Reddit debates the best NHL players who never tasted Stanley Cup glory
For each Stanley Cup champion, there's a generational star that, despite brilliance, never got to hoist Lord Stanley's chalice. A new Reddit thread posed the agonizing but intriguing question: Who are the greatest NHL players ever not to have won a Cup? What ensued was an impassioned snowslide of hockey fandom, heartache, and some legendary monikers.
Here are the greatest and most argued names of that thread — players whose excellence never received the ring it was due.
Pavel Bure: The Russian rocket
Reddit made one thing clear: Pavel Bure was a force. Nicknamed The Russian Rocket, Bure amazed with speed, flash, and scoring ability that dropped jaws.
'Bure was the most exciting player in the nhl between gretzky and mcdavid,' a user shared.
'All time favorite player. Bure was electric,' another said to which a user replied, 'My all-time favourite player too (I'm from Vancouver lol).'
'When I think of players that stood out from the pack, Bure always comes to mind,' a user said.
Most signed off that Bure was a man before his time. His speed was supernatural, and supporters compared him to skating like McDavid — very high praise in any generation. Injuries unfortunately abbreviated his tenure, but his reputation as one of the most dynamic players of all time remains unassailable.
The NHL's Top 10 CUPLESS Players EVER 🏆
Marcel Dionne: The overlooked great
If there's one player whose name jumped out with the sheer dominance and heartbreaking absence of playoff success, it's Marcel Dionne.
'This is the answer. A not well enough known generational talent,' one user wrote.
'Marcel Dionne played 1,348 regular season games and 49 playoff games,' another fan said, 'He ranks 6th in all time goals and points.'
Even though one of the greatest scorers in NHL history, Dionne never reached the second round. Fans dubbed him the most underrated superstar ever — and on Reddit, that injustice apparently still hurts.
Paul Kariya: The artist
The love for Paul Kariya runs deep. An icon of skill and sportsmanship, he was a foundational piece of the '90s and early 2000s NHL identity.
'Favorite player as a kid. Sent a letter and got an autographed pic back. Mailman folded in the mailbox,' a Reddit user shared.
His comeback from a crushing blow to score during the 2003 Finals is one of the greatest and saddest moments in hockey history. No Stanley Cup, but forever respected.
Jarome Iginla & Joe Thornton: The 'what if' era kings
Several users cited Jarome Iginla and Joe Thornton as the greatest players of their generation who did not have a championship.
'J. Iginla & J. Thornton are probably the biggest two from the last "era" or so. Both had their chances,' a Reddit user commented.
'And Iginla kept going to the wrong teams which was the frustrating part,'
Both came agonizingly close. Iginla's 2004 Calgary near-miss, Thornton's 2016 San Jose Finals loss.
Dominant leaders, face of franchises, and alas, Cup-less legends.
Henrik Lundqvist: King without a crown
Though he didn't win the thread, Henrik Lundqvist had a consistent stream of good wishes.
'Marcel Dionne, Jerome Iginla, Joe Thornton, Dale Hawerchuk, Pavel Bure, Alexander Mogilny, Sedin twins, Roberto Luongo, Henrik Lundqvist… have all been mentioned,' a user shared.
Lundqvist was a wall for more than a decade. His Vezina-winning performance in goal made him an equal of any other in the league, and fans think his legacy richly deserved a Cup.
Honorable mentions From Reddit
Mats Sundin
Dale Hawerchuk
Alexander Mogilny
Pat LaFontaine
Roberto Luongo
The Sedin Twins
Also read:
NHL Awards to spotlight season's top performers during Game 4 broadcast of Stanley Cup Final
If only hockey were fair, each name on this list would've had at least one parade. But greatness isn't always in Cups. The players Reddit cheered for weren't simply gifted — they were icons, game-changers, and adored.
