‘Even Pakistan is younger': Sanjeev Sanyal warns of India's aging cities, says it's time to move past family planning
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
Urban homes empty, cultural identities under strain
India not the youngest country anymore
Fertility rates dropping across India
Tired of too many ads?
Remove Ads
Urban crowding linked to poor management, not population growth
Decline hard to reverse, long recovery cycle
North-South imbalance could trigger migration tensions
Northern regions also showing strain
India's population trends are already showing signs of long-term decline, with regions like Kerala witnessing empty homes and West Bengal's urban Bengali Bhadralok community shrinking both in numbers and presence. Economist Sanjeev Sanyal , a member of the Prime Minister's Economic Advisory Council , has warned that India is not as young as widely believed and is already seeing the impact of falling fertility and increasing migration. He noted that even Pakistan is younger than India.During a conversation with historian Hindol Sengupta on a podcast, Sanyal said, 'If you just go through major towns in Kerala — take Thrissur, for example. Thrissur is the financial and intellectual capital of Kerala. Now you go there — there are beautiful bungalows, a lot of them belonging to wealthy families, particularly Syrian Christian families and others as well. Now irrespective of which community they are from, they have lovely bungalows. All of them live in Dubai or Abu Dhabi or now their children have moved to the West. At best, those bungalows have a few aging grandparents. Now after this, they're going to be just empty.'He made a similar point about West Bengal's urban elite. 'At this rate, the Bengali Bhadralok will go extinct. Because if you combine this birth rate and out-migration from Kolkata to other states and other parts of the world, the Bengali Bhadralok will go extinct. These are statistical points, it's not even an opinion,' he said.Sanyal challenged the widely held perception that India is the youngest country. 'We keep fooling ourselves saying - 'We are the youngest country in the world'. First of all, we are not the youngest country in the world,' he said. 'There are countries in Africa, there is Pakistan, there is Philippines - which is younger than us. Secondly, even though we are younger than the West or East Asia, we too are aging and we need to begin to think in those terms.'Sanyal said that India's overall fertility rate has fallen to 1.9 children per woman. 'The only reason it is at 1.9 and not lower is because of UP and Bihar,' he said. 'Large parts of southern India but also other parts of India, say for example the state of West Bengal, are now somewhere in the 1.6 range. Urban Bengal is 1.2.'On the perception of India's overcrowded cities, Sanyal said this was due to poor planning rather than high population. 'First of all, please separate your urban management problem from the demographic problem. We have this impression that our cities are overcrowded. No, they are badly managed,' he said.He cited the example of Mumbai's southern suburbs. 'In just the last 10 years, the traffic situation in southern Mumbai has improved. Has this been because of out-movement of people? No. In fact, there are more high-rises in Worli today which you can see from the sea-link than there were 20 years ago. But the traffic has improved. Why? Because you have better infrastructure. So the problem is infrastructure building, it is not a crowding problem.'Sanyal pointed out that once the fertility rate falls below replacement level, recovery is slow. 'Let's say China today — it's already gotten rid of the one-child policy. Once society changes and you have a generation who's born up without having siblings, the social structure that keeps a higher birth rate simply goes away,' he said.'In China, their birth rates kept falling. And even if they succeed in reversing this, the benefits will not show up for another 25 years.'Sanyal said states in southern India may face labour shortages. 'You'll have parts of the country, for example - the South, which will have huge shortages of people. Now either they give up on growing, or they decide to import people. When people are imported, where do they come from? The places where they have more children — which is UP and Bihar. Then you will complain about language, culture, all kinds of things.'Even parts of North India are beginning to see the effects. 'In Himachal, one major problem is you don't have enough children. You have a large number of schools that do not have a minimum quantum of children to keep those schools running,' Sanyal said.He concluded, 'Reproductively speaking, we are no longer reproducing ourselves. The number of children peaked 10 to 15 years ago. So this is an obvious point and I am amazed that I have to debate it.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
02-07-2025
- The Hindu
Samik Bhattacharya is the new West Bengal BJP president
Senior Bharatiya Janata Party leader and Rajya Sabha MP Samik Bhattacharya was on Wednesday (July 2, 2025) unanimously elected as the next president of the West Bengal unit of the BJP. Mr. Bhattacharya filed the nomination papers for the post of BJP president, accompanied by outgoing State president Sukanta Majumdar and Leader of the Opposition in the West Bengal Assembly Suvendu Adhikari. As no other candidates filed nomination for the post by Wednesday's (July 2, 2025) deadline, Mr. Bhattacharya was unanimously elected to the post. The 62-year-old BJP leader is a party loyalist and has been associated with the party for over four decades. He has been with the saffron party from the time the BJP's vote share in the State was a mere 3% in the 1990s. Mr. Bhattacharya has been a Rajya Sabha MP from West Bengal since April 2024. A prominent face of the party on television news channels, he is also the chief spokesperson of the party for the State. The elevation of Mr. Bhattacharya comes ahead of the Assembly polls in West Bengal scheduled in 2026. The BJP has emerged as the principal Opposition party in the State, but, with about 38% vote share, lags behind the ruling Trinamool Congress, which had taken about 48% of votes in last year's Lok Sabha polls. The task for the new BJP president is to strengthen the party organisation ahead of the Assembly polls and bring the