourne dead at 76: Rock legend's long health battle with Parkinson's, spinal injuries
Image credits: Getty Images John Michael Osbourne, popularly known as "Ozzy" Osbourne, was a legendary English singer who was the lead vocalist of the heavy metal band Black Sabbath. Also known as the Prince of Darkness, the 76-year-old had just recently reunited with his bandmates to perform a huge farewell for the fans. Now, in a statement, his family announced his death, saying, "It is with more sadness than mere words can convey that we have to report that our beloved Ozzy Osbourne has passed away this morning. He was with his family and surrounded by love." Throughout his life, Osbourne had dealt with a variety of health concerns. From breaking his neck to dealing with Parkinson's and depression, the singer had braved a lot. Here's a look at his medical history. Quad bike crash Image credits: X In 2003, the rockstar was seriously injured in a quad bike accident at his Buckinghamshire estate, when he broke his collarbone and six ribs. Then, a fall from a toilet in 2019 dislodged the metal rods in his back from the quad bike crash. 'I fell over and I landed wrong,' he later said. "I went to the doctor's, and you assume everybody knows what they're doing. I haven't walked properly since.' In 2023, he revealed that a fourth operation was the last one his body could handle. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years IC Markets Learn More Undo 'It's going to be the final surgery, because I can't do it any more. Regardless of the way it ends up, I can't.' 'I walked upstairs today for the first time in a while, and my feet feel like I've got diving boots on,' he added. ADHD and dyslexia The star also faced troubles with dyslexia and ADHD. In a 2019 interview with GQ magazine, he shared how, along with his recovery, he also had to do a daily inventory of how his day went. And since he is dyslexic and has ADHD, he used to carry a tape recorder with him to record a melody straight away. Parkinson's disease Image credits: X Osbourne was diagnosed with Parkin 2, a mild form of Parkinson's disease in 2019, which he publicly revealed in 2020. Along with mobility issues, the condition led him to suffer from pain, depression and blood clots. Pneumonia In 2019, he also came down with pneumonia and had to axe his tour dates to recuperate for six weeks on doctors' advice. "Ozzy recently developed pneumonia & has spent some time in hospital. He is through the worst part. His doctors have advised that he stay at home to recuperate for a full six weeks," his wife Sharon wrote on social media. In an interview, he had also shared that the blood clots in his legs caused him blood pressure issues and had to be treated with blood thinners. Emphysema and spinal tumour Image credits: X Additionally, in 2019, the star also suffered from a severe upper-respiratory infection that led to emphysema (COPD). In November 2023, Osbourne revealed that he had been diagnosed with a spinal tumour but remained hopeful that he would be able to perform again to say goodbye to his fans. Recently, in July 2025, with his other bandmates, he gave a final concert to some 40,000 fans at Villa Park soccer stadium in Birmingham, England. Needless to say, the godfather of heavy metal will be remembered forever.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
La La Anthony celebrates niece's birthday as Carmelo Anthony reflects on loyalty and brotherhood in NBA
Carmelo Anthony's ex-wife recently made the news (Image via Getty Images) La La Anthony , the ex-wife of NBA legend Carmelo Anthony, recently shared warm birthday wishes for her niece on social media, demonstrating the strong family ties. On July 22, she wrote a birthday post dedicating her on Instagram. A number of the birthday girl's beach photos were also included in the post. Meanwhile, La La Anthony herself attracted attention two days ago with her gorgeous swimwear photos which she also uploaded on Instagram. Carmelo Anthony speaks on loyalty while La La Anthony shares heartfelt birthday tribute to her niece Celebrating this significant day, the actress and TV personality sent a message and old pictures, showing her admiration and pride in each text. She took to her Instagram Story and wrote: 'My niece. My cancer twin. Happy Birthday @saditysanea. Beautiful from the inside out!!! Love you!!!' This action demonstrates La La Anthony 's dual roles as a loyal family member and a loving aunt. Her off-screen persona as a devoted mother who cherishes her loved ones is revealed through these intimate moments. La La Anthony is actually NBA icon Carmelo Anthony's ex-wife. They got divorced in 2021 after being married since 2010. They also had a son, Kiyan. The socialite has highlighted on many occasions that they are still close friends and co-parents despite everything. Meanwhile, Carmelo Anthony was in the news recently after he complained about the Milwaukee Bucks waiving their leading star, Damian Lillard. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Affordable Mobile Plan for Switzerland Lebara Learn More Undo In a post that was shared on Instagram announcing the news, the NBA icon left a series of comments denouncing the move. He wrote: 'SMH… 'BUSINESS PER USUAL!!! NO LOYALTY IN SPORTS!!!' Carmelo Anthony recently supported Damian Lillard (Image via Getty Images) Damian Lillard will be sidelined for a long period while he heals after tearing his Achilles during the playoffs' opening round. Carmelo Anthony and Damian Lillard shared the court during their two seasons with the Portland Trailblazers, which ran from 2019 to 2021. As two NBA legends from different periods brought together by a love of the game and a dedication to supporting one another, their relationship now serves as a monument to brotherhood in the league. Also read: Milwaukee Bucks risk losing Damian Lillard as the star now open to joining Boston Celtics after past rejection Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Was Wayne Gretzky's daughter Paulina Gretzky cheated on by Dustin Johnson? What really happened in 2018 that sparked panic among fans
Paulina Gretzky has been with Dustin Johnson since 2013.(Image via Marco Garcia/Associated Press) Wayne Gretzky, the NHL legend, has mostly maintained a low profile in the last couple of years but his eldest child, Paulina Gretzky , has been turning heads with her marriage to pro golfer Dustin Johnson. The couple have been together for more than a decade and tied the knot in 2022 and are already parents to two little boys. While their love story is nothing short of a fairytale, at one point, there were speculations of Dustin Johnson cheating on Paulina Gretzky. Did Dustin Johnson cheat on Paulina Gretzky in 2018 with another woman? Back in September 2018, Wayne Gretzky's daughter, Paulina Gretzky sparked panic among fans as she deleted all her pictures with Dustin Johnson on her social media. At that point, Paulina Gretzky and Dustin Johnson had been dating for five years and were already parents to a boy. But then there were speculations of Dustin Johnson being unfaithful to Paulina Gretzky. As per reports, in 2018, Dustin Johnson was speculated to have cheated on Wayne Gretzky's daughter with a woman named Yassie Safai. While not a lot is publicly known about Yassie Safai, she slammed such speculations and denied ever having an affair with Dustin Johnson. At that point, Yassie Safai took to her social media to deny any rumours of Dustin Johnson cheating on Paulina Gretzky with her. Yassie Safai's statement on social media read as, 'My world has been turned upside down. … I am not in a relationship with Dustin Johnson. Nor have we had any prior relationship.' Yassie Safai's statement added, 'I met Dustin Johnson at Sherwood country club. I have run into him at Sherwood maybe 4 times … I have never met Paulina Gretzky and do not know the Gretzky family, but again, I am sure they are great people.' Paulina Gretzky and Dustin Johnson were soon spotted on a holiday together Neither Wayne Gretzky's daughter, Paulina Gretzky nor Dustin Johnson ever addressed the rumours of any infidelity. However, Dustin Johnson did speak about how every relationship had its 'ups and downs' a few weeks later. Two months later, Paulina Gretzky and Dustin Johnson were spotted on a holiday together and in 2022, they tied the knot at a beautiful wedding ceremony. FAQs How many children does Paulina Gretzky and Dustin Johnson have? Paulina Gretzky and Dustin Johnson have two children When did Paulina Gretzky meet Dustin Johnson? Paulina Gretzky met Dustin Johnson in 2013 Also Read: Wayne Gretzky's daughter Paulina Gretzky's Hollywood dreams and massive net worth show she's more than just the NHL legend's daughter Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