That's what makes this list stand out — not merely ability, but unforgettable magic on the ice.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Shocking! Jasprit Bumrah to quit Test cricket? 'Shareer saath nahi de raha'
Jasprit Bumrah (Getty Images) NEW DELHI: Former India batter Mohammad Kaif sparked debate with a bold statement, suggesting that Jasprit Bumrah may soon walk away from Test cricket. Kaif questioned whether the star pacer can continue in the demanding format, pointing to signs of physical struggle and a noticeable dip in intensity. In the ongoing Test at Old Trafford, Bumrah has picked up just one wicket across two days of play. 10:08 Jasprit Bumrah press conference: Hits out at critics, on Lord's Honours Boards, ball controversy Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! His pace has also raised eyebrows — he's breached the 140 kmph mark only once so far in the match. To make matters worse, he reportedly sustained a minor injury while walking down the stairs at the venue. "Jasprit Bumrah. Mujhe lagta hai ki aane wale Test matches mein aapko unhe khelte hue na dikhein, aur ho sakta hai woh retirement bhi le lein. Shareer se woh joojh rahe hain, dheemi ball daal rahe hain, raftaar dikhi nahi is Test match mein, aur woh khuddar bante ja rahe hain. Agar unhe lagega ki main 100% nahi de pa raha hoon, desh ke liye, main jeeta nahi paa raha, wickets nahi le paa raha hoon, toh woh khud hi mana kar denge – aisi meri feeling hai. Aur agar samay na mila, woh alag baat hai. [I feel that in the upcoming Test matches, you may not see him play, and perhaps, he might even retire. He's struggling physically, bowling slower deliveries, and his pace hasn't been visible in this Test match. He seems to be becoming more self-aware and principled. If he feels he can't give 100% for the country, that he's no longer winning games or taking wickets, I believe he'll step away on his own. That's my gut feeling. And if he doesn't get time to recover, that's another issue]," Kaif said on his social media handle while posting a video. "Par jo raftaar thi – 130, 125 ki speed se ball daal rahe hain. Aur jo wicket mili – ek aage ka catch jo keeper ne liya tha – woh bhi aage dive maar kar pakda. Fit Bumrah bhai yahaan out karte hain, yahaan par keeper catch pakadta hai, itni raftaar se ball jaati hai ke batsman ko hawa bhi nahi lagti – chaahe Joe Root ho ya koi bhi. Aise bowler jab chahein batsman ko out kar sakte hain. [But the pace he once had – now he's bowling at 130, 125 km/h. Even the wicket he got – the catch that was taken by the keeper diving forward – that wasn't the Bumrah we know. A fully fit Bumrah dismisses the batter outright – the keeper just finishes the job. His pace used to be such that batters like Joe Root didn't even feel the air of the ball before they were out. Bowlers like him could dismiss anyone whenever they wanted.]" "Par mujhe lagta hai ki wohi hai – shiddat, desh ke liye khelne ki chahat. Par unka shareer unka saath nahi de raha. Fitness ke maamle mein woh har chuke hain. Is Test match mein unka na chalna saaf taur par yeh sabit karta hai ki aage dikkat aayegi, aur ho sakta hai Test matches mein aap unhe na dekhein. [But now, the intensity and desire to play for the country are still there, yet the body isn't supporting him. He's lost the battle with his fitness. His performance in this Test match clearly shows that challenges lie ahead, and maybe you won't see him in Tests anymore.]" "Pehle Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma, R Ashwin nahi hain. Ab shayad Bumrah ke bina bhi – jo humare Hindustani fans hain – unhe aadat dalni padegi. Bhai, mujhe lagta hai ki aapko unke bina Test match dekhne ki aadat daalni hogi. [First, there's no Virat Kohli, no Rohit Sharma, no R Ashwin. And now, perhaps Indian fans will have to prepare themselves for Test cricket without Bumrah too. I genuinely feel that you may need to get used to watching Test matches without him. ]" Manchester weather forecast - Rain, chilly winds in store on Day 4 and Day 5 "Dua karta hoon jo main keh raha hoon, meri prediction galat ho. Par jo maine is Test match mein dekha – mujhe laga ki woh enjoy nahi kar rahe hain. Bilkul bhi enjoy nahi kar rahe. Woh shareer se haare hue hain. Zehan bilkul tez hai, jazba wahi hai – par shareer saath nahi de raha hai. Toh phir aap kya kar sakte ho? [I hope and pray that I'm wrong, and this prediction doesn't come true. But from what I've seen in this Test, he doesn't look like he's enjoying it anymore. Not at all. He's physically defeated. His mind is still sharp, his passion remains, but his body isn't keeping up. So what can you really do?]" he said. For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
134th edition of Durand Cup Jamshedpur leg kicks off with grand opening ceremony