rival factions of the party together. The BJP leadership's decision to direct only Mr. Bhattacharya to file the nomination is also an attempt to display the unity in the party rank and file. Mr. Bhattacharya was also MLA of the Basirhat Dakshin constituency from 2014 to 2016. In 2021, the BJP leader contested the Assembly polls unsuccessfully from Rajarhat Gopalpur constituency. The selection of an upper caste leader as a BJP president is a statement that the party wants to consolidate Hindu votes. The State unit wants to project Samik Bhattacharya as a face who will appeal to the Bengali Bhadralok. Leader of Opposition Suvendu Adhikari has already emerged as a prominent leader of the party who is taking on Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee. The soft-spoken and educated image of the new Bengal BJP president is in line with that of the outgoing BJP president Sukanta Majumdar, an academic, representing the Balurghat Lok Sabha constituency since 2019. In 2024, Mr. Majumdar was appointed as Union Minister of State for Education and Development of North East Region.
Economic Times
01-07-2025
- Economic Times
‘Even Pakistan is younger': Sanjeev Sanyal warns of India's aging cities, says it's time to move past family planning
Economist Sanjeev Sanyal warns that India's population trends indicate a long-term decline, with fertility rates falling below replacement levels in many regions. He highlights the aging population, potential labor shortages in the South, and the challenges of reversing this demographic shift. Sanyal emphasizes that India is not the youngest country and needs to address these issues proactively. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Urban homes empty, cultural identities under strain India not the youngest country anymore Fertility rates dropping across India Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Urban crowding linked to poor management, not population growth Decline hard to reverse, long recovery cycle North-South imbalance could trigger migration tensions Northern regions also showing strain India's population trends are already showing signs of long-term decline, with regions like Kerala witnessing empty homes and West Bengal's urban Bengali Bhadralok community shrinking both in numbers and presence. Economist Sanjeev Sanyal , a member of the Prime Minister's Economic Advisory Council , has warned that India is not as young as widely believed and is already seeing the impact of falling fertility and increasing migration. He noted that even Pakistan is younger than a conversation with historian Hindol Sengupta on a podcast, Sanyal said, 'If you just go through major towns in Kerala — take Thrissur, for example. Thrissur is the financial and intellectual capital of Kerala. Now you go there — there are beautiful bungalows, a lot of them belonging to wealthy families, particularly Syrian Christian families and others as well. Now irrespective of which community they are from, they have lovely bungalows. All of them live in Dubai or Abu Dhabi or now their children have moved to the West. At best, those bungalows have a few aging grandparents. Now after this, they're going to be just empty.'He made a similar point about West Bengal's urban elite. 'At this rate, the Bengali Bhadralok will go extinct. Because if you combine this birth rate and out-migration from Kolkata to other states and other parts of the world, the Bengali Bhadralok will go extinct. These are statistical points, it's not even an opinion,' he challenged the widely held perception that India is the youngest country. 'We keep fooling ourselves saying - 'We are the youngest country in the world'. First of all, we are not the youngest country in the world,' he said. 'There are countries in Africa, there is Pakistan, there is Philippines - which is younger than us. Secondly, even though we are younger than the West or East Asia, we too are aging and we need to begin to think in those terms.'Sanyal said that India's overall fertility rate has fallen to 1.9 children per woman. 'The only reason it is at 1.9 and not lower is because of UP and Bihar,' he said. 'Large parts of southern India but also other parts of India, say for example the state of West Bengal, are now somewhere in the 1.6 range. Urban Bengal is 1.2.'On the perception of India's overcrowded cities, Sanyal said this was due to poor planning rather than high population. 'First of all, please separate your urban management problem from the demographic problem. We have this impression that our cities are overcrowded. No, they are badly managed,' he cited the example of Mumbai's southern suburbs. 'In just the last 10 years, the traffic situation in southern Mumbai has improved. Has this been because of out-movement of people? No. In fact, there are more high-rises in Worli today which you can see from the sea-link than there were 20 years ago. But the traffic has improved. Why? Because you have better infrastructure. So the problem is infrastructure building, it is not a crowding problem.'Sanyal pointed out that once the fertility rate falls below replacement level, recovery is slow. 'Let's say China today — it's already gotten rid of the one-child policy. Once society changes and you have a generation who's born up without having siblings, the social structure that keeps a higher birth rate simply goes away,' he said.'In China, their birth rates kept falling. And even if they succeed in reversing this, the benefits will not show up for another 25 years.'Sanyal said states in southern India may face labour shortages. 'You'll have parts of the country, for example - the South, which will have huge shortages of people. Now either they give up on growing, or they decide to import people. When people are imported, where do they come from? The places where they have more children — which is UP and Bihar. Then you will complain about language, culture, all kinds of things.'Even parts of North India are beginning to see the effects. 'In Himachal, one major problem is you don't have enough children. You have a large number of schools that do not have a minimum quantum of children to keep those schools running,' Sanyal concluded, 'Reproductively speaking, we are no longer reproducing ourselves. The number of children peaked 10 to 15 years ago. So this is an obvious point and I am amazed that I have to debate it.'
