26-06-2025
- Politics
- Los Angeles Times
Opinion: Bridging barriers of California's bilingual education: From legislative intent to meaningful action
When it comes to the value of bilingual education in improving educational outcomes for Hispanic youth, the message should not get lost in translation: dual-language academic offerings dramatically enhance these students' English language acquisition, standardized test scores, graduation rates, and college preparation, as reported by CalMatters .
Based on overwhelming evidence supporting these benefits, California enacted Proposition 58 in 2016, repealing the restrictions imposed by Proposition 227, which had previously banned bilingual education. Even with Proposition 58, CalMatters says the expansion of bilingual education in California has been slow, despite a desperate need. Such programs in states like Texas had a more rapid implementation, even though California has more English learners than any other state.
Why?
According to Century Foundation , the primary barrier is a shortage of qualified bilingual teachers, underscoring the necessity of backing such legislation with resources to enable its success. To address this gap, California should create incentives to attract and retain bilingual educators and partner with colleges to create robust teacher training programs. The lack of qualified instructors —a consequence of the previous ban—has created a professional deficit that should be bridged to meet the demand for dual-language programs.
This situation mirrors the challenges of de jure versus de facto implementation seen in the civil rights movement in the United States. Simply passing legislation is not enough; achieving meaningful change requires the necessary infrastructure and strong legislative and executive support. For example, according to EdSource , only 16.4% of English learners in California are enrolled in bilingual classrooms, compared to 36.7% in Texas.
In response to these challenges, California launched the Global California 2030 initiative. This ambitious plan aims for half of the state's students to be on a path to bilingualism and for 1,600 schools to offer dual-language programs by 2030. While well-intentioned, this initiative faces the same implementation hurdles. As stated in EdSource , Goals without actionable plans can falter, and this initiative is no exception. To make bilingual education more accessible and empower Hispanic youth, policymakers should provide funding for specialized training programs, offer financial incentives, establish targeted recruitment programs, and ensure robust oversight and planning.
Without addressing the logistical and practical barriers to implementation, reaching the intended outcomes of policies like Prop 58 can take much longer and be more difficult to achieve. Meanwhile, hundreds of thousands of California's Hispanic students will miss out on valuable educational opportunities. We owe it to them to ensure that Prop 58 is accompanied by the necessary funding, oversight, and planning to set ESL students up for success. Related