The Jamshedpur leg of the 134th Durand Cup began on a spectacular note, despite heavy rain, with an electrifying opening match at The Furnace —the home ground of Jamshedpur FC . The stadium was packed with passionate football fans who braved the weather to cheer for their teams and witness the grand cultural and sporting spectacle. The opening ceremony was graced by Sudivya Kumar, Hon'ble Minister of Urban Development and Housing, Higher and Technical Education, Tourism, Art & Culture, and Sports & Youth Affairs, and Lieutenant General Ram Chander Tiwari, PVSM, UYSM, AVSM, SM, General Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Eastern Command and Patron of the Durand Cup Organising Committee (DCOC). They were joined by Major General Dhurba Prakash Shah, Director General of Military Training of the Nepali Army. The event also saw the presence of several dignitaries including Shri Saryu Roy (MLA, Jamshedpur West), Smt. Purnima Das Sahu (MLA, Jamshedpur East), Shri D. B. Sundara Ramam (Vice President, Corporate Services, Tata Steel), Shri Sanjeev Kumar Choudhary (Executive Director & State Head, Bihar & Jharkhand, IOCL), Shri Mangal Kalindi (MLA, Jugsalai) and Shri Manoj Kumar Yadav, a distinguished sports personality and administrator from Jharkhand. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Senior tries new socks to relieve foot pain, and it works TISOX Read More Undo Top officers of the Indian Army in attendance included Lieutenant General Yash Ahlawat, AVSM, YSM, SM (General Officer Commanding, Brahmastra Corps), Major General Rajesh Arun Moghe, VSM (GOC, Bengal Sub Area & Vice Chairman, DCOC), and Major General Paramvir Singh Dagar, VSM (General Officer Commanding, Cockerel Division). The grand ceremony featured a vibrant cultural line-up: A Paika dance performed by Gulab Singh Munda and his team from Icchagarh A Khukhri dance by the 6th Battalion of the 8th Gorkha Regiment A lively Jhumair dance, a local folk performance And a thrilling Kalaripayattu display by the 21st Battalion of the Madras Regiment In a gesture of friendship and mutual respect, Lieutenant General R.C. Tiwari and Major General Dhurba Prakash Shah exchanged greetings and souvenirs before the match, reinforcing the longstanding camaraderie between the Indian and Nepali Armies. They also met the players and staff of Tribhuvan Army FC (Nepali Army), posed for photographs, and wished them well for their campaign. Adding to the excitement, souvenir footballs were kicked into the stands to engage the young audience. The Jamshedpur leg will host seven matches, including a quarterfinal. Apart from Tribhuvan Army FC, Indian Army FT and 1 Ladakh FC—the latter making their debut in the tournament—are also part of Group C. With a passionate crowd and a rich blend of culture, tradition, and sportsmanship, the Durand Cup continues its legacy as one of India's oldest and most celebrated football tournaments.
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Bengaluru techie's 25 kms commute nightmare: ‘Everyone's angry, sweaty, and silently screaming'
A viral post by a frustrated software engineer from Bengaluru has gone viral, shedding light on the grim realities of daily commuting in the city after return-to-office mandates resumed in full swing. The techie, who describes himself as a 'proud Bangalorean, born and raised,' shared his ordeal of traveling 25 km to and from work.(PTI) The post, titled 'Bengaluru public transport + return to office = certified insanity', paints a chaotic picture of packed buses, unsafe drop-off points, and fraying tempers on the city's roads, particularly along the notoriously congested Outer Ring Road. Read his full post here: Reddit viral post.(Life_In_Progress13) The techie, who describes himself as a 'proud Bangalorean, born and raised,' shared his ordeal of traveling 25 km to and from work using public transport, a decision he made believing it would be the responsible, eco-friendly choice. Instead, he describes the commute as 'a test of endurance.' 'This is not commuting. This is survival,' he wrote, in a post that has now struck a chord with thousands of city dwellers. Among the incidents he recounted was being dropped on a flyover near Nagawara Junction, instead of at a designated bus stop. With no footpath or crossing in sight, he was forced to dodge high-speed traffic to get to the other side, just to catch another bus. When he tried to board a waiting bus at a signal, the conductor yelled, 'This is not a stop! Go to the bus stop!' 'Bro. Your colleague just dropped me in the middle of nowhere. What stop??' he wrote, calling it 'real clownery.' He also criticised the behavior of BMTC staff, saying, 'The driver looks like he's five seconds away from quitting, and the conductor treats you like you owe him rent.' The Reddit post also took a jab at the seemingly never-ending metro construction on Outer Ring Road (ORR), which has compounded traffic woes. He summed up the commute as 'a team-building exercise for introverts, a cardio session for the brave, and a lesson in patience for all.' The post, which quickly gained traction across social media platforms, has reignited debate over the state of Bengaluru's public transport infrastructure, particularly for long-distance commuters who don't own private vehicles. (Also Read: Karnataka's free bus travel spurs 23% rise in women's employment in Bengaluru: Report)