Time of India
01-07-2025
- Time of India
‘Even Pakistan is younger': Sanjeev Sanyal warns of India's aging cities, says it's time to move past family planning
India's population trends are already showing signs of long-term decline, with regions like Kerala witnessing empty homes and West Bengal's urban Bengali Bhadralok community shrinking both in numbers and presence. Economist Sanjeev Sanyal , a member of the Prime Minister's Economic Advisory Council , has warned that India is not as young as widely believed and is already seeing the impact of falling fertility and increasing migration. He noted that even Pakistan is younger than India. Urban homes empty, cultural identities under strain During a conversation with historian Hindol Sengupta on a podcast, Sanyal said, 'If you just go through major towns in Kerala — take Thrissur, for example. Thrissur is the financial and intellectual capital of Kerala. Now you go there — there are beautiful bungalows, a lot of them belonging to wealthy families, particularly Syrian Christian families and others as well. Now irrespective of which community they are from, they have lovely bungalows. All of them live in Dubai or Abu Dhabi or now their children have moved to the West. At best, those bungalows have a few aging grandparents. Now after this, they're going to be just empty.' He made a similar point about West Bengal's urban elite. 'At this rate, the Bengali Bhadralok will go extinct. Because if you combine this birth rate and out-migration from Kolkata to other states and other parts of the world, the Bengali Bhadralok will go extinct. These are statistical points, it's not even an opinion,' he said. India not the youngest country anymore Sanyal challenged the widely held perception that India is the youngest country. 'We keep fooling ourselves saying - 'We are the youngest country in the world'. First of all, we are not the youngest country in the world,' he said. 'There are countries in Africa, there is Pakistan, there is Philippines - which is younger than us. Secondly, even though we are younger than the West or East Asia, we too are aging and we need to begin to think in those terms.' Fertility rates dropping across India Sanyal said that India's overall fertility rate has fallen to 1.9 children per woman. 'The only reason it is at 1.9 and not lower is because of UP and Bihar,' he said. 'Large parts of southern India but also other parts of India, say for example the state of West Bengal, are now somewhere in the 1.6 range. Urban Bengal is 1.2.' Live Events Urban crowding linked to poor management, not population growth On the perception of India's overcrowded cities, Sanyal said this was due to poor planning rather than high population. 'First of all, please separate your urban management problem from the demographic problem. We have this impression that our cities are overcrowded. No, they are badly managed,' he said. He cited the example of Mumbai's southern suburbs. 'In just the last 10 years, the traffic situation in southern Mumbai has improved. Has this been because of out-movement of people? No. In fact, there are more high-rises in Worli today which you can see from the sea-link than there were 20 years ago. But the traffic has improved. Why? Because you have better infrastructure. So the problem is infrastructure building, it is not a crowding problem.' Decline hard to reverse, long recovery cycle Sanyal pointed out that once the fertility rate falls below replacement level, recovery is slow. 'Let's say China today — it's already gotten rid of the one-child policy. Once society changes and you have a generation who's born up without having siblings, the social structure that keeps a higher birth rate simply goes away,' he said. 'In China, their birth rates kept falling. And even if they succeed in reversing this, the benefits will not show up for another 25 years.' North-South imbalance could trigger migration tensions Sanyal said states in southern India may face labour shortages. 'You'll have parts of the country, for example - the South, which will have huge shortages of people. Now either they give up on growing, or they decide to import people. When people are imported, where do they come from? The places where they have more children — which is UP and Bihar. Then you will complain about language, culture, all kinds of things.' Northern regions also showing strain Even parts of North India are beginning to see the effects. 'In Himachal, one major problem is you don't have enough children. You have a large number of schools that do not have a minimum quantum of children to keep those schools running,' Sanyal said. He concluded, 'Reproductively speaking, we are no longer reproducing ourselves. The number of children peaked 10 to 15 years ago. So this is an obvious point and I am amazed that I have to debate it.'